Foundation For Brown V. Board Of Education - Anna Maria College/race And Crime - Essay

3698 words - 15 pages

Anna Maria College
The Development of the Argument against Separate but Equal
Harlan’s Dissent and Thurgood Marshall
Trevor Brown
Professor Brown
Race and Crime
December 19, 2017
Throughout history, African Americans have been oppressed merely for their color of
their skin. There have been a countless times when laws against Africans Americans have been
challenged due to their unconstitutionality. Brown v. Board of Education was the landmark case
in 1954 that undermined the laws that implemented unconstitutional segregation between white
and black citizens. This case, however, was backed by years of litigation that helped set the stage
for this landmark to finally be passed. Along with the very important dissent of Justice John
Marshall Harlan, who was the lone dissented in Plessy v. Ferguson, Thurgood Marshall was the
man who made the win in Brown v. Board of Education.
In 1892, passenger Homer Plessy refused to sit in a Jim Crow car, a segregated all black
railroad car. Even though Plessy was one-eighth black and seven-eighths white, he was still
considered black under Louisiana law. Under the Separate Car Act passed by Louisiana State
Legislature in 1890, all railway companies required equal, but separate train car accommodations
for both races. For violating this law, Plessy was brought before Judge John H. Ferguson of the
Criminal Court for ​New Orleans​, who upheld the state law. The law was challenged in the
Supreme Court on grounds that it conflicted with the Thirteenth and Fourteenth Amendments.
The ruling in supreme court went to a 7-1 vote, with Judge John Marshall Harlan
as the lone dissenter. The majority believed that the the state law, set in 1890, is within
constitutional boundaries. Justice Henry Billings Brown led the majority decision and upheld the
segregation law imposed by the state. All justices that were on the upheld side based their
decision on the separate but equal doctrine. This doctrine says that separate facilities for blacks
and whites are constitutional under the Fourteenth Amendment so long as all facilities are equal.
Justice Brown had an entirely contrasting opinion in which he stated that the Fourteenth
Amendment intended to establish absolute equality for all races. Brown also noted that
segregation does not in itself constitute unlawful discrimination. This meaning that just because
segregation is present, it doesn’t mean that the separation of the races in unlawful.
Harlan was on the losing side of the 7-1 decision but his dissent was what helped set the
precedent for the reversal of the law in the 1954 landmark case ​Brown v. The Board of
Education​. He noted in his dissent that ​a legislature could not differentiate on the basis of race
with regard to civil rights. He discussed how white citizens view themselves as the dominant
race but the Constitution says nothing of who the dominant race is, or that there even is one.
Harlan continued his dissent by saying that the Constitution is colorblind and t...

More like Foundation For Brown V. Board Of Education - Anna Maria College/race And Crime - Essay

Brown V.s Board Of Education Background Information - English9 - Expository Essay

668 words - 3 pages ... Greifzu Brown Vs The Board of Education Background Information Expository Essay The Plessy v Ferguson, the Supreme Court Case that stated although colored and white people were separated, as long ad the facilities were equal, it was constitutional. Now, people know that isnt the true because a lot of the colored facilities weren’t equal. Over 50 Years later a new cases, which consisted of five separate cases that were combined into one that is ...

Paper On Brown Vs. The Board Of Education

679 words - 3 pages ... segregation in schools such as having to sit in the back row with a broken desk and a sticky chair just because you are black. Even though the case is labeled Brown vs. the Board of Education, it is only named that in honor of Oliver Brown Linda's father, the NAACP actually brought up the case.The second court hearing for the Brown versus the Board of Education was only a few years later in 1955. This was also called the mandate of "with all ...

The Importance Of Brown Vs. The Board Of Education

1420 words - 6 pages ... Brown v. Board of Education was a landmark case in the history of American education. There were several events and issues which led up to this critical event. From the 1892 Plessy vs. Ferguson Supreme Court Case, the precedent of "separate but equal" was set. This doctrine affected the school system, in that there were separate schools for white and black children. These schools were constitutional as long as they were equal. In the 1900s, with ...

College Essay For College Board - Alabama School Of Math And Science - Essay

639 words - 3 pages ... like it took forever, like waiting in line for that one amazing roller coaster everyone wants to ride on. I hopped out of the car and sleepily dragged myself to the room my mother was placed in. My mom was wide awake and ready to have her son come to the world. Seeing the look on her face, brightened my mood and I finally was ready to see my baby brother. The anticipation was killing me and I was more than ready for this new adventure. I know my ...

Effective Study Skills Are The Sole Foundation Of A Sound Education. - Healthcare - Essay

587 words - 3 pages ... 17062101 22/9/17 Portfolio Task: Module 1 (500 Words) Study the following phrase and then write a properly referenced academic essay to discuss it Effective study skills are the sole foundation of a sound education. This essay will explore if effective study skills are the sole foundation to a sound education. The term effective is defined as “successful in producing a result or effect” (Cited in the Chambers English dictionary, 1992, p452). A ...

