Examine The Controversy That Surrounds The Question Of What Judges Are Doing When They Are Deciding Cases

3717 words - 15 pages

If we accept the hypothesis, that judges do indeed make law through their decisions, we need to look closely at the judges themselves to decide whether they are capable of performing that function. Judges are not, in this country, elected, as are the other law-makers (the legislators). If judges had no law-making role, then the uncertainty over judicial decision making would not arise; it would not matter whether the judiciary was representative of the society within which it operates, or whether it was capable of acting impartially. Lord Denning stated that: "Every judge on his appointment discards all politics and all prejudices. You need have no fear. The Judges of England have always in ...view middle of the document...

The significance of Dworkin's attack on conventionalism, in general, and legal positivism, in particular lies in the failure of such theories to provide either a credible account of the process of law-making or a sufficiently strong defence of individual rights. In the case of McLoughlin v O'Brian the plaintiff was informed by a neighbour that her husband and four children had been injured in a motor-car accident. The neighbour drove her to the hospital where she saw her husband and sons seriously injured, and she was told that her daughter had died. She suffered nervous shock from this experience and sued the negligent driver who caused the accident. As the law stood, a plaintiff could recover damages for nervous shock only where he or she had actually witnessed the accident or arrived at the scene of the accident immediately after. However, the House of Lords reversed the decision of the court of appeal and unanimously held that, despite precedents to the contrary, the plaintiff (Mrs McLoughlin) could recover damages for nervous shock. On 'policy' grounds the Law Lords held that there was nothing in the law to prevent the plaintiff from succeeding. Controversially, Lord Scarman stated that: 'Policy considerations will have to be weighed; but the objective of the judges is the formulation of principle. And, if principle inexorably requires a decision which entails a degree of policy risk, the court's function is to adjudicate according to principle leaving policy curtailment to the judgement of parliament' Dworkin praised Lord Scarman, but he failed to emphasize that the other judges were horrified by these sentiments. As it happened, both Lord Scarman and his colleagues reached the same result in this particular case, but nobody bar Dworkin would want to claim that this isolated passage by lord Scarman had by this stage elevated his US doctrine in British judicial practice.Although it is difficult to determine the ratio of the case it is clear that, in formulating the law, the House of Lords arrived at a decision on the basis of what it regarded as the law. Therefore, according to Dworkin, a conventionalist would say that in this case there is no law and that the judge must therefore exercise a discretion and make new law which is then applied retrospectively to the parties in the case. However, Dworkin believes that '...propositions of law are true if they figure in or follow from the principles of justice, fairness and procedural due process that provide the best constructive interpretation of the community's legal practice' Therefore, in McLoughlin v O'Brian deciding whether the plaintiff should recover involves deciding whether legal practice is seen in a 'better light' if we assume the community has accepted the principle that people in her position are entitled to receive compensation. In other words, in Dworkin's vision of 'law as integrity', a judge must think of himself not (as the conventionalist would have it) as giving voice to his...

Other Essays On Examine The Controversy That Surrounds The Question Of What Judges Are Doing When They Are Deciding Cases

The only people we can feel sorry for in Medea are the children. Everyone else gets what they deserve

581 words - 3 pages The characters of Euripides' play Medea require to be viewed from a variety of perspectives. To say that the only characters that deserve the audience's sympathy are the children is not totally correct. As far as the plot is concerned the children are no doubt the innocent victims of this conflict between Medea and Jason, however there are other characters that also deserve our sympathy. Also to vaguely state that 'everyone else gets what they

What are three ways that the fast food industry is affecting society for the worse - Class - Essay

763 words - 4 pages difference between your smallest and largest circumferences, you should see the average distance traveled go up very quickly as the balloon’s circumference increases. All rockets work by shoving gas out of their nozzles really rapidly. This pushes the rest of the rocket in the other direction, as predicted by Newton’s Third Law: “For every action there is an equal and opposite reaction.” What this means is when you push on something, it pushes back on

Concentration Camps Vs. School: Are They Really That Different?

817 words - 4 pages camp and the feeling of being in school are completely different, if someone has never been to a concentration camp, then school is all they know and that's bad enough. Those who have been to concentration camps have been through a world with bells, fences, fear of the leaders, and the longing to escape, just like students at school.Elie talks about the bells and how they run the show. Bells are the things that tell you when to go from one place

The American Dream For The mice of men book and movie and how they are connected - La eassy - eassy

659 words - 3 pages Russell 1 Russell 1 Roy Russell Ms. Nabaty La 10B 10 June 2016 Truth Of America When people think that their American Dream can be achieved, they are incorrect to what the American Dream is. In the Great Gatsby it is how someone could chase one girl if you love her even if she’s married. Of Mice and Men it is base in the 1920’s so they are saying that making money and owning a home. Anna Quindlen’s essay is talking about the American Dream being

Extended Definition Of Death And The Benifits To Society That Are Not Commonly Discussed

