Explain And Assess Jacksons Knowledge Argument Nottingham Essay

1908 words - 8 pages

Explain and assess Jackson's Knowledge Argument.
Introduction
The Knowledge Argument was first formulated by Frank Jackson in order to refute
Physicalism. Whilst he no longer refers to it, it still remains one of the most profound
arguments in Philosophy of the Mind. The idea that conscious experience, the
existence of qualia suggests non-physical properties is at the heart of the ontological
debate between monism and dualists. It aims to establish that one can have
complete physical knowledge regarding another conscious entity, but still lack
specific knowledge of what it feels like to have that experience of the entity. In the
first part of my essay I will outline and explain Jackson Knowledge argument.
Following on from this I will assess this argument by analysing the responses to this
argument and assessing the ways in which Jacksons knowledge argument can be
defended against its criticism.
The Knowledge Argument
Physical information can be defined as the ‘physical, chemical, and biological
sciences which provide information about the world we live in (Jackson, 1982).
Jackson believed that there are experiences whereby no amount of information
regarding its physical properties can explain. He suggests that consciousness is
depicted by qualia which he describes as “certain features of the bodily features of
the bodily sensations, but also of certain perceptual experiences, which no amount
of bodily sensations, but also of certain perceptual experiences, which no amount of
purely physical information includes”. He begins by using two hypothetical situations.
The first example is that of Fred, who is described as having an elite level of color
vision and when presented with two batches of tomatoes, he is able to sort them into
two equal groups, even when blindfolded. When questioned on how he sorts the
tomatoes, Fred responds by stating that there are two distinct colors between each
group. Whilst others are only able to visualize one red color, Fred is able to
distinguish them between ‘red1’ and ‘red2’, the same way we distinguish between
red and yellow. We can therefore perceive Fred’s ability to discriminate between the
tomatoes, yet we are incapable of understanding what it feels like to see reds as two
different colors. Jackson highlighted the fact although we can obtain all of Fred’s
physical information the still be unable to know what it is like to see the color the way
he does.
Jackson similarly uses Mary, who has been confined within a monochromatic
environment since birth. Apart from black, white and different shades of grey, she
has never seen any colors for the duration of her life. On the other hand, she
familiarized herself with everything there is to physically know about the color red
from ‘completed physics, chemistry and neurophysiology’ (Jackson, 1986) she
knows every physical fact about red. She is acquainted with every fact concerning
color vision, the eye, the brain, including the physical’. The question that the...

Other Essays On Explain and Assess Jacksons Knowledge argument - nottingham - Essay

Critically assess the relationship between social inequality and public health - Health Policy - Essay

3453 words - 14 pages explain the SES health gradient? Proc Natl Acad Sci 2002;10929–10934. 22. Spandorfer JM, et al. Comprehension of discharge instructions by patients in an urban emergency department. Ann Emerg Med 1995;25:71-4. 23. Williams MV, et al. Inadequate literacy is a barrier to asthma knowledge and self-care. Chest1998;114:1008-15. 24. Berkman ND, et al. Low health literacy and health outcomes: an updated systematic review. Ann Intern Med 2011;155:97-107. 25

knowledge is both a blessing and a curse Frankenstein - School - Essay

545 words - 3 pages FRANKENSTEIN – Essay Preparation By the end of class today you will need to have the introduction and one paragraph written in response to the following topic. Refer to your notes on writing an introduction before you begin. Nick Dear’s Frankenstein explores the dangerous and destructive power of knowledge. Discuss. You should be able to finish it in class time and it will need to be dropboxed by the end of today. Edit your work carefully. P1

the role of Indigenous people and traditional ecological knowledge in land, water - UNISA - Essay

2224 words - 9 pages people and traditional ecological knowledge in land, water and/or biodiversity conservation now and in the past – use particular examples. During the course of this study, we as students were acquainted with the substantial knowledge essential to the Indigenous Australians history and culture. We ascertained knowledge on the colonial policies and processes, bio-diversity and complexity of Indigenous Australian cultures. We most importantly learnt on

Examine the relationship between power and knowledge in contemporary development - Geography - Essay

2407 words - 10 pages to produce, map and govern the Third World. This essay will use the framework introduced by Foucault to investigate how the development dispositif as the sum of its individual parts produces and manages the relationship between power and knowledge in contemporary development. Before delving into the ways in which power and knowledge command contemporary development it is necessary to isolate the relationship of these terms outside of it. Power and

Explain the difference between interactionist dualism, epiphenomenalism and parallelism. - PHIL1011 - essay

