Essay On Free Will Vs. Hard Determinism (Philosophy) Introduction To Philosophy/Bellarmine University Essay

815 words - 4 pages

Circumstances: Self-Made or Natural?
Many people have wondered throughout the world, why am I in the position I am right
now? How did my life go so wrong/right? Some may answer that their circumstances are a result
of their own decisions, while others may say the reason is because of the “universe”. To
understand both perceptions, Richard Taylor’s Agency Theory and Baron d’Holbach’s Hard
Determinism Theory will be analyzed. By comparing, contrasting, and examining the two
theories it will be concluded that Richard Taylor’s Agency Theory and the belief in free will is
the superior theory.
Richard Taylor’s Agency Theory is centered on the idea of free will. Free will is the idea
of one’s ability to act at his/her own discretion. Taylor describes two actions every human does
which coincides with the theory of free will. First, he brings up the action of deliberation.
Deliberation is when people think about which action to take, this or that. Deliberation is an
example of free will because it involves one making up his/her own mind. Second, Taylor brings
up a point that we often overlook. He brings up the feeling that it is up to the person about what
he/she will do and he uses the example of one’s want and ability to move his/her own finger any
which way he/she wants. Taylor’s theory can easily take on other theories such as simple
indeterminism and soft determinism. Simple indeterminism states that many things people do
happen at random. With that said, simple indeterminism means that the vast majority of human
activity would have no meaning and be highly unpredictable. Soft determinism states that human
behavior and actions are wholly determined by causal events, but where human free will does
exist it is still shaped by external factors such as heredity, society, upbringing, etc. However,
when looking at a person-by-person analysis it does not hold up. For example, if you were to
look at a person who was raised in the inner city in an impoverished neighborhood where there
are drugs and a high crime rate you would expect that person, according to soft determinism, to
either be involved with drugs or crime. While that may be true for some individuals, how does
that explain people like Ben Carson who was raised in government-subsidized housing and
raised by a single mother in an area riddled with crime, but is today one of the best
neurosurgeons in the country and in 2016 was a candidate in the...

Other Essays On Essay on Free Will vs. Hard Determinism (Philosophy) - Introduction to Philosophy/Bellarmine University - Essay

Utilitarianism and John Stuart Mill - Hofstra University; Philosophy 14 - Essay

656 words - 3 pages process of gaining pleasure. This is known as the Right Action Theory which further states that people are motivated by an interest in what they have to gain from their actions. John Stuart Mill then goes on to believe that there are different measures and different kinds of pleasures. Some pleasures are more superior to others and it differentiates the amount of happiness that they can bring to each individual. He mentions “of two pleasures, if

An Analysis of the Free Will Problem - UNT - Philosophy - Psychology

1506 words - 7 pages , in context of an ever-expanding pool of choices and options of human development, does exist, allowing for contextualization and creativity to function in tandem with one another. To begin this argument, there is an importance to be put on the three main argumentative stances. Fully understanding each position’s main points of contention is key to developing a fully fleshed out perspective of what free will is and is not. First, we will discuss

Hate Speech in Public Areas and Universities - The University of New Mexico, Philosophy 156 - Essay

1710 words - 7 pages The University of New Mexico Hate Speech in Public Areas and Universities Joseph A. Armijo Philosophy 156-005 Mr. James Bodington 5/06/17 Word Count: 1,712 The freedom of speech is protected under the First Amendment of our constitution. Through this right, great strides or acts have been made that are revered in American history. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. was able to take steps in abolishing segregation through his powerful and effective

The Philosophy of Intelligent Design - Portland State University / Critical thinking - Essay

777 words - 4 pages this isn’t to say that the information you obtain from the internet can’t be interpreted on a deeper level once the user is no longer on the web. I don’t necessarily agree that the internet weakens our critical thinking as a whole, but it does affect it while one is “plugged in”, so to say. I would argue that the average person thinks more critically today than ever before in human history. With that, I will say that I believe critical thinkers are

Philosophy: Ethical Perspectives - Griffith University - Assignment

3127 words - 13 pages our students and pushing them towards actualising their potential, because meeting their needs is our priority. The function of our educational system and the work of our teachers is constructed to meet our students’ necessities with careful intervention, so that they never feel completely dependent on their teachers’ will, but rather self-direct and gratify their own talents and desires. This confirms that we defend students against dishonour or

