Evaluation Of The Effectiveness Of Trade Embargoes

1310 words - 6 pages

Evaluation of the Effectiveness of Trade EmbargoesAlthough I am a strong critic of the use and effectiveness of economic sanctions, such as trade embargoes, for the sake of this assignment, I will present both their theoretical advantages and their disadvantages based upon my research. Trade embargoes and blockades have traditionally been used to entice nations to alter their behavior or to punish them for certain behavior. The intentions behind these policies are generally noble, at least on the surface. However, these policies can have side effects. For example, FDR's blockade of raw materials against the Japanese in Manchuria in the 1930s arguably led to the bombing of Pearl Harbor, which ...view middle of the document...

At the same time, trade sanctions may narrow the domestic support of authoritarian regimes and aggravate internal divisions.Economic sanctions can raise the cost of trade and finance to the targeted nations, but in most cases do not ruin their economies. Denied finance can compound the cost to the target country by inhibiting its ability to engage in trade without formal trade controls being imposed. Over time the target nation can develop alternative suppliers and markets, although at increased cost. The target country may receive economic or military aid from other countries opposing the embargoes. If "saving face" is important to the target nation, or if the embargo receives substantial publicity, it may provoke a backlash from the targeted regime and instead increase violent conflict. Backlash from the sender's allies may be exacerbated if attempts are made to enforce the sanctions extraterritorially.WeaknessesSkeptics question whether the costs paid by senders of trade embargoes are worth the benefits derived, or if the costs to innocent groups in the target countries are justified. Trade embargoes often do not succeed in changing the behavior of other countries, depending on various factors. In contrast to most foreign and defense actions financed by the government treasury, the embargo's costs are mostly felt by businesses whose trade is affected. They can amount to a discriminatory, sector-specific tax to finance foreign policy. Complaints of losses to domestic firms may undermine an embargo's initiative when it interrupts trade and financial contacts; businesses may fear loss of their reputation for reliability. Trade embargoes may alienate the sender's foreign allies.Popular regimes are more vulnerable than authoritarian regimes to domestic pressure for the state to change its behavior. Governments with high degrees of control over information can manipulate the public to blame foreign countries for unjustifiably inflicting damages against them. Embargoes can impose a high cost on noncombatants in the target country.In addition to trade embargoes, diplomatic sanctions such as breaking bilateral ties or denying a target country organizational membership, deny sender states and organizations some of their direct leverage against the target regime.Sender governments may fail to honor their commitments to enforce embargoes, gaining political advantage from cooperating in international efforts while reaping economic benefits by looking the other way as their companies evade the embargoes and illicitly take over the market share of other sanctioning countries.Trade embargoes are blunt tools with limited ability to focus economic pressure against particular groups in the target society. They can have substantial inadvertent adverse impact on the economy and non-targeted population groups; more authoritarian regimes may use their population's suffering to motivate senders to lift sanctions. Senders can try to design embargoes to impact most...

Other Essays On Evaluation Of The Effectiveness Of Trade Embargoes

The Results Of The Introduction Of The Commertial Fur Trade Into Canada

731 words - 3 pages An essay describing the effects of the fur trade on the Native peoples of Canada Excellent.EssayThe trapping of beavers for their fur had always been an integral part of native culture. The introduction of the profit-seeking fur trade caused drastic changes in the native way of life. These changes ultimately concluded with the destruction of an enormous part of native culture. It can be said that, "The introduction of the commercial fur trade

Is The U.S. Using The Issue Of Truck Safety As A Trade Barrier To Mexico?

884 words - 4 pages 1. Is the U.S. using the issue of truck safety as a trade barrier? What proof can you offer?I think U.S. is using the issue of truck safety as a trade barrier because the increase in Mexican trucks within the limited border zone has had an adverse affect on safety in the U.S. For example, in Texas border counties, within the commercial border zone, have seen a dramatic increase in highway fatalities and serious injuries from truck with Mexican

Are there any arguments to be made that self-sufficiency is desirable? What would be the arguments of those who contend that trade in cultural relics should be strictly state-regulated?

