Edgar Allen Poe Short Story Analysis - Bhs/19 - Essay

1598 words - 7 pages

S. Gonzalez
English 11
Edgar Allan Poe
Short Story
Annotations & Analysis
October 2017
Directions: Read the Edgar Allan Poe story of your choice. After reading, reread and annotate. Once you annotate you will compose an original analysis of the short story focusing in on a question or literary device of your choice.
Annotation Requirements
10 literal thoughts - you must point out the significance for the sentence or word.
10 inferential thoughts - you must explain the idea and your own interpretation (inference)
10 critical thoughts - you must thoroughly discuss the importance and your own thoughts on the example.
Analysis Requirements
1000 word minimum written essay
Summary should not be dominant throughout.
Your own thoughts can be woven into the analysis with textual evidence to prove them.
You must use textual evidence throughout your analysis.
You must focus in on a theme, motif, allegorical idea, character, or literary device of your choice.
You must look at the author’s purpose throughout in order to conduct a clear analysis.
In "The Black Cat", by Edgar Allan Poe, I understand it to be that the unnamed man is only making excuses for his actions. So people do not blame him, they instead blame excuses made him do so. The writer begins his confession looking back. To a time where he considered himself to be a normal person. Known for his "tenderness of heart" and his merciful considerations of animals and people. His parents encouraged his mercy for animals, and he acquired many different kinds of pets. He was lucky to marry a woman who resembled himself. In the sense that she cared for animals too. Among the many pets that they possessed in their marriage was a black cat named Pluto. Since his wife often hinted at the popular idea that all black cats are "witches in disguise", the name Pluto (which is the name of a Roman god of the underworld) becomes important throughout the entire story. Another popular idea relating to this story is the belief that cat's have nine lives. This superstition becomes a part of the story when the second black cat— believed to be a reincarnation of Pluto— has an imprint of the gallows on its chest.
It is alluring to believe Pluto was the writer's favorite animal and for many years, there was a very special relationship between the animal and him. Then "due alcohol" the man underwent a change. "I grew, day by day, more moody, more irritable, more regardless of the feelings of others." To restate from introduction of the story, the writer believed that people were capable at any time of reversing their personality and falling into a state of madness at any moment. It is here that the man undergoes the reversal. The effect from this is when he came home intoxicated, imagined that his "best playmate" is avoiding him, then grasped the cat by its throat and with a knife cut out one of its eyes. This delusion is only the starting trigger for more unspeakable acts to come. This also shows the two faced-ness effect that the writer wants us to believe; so we don't blame him as a whole.
He writes later, horrified by what he had done, telling how the cat has recovered but is now avoiding him on purpose. As the cat continued to avoid the writer, the spirit of his two faced-ness reverses him again; this time, with an yearning deep inside him to "offer violence . . . to do wrong for the wrong's sake only." Without warning that morning, he put a noose around the cat's neck and hanged it from the limb of a tree, crying while doing so. He showed remorse of his determination to "offer violence" because he knows that the cat had loved him and had given him no reason to hang it. What he did was an act of the "reversal" or so he wants to us believe. The writer's house burned down shortly after.
Being a such "rational" person, the writer refused to see a connection between his dastardly act of killing his cat and the disaster of his house. Here, we have an example of the insane mind rejecting the idea that the burning of his house might be punishment for killing the cat. Yet, on the following day, he visited the ruins of the house and saw a crowd of people gathered around. A wall, standing new, re-plastered. It was the wall above where his bed had before been. Engraved in the plaster was an image of a gigantic cat with a rope around it's neck.
Once again, the writer's insane mind attempts to offer a rational explanation for this paradox. He believes that someone found the cat's dead body, flung it into the burning house to wake him up; that because of the burning of the house, the falling of the walls, and the ammonia from the body of the cat contributed to the creation of the image in the wall. So we must assume that the image hit home with the writer, because he was in such "denial" that it was his fault. For months, the narrator could not forget about his black cat. One night when he was drinking , he saw another black cat that looked like Pluto except for a patch of white on its chest. He then proceeded to take it home with him. The cat became a great favorite of his and his wife. The man's "reversal" had caused him to change again and the cat's fondness for them began to disgust him. It is now that he began to loathe the cat. What increased his loathing of the new cat was that it had looked like Pluto, with one of its eyes missing. In the mind of the writer, this cat is a reincarnation of Pluto. He even says to himself that the one trait that had at once time defined him, ( a feeling of humanity) had now almost disappeared. This is a prime example, from the introduction. Of how people were capable at any time of reversing their personality and of falling into a state of madness at any moment.
Soon, the man develops an absolute hatred of the cat. When he discovers that the white patch on its chest, which at one time was obvious, had "assumed a rigorous distinctness of outline" and was a hideous, image of the gallows. "Oh, mournful and terrible engine of Horror and of Crime — of Agony and of Death!" Here we can assume that the change occurs within the mind of the insane in the same way that he thinks this "beast" to be a reincarnation of the original Pluto. As he and his wife were going into the cellar, the cat tripped him; he grabbed an axe to kill it, but his wife stopped the blow. He then "buried the axe in her brain." This sudden gruesome act is not prepared for in any way. Many times was this pointed out that the narrator loved his wife very deeply. This part in the story shows flaw. There was no real rhyme or reason for this act as the other ones had. There was no "reversal" making me believe that he had no excuse for this. That he is truly insane and has nothing to blame it on at this point.
The man realizes that he must get rid of the body. He thought of "cutting the corpse into minute fragments," but rather than dismemberment, he decided to " Wall it up in the cellar." After having accomplished the deed and cleaning up so that nothing was detectable, the man decided to kill the cat as well. Reasonably, it had disappeared. After only three days, the writer decided that the "monster of a cat" had disappeared forever; he was now able to sleep in spite of killing his wife. This lack of guilt is ironic compared to beginning of the story. Police arrive to inspect the premises. The man became overconfident; he relishes in the fact that he has so cleverly concealed his horrible crime and so he welcomes the inspection.
But, here, in an act of crazy boastfulness, he speaks so heavily upon the bricks that entomb his wife, that to his horror, a "voice from within the tomb" answered. At first, it was a muffled and broken cry, but then it grew into an "utterly anomalous and inhuman . . . howl . . . a wailing shriek, half of horror and half of triumph, such as might have arisen only out of hell, conjointly from the throats of the damned in their agony and of the demons that exult in the damnation." The police immediately began to tear down the brick wall, and they discover the rotting corpse of the writer's wife and, standing upon her head was the "hideous beast whose craft had seduced me into murder . . . I had walled the monster up within the tomb."
The final irony, is that the cat which he had come to despise, served as a symbol of punishment against him. By the end of the story, thus, we can see how the man, accuses himself of the insanity which he denied at the beginning of the story. Which proves to me that he is after all truly insane; he just wants to give us excuses and wants to have things to blame, so he can die with the knowledge that it wasn't really his fault.`

