Evaluate The Contribution Of Interview Research To Our Understanding Of Friendship. Undergraduate Psychology Essay

1102 words - 5 pages

Evaluate the contribution of interview research to our understanding of friendship.
The use of interview has long been used by researchers to elicit information from questions in order to better understand a topic from that person's perspective. In relation to friendship, interviews are a very useful tool as it allows researchers to give rich detail on their thoughts and feelings in response to the question. Despite this, being based on individuals means its use as a method can limit its generalisability to wider environments such as different races and locations, therefore it is difficult to theorise to a wider scale using this qualitative method which is a challenge in understanding friendship, so other methods could be better served.
A key study of friendship was conducted by Bigelow and La Gaipa (1975, as cited by Brownlow, 2012) who were interested in the development of friendships as children grew. They asked 480 children to write an essay about their expectations of their best friend. This method allowed a large sample size to be collected quickly as if they had conducted individual interviews they would have required a trained interviewer, and the time required to conduct interviews to this scale would have been expensive and time-consuming. Bigelow and La Gaipa took this qualitative data and made it quantitative by using content analysis. Before the essays,  they identified 21 categories that could be used to analyse the essays with and the frequency of these topics could be noted to highlight patterns and trends within the wider data. From this data, Bigelow and La Gaipa (1975, as cited by Brownlow, 2012) concluded that friendship becomes more complex with age and began to develop a model that showed the evolution of friendship and its expectations as children grew up. This transition from qualitative to quantitative data enabled these developments, which is now regarded as a key foundation of our understanding of friendships and this would not have been possible using a pure interview method as the conclusions could not be drawn from qualitative data.
McLeod et al (2008, as cited by Brownlow, 2012) used the method of interviews to investigate the social context and reasoning for smoking and its correlation to friends. Much of the early research into friendship viewed adolescents as passive recipients of peer influence but through McLeod and other research, they are now seen as playing an active role in selecting peers meaning influence is a far more complex dynamic (Brownlow, 2012). McLeod (2008) used 14 pairs of identical twins, aged between 27 and 33, and conducted interviews with the smoking and non-smoking twin. Using twins eliminates a number of variables like genetic differences allowing the researcher to focus on the effects of friends on this outcome as many of the twins said they had differing social groups. McLeod found that many of the smokers highlighted social mobility as a key reason, as smoking gave them access to a particular group they wanted to associate with, or just like the image that came with that. Whilst nobody said they were forced to smoke, they did acknowledge that the peers they wanted to be with did smoke and therefore it was just something to do. Non-smokers cited a dominant non-smoking image was present within their circles. Both of these groups were therefore aware of creating a social image thereby developing and maintaining a sense of collective identity.
The use of interview in McLeod's research enabled flexibility when talking to participants by being able to follow up with questions regarding interesting points that may have been raised. This exploration can gain a greater understanding of one's reasons for the act of smoking in this example rather than a quantitative method such as observation where context can be lost. An example of this comes from William Damon (1977, as cited by Brownlow, 2012) who conducted interviews on children between 4 and 9 into their understanding of things like gender roles and their feelings towards their peers. Damon (1977) and Bigelow and La Gaipa (1975) both touched on these same issues but using this different method. Damon (1977) found that an understanding of friendship was found in younger children that had previously been theorised through the use of interviews. The textual data collected could be analysed in greater detail than by Bigelow and La Gaipa’s (1975) essays, as it was not in an effort to generalise the findings, but to illustrate ideas and conclusions from the individual children. Interviewing young children can be problematic, as they can find it difficult to vocalise complex thoughts and feelings, particularly to a stranger interviewing them. It is also possible that interviews can lead to social desirability bias where the participant is providing answers they believe the researcher is looking for. Similarly, interviewers can suffer from researcher bias when using leading questions to elicit responses they require but are not genuine.
Corsaro (2006, as cited by Brownlow, 2012) provided further insight into the development of friendship using an ethnographic approach, where he observed and interacted with children in a real-life setting and was able to record responses and interactions which could be analysed. Being involved in the group can lead to greater understanding as context and subtle influences arent missed like when observing from outside the group. The natural interactions produce rich data, but this can again be difficult to generalise to a wider setting.
In conclusion, the use of interviews for exploring complex processes like the development of friendship can provide real insight into the deeper meanings behind interactions. Particularly when investigating specific items like smoking in McLeods (2008) research where great detail is needed to uncover themes. Despite these positives, interviews are resource intensive and lack the ability to be put into a greater context as it does not contain generalisability in most circumstances. This lends itself to being an excellent secondary research method to build on a quantitative measure like observation or survey. Interviews could then be used to identify themes and provide greater insight into topics, to provide the depth required to produce models and prove hypothesise.
(999)
Bigelow, B.J. and La Gaipa, J.J., 1975. Children's written descriptions of friendship: A multidimensional analysis. Developmental Psychology, 11(6), p.857.
Brownlow, C. ‘Making Friends’ in Brace, N. and Byford J. (eds) Investigating Psychology, Oxford, Oxford University Press/Milton Keynes, The Open University, pp. 237–269
.
Damon, W., 1977. The social world of the child (p. 137). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
McLeod, K., White, V., Mullins, R., Davey, C., Wakefield, M. and Hill, D., 2008. How do friends influence smoking uptake? Findings from qualitative interviews with identical twins. The Journal of genetic psychology, 169(2), pp.117-132.

