Hamlet Movie Vs Play Comparative Essay Blythe Online Academy, Grade 12 English Essay

1164 words - 5 pages

PAGE 4
Stephanie Gwynne
Ms. Howald
ENG3U-d6
March 15th 2018
Heartbroken or Hateful Hamlet?
Hamlet is an iconic Shakespearean tragedy that has many themes and quotes that have been prominent in society. The play has been adapted to the big screen twice, both renditions varying in style and modernization. Many of Shakespeare’s plays have been transformed into a movie rendition, and Hamlet was even nominated for an Academy Award. The director of Hamlet (1996), Kenneth Branagh, who also starred as Prince Hamlet, is known for his creativity and impeccable screen work. Although he is a prestigious director and Hamlet did very well in the film industry, did it capture the true themes of Shakespeare’s Hamlet? The main character is always hard to accurately portray, and the film unfortunately missed the mark on Hamlet. Branagh changed Hamlet in many ways, mostly through the main character, Hamlet, by turning him into a crazed henchman for the ghost of his father. Most young people enjoy watching a movie over reading a book, but are they really getting the full experience, especially when the main character has been tampered with?
Hamlet in the play was portrayed as ‘emo’ and very suicidal. This proved that he was quite depressed and nothing seemed to help him ease the pain he was feeling. However, Branagh portrayed Hamlet as insane. It was clear that Hamlet was troubled, but the film showed Hamlet acting very crazy in many situations. Shakespeare allowed the readers to assume for themselves if they considered Hamlet to be crazy. The play dictated him as a weak, young boy, due to the loss of his father, and portrayed him to be searching for his own identity. However, the movie depicted him as arrogant, and that he knew what he wanted from the kingdom. The play never once said that Hamlet was dying to be king, nor was the fact that he wanted to kill Claudius made very clear to the readers. He was depressed, and the only thing on his mind was suicide. In the play, Claudius disregarded and degraded Hamlet by claiming his sadness was “unmanly grief” (Act 1, Scene 2, Page 4) and wanted Hamlet to stop grieving. The story of Hamlet is meant to be very harrowing and sad, due to the betrayal and death. Hamlet’s Uncle killed his brother, Hamlet’s father, and then re-married Hamlet’s mother. It is very easy to feel sympathy for Hamlet, as his life turned upside down because of his corrupt family. The movie did not allow for such sympathy. The director turned Hamlet into an action film full of drama. Thus, dissolving most of the character’s true emotions.
It was very clear in the play that Hamlet was an unhappy child, yet the movie showed him as cocky and outspoken. In particular, he was very rough with his girlfriend, Ophelia, during their breakup. Shakespeare noted that he was more sad than angry, but the movie showcased an angry version of the breakup. Hamlet in the play never voiced any distaste for Ophelia, let alone manhandle her. Branagh...

Other Essays On Hamlet Movie vs Play Comparative Essay - Blythe Online Academy, Grade 12 English - Essay

Collage response- english grade 12 - english - Homework

910 words - 4 pages Explain why you chose the images included on your collage. What do they represent? The pictures I choose for my collage all revolve around the theme of things that laughter can bring and or show. I’ve included a picture of my collage before all the text was added so you could view the pictures better. The picture of the lady wearing the funky outfit with big hair was chosen because when someone laughs, especially someone you care about and are

Hamlet Essay - how does hamlet hold up a mirror to human nature - Year 12 English Advanced/Extension 1 - Essay

1339 words - 6 pages Through Shakespeare’s perspicacious genius, in Hamlet he has depicted an aspect of humanity that belongs essentially not to his age but ours. He does so by subverting the audiences’ expectations of a revenge tragedy through his characterization of Hamlet as having an over-active intellectual mind, which results in his delay from action. Hamlet spends the vast majority of the play ruminating over philosophical questions related to the typical

Timothy Findley- An Insight and Impact of his Life - John Fraser Grade 12 English(ENG 4U) - Essay

700 words - 3 pages leave school during grade 10 due to health reasons. (Anthony) Findley declared his homosexuality as a teenager but married the actress Janet Reid in 1959 which lasted about 3 months before a divorce. Findley eventually found his partner Bill Whitehead, whom he met in 1962. Revealing oneself as a homosexual in the 1940s was a brave act to perform that required tremendous courage, as homosexuality was considered a disease, an abomination and

Is the movie "Sully" accurate compared to the true story? - 10th grade English - compare and contrast

971 words - 4 pages that particular situation. Having made sure these small details were precise, Eastwood was able to make this movie accurate. In the Miracle of the Hudson Plane Crash documentary, survivor Barry Leonard and flight attendant Doreen Welsh opened up about their injuries. Leonard recalls, “My knee hit my sternum and actually cracked my sternum” (History vs. Hollywood) while Welsh had a deep L-shaped laceration on her leg. Both of these injuries were

hamlet speech is a speech about hamlet for year 12 advanced english. - james ruse agricultrual high school - speech

4776 words - 20 pages English Speech The purpose of your speech is to develop community awareness of the significance that a critical study of Shakespeare has made to understanding of your world through your reading of the set text. · Shakespeare’s context in the Renaissance world · Aristotelian dramatic genres and their influence on meaning · Characterisation as explored and refined by Shakespeare · Ideas and thematic concerns of the play · The forms and features of