1115 words - 5 pages born it is known that they will one day die. What is a tragic lossto some could be a personal improvement to others. When someone dies for a cause they believe in those that share their beliefs gain by having a role model for their own future actions. In short, death is a new beginning. Thereare three areas to illustrate the positive image of death: personal gains, society gains, and martyrdom.The first area used to illustrate the positive image

There are over millions of robots in the world that created a great universal purpose. - U of M SCMS - There are over millions of robots in the

586 words - 3 pages warzones? They would have much faster reactions, speed, increased strength and these features can be a great beneficial and no humans’ lives would be in danger. Despite all the good from AI Robotics it does have some downfall, it will lead to large amount of jobless people, it might not happen today but in the long run eventually and it will affect many jobs. For example, one of the jobs that might be at risk are call centers, instead of someone

All Programs That Are Aimed At Women And Are Affirmative In Orientation Should Be Abolished Because They Provide For Unfair Discrimination In Favour Of Women

2162 words - 9 pages experience a double burden of work and family responsibilities, given that domestic tasks are still not shared equally between men and women. Women are also more likely to experience interruptions to their careers as a result of having children. As primary carers, they are less able to work the long hours which are sometimes expected of employees in order to gain promotion. Women's full participation in the workforce can also be hindered by lack of

What are the advantages and disadvantages of living away from home to freshmen students?

513 words - 3 pages Living away from homeTo many students coming from distant provinces, the experience of living away from home may be one of the best parts in their university life. This can be really unforgettable and exciting, and at the same time, it has a very important effect on students' life, especially freshmen, as for many of whom, this is their first time living so far away from home in such a long period.The major, and also a very common, problem that

Are there any arguments to be made that self-sufficiency is desirable? What would be the arguments of those who contend that trade in cultural relics should be strictly state-regulated?

395 words - 2 pages to the less developed. Less radical analysts called for policies of temporarily restricting imports so that countries could develop a comparative advantage in higher value added products.Adam Smith argued that it would be foolhardy to purchase higher priced domestically produced goods if such goods were available elsewhere at a lower price. Mutual gains from trade are due to division of labor (advocated by liberal economists). Self-sufficiency

What Are The Major And Minor Harms For Self Tattooing??

437 words - 2 pages What are the major and minor harms for self tattooing?? What makes tattooing so bad that it is illegal until your 18?? People ask some interesting questions. As for the age requirements, it's like drinking, driveling a car, or anything else with an age restriction attached to it! A point I've always argued on this, there are 14 year olds today that have much better judgment that 21 year olds! Age doesn't automatically indicate maturity by no

Who Are The Celts?

5315 words - 22 pages Christian era, and what information comes to us from folklore and artifacts. Druids pursued such things as scholarship, leadership, healing, art, solar holidays, and the old Celtic agricultural festivals. They hold public rituals, that all are invited to attend and participate. They seem to have been responsible for all public religious rituals (private ones were run by the heads of each household). Public ceremonies were most often held in

Similar Papers

What Are Some Of Characteristics That You Would Associate With The American People And Their Society? Why?

2189 words - 9 pages What are some of characteristics that you would associate with the American people and their society? Why?The United States of America - country which is home and shelter for almost 300 millions of people, divided into 50 states. The larges population of many different nations undeniably has many features which are considered as characteristic ones, like obesity, patriotism, mainstream and race diversity. These features are unique for Americans

Ethical Leadership, Understanding The Principles Of Leading When Lives Are At Stake Cu Boulder, Milr4072 Essay

688 words - 3 pages ’ PROFESSIONAL ETHIC— PAST, PRESENT, AND FUTURE, we are given seven principles by which to guide the ethics of our leadership. The first principle reads “Accept service to country as their watchword and defense of the Constitution of the United States of America as their calling. They subordinate their personal interests to the requirements of their professional functions and the accomplishment of assigned missions.” This means that once we accept our

What Are The Benefits Of Exrcise Gym/Pe Essay

972 words - 4 pages Lenin Rodriguez 12/10/2018 GYM/PHYSCIAL EDUCATION What are the benefits of exercise? A question that numerous people tend to ask on a daily basis. Exercise is fundamental and essential for the human body, not only is it beneficial to sustaining our health but helps our self-esteem simultaneously. There are so many perks and benefits to exercising that I personally feel that anyone who is capable should indulge in some form of exercise. It’ll

What Are Stakeholders? Why Can They Influence Organisations? Do Stakeholders Always Have The Same Amount Of Influence Over An Organisation? Why Or Why Not?<Tab/>

427 words - 2 pages great influence on organisations.Stakeholders do always have the same amount of influence over an organisation and the organisation has to take into account when formulating its strategies. It is because stakeholders have a great influence in the organisation. They can simply just withdraw their support from the organisation. Stockholders may sells their shares, employees leave their job and customers but elsewhere. Besides that, suppliers are