RELATED

Contribution Of Leakey Family To Our Increased Understanding Of Human Evolution

741 words - 3 pages remarkable discovery, announced in the journal Nature, has profound implications in understanding the origins of mankind. In its front-page story on March 22, 2001, The New York Times wrote that the discovery "threatens to overturn the prevailing view that a single line of descent stretched through the early stages of human ancestry.field research in Turkana has focused on finding evidence of the very earliest human ancestors, concentrating on sites

Critically evaluate the evidence for and against geographical profiling - Undergraduate Psychology - Essay

1420 words - 6 pages Critically evaluate the evidence for and against geographical profiling Birmingham City University There are many possibilities that criminals can have that will affect their choice regarding their location to commit a crime. Geographic profiling is an investigative methodology that analyses the locations of a connected series of crime to determine the most credible area of an offender’s base (Rossmo, 2000). Its key purpose is to assist the

our response to mental illness: analysis - philosophy of psychology - essay

1677 words - 7 pages , and more importantly, if the goals, actions and reasonings can be justified on ethical grounds. In this essay I will be exploring mental health through an ethical lens, in order to highlight significant issues that stem from the influence that the current models for the classifications, diagnosis and treatments of mental illnesses and psychiatric disorders have on how patients are perceived and addressed on a societal, institutional, and

Outline and evaluate the ethological explanation of aggression - psychology - essay 16 marker

672 words - 3 pages Outline and evaluate the ethological explanation of aggression (16 marks) In his book, On Aggression, Lorenz (1966) stressed that as humans are animals and therefore show similar behaviour to other animals, his ethological research could be generalised onto humans as part of the evolutionary approach to explaining human aggression. Lorenz proposed four main driving forces behind the behaviour of any animal: fear, hunger, reproduction and

Second wave of Feminism in Canada: contribution to the passing of gender-discrimination laws - History - Essay

1644 words - 7 pages History essay Did the Second Wave of Feminism in the 1960s and 1970s contribute to the passing of gender based anti-discrimination bills in Canada? In the late 19th century, many Canadian women, feeling repressed and under-represented, developed a strong sense of feminism. They paid closer attention to the inequality between themselves and men around them, and strove to create change in the way they were treated. Women started to speak up for

Art review: Undergraduate Homecoming Exhibit - Understanding the Visual of Arts - Assignment

553 words - 3 pages Free the gallery. The only suggestion is expanding the story and understanding of what you’re trying to tell others and our generation. A lot of great things are being told on the campus of Southern University, but that’s just SU. Our African American nation need to be aware for them to have the right to understand.

