“Explain The Reasons Why The Australian Imperial Force (Aif) Failed To Achieve Victory At Gallipoli” School Essay

1049 words - 5 pages

“Explain the reasons why the Australian Imperial Force (AIF) failed to achieve victory at Gallipoli”
The Australian Imperial Force was the main expeditionary force of the Australian army in World War I. The campaign at Gallipoli in 1915 is regarded as one of the most spectacular failures of World War One. Numerous reasons evidently state why the AIF failed to achieve victory in Gallipoli. The AIF had a poor understanding of the nature of the terrain they were expected to fight on and this was influential in the in the defeat of the allied troops. The poor command and leadership of the army was evident with the lack of maps and the unsuccessful landing while it is also patent through the concerted but unsuccessful allied attempts to break through in the Australian attacks at the Nek. Poor planning and insufficient medical resources brought about a lack of provisions and engendered illness and disease. All these factors combined to play a role in the failure of the AIF to achieve victory at Gallipoli.
The allies had a poor understanding of the nature of the terrain they were expected to fight on and this was significant in their defeat. Both sides were aware that due to the terrain there were only a limited number of locations where the landing could be executed which were Cape Helles, Gaba Tepe and Kum Kale. Land system analysis demonstrates that these were disadvantaged by terrain, with steep, deeply-incised slopes and narrow beaches. Landings was further disadvantaged by inadequate mapping of the peninsula. Furthermore, constant readjustments and gradual northwards drifts meant that the troops landed too far to the north in a steep cove later renamed Anzac Cove, becoming easy targets for the Turks in their position from high up in the cliffs. The terrain is noted by Bean, “steep gravelly waterways … it was as much as a strong man could do.” However, Doyle disagrees stating, “The benefit of the terrain was not effective as there was no reconnaissance raids or other detailed observations.” Furthermore, the difficult landing at Anzac Cove is supported by Crampin, “…. a gradual northwards drift, meant that the troops landed too far to the north. While the view that the failure of victory at Gallipoli was caused by the mountainous terrain can be accepted it is also fair to agree that there were no raids as stated by Doyle. However, such unfair advantages to the Turks clearly puts the AIF in peril, clearly mentioned by Charles Bean. Thus, while Doyle’s view cannot be accepted by all historians, White states that although there was no surprise attack this did not amend the AIF vulnerability. Hence it is clear that the AIF were highly affected by a rigorous environment however, one must also acknowledge the poor command and leadership throughout the campaign clearly affected the AIF’s chance of victory.
Inadequate command and leadership was a significant factor in the failure of the AIF. The prime issue was the underestimation of the scale of what was needed and a lack of assessment by the allied leaders. Planning was rushed, leaving the Turkish defence with little difficulty in repelling allied attacks and inadequate mapping of the peninsula demonstrated a lack of clear objectives. The attack on the Nek on 7th of August 1915 stands as a key moment in the campaign highlighting the effects of a breakdown in communication. The poor judgement of the British Government is supported by Hart who emphasises that the British leadership had no coherent plan … and they had an uncultivated underestimation of the enemy. Barnett agrees, “everything about the campaign was too unrehearsed for it to have a chance of success. “De Groot contends, “The campaign was from the start starved of men, weapons, ships and supplies.” In contrast Von Sanders and Turkish commander Mustafa Kemal’s leadership has been praised as confirmed by Patton, “Had the two sets of commanders changed sides, the landing would have been as great a success as it was a dismal failure.” Hart argues, “Few military operations have begun with such a cavalier disregard for the elementary principles of war.” The significance of poor planning and leadership is further highlighted by Maxwell who further states that the whole thing was nothing but bloody murder due to miscommunications. Thus, many historians agree that the worthy leadership of the Turks clearly affected the AIF ability to achieve victory at Gallipoli. Poor planning and leadership is plausible in the AIF failure to achieve victory at Gallipoli however, a lack of basic medical provisions also attributed to this factor.
The Failure of the AIF can also be credited to the lack of basic medical provisions and the spread of disease. Inexperienced doctors, overcrowded base hospitals and a shortage of medication added to the many who were lost and significantly contributed to the failure of the campaign. The situation that there were limited medical provisions is supported by Hammer who debates that the allies had insufficient medical supplies in the field hospitals which contributed to leaving thousands injured pleading for water supplies until they perished. Steel concurs, arguing that “those in need could only expect minimal treatment unless they were in danger of expiring.” Poor medical care and a lack of sanitation resulted in the spread of disease reducing the number of troops able to sustain the front. Bean further notes that due to a lack of medical provisions, “The sick rate in the trenches were at least 660 a day.” Cleary ascertains that p[oor nutrition together with limited fresh water supply caused a rapid spread of disease that significantly contributed to the AIF failure of Gallipoli. Hence, minimal medical necessities and provisions left the AIF to diminish, plainly indicated by Hammer states why the AIF failed to achieve victory at Gallipoli.
The failure of the AIF achieving victory at Gallipoli is given by the poor command and leadership of the army through the lack of maps and the unsuccessful landing. This factor is clear through the concerted but unsuccessful allied attempts to break through in the Australian attacks at the Nek. Poor planning and insufficient medical resources brought about a lack of provisions and engendered illness and diseases. All these factors combined to play a role in the failure of the AIF to achieve victory at Gallipoli.


