Elonis Vs United States Supreme Court Case 12th Drae Government Reasearch Paper

953 words - 4 pages

Meas Kassahun
U.S Gov Final Draft
Elonis vs United States
Social Media and Free speech
Facebook had only been created six years prior and, it was still relatively new to the people. The rules on how to properly use the app had not been made clear yet. The rapid growth in technology makes it challenging to interpret ideas and, determine true intents to one's actions. However, The decision of the supreme court that one’s “true intent” must be proven to be convicted is dangerous to society.
Elonis vs. United States is a relatively recent and strange case for the supreme court, mainly because, it involves the use of the internet. The defendant, Anthony Elonis posted several statements via Facebook that appears to threaten his ex-wife, children, an FBI agent, law enforcement officers and, other individuals in his life. Prior to the posts, Elonis had been facing challenges with his wife as well as losing his job. On December 8, 2010 Elonis was arrested on five counts of violating a federal anti-threat statute. A trial was held before a grand jury in the Eastern District of Pennsylvania where Elonis was accused of transmitting a threat to harm another individual(s) under the anti-threat statute. Elonis asked to have his charges dismissed stating that his posts weren’t real threats. He continued to argue that “he was an aspiring rap artist and that his comments were merely a form of artistic expression and a therapeutic release to help him deal with the events in his life.”(US courts). Despite the fact that all the individuals who he threatened perceived it as such, Elonis argued that he could not be prosecuted of making the threats because, he didn’t intend for the posts to be threats. The court denied Elonis’ motion, and informed the jury that the defendant can be convicted if people receiving the comments perceive it as a threat. The U.S court of appeals for the third circuit affirmed the district court’s decision. Elonis was convicted and sentenced to 44 months of incarceration along with 3 years of supervision after his release. Elonis took the case to the U.S supreme court where one of the biggest arguments were made. The argument being whether a conviction of threatening another person under federal anti-threat statute require proof that the defendant meant what he said in a literal sense. While both the district and appeals’ court decided that the answer to this question simply lies under whether the person(s) being threatened  perceived it as a threat. The U.S supreme court decided for Elonis and, against the decision of the lower court. Elonis argued that in the case of Virginia vs Black, the supreme court’s decision of true threat “barred the prosecution his prosecution absent proof that he subjectively intended to threaten the subjects of his posts”(HLR).
On June 1, 2015, the supreme court reversed and remanded the decision made in the lower court in an 8-1 decision for Elonis. In an opinion delivered by Chief Justice Robert, the court h...


the Consitutional notes of united states of america chaoter 2 - Government - Reasearch

3443 words - 14 pages to create a republic, by which a government was operated by a system of representation; a pure democracy was NOT desired, as shown by the fact that state legislatures, not the people, elected senators 2. They wanted both the majority of voters AND the majority of states to make key decisions, not just one or the other. 3. The power of the Supreme Court to declare acts of Congress unconstitutional, or judicial review, was another way of limiting

Government of the United States - government - essay

2084 words - 9 pages ■ does Marbury have a right to the commission? ■ do the laws of the United States afford him a remedy? ■ is the appropriate remedy a writ of mandamus issued by the Supreme Court? ○ Marbury’s favor on the first two...but answered no to the last ● Marshall’s Reasoning ○ Writ of mandamus case is not listed in Article III ○ No power to add writ of mandamus to courts jurisdiction ○ If the Constitution is superior… ■ A legislative act contrary to the

Supreme Court: Fixed Term or Life Appointment - AP Government - Essay

502 words - 3 pages Limit Over Life Throughout the years, there has been great controversy on whether or not Supreme Court justices should serve a fixed term rather than a lifetime appointment. I agree with the argument for a term limit for several reasons, some of which including decrepitude and randomness. There are a large amount of views and opinions on this topic, however, stronger evidence shows the reasons why justices should in fact serve a fixed term

The Founding Documents of the United States - Liberty University Government - Essay

804 words - 4 pages 2 COMPARATIVE PAPER The Founding Documents of the United States of America COMPARATIVE PAPER The Founding Documents of the United States of America The founding documents of this country have shaped our national government and our society. This paper examines the founding documents, and the principles found in the Holy Scriptures, in an effort to explain how Biblical principles helped form our civil government. Founding Documents Declaration of

How the War on Terror changed modern day United States - Federal Government - Essay

1159 words - 5 pages Blankenship 1 Shelbie Blankenship Professor Goral Federal Government 2305A52 24 April 2019 Federal Government Essay On October 7, 2001, the United States entered its longest lasting war, which continues to this day, just a month after the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001. The attacks of 9/11 triggered major United States initiatives to combat terrorism and defined the presidency of George W. Bush. For the duration of the attack, 19