The Contribution Of Jean Piaget To Cognitive Development

2740 words - 11 pages solutions to a problem and the ability to reason about the possible as well as the actual.Jean Piaget made an immeasurable contribution to our knowledge of cognitive development in children. His theories have had a huge influence on education and psychology. In the mid twentieth centaury, behaviorists such as John Watson and B.F. Skinner, took a different approach in explaining cognitive development in children, for example, both Watson and Skinner

Assess The Significance Of Garibaldi's Contribution To Italian Unification

1012 words - 5 pages revolutions of 1848 reached him and he decided to return to his homeland. He did this with some out of date weapons and some of his colleagues. Word of his military campaigns in South America had by now reached the Italian States and upon his return, recruits assembled to join Garibaldi's legion.Garibaldi's contribution in South America had a profound effect on events later on in the fight for unification, as it was due to his military involvement that

The Will to Power as a neccesary negation of Friendship in Lord of teh Rings - Christendom College/Inklings - Research Paper

3273 words - 14 pages 3 Maria McFadden HIST/ENG 409 Dr. Schwartz November 29, 2017 THE WILL TO POWER NECCESARILY NEGATES FRIENDSHIP AS SHOWN IN THE LORD OF THE RINGS TRILOGY In the well-known trilogy, The Lord of The Rings, John Ronald Ruel Tolkien proposes a philosophical question, which he answers throughout the trilogy in the actions of his characters and their rightful consequences. Here is brought to question the relationship between the will to power and the

explore the aspects of modernity that were of greatest concern to Durkheim - sociology undergraduate - essay

1233 words - 5 pages is harmful as to him it would mean society is progressively falling apart. References Durkheim, E. and Lukes, S. (2014). The rules of sociological method. [Place of publication not identified]: Free Press. Hamilton, P. (1995). Emile Durkheim. 2nd ed. London: Routledge. McLuhan, M. (1965). Understanding media; the extension of man. New York: McGraw-Hill Book Company.

Information On The Contribution Of One Of The Following To The Development Of Space Exploration: Tsiolkovsky

698 words - 3 pages Konstantin Eduardovitch Tsiolkovsky1857-1935Konstantin Tsiolkovsky was a true visionary and pioneer of astronautics. He theorized many aspects of human space travel and rocket propulsion decades before others, and played an important role in the development of the Soviet and Russian space programs.He was born on September 17,1857, in the village of Ijevskoe, Ryasan Province, Russia, the son of a Polish forester who had emigrated to Russia. He

outline and evaluate the behavioural approach to treating phobias - A level Psychology - essay

530 words - 3 pages Free Arusha Ezaz Rahman Emily Browne 6 March 2018 Outline and evaluate the behavioural approach to treating phobia A phobia is an extreme or irrational fear of or aversion to something, which according to the behavioural approach, can be caused by the social learning theory, classical conditioning or even operant conditioning. Phobias cause significant problems in a persons life and it may hamper their ability to cope with the demands of everyday

The Truth of The Digital Persona - Undergraduate - Essay

2580 words - 11 pages Free purpose of this essay is to examine the validity of the statement ‘As we have full creative and editorial control of our social media profiles’, these represent the truest version of the self with regard to Goffman theoretical framework and consider the impact of digital communications on human interactionism. In his aptly titled work, The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life, sociologist Erving Goffman analyses human identity construction and

Theme of Friendship with examples - English - Essay

859 words - 4 pages Free Friendship is a strong bond between two or more people that allows on another to gain each others trust and moral support. This type of relationship is portrayed in a lot of books, movies, and TV shows, to allow people to look up to them and grow with their own friendships. Out of all of the themes in the book ​The Death Cure, ​I think this theme is portrayed the most because they have to learn to trust each other and know that they will all be

Neighbourhood influences contribution to interventions to support families with young children - psychology 2nd year - essay

4564 words - 19 pages Discuss whether increased understanding of neighbourhood influences has contributed to interventions to support families with young children, with reference to theories and research evidence. Discuss whether increased understanding of neighbourhood influences has contributed to interventions to support families with young children, with reference to theories and research evidence – Jacqueline Barnes. Every human being that has existed derives