Compare And Contrast Essay On High School V. Community College

595 words - 3 pages ... De Nobrega 1 Zachary DeNobrega Professor Bush ENGLISH 1301 10 December 2018 High School v. Community College High School and College are often argued over when trying to decide which is better. Though the level of freedom and difficulty in curriculum differ from each other, both share similarities such as the responsibility and accountability for your mistakes, and the goal to prepare you for the future. The subtle differences between the two ...

Impacts Of Slavery Mentioned By Brown And Douglass - DWC201 - Essay

1106 words - 5 pages Free ... Trung Vu DWC201 – 001 Fr. Batts October 8, 2018 What are the similar impacts of slavery on the slaves and slaveholders in the African American society that both Douglass and Brown mention in their biographies? William Wells Brown and Frederick Douglass are two famous figures in the American and African American literature in the nineteenth century. They are both famous for their biographies that reflect the life of slaves and condemns the ...

Locate, Read, And Review The Following Article: Miller, Toyah And Del Carmen Triana, Maria. 2009. Demographic Diversity In The Boardroom: Mediators Of The Board Diversity–firm Performa...

1373 words - 6 pages ... applied in the States? Can we also apply gender diversity? In some countries of the Middle East where the business community presents its weight on the international market, we find it difficult to discuss the introduction of gender diversity in the board. Yet and as time goes by, change is coming to some countries. For example, the election of two women to the Jeddah Chamber of Commerce & Industry (JCCI) last year provided another example of ...

Foundation Of Economics Essay Question - Leicester - Essay

1801 words - 8 pages ... Question 1 a) DA + DB = AD I used the following two equations when calculating the aggregate demand for each of the consumer groups: ADA = 20,000,000(5-0.2p) ADB = 20,000,000(6-0.3p) The two consumer groups overlapped between the boundary 0 to 20 therefore from 20 to 25, I used the aggregate demand equation for consumer A and as a result the 2 equations I used to calculate the total aggregate demand were: ADT = 20,000,000(11-0.5p) 0 ≤ p ≤ 20 ...

A Psychological Essay On The Inclusion Of Sex Education For Both The Primary And Secondary Curriculum

4118 words - 17 pages ... government may work hand in hand with civil society and the private sector in the establishment of a strong foundation for moral value formation in the government bureaucracy."The Presidential Council on Values Formation (PCVF), chaired by Arroyo, counted "members of the clergy and ministers," among others, as those seating in the council, said Lapus.With regards to its composition, separate checks by Inquirer Research and the Department of Education ...

Sex Education: A Conversation We Can No Longer Avoid - Marist College/writing For College - Essay

1682 words - 7 pages ... Katie Hillman Professor Fisher Writing for College - Civic Engagement 3/8/18 Formal Essay 1 Sex Education: A Conversation We Can No Longer Avoid Imagine that your first exposure to sex education is a woman being compared to a pair of dirty gym sneakers, a used toothbrush, or a piece of chewed up gum because she engaged in healthy sexual activity before marriage. The red lights are flashing, and the warning signs are going off in your head. The ...

Theology: How Some Aspects Of Christian Anthropology Could Serve As The Foundation For A Moral Life - Essay

1447 words - 6 pages ... Discuss how some aspects of Christian anthropology could serve as the foundation for a moral life The development of humankind from a Christian perspective is grounded in the idea that humans are made in the image and likeness of God. Christian anthropology strives to provide explanations for human behaviour through a religious understanding. Christian anthropology transcends other anthropological divisions as it is descriptive, but ...

Comparing Young Goodman Brown And Story Of An Hour - Ncc/english 110 - Essay

897 words - 4 pages ... , the societal pressures on these characters were so great that would rather die that feel outcaste by their peers. “Young Goodman Brown” and “The story of an hour” are perfect examples of why people need to stop succumbing to the pressures of their society. Both Goodman Brown and Louise had the means to obtain their desires; they just didn’t have the courage to stand up to their societies pressures. Works Cited Chopin, Kate. “The Story of an Hour.” Writing about Literature. 13th ed. Edgar V. Roberts. New York: Pearson, 2012. 316-17. Print Hawthorne, Nathaniel. “Young Goodman Brown.” Writing about Literature. 13th ed. Edgar V. Roberts. New York: Pearson, 2012. 317-26. Print ...

Reading Response On Trials Of Chelsea Manning And Trayvon Martin - Brown University HIST150 - Short Essay

682 words - 3 pages ... often look for specific evidence in a trial as proof, yet in the Manning trial, they excluded the evidence as it made Manning seem to be not guilty. Furthermore, these cases heavily focus on framing the narrative in order to paint a specific picture while in court. We witnessed the same type of framing in the OJ Simpson trial, as the defense attempting to shape his character as an “American man-esque” figure and not a killer. Especially so, trials of our times rely on framing to shape the historical significance of the cases. ...

Final Essay Over V For Vendetta - English - Essay

1153 words - 5 pages ... he would like to enter with him and after a long thought process he chooses his mother, Emily Stevens, who was a college drop out and was recently diagnosed with severe depression. We chose them because its like a two for one special. They’re both healthy and able to be active in case of emergency, and they both know how to survive off very little considering the fact the mom know how to garden and plant crops and the son is a two year ...