1494 words - 6 pages (6) Explain the difference between interactionist dualism, epiphenomenalism and parallelism. Discuss the costs and benefits of each of these theories. If thoughts and bodies are different fields, whether it is property or the way that material dualism requires, then how they relate to each other, they interact in life: thoughts and feelings; sometimes they cause physical reactions, sometimes caused by physical events. I will now briefly discuss

changing work patterns for women, technology and life balance - school - explain essay

704 words - 3 pages will ask students to address one question in regards to anti-discrimination legislation and the extent to which it protects individuals in the workplace. Weighting: 25% Description of Activity/ Task Instructions In class response Students will need to answer; · TWO unseen short answer questions and the following extended response; Explain (cause and effect language) how work patterns have changed over the past twenty years. Possible changing work

Psychology of Ancient Philosophers and a Hole in Aristotle's Argument on Psychology - Randolph-Macon College Philosophy - Essay

2157 words - 9 pages Psychology of Ancient Philosophers from Parmenides to Aristotle and a Hole in Aristotle’s Argument on Psychology Regarding Hypothetical Comatose Patients For thousands of years, philosophers have debated the relation between body and soul. The ancient philosophers built upon one another’s ideas, expressing multiple ideologies that still hold relevance in the debate on philosophical psychology to this day. The following essay will examine the

Assess the strengths and weaknesses of alexander II’s reforms - IB history - Essay

1410 words - 6 pages Assess the strengths and weaknesses of alexander II’s reforms. During Alexander II’s rule, between 1855-1881, he can be greatly recognized for his modernization of Russia with specific references to his multitude of reforms. These reforms were implemented with the aim to gain popular support for the Tsarist regime from the Russia people, mainly the peasantry. They were introduced in hopes that they would maintain a strong autocratic rule within

existentialism essay using "A Clean, Well Lighted Place" - Augusta Prep Rhetoric and Argument - Essay

607 words - 3 pages Keaton Hill Mrs. Aubrey Bryant AP Language and Composition 13 September 2015 Existentialism Essay In “A Clean, Well-Lighted Place” the idea of nothingness and what it means is shown to the reader through in depth dialogue between complex characters. Existentialism is a major theme throughout the story which the reactions of both the waiters and the old man demonstrates. When looking into the inner monologue of these three characters, humanity’s

Explain the types of economic systems and what they do - Economics - Essay

998 words - 4 pages Economic systems Everyday of the year, people across our country and every other country around the world make decisions as buyers and seekers, workers and business owners. All of their collective decisions makeup a nation’s economic system. Around the world, there are a variety of economic systems some of which are Command Systems, Market Systems , and Traditional System. A traditional economy is a system that replies on customs, time honored

Explain the concepts of religious language as analogy and symbol - university - essay

1157 words - 5 pages Explain the concepts of religious language as analogy and symbol (30) Language is an extremely limited way of describing God. When we begin to interpret God through words we start to anthropomorphise his metaphysical being, this results in different perceptions of God which shouldn't occur as something which is beyond our understanding cannot be 'this' neither can it be 'that'. Some people believe that expressing religion through symbol is a

Similar Papers

Social Media And The Healthcare Industry University Of Nottingham Essay

3009 words - 13 pages Hu (2016): dialogue, collaboration, broadcast, and sociability. This essay will then address the challenges that it poses to the industry, discussing issues with patient privacy, poor quality information, lack of professionalism, and Social media inspires dialogue and collaboration between professionals within the healthcare industry, allowing them to share information and knowledge, and to crowdsource solutions. Many social networks have been

Compare, Contrast And Evaluate Positivism And Constructivism University Of Nottingham Essay

2016 words - 9 pages argument presented by Quine, that our senses cannot give us information that is independent of the knowledge that we use to classify it (Hollis and Smith: 55). In other words, we interpret rather than objectively observe because we unconsciously use ideas to describe findings and these ideas will change the result. This logic also applies when assessing theories; the theory will change the result of the experiment because it is changing how we view the

Explain How The Managerial Ideas Of Taylor And Fayol Differ From Mayo. Assess The Relevance Of Classical Management Theorists To The Management Of Contemporary Organisations

1002 words - 5 pages Explain how the managerial ideas of Taylor and Fayol differ from Mayo.The Classical Management approach attempted to apply logic and scientific methods to management of complex organisations, such as factories. It assumed that there was "one best way" to manage an enterprise. Classical Management comprises three different approaches:· Scientific Management, which represents Frederick W Taylor's work, developed scientific principles of

Deductive Argument And Reasoning Miami Dade College Ethics Essay

1510 words - 7 pages Section A – Question 2 A deductive argument is an argument whose statements are known to be true or deductively valid. It intends to give a case a conclusive logic. The conclusion of a deductive argument must come after the premise. If the premise is true, then the conclusion can’t be false. When a deductive argument is well made, has the right form, and the premises back the conclusion, then the argument can be what we call valid, as in