More like Edgar Allen Poe Short Story Analysis - Bhs/19 - Essay

Paper On What Killed Edgar Allen Poe?

795 words - 4 pages ... Edgar Allen Poe was an American writer, poet, and editor and was best known for his dark and twisted stories and poems that seemed to linger in readers' imaginations. His mystifying artistry delivered tales of horror and mystery; in fact, he is thought to be the founder of the modern detective story. With that in mind, it seems almost ironic that, to this day, no one is quite sure just how the man died. Like any good detective story, there are ...

Poetry Analysis Of Edgar Allen Poe Annabelle Lee - English 1312 - Literary Analysis

1306 words - 6 pages Free ... separated. For even the moon brings him dreams of her and the stars remind him of her eyes as Poe uses imagery to invoke emotion in the reader. Subsequently, it is obvious that Edgar Allan Poe used imagery of words to arouse a sentiment in the reader of the passion and love that was shared between them. Edgar Allen Poe’s main intent of “Annabel Lee” was to allow the reader to feel an emotional response to the poem. In fact, this poem has an almost ...

Three Short Stories Essay: "the Black Cat" And "the Tell Tale Heart" By Edgar Allen Poe And "call It Madness" By Guy Du Maupassant

3193 words - 13 pages ... This is about the three short stories "The Black Cat" and "The Tell Tale Heart" written by Edgar Allen Poe and "Call It Madness" is written by Guy Du Maupassant"The black cat" is written by Edgar Allan Poe and is about a man who is paranoid about his cat. After turning to alcohol he becomes very violent and starts to abuse his animals and his wife.The man became more and more violent and took his rage out on the cat. He was a bully. He killed ...

Dramatic Structure Of Edgar Allen Poe - Florida Atlantic University - Essay

859 words - 4 pages ... of classic dramatic structure is the exposition. This part of the play provides background information necessary for the viewer to understand the story Part two is called the rising action. In this part, the main character struggles against various minor obstacles. This part sets the stage for the drama's central conflict. Part three is the climax. This is the turning point in the story; if the drama is a comedy (in other words, it will have a ...

Poetry Analysis On Edgar Allen Poe's The Raven - Savannah Technical College. Engl 1002 - Essay

1225 words - 5 pages ... Grimm 2 Christine Grimm Ms. Hunt English 1102 March 21, 2019 Sanity and Love No More Memories of lost loved ones usually are portrayed as something purely positive and a source of comfort, a way to keep them close and active in the memories of those left behind. Edgar Allan Poe does the opposite by portraying the memories as a burden that one cannot escape. The loss of a loved one can cause anyone to enter a deep depression. Edgar Allen Poe is ...

The Black Cat By Edgar Allan Poe, Essay Analysis - An Unreliable Author - U Of A - Essay

1032 words - 5 pages ... An Unreliable Narrator in “The Black Cat” The point of view in which a narrative is told influences the audience directly, as well as sets up the theme and setting of the story. The point of view presented by Edgar Allan Poe, in the short fiction “The Black Cat” is very significant as it contributes directly to how the story is perceived by the reader. The story is conducted by an anonymous narrator speaking in first person, ​with the narrator ...

