Examine The View That Love Is Presented As Something That Is Forbidden Queensbury Academy, Year 13 Essay

1234 words - 5 pages

Rebecca Preece
Examine the View That Love is presented as something that is forbidden
“Atonement” by Ian McEwan and “The Great Gatsby” by F.Scott Fitzgerald both portray social class as being a big factor in the societies they were set in. “Atonement” is set through the 1930-40s where women were adjusting to having more power, for instance in work environments women were being brought in as substitutes for the men away fighting. Social divide meant that those with money could pay for the best education for both their female and male children. In Cecilia’s case, this means an education at Cambridge, however no degree as women were still seen to be the weaker sex. “The Great Gatsby” however was set in the 1920s, as women had just earned the vote and had begun to explore their freedom with sexuality, e.g. flapper dresses, and fame, for instance Jordan Baker being a famous golfer. Women however were definitely seen as the weaker sex, and would be in far more trouble for adultery than men.
Fitzgerald writes Daisy as being “descended from the Dukes of Buccleuch” implying that money and status is of great importance to her, and so the social divide of the nouveau riche from the old money is a running theme. This “old money” trait is shown by Nick knowing this link to rather rich people in his family history. Gatsby however, was a “penniless young man” when he first met Daisy, showing that due to the time period he had to hide who he was in order to be with Daisy, showing the forbidden nature of their relationship. This is shown by the quote “the invisible cloak of his uniform might slip from his shoulders” as the metaphor indicates that he knows the situation is wrong and he is paranoid and anxious that they will know who he is. This shows he knows their relationship is forbidden in societies eyes even as they first met. This social divide is also present in the relationship of Robbie and Cecilia, as Robbie was “the cleaning lady’s son”. This quote shows he is seen as of less importance as he is not being referred to as his own person but in a way that suggests he is lesser due to his mother’s income. The relationship between Cecilia and Robbie would have been disapproved by society, as they saw Cecilia as Robbie’s “Mother’s employer’s daughter” implying that he was not a friend or anything more of hers as he could not be.
McEwan writes Briony as being a large factor in Robbie and Cecilia’s relationship being forbidden as she was in love with Robbie and was the reason behind him being sent to prison and ultimately being sent to war. Briony sees love as a fairytale, “she herself had written a tale in which a humble woodcutter saved a princess from drowning”. This implies her overwhelming urge to relate Robbie and Cecilia’s situation to herself and has a rather selfish attitude to the situation. This is mirrored further in the novel as Robbie recalls her asking “If I fell in the river, would you save me?” This suggests that Briony sees herself...

Other Essays On Examine the View That Love is Presented as Something That is Forbidden - Queensbury Academy, Year 13 - Essay

Bullying is a serious offence that needs to be stopped - Year 8 - Narrative

620 words - 3 pages Why Should Bullying be taken as a Serious Offence? Bullying is something done deliberately against a person or group of people to upset or hurt them or damage their property, reputation or acceptance by others. Bullying can be in person or online, and it can be obvious or hidden. Most bullying occurs at schools, some more severe cases than others. But should bullying be tolerated? Or should bullies be let go? I strongly believe that a crime

Essay that discusses the morals of an individual using Lord of the Flies as the example. - Year 10 English Advanced - Essay, critical response.

1096 words - 5 pages society without nurture to guide and shape that unacceptable etiquette into something that would in present times be identified as ‘good’ just as the body wouldn’t function without those three essential segments. We see how important our cognitive psychology is in ‘Lord of the Flies’ where once the environment was changed, so was the mentality of the group. Although it undertook a slow process, the vast majority of the group reverted to that

This Is A Screenplay That My Friend Gave Me. Love It!!

7950 words - 32 pages home and use white-out and a pen to change the price to something much lower, and the total much higher, then return and demand a refund 102. get a cardboard box, go in the store and pop out of the box and give out candy to passerby 103. Find the fish section and when someone walks by begin to pet the fish tank and say, "I know how you feel..." 104. Spill water on the floor, and run around claiming that the store is flooded 105. As the

gap year and experience during that time - chaminade madonna - essay

479 words - 2 pages Nowadays, gap year is a common thing for graduated high school students. Some people would argue that it would be more beneficial for them to take a gap year. However, some would claim that there is more disadvantages than benefits if one does not attend college or university right away. From my point of view, both have their own strengths and drawbacks. Comment by Tara Weinberg: article Comment by Tara Weinberg: reword Comment by Tara Weinberg

CREATIVE about a moive that youll love - year 11 lit - English Creative

1414 words - 6 pages you remember about being in a concentration camp? JOSHUA OREFICE: I remember being really confused when we got taken away and were told to go on the train and I was confused why we were there. I would ask my father, but he never told me the truth about the Nazis and the holocaust and I guess this is what really protected me as a child. When I asked questions, my father would always reply saying something like this is all apart of a game, so you