In WWI, why were conditions in France in 1916 and 1917 so difficult for the Australian Imperial Force (AIF)

393 words - 2 pages The conditions in France during WW1 for the AIF were horrendous because of the stalemate in the trenches, disease, rainy conditions and new weapons of war.The stalemate and the war of attrition took a heavy toll on the troops of the AIF. There was constant enemy fire and the constant attacks and counter attacks to attempt to make ground shattered the soldier's morale and strength. The trenches also created psychological stress and broke their

Assessing the reasons why Henry VII was able to reduce the power of the Nobility - Dhahran School / Grade 11 - Essay

1066 words - 5 pages How successful was Henry VII in achieving his foreign policy aims When Henry VII usurped the throne in 1485 one of his immediate tasks was to establish positive links with the other nations of Europe in order to achieve recognition and acceptance of his dynasty. As his reign progressed and he more established, it was inevitable that he would pursue a more ambitious foreign policy where he increasingly attempted to drive, rather than respond to

the use of flattery to achieve personal gain in Julius caesar - brampton christian school/English - essay

1182 words - 5 pages Senate, so that the he, along with the conspirators, can kill him. Finally, Antony uses the tool of flattery against Brutus and the conspirators, so that he may speak at Caesar’s funeral, and avenge him. These three instances in the play, Julius Caesar, reveal how flattery is an effective tool to achieve one’s personal agenda. Works Cited Shakespeare, William, and John Crowther. Julius Caesar (No Fear Shakespeare). Spark Notes, 2003.

Reasons for the pilgrimage of Grace - School - Essay

2418 words - 10 pages Free Urjaa Using your understanding of the historical context, assess how convincing the arguments in these three extracts in relation on the reasons for the outbreak of the Pilgrimage of Grace Extract A is convincing to a certain extent in relation to arguing the reasons for the outbreak of the Pilgrimage of Grace. Its main argument is that the rebellion “at heart, the work of a political faction which utilised social, economic and religious

Comparing to essays on women place in the work force - Manhasset high school 11th grade english - essay

807 words - 4 pages Slaughter felt the need to change the way women struggle with having both a professional life and a home life so she focused on “Why Women Still Can’t Have It All?”. Slaughter went on to work as the Dean of the Woodrow Wilson School and used her position of power to change the work environment for women for the better. She would purposely let her colleagues know that all facility meetings had to be done at 6 so she could eat dinner with her family

the reasons for hitlers rise to power - history - essay

1603 words - 7 pages The reasons for Hitler’s rise to power essay 1. The treaty of Versailles 2. Weaknesses in the Weimar republic= hyperinflation, occupation of the Ruhr, the great depression, economic downturn, fear of communism, wall st crash, extremism on the rise 3. Nazi party organisation, Hitler appealed to all classes, being able to deal will the communists, SA, Harzburg front 4. Tactical skills 5. Hitler Role of Hindenburg- used article 48, authoritarian

my goals for the future and how to achieve them - drug class - essay

527 words - 3 pages Cynthia Kraus My goals for the future and how to achieve them There are many goals in my life that I would love to achieve. I am only 16 years old so I can’t write as much as someone twice my age so to say, but I strictly know my high school goals, college goals, and personal goals. As a 16-year-old I have a lot already planned out so I will soon see how close I follow my goals. My first and most important high school goal I have is to finish