395 words - 2 pages (Vinod K. Aggarwal)Dependency theorists have argued that declining terms of trade particularly declining prices of primary commodities without corresponding drops in prices of manufactured goods-could permanently impair the ability of developing countries to compete in the global economy. More radical theorists argued for a break with the capitalist world, suggesting that trade with rich, advanced capitalist countries will always be detrimental

Man Of The People

937 words - 4 pages Being set in the 60s, Chinua Achebe's book A Man of The People, introduces the reader to the social and political upheaval that was prevalent in the newly liberated African countries. Achebe skillfully weaves underlying themes like nationalism, empirism, corruption and the effects of western influence into the story. The quality of Achebe's writing is also seen in the way he presents one or a combination of these themes in his characters. Chinua

The Future Of Management

747 words - 3 pages Article SummaryTo see the future of management and where the current trends are leading, look first to the past. Look at the foundations upon which management theory was built. Fayol, Taylor, Weber and MacGregor (Warner, 2003) each contributed to the field at critical times in recent history. The introduction and in some cases, subsequent discard of their individual and collective theories points to the idea that the future in this subject is

The Lady Of Shalott

1132 words - 5 pages The Lady of Shalott written by Lord Tennyson is a mythical poem about a worman's love for an unattainable man. One interpretation regarding the function of the morror is crucial to identifying before one can fully grasp the rest of the poem. One comes to this conclusion because the function of the mirror is derectly responsible for what happens in the rest of the poem. This statement denotes that the fulfillment of the rest of the Lady of

Lord Of The Flies

284 words - 2 pages On an island where no established civilization exists, fear consumes all and converts human beings into savages. In Lord of the Flies by Golding, Jack lures small children into his tribe, and controls them through means of fear. Jack, the chief hunter, ensnares susceptible children with a scarce delicacy -- meat. Through the children's fear of hunger, Jack is able to impose his will upon the members of his tribe. As they hear more about the

The Purpose Of Accounting

1362 words - 6 pages The Purpose for AccountingAccording to BusinessWeek.com, accounting and finance play a huge role in every business. Without the proper accounting practices, a business cannot truly understand the financial position of the company and how to position it for the future. In order for any business or entity to be successful it starts with understanding and knowing the purpose and meaning of accounting. Accounting and financial statements are the

The Rate Of Photosynthesis

3760 words - 16 pages Anas Ahmed 10JCBiology Controlled Assessment- Investigating the rate of photosynthesisAll living things require energy to carry out their life processes. The green plants obtain their energy from sunlight for their life processes. They capture the solar energy and then convert it into a chemical energy. Photosynthesis is an important process , to plants, because they produce glucose and they use the glucose to produce other important and useful

The Structure Of DNA

1225 words - 5 pages PAGE PAGE 1 The Structure of DNA The Structure of DNADNA, or deoxyribonucleic acid, is the hereditary material in humans and almostall other organisms. Nearly every cell in a person's body has the same DNA. Most DNAis located in the cell nucleus (it is called nuclear DNA), but a small amount of DNAcan also be found in the mitochondria (U.S. National Library of Medicine, 2009). ADNA molecule consists of two chains of nucleotides (polymers of

The Drug of Love

453 words - 2 pages This I Believe This I believe, I believe that love is the most powerful drug in the world. Love is an over-the-counter drug that is available to the public. Love is sold in all stores across the world. The stores that carry love are the many people of the world. The only problem with the stores is that some carry to little of the drug . I believe that the access to the drug is not the same in all stores. I believe the store of a woman

Similar Papers

Evaluation Of Stratigic Management Essay

4178 words - 17 pages Introduction"Strategic management is the process of decision making which have high medium term to long term impact on activities of the organization including the implementation of those decisions to create value for customers and key stakeholders and to outperform the competitors"(Hubbard, G., 2000, p-2).Strategic management has three elements such as strategic analysis, strategic choice and strategic implementation. Strategic analysis gives

A Complete Evaluation Of The Country Of Nigeria

1565 words - 7 pages : limestone, petroleum, tin and gases.Nigerians hardly trade with other African countries but they trade with USA, EU and Japan.Nigeria is amongst the worlds leading producers of cacao, palm oil, peanuts, rubber, tin and petroleum. Petroleum is the most valuable resource in Nigeria, most oil fields being found in south-west of Nigeria.Nigerians earnings come from cotton, coffee, gravel and petroleum. If you buy a jar of coffee costing $1 only 8p will

Describe The Step By Step Process Of Evaluation

561 words - 3 pages Describe the step by step process of evaluationThe step by step process of evaluation includes:Safety policy and its objectivesManagement commitment and responsibility: The organisation shall define its safety policy which should be in accordance with international and national requirements reflect organisational commitments regarding safety and provision of the necessary human and financial resources for its implementation. The safety policy

This Essay Discusses The Fair Trade Coffee Movement And The Advantages Of Fair Trade Coffee Over Regular Coffee

1076 words - 5 pages The Fair Trade Certified coffee movement exists today to ensure that the small sizecoffee producers, who make up the majority of the world's coffee production, receive afair price for their coffee. Mass producers of coffee are able to grow their products at acheaper expense, often with lower quality, and as a result, they can sell their coffee for acheaper price. The problem with this is that the smaller producers must lower theircoffee prices