Essay On Letters Of Heloise And Abelard Dartmouth College Hist 42 Essay

902 words - 4 pages

1
B. McCallister
Brady McCallister
Professor Simons
History 42
28 September 2018
Heloise: Misogynistic or Infatuated?
Heloise d’Argenteuil and Peter Abelard, the infamous star-crossed lovers of the 12th Century, exchanged a series of letters fifteen years after their notorious affair. These letters, while intriguing to many for their enchanting and passionate nature, provide significant insight into the realities of gender roles during the time period. Heloise, as evidenced in her direct confrontations of Peter, was an exceptionally assertive and strong willed individual. Curiously, however, Heloise makes rather misogynistic claims throughout the exchange that seem to contradict her intelligent and independent disposition. However, it is likely that this contradiction is more apparent than real because of the influence that her overpowering infatuation for Peter Abelard had on her interactions with him.
Throughout the documented interaction, Heloise continually proves her assertive and intelligent nature via her direct confrontations of Peter. Heloise’s main concern at the time was that Peter had neglected and forgotten her[footnoteRef:1]. She directly questions his character suggesting that lust, not love, inspired his desire for Heloise in the first place[footnoteRef:2]. In addition to questioning his actions in the past, Heloise denounces Peters actions in the present stressing that he owes Heloise and her abbey greater attention[footnoteRef:3]. Heloise goes so far as to say that Peter is wasting his time preaching to swine as opposed to dividing more of his attention to her and her community[footnoteRef:4]. Even Peter, in his public letter to console his friend, recounts Heloise’s unmatched assertiveness as she questioned his ability to abstain from the impurities of bodily pleasures[footnoteRef:5]. Clearly, Heloise demonstrates her sharp and forceful character traits throughout the exchange. She aptly proves her default conviction and establishes what might seem like a relatively egalitarian perspective for the period in which she lived. [1: McLaughlin, Letter 2, 54] [2: McLaughlin, Letter 2, 55] [3: McLaughlin, Letter 2, 52] [4: McLaughlin, Letter 2, 53] [5: McLaughlin, Letter 1, 28]
The most contradictory aspect of Heloise’s disposition, however, is her perspective on gender. There are many instances where Heloise supports misogynistic opinions. Heloise, firstly, does so through her conversations with Peter on marriage. She claims that it is deplorable that Peter would tie himself down to one woman and follows up by saying that any wise man should never take a wife[footnoteRef:6]. Further on, Heloise corroborates the concept that the baneful influence of women did afflict most severely the greatest of men[footnoteRef:7]. Many times Heloise comments in this vein marking women as evil or inferior to men. For example, in asking Peter to divide more of his attention to Heloise and the abbey, she...

Other Essays On Essay on Letters of Heloise and Abelard - Dartmouth College - Hist 42 - Essay

Murder in Amsterdam and its effect on Immigration - HIST 108 - History Essay

1215 words - 5 pages Amanda Conley HIST 102 Professor Kauffman December 1, 2018 Murder in Amsterdam Ian Buruma in his book Murder in Amsterdam talks about the controversy regarding the assassination of Theo Van Gogh. Van Gogh made a film called Submission. In the film verses from the Koran were projected onto women’s naked bodies. This was a not so subtle attempt to show the oppression of women in Muslim communities. On November 2, 2004 Van Gogh was shot in the

Poetry analysis of “Letters to Martha” - ENG2603 - Essay

974 words - 4 pages 56780036 ENG2603 Assignment 1 1. Poetry analysis of “Letters to Martha” The letters were written by Dennis Brutus during his incarceration on Robben Island. During this time he wrote numerous poetic letters to his wife, Martha. The writer employs the use of metaphor to describe his feelings of containment during his time in solitary confinement. The poem I will be analyzing in the following essay is with reference to the metaphor of

Letters from Hernando Cortes to Charles V - Union County College/ History - essay

561 words - 3 pages Letters from Hernando Cortes to Charles V In the “Two letters to Charles V: On the Conquest of the Aztecs” written by Hernando Cortes in 1521 to the King of Spain and Holy Roman Emperor Charles V, Cortes describes the events that happened during his course in the New World, or as we call it today, the Americas. He also provides results from the conquest of the Aztec Empire of Mexico and he explains the reasoning behind the conditions of how it

A question of Sovereignty in the US - HIST 100 - Essay

1131 words - 5 pages , but not without first creating a set of conditions known as the Declaration of Rights. The Declaration of rights was in short, “a set of limitations and conditions imposed on William and Mary.” (Lecture, 01/24). However, the people were not necessarily pushing towards any new political ideals, they just wanted a Protestant King to rule fairly and not infringe on what they considered to be “ancient rights”.  The first hint of popular sovereignty

Neoplatonic Philosphers Of The 11th Century The Major Philosophies Of Anselm, Al-Ghazali, Abelard And Acquinas

2232 words - 9 pages when simplified to the fact that under the confines of our minds rationalism and individualism does exist. More importantly is the common bond, in this case faith, which the individuals share. For this, faith, exists separately from our mind, with it's own rights. This is very similar to the Islamic philosopher Al-Ghaliza who also put emphases on religion but did not deny that rationalism doesn't exist. Another view of Peter Abelard that was