Factors that influence interpretation of 'The Diary of a Young Girl'- Anne Frank - PLC Year 8 - Essay

916 words - 4 pages Gender are both contributing factors that effect how the reader uniquely deciphers the text. Relationships are also another contributing cause for an individuals’ interpretation of the text as they affect how the reader understands the emotional concepts throughout the book. Restriction is also an additional concept that can be shared between the audience and the protagonist which enables connection. These four factors along with the writing style of

Socratic Seminar for the Great Gatsby that includes themes such as marriage and love - english - socratic sominar

2162 words - 9 pages something far off, something in sight but definitely out of reach. This famous image of the green light is often understood as part of The Great Gatsby’s meditation on The American Dream – the idea that people are always reaching towards something greater than themselves that is just out of reach. “His heart beat faster and faster as Daisy's white face came up to his own. He knew that when he kissed this girl, and forever wed his unutterable visions

Examine The Claim That Cities Have Recently Entered A "Postmodern" Stage In Their Development

1636 words - 7 pages Anthony Giddens defines postmodernism as "the belief that society is no longer governed by history or progress." He sees postmodern society as "highly pluralistic with no 'grand narrative' guiding its development"(Giddens, 2001). But it is also important to look at 'postmodernity' in relation to 'modernity', to see it as the direct result of the latter, as a reaction to the industrial, functional qualities of the modern movement (James

Evaluate the view that the Nazi consolidation of power was a legal process - Modern history yr 11 KCAHS - Essay

1010 words - 5 pages Evaluate the view that the Nazi consolidation of power between January 1933 and August 1934 was a ‘legal process’. (10 Marks) The period between January 1933 and August 1943 was a key period for Hitler and the Nazi party to consolidate power in the form of a dictatorship. Hitler’s change of strategy to gain power legally was an effective process as he created a legal image in the eyes of the public. For example the appearance of legality was

Evaluate the view that Utilitarianism continues to offer a useful way of resolving moral dilemmas - St ambrose college, 6fr - Essay

1523 words - 7 pages . Mill emphasised, and based his theory, upon the idea that there are many different ‘types’ of pleasure, and categorised these pleasures into two sections, ‘higher’ and ‘lower’ pleasures. His thought was that there is something different about pleasure of the mind such as art, music, literature, philosophy and bodily pleasures, alcohol and other material objects. He also recognises that we have a strong internal conviction that an action cannot be

Political arguments and analysing competing arguments that are compelling - University of Johannesburg,year 1 - Essay

865 words - 4 pages arguments you have analysed is the most persuasive. It is recommended that you allocate roughly 200 words to your evaluation, which should come at the end of the report (much like a conclusion). Your evaluation needs to be much more than a statement of personal opinion or preference. You instead need to be able to effectively justify and defend why you regard one line of argument, or arguments, as more compelling or persausive. This may involve

Similar Papers

Critically Assess The View That Religious Language Is Meaningless Year 11 Essay

834 words - 4 pages verificationism as truth and the measure of all things if it has nothing to be measured by to prove or even suggest it's validity. This theory is seen to dismiss something as false or meaningless simply because it cannot be understood or observed. If we look back in history, the Earth was once regarded as flat but science advanced and disproved that notion. At the time the statement 'the Earth is round' would have been meaningless but has since been

Inequality Is Something That We Cannot Resolves Because There Will Never Be Equality School Essay

1547 words - 7 pages to equalize. With the fact that it is impossible to equalize differences in family background, educational equality cannot be achieved when students from higher income groups have more advantage over lower income groups. There can never be equality because the different family background is already an inequality to begin with. Our education system gives opportunities for those who excel. It is deemed to be meritocratic as the progress is based on

Explore The Significance Of Crime Elements In This Extract Of American Psycho. Pimlico Academy, Year 13 Essay

1281 words - 6 pages Explore the Significance of Crime Elements in this extract of American Psycho. Remember to include relevant detailed analysis of the ways that Easton Ellis has shaped meanings. American Psycho is written in first person which tells us that the narrator, Patrick Bateman - a psycho serial killer, is unreliable. He is also a Wall Street trader which is a likely contributing factor as to why he is a ‘psycho’ – the stress of working as a stockbroker

How Does Eliot Present The Individual Within A Relationship In Middlemarch's 'three Love Problems'? Year 13 Essay

1527 words - 7 pages -sided chivalric ideal of his love, describing her marriage as ‘the most horrible of virgin sacrifices. As with Eliot’s subtle mockery of D’s idealisation of C in book one, she does so here: ‘painted to himself what were D’s inward sorrows as if he had been writing a choric wail’, with the ungraceful ‘wail’ removing any romantic notions from his idea. Combined with the ostentatious ‘painted’ on his assumptions of D’s feelings, is it suggested that