How a bill becomes a law within the United States Government - AP Government - Assignment

1097 words - 5 pages Step 1: An idea for a bill is established by a citizen. Step 2: The idea of the bill is developed and is written. Step 3: A member of Congress officially introduces the bill to Congress by becoming a sponsor for the bill. Step 4: Representatives of the bill try to gain support for the bill in hopes of it becoming a law. Step 5: In the House, the sponsor of the bill (member of Congress) places the bill in a special box (the hopper) to properly

Debate Essay over Rome vs United States - Whitefield Academy - Research Paper

462 words - 2 pages Gachoya 1 Justin Gachoya Mr. Unsicker History 3rd 16th May 2018 Rome vs United States Rome and the United States have many similarities and differences that define these two countries relation. Both these countries are successful since their independence, and have a legacy of each other. Lots of aspects that the Romans established were adopted by the United States, setting a influence in the modern world as of today. Furthermore, the romans

The Court Case Of Tinker Vs. Des Moines

532 words - 3 pages Free and suspended from school until they would come back without their armbands. They did not return to school until after the planned period for wearing armbands had expired -- that is, until after New Year's Day.This complaint was filed in the United States District Court by petitioners, through their fathers, under § 1983 of Title 42 of the United States Code. It prayed for an injunction restraining the respondent school officials and the

Maternal Mortality Rates in the United States Case Study - Public Health Policy and Decision - Case Study

1010 words - 5 pages Maternal Mortality Rates in the United States Case Study Public Health Policy / Decision Making Natalie Sepulveda Problem Statement How can the United States improve the maternal mortality rate (MMR) from one of the highest compared to other industrialized countries? Background According to the CIA, in 2015, the MMR of the United States ranks 138 out of 184 countries with 14 deaths per 100,000 live births compared to Greece (184), Iceland (183

United States Political Science Paper - Lamar University Political Science - Essay

1554 words - 7 pages Free , eds. Applying International Humanitarian Law in Judicial and Quasi-Judicial Bodies: International and Domestic Aspects. Springer, 2014. Pacelle, Richard. The role of the Supreme Court in American politics: The least dangerous branch. Routledge, 2018. Wilson, Woodrow. Constitutional government in the United States. Routledge, 2017.

Vernonia School District Vs. Acton Essay - Honors U.S. History - Reasearch Paper

456 words - 2 pages jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws". This means in the case of James Acton that the school cannot search James without a warrant or his consent. The family lost in the U.S. district court but the court of appeals decided that the school district had violated his fourth amendment rights and those of the Oregon Constitution. Though after that the school filed appeal against this and the case was brought to the supreme court. And in 1995, four

Thesis on Healthcare in the United States - UT Austin ACC366P - Thesis Research Paper

3027 words - 13 pages income pay less than 5%; the middle 10%, just under 10%; and the highest 10%, between 10% and 15%. However, there is no direct healthcare tax in Canada, and coverage is paid for via general government revenues. Thus, it is difficult to determine the exact dollar amount each family contributes to this cause, as these revenues are sourced from income taxes, import duties, pensions, and more. Because the United States government already operates on a

Research Paper On The Wage Gap In The United States, And Class Struggles From The Underclass With Sources Included

3633 words - 15 pages class distinctions that were present in Europe's feudal system or the caste systems of India; however, I believe when it comes to the United States people are either confused, uneducated, or in a state of denial because the issue of class in America is seldom discussed or acknowledged. However, if the working class ever intend on ascending in class rank they must at the very least acknowledge what they are up against. I will hopefully be able show

Graphing in States with No Academic Mandering - The True Size of States - Government - Research Paper

1901 words - 8 pages Sample Size Calculations for the Modular Grant Application Process Outcome Evaluation Study One purpose of this paper is to describe and illustrate the methods used to determine the sample sizes for the Modular Grant Application Process (MGAP) Outcome Evaluation Study. The sampling strategy for this study involves selecting a simple random sample without replacement from four of the six study populations. (A census was used for the remaining two

Public Good in the United States - Virginia Commonwealth University, Political Economics - Argumentative Paper

1611 words - 7 pages Public Good By: Rebecca Hang Global poverty is a battle we have been fighting for as long as most can remember. It is an intriguing and important topic to be informed about because first, the rate at which individuals are dying due to poverty. An average of 25,000 children under the age of five die each day, from preventable interventions. And second, if we look at the statistics, there is no reason global 1 poverty should be as severe as it is