The revolutionary vision of human equality that Thomas Jefferson attempted to achieve. - Intermediate English Composition - Essay

1617 words - 7 pages to “life-ruining”, specifically targeting women who are vulnerable on the internet. In this essay, I will discuss the pervasiveness of the Incel Movement in today’s society, how the internet caused this phenomenon, and why this is the most plausible reason for this trend. “Incel” is a word that describes someone who is involuntary celibate. They have been characterized generally as a white male who has traits such as resentment, racism, sociopathy

Nationalist victory in the Spanish civil war - History - essay

4434 words - 18 pages Free compared to the more quantifiable impact of foreign intervention; indeed seeing it as “more like a chorus than of any of the leading characters”[footnoteRef:41]. [41: Raguer, H Gunpowder and Incense: The Catholic Church and the Spanish Civil War. (2007) New York: Routledge. 2007, p1] To conclude, the Nationalist victory in the Spanish civil war can be explained by a range of different reasons. The Republicans were successful at the beginning of the

The Tragedy at Columbine High School - Introduction to Criminal Justice - Essay

1376 words - 6 pages opinions into play about why violence in schools occurs. These causes range from violence in the media, being treated poorly by peers and administrators in the school, all the way to poor parental decisions. Although these are only a few of the possible causes for violence in schools, they are defiantly the most prevalent reasons of school violence. Works Cited Eric Harris. (2012). Biography.com. Retrieved 09:56, May 15, 2012 Langman, P. (2009, May 20

Factors affecting the the political backstabbing in Australian politics - Sachdeva Global School - Essay

2420 words - 10 pages Revolving Doors of Prime Ministers The last ten years were the most uncertain period in Australian politics with the country seeing five Prime Ministers from 2007 to 2015. This situation has been regarded as an ‘aberration’ (Walsh as cited in Walsh 2017), ‘the new normal’ (Watson as cited in Walsh 2017) or even a political ‘crisis’ (Kelly as cited in Walsh 2017 pp. 465). This essay is divided into two sections; the first section gives an

To what extent has the Modern Revolution been a positive or negative force? - John cgrew - Essay

647 words - 3 pages To what extent has the Modern Revolution been a positive or negative force? The modern revolution has been a positive force to a somewhat large extent. This is due to the various innovations that it brought such as steam locomotive and computers which have revolutionised the way humans interact with the world. The modern revolution also brought major advancements in medical science which improved the lives of millions and raised the average life

Nat Turner and the reasons behind on why he did what he did - MSJC /History - Essay on a historical figure

625 words - 3 pages responsibility to fight the serpent, “for the time was fast approaching” (Marcus, Giggie, Burner 234). August 21, 1861, proved to be a day of sorrow, pain, and a day where many lessons were learned. Nat Turner was born on October 2, 1800, on Benjamin Turner plantation in Southampton County, Virginia. Nat Turner was brilliant and imaginative even from early childhood. Since Benjamin allowed Nat Turner to learn how to read and write At times he was overheard

Acknowledging the Australian Film Industry - Brisbane State High School - Expository Essay

1145 words - 5 pages promote the creation of unique Australian stories that showcased our country, history and culture. Through the support of the commission we have established a thriving film industry which is focused on telling our stories, our way. These films have contributed to how we see ourselves as a people and have mirrored the changes that have occurred within this great country. The Castle sits with other landmark Australian films which have had an enduring impact on our development as a nation and a person. Thank-you all and enjoy the rest of this night of nights at the AACTA Awards for 2018.

How the Beauty Industry Failed Women of Color - Binghamton University, Media and Politics - Essay

4211 words - 17 pages shopping at whole foods. Unfortunately, when I left high school, I kind of lost this inspiration as I wasn’t being constantly educated about the injustices of the food industry. It’s also strange that you are very similar to my AP Environmental Science teacher. My teacher, Mr. Finkelstein, was a middle aged Jewish man who cared a lot about what he taught, but much more about his kids. Your teaching styles are very similar as well, both assigning