Poe Sample Revenge Is Bitter Sweet, Essay For English Over Allen Poe, Cask Of - English - Essay

974 words - 4 pages ... , in the end, the cask symbolizes the place where Fortunato’s body will rest. Poe does an excellent job of conveying the theme of the story, and bringing forth distinctive examples of literary elements that are meant for gothic fiction. Work Cited May, Charles E. “The Cask of Amontillado.” Magill’s survey of American Literature (2006): par. 1. Literary Reference Center Plus. Web. 1 Oct. 2011 Poe, Edgar Allan. “The Cask of Amontillado.” 1-4. Print. ...

Symbolism Analysis Of Short Story - Los Angeles Community College - Essay

1692 words - 7 pages ... door,” the guilt, by giving a confession. This is mine. Becker 5 Works Cited Poe, Edgar Allan. “The Tell-Tale Heart.” Backpack Literature: An Introduction to Fiction, Poetry, Drama, and Writing. Ed. X. J. Kennedy and Dana Gioia. 3rd ed. New York: Longman, 2010. 42- 46. Print. Robinson, E. Arthur. “Poe's “The Tell-Tale Heart.'” Nineteenth-Century Fiction. 19.4 (Mar. 1965): 369- 378. JSTOR. Web. 28 May 2015. ...

A Short Story Analysis Of The Juggler - Vanier - Short Story Analysis

1080 words - 5 pages Free ... General Statement The short story, “The Juggler”, written by Ursula Hegi, takes place in Coeur d’Alene in the first weekend of October. This first-person narrator tells the story of a mother who is struggling to accept the fact that her daughter Zoe’s boyfriend Michael is slowly losing his eyesight. The author starts by describing the relationship between Michael and Zoe as very loving but dependant relationship. Main idea He then proceeds to ...

Sobibor, Tells The Story Of A Nazi Officer Gone Mad...losely Based On Edgar Allen Poe's "tell-tale Heart"

1734 words - 7 pages ... The eyeball, glazed over, shifted toward me. Even though he was blind, he seemed to be looking right at me. Holding the gaze for what seemed like an eternity, as my eyes met his my heart seemed to beat as swiftly as the wings of a humming bird. I let the trap door down, stopping his heart with the grisly rope around his neck. This was the first time I ever felt sympathy for those animals those inhumane beasts, but as soon as the rope tightened ...

Text Analysis – Short Stories Bloodlines By Archimede Fusillo And Manhood By John Wain. - English - Essay

981 words - 4 pages ... Text Analysis – Short Stories Bloodlines by Archimede Fusillo and Manhood by John Wain are two short stories with major differences in characterisation and language techniques. Both stories have examples of family issues which are quite similar. The stories revolve around the fathers pushing their sons to pursue something they are not interested in. Having said that, the stories also have differences in the family issue with Bloodlines being ...

Short Story: Tales Of The Eastside - English - Essay

1557 words - 7 pages Free ... Nathan Hamm April 26, 2018 4th hour Short Story: Tales of the Eastside (Rough Draft) Have you ever been stuck in unfamiliar territory? Well I have. My name is Nathan and I have been a west sider all my life. I live in Detroit Michigan. Although I have inhabited the west side and breathed its air for nearly 18 years, I haven’t even discovered nearly half of the west side of Detroit or any of the east side. I’m very unfamiliar with Detroit. I ...

Short Story On Fear And Isolation - Meadowvale//10 - Essay

1525 words - 7 pages ... they thought, and the guards overheard. They rapidly entered the room to the sight of Adam and Clarissa exiting. Adrenaline rushed through the both of them. The force field was only a mere 200 metres away. A short distance which would lead to a larger outcome. They both ran as fast as their legs could move. The two guards ran behind, firing at them both. Somehow they managed to dodge the bullets for the first two minutes. Adam ran ahead of Clarissa ...

Harrison Begeron: The Role Of Conformity - English - Short Story Essay

606 words - 3 pages Free ... September 19th, 2017 The Results of Conformity The human brain is programmed in such a way that we strive to feel accepted into society. We may not agree with the system of which we have decided to follow, however, due to the fact that everyone is following it, we choose to do the same. This is what is known as conformity. Unconsciously, everything we do is somehow conforming with society. Throughout this short story ​Harrison Bergeron ...

Short Story For English Language Arts - Ela - Essay

1198 words - 5 pages ... Jason Pereira Block: 2 November 16, 2018 Curious Little Ethan By: Jason Pereira “Jason, where does the rain come from?”, asked little curious Ethan, wide-eyed while scratching his head, confusedly. He was looking at the water drooping down the wet window pane and seeing how gracefully the rain slowly falls from the distant sky, down to the ground. The person, to whom the question had been addressed to, was none other than Jason, his elder brother ...