The Emotional Effect of Poetic Structure on “Leda and the Swan” - College English 105 - Essay

674 words - 3 pages English 105.A01 4 November 2018 The Emotional Effect of Poetic Structure on “Leda and the Swan” The poem “Leda and the Swan” by W.B. Yeats is a poetic retelling of Zeus’s rape of Leda in Greek Mythology. According to the original myth, Zeus transformed himself physically into the form of a beautiful swan. As the swan, Zeus came to Leda and forced himself upon her, raping her. Poets make crucial choices every time they create a new work. They

The Roles of Advice Literature, Experts, and Child-Savers in the 19th and 20th Century Childrearing - The University of Memphis/ HIST 4863 - Essay

969 words - 4 pages , missionaries, and charity workers who were concerned with child welfare (2). Experts printed advice literature on parent-child relations and childrearing, and developed institutions as safe environments in which poor children could escape from the negative influences of the streets (3). Child-savers also influenced several aspects of children's' lives, such as child abuse, child labor laws, and the development of the juvenile justice system. The advice

Witchcraft and the Malevolance of the Susect: Targetting Midwives and others in Early Modern England - university of regina HISt 225 - Essay

1305 words - 6 pages Witchcraft in England gave rise to the most oppressive and sexist accusations in the seventeenth century. It was a fact that people sighted and witnessed unruly conduct, and sometimes immediately or after a while, exploit suspicious ‘maleficium’ practitioners to authorities in an English society deeply rooted with patriarchal hierarchies. This is the genesis of the ‘uneven distribution of witchcraft accusations bearing on the lives of women

Letters Of John And Abigail Adams- A Love Story

619 words - 3 pages emancipation and kept her husband up-to-date on the politics at home. The letters chronicle the passion that these two had for each other. It is a stereotype of their time that the woman of the house was to sit back and the husband was the strictly the enforcer and master. In this marriage, that was not so. For more than a decade, John and Abigail were away from each other while John traveled across America and abroad. During this time, many

Analysis of Mouzi's Disposing of Error - University of Georgia Hist 3661 - Essay

1696 words - 7 pages Jonathan Book HIST 3661 4/5/2018 Foreign in Name Only Mouzi, in his Disposing of Error, counters attacks on Buddhism by champions of classic Confusion teachings as well as Daoist philosophies. In a back and forth in which naysayers ask questions and express doubts about Buddhism, Mouzi uses rhetorical devices to diffuse concerns and promote Buddhism. These arguments include metaphor and simile to relate foreign ideas to natural observances

China's Impact on Japan and Korea - college freshman - Essay

436 words - 2 pages Unit 3 Essay: China's Impact on Japan and Korea You have now read a chapter on the early history of East Asia that focused primarily on the history of China but also included the equally important early histories of Japan and Korea. In an essay of approximately 800 words, please explain when and how Japan’s and Korea’s histories were impacted by China, but also what was unique about the historical development of each. To do so, you will want to

Similar Papers

Effect Of Imperialism On My Ancestors Solano Community College Fall Hist 018 History Essay

1548 words - 7 pages consonant with a capitalist revolution. But on the contrary it added to the existing strata of parasitic elites.”My ancestors were exploited and denied the opportunity to advance economically in their clan grouping. Score 6: Responses at this score point demonstrate effective skill in writing an argumentative essay. · The writer generates an argument that critically engages with multiple perspectives on the given issue. The argument’s

Letters Of John And A Big Agreement Letter Troy Essay

3722 words - 15 pages DOCUMENT 7–2 Letters of John and Abigail Adams While the Second Continental Congress deliberated in Philadelphia on the colonial crisis, Massachusetts delegate John Adams maintained a correspondence with his wife, Abigail, who remained at home. A leader in the independence movement, Adams exchanged news, ideas, and concerns with his wife. The following selections from the Adams’s correspondence illustrates the determination tempered by anxiety

Analysis Of Ouyang Xiu's Essay On Fundamentals University Of Georgia Hist 3662 Essay

1207 words - 5 pages 4 Jonathan Book 9/6/2018 HIST 3662 First Essay Trunk Before the Branches Through the use of natural, architectural, and medical metaphors Ouyang Xiu, in his “Essay on Fundamentals,” confronts the issues of lackluster policy and institutions in the Song and the ever-present threat, which he argues, Buddhism poses to the moral fortitude of the citizens in the Song Empire. Ouyang compares empires to trees needing a strong foundation, dynasties to

The Effects Of Slavery On African American Children The University Of Memphis/ Hist 4863 Essay

1161 words - 5 pages Heather Alexander History 4863 Midterm Question 1 The Effects of Slavery on African American Children The practice of slavery caused the suffering of millions of African Americans from the year 1619 until the 13th amendment finally abolished the practice in 1865. Throughout a nearly 250-year span, an estimated 12 million Africans were forced into slavery by Americans, with a fourth being youth and adolescents (1). Slave owners considered slave