Paper #2 Philosophy of the Human Person - St. Johns University - Philosophy

1157 words - 5 pages for what gives us the most joy. We are probably not going to go for things that will cause agony and distress. Hobbes underpins his origination of human joy by giving thinking in which his proposed origination of human bliss applies. As expressed in his contention hunger with a desire for progress is expectation and craving without such desire is called give up, by wanting to have wealth we fulfill our substantial hungers for material joys

Personal Nursing Philosophy Paper - Liberty University Nurs 502 - Assignment

1524 words - 7 pages Running Head: PERSONAL NURSING PHILOSOPHY 1 PERSONAL NURSING PHILOSOPHY PAPER 1 Personal Nursing Philosophy Paper Jovana Saunders Liberty University Abstract Nursing philosophy described as a personal definition, I provide a comprehensive discussion of personal philosophy related to accountability, compassion and professionalism that drives my personal practice. Life and career experiences are used to demonstrate application of philosophy

What is Socrates’ argument that no harm can come to a good man - Thompson River University PHIL-1110 - Philosophy Paper

1524 words - 7 pages took the Oracle’ proclamation of himself as the wisest man of all (pg.2) as secondary proof of the soul. Since he is the wisest, it follows that he must be correct; there is a soul and it is eternal. He says that killing him will only free his soul from its earthly entrapments, leaving it either free to wander a pleasant afterlife or enjoy a sleep free from pain, as previously mentioned. He builds on this certainty of the existence of the soul

Deontology, Act Utilitarianism and the Pursuit of Autonomy - McMaster University, Philosophy - Case Study

1456 words - 6 pages world where everyone coerced one another, free will would cease to exist. The second of Kant’s formulations states that you must never treat people as a mere means, but always at the same time as your ends (Boetzkes & Waluchow, 2000). Sylvia and Jack’s actions also fail the second formulation, as they are using Olive as a means by coercing her into donating her kidney in order to save their daughter Nancy. Furthermore, Kant emphasizes that

Is Seeing Believing- Answering the long anticipated question cn w believ what we see - Philosophy, University Of Nottingham - Essay

462 words - 2 pages perceive . Everyone’s eyes have a blind spot where the optic nerves connect it to the brain so the brain can fill in and practically guess what goes in that spot. Quite reliable ,huh? While on the subject of eyes , humans are 1 of many species on this earth and our vision is not always the same . For example , bees see the world in tiny fragments that form a honeycomb looking lens. They would pretty much see us like this. Then you have snakes who

Mind Over Matter- Philosophy essay - Philosophy - Essay

1953 words - 8 pages and analysing his opinions on gay marriage, abortion, and drug legalization. According to him, it does not matter what these people think they have the right to do. It matters what his perceived ideal form of culture is like, and how their actions will affect others. Again, the individual does not have choice. He is subject to the state, however unlike Nietzsche or Aristotle, Adam does not follow naturalistic ethics. Devoid of any role for reason

Similar Papers

Hard Determinism: True Or False Philosophy Philosophy 101 Essay

1377 words - 6 pages actions are predetermined by factors outside of our control; we do not have the ability to decide for ourselves. Many philosophers have made strong and sound arguments for each stance however, in this essay I examine the question of free will. I attempt to show through a hard deterministic view that free will is merely an illusion. I, then,attempt to show the implications hard determinism has on morals. Hard Determinism is a philosophical position

A Paper On Free Will And What It Means To You Philosophy Research Paper

1552 words - 7 pages philosophers have not been successful at this attempt despite their deliberation. This paper discusses the concept of free will with a particular bias to the take of the philosopher Aristotle. The paper also explores the different theories on this topic including determinism, indeterminism compatibilism, and incompatibilism. The paper will give compelling evidence to support Aristotle’s position that free will is possible and it does exist. Aristotle

Virtue Ethics In Jouralism Question Philosophy, University Of Warwick Essay

1876 words - 8 pages position, etc. In this case, there are some journalists have never hacked and will never hack, it is the partial virtue of their disposition which involved in their job; in contrast to those journalists who are doing phone-hacking, they are not only living without virtuously but also without a life. 3. Modern Theory (Neo-Aristotelian) Compare to classic theory, modern moral philosophy recommends that ethics should instead focus on how to form our

Anger According To Aristotle And Seneca Xavier University Of Louisiana Philosophy Essay

764 words - 4 pages Khamryn Stansell October 23, 2018 Happiness and Meaning of Life Section 2 Word Count: 759 The Depths of Anger: Aristotle vs Seneca Everyday humans are faced with many emotions. Some are easier to control than others. Out of the various emotions that we continuously feel, there is only one that can’t be hidden. Most of your emotions can be covered or faked but anger is the only emotion that will always reveal itself no matter the situation. This