Symbols in "Not Wanted on the Vouage" - English- Grade 12 - Assignment

623 words - 3 pages In 1933, the Holocaust was created by Nazi Germany in an attempt to divide and dispose of the “unwanted” and undesirable. Anyone that was not Hitler's version of “ideal” was murdered in order to cleanse Germany. This cruel and vicious way of thinking is displayed in “NOW TV” through Noah Noyes. Throughout the text Findley references the Holocaust directly and indirectly. Findley demonstrates the connection “Noah’s Ark” has to the holocaust, and

Zen and art of motorcycle maintenance chapter 1 and 2 - English grade 12 - chapter summarys

703 words - 3 pages Sylvia are frustrated by technology and refuse to adapt to it. They feel alienated by a system of change and new developments. (Johns refusal to try to fix motorcycle and sylvia's displaced aggression towards dripping tap.) -Man vs Machine conflict. (pg 15) Philosophical Criticism​: ​Within this chapter, the man separates things into categories of bad or good. He describes busy cities, billboards, and loud noise as bad and prefers rural areas for

Writing prompts for essay ideas - grade 12 - assignment

952 words - 4 pages to do with quality of life—generally the idea that simplicity is good. The challenge, I think, is for students to avoid clichés while also avoiding being too cute or clever. There’s no short-cut around the fact that upper level papers are well-written and engaging. Here’s a list of Provincial Exam writing topics. They use exactly the same kinds of topics on the English 10 exam as on the English 12 exam. People learn from a variety of sources. The

Comparative Analysis of Hamlet Film Adaptations - Shakespeare Class - Essay

1253 words - 6 pages Max Sotnikov November 12, 2018 ENGL 3000-105 Essay #2 Essay #2 In two film versions of Hamlet, the usage of set and prop design makes Hamlet appear differently during the recitation of this soliloquy. These cinematic elements make the Hamlet in Branagh’s film appear as if he is angry and vengeful and only feigning his madness while in Almereyda’s film Hamlet appears as if he has actually gone mad and is bitter and scornful. Branagh’s film

Comparative essay on urban vs rural lifestyle - university - essay

1090 words - 5 pages Running Head: URBAN VS COUNTRY LIFESTYLES 1 URBAN VS COUNTRY LIFESTYLES 2 Assignment Number 4 Comparative Essay Yorkville University Jasman Singh Submitted to: Kateryna Yuri Student ID: 2018081930 ENG 101/1F There is always a debate about which lifestyle is better whether it is urban or country lifestyle. The answer is everyone has their own preference and point of view. Both lifestyles has their

Argumentative Essay: Fahrenheit 451 and The Crucible - bridgeport military academy english 11 - essay argumentative

573 words - 3 pages which has more power. o End with a powerful statement that will leave your readers thinking about your viewpoint. Argumentative Essay Fahrenheit 451 English 11 Mrs. Lametta Writing Your Essay in MLA Format: → Keep the essay objective – no using I, me, my, you, your, etc. → 12-point Times New Roman, Cambria, or Calibri font, double-spaced. → Cite any direct quotes from either of the two texts in quotation marks – ex. “Information from the text

Similar Papers

Life Of A Free Man Essay Grade 12 Grade 12 English Essay

437 words - 2 pages Daniel Starr Gaming When I was in grade 6 my parents bought me an Xbox, I thought it was the best thing ever at the time, but I think if they could go back in time they would never had bought me it. I used to always be outside and running around until the day they bought me the consol. I got addicted to the Xbox very fast and didn’t go outside unless it was to bounce on the trampoline. I used to fake sick from school, so I could play, eventually

Beowulf: Revenge And It's Consequences English Grade 12 Essay

612 words - 3 pages Kailyn Showers Ms. Roney English 12 2 February 2018 Beowulf The quest for revenge has been in battle stories for centuries. This has been displayed through the hero and the villain. In the poem, Beowulf, the quest for revenge and its consequences is shown through Grendel’s mother, the dragon, and Beowulf. The sole purpose and motivation behind Grendel’s mother attacks was Grendel’s death at the hands of Beowulf. “Goes to Herot to avenge her

The Difference Between Baba And Amir English Grade 12 Essay

939 words - 4 pages The Differences Between Amir and Baba in The Kite Runner By Nathan Strub Usually children take after their fathers, however, In The Kite Runner, by Khaled Hosseini it is the opposite. Since Baba and Amir have many differences including their hobbies, their personality, and their expectations of each other. Because of this, they are unable to understand each other. Therefore Amir feels as though he is the son Baba never wanted. Firstly, Amir is

Education Of The Twenty First Century Grade 12 English Demand Essay

1424 words - 6 pages the capability of learning. In this logical perspective, the educational system really requires both teaching and learning as an intertwined piece in order to uphold its missions and visions. Today’s generation are becoming more and more incurious of how to express teaching and infuse learnings. Robert Nielsen, in his provocative essay, states that “Students have no understanding of evil and even doubt its existence, thus lacking awareness of the