How Does Eliot Present The Individual Within A Relationship In Middlemarch's 'three Love Problems'? Year 13 Essay

1527 words - 7 pages

' Moral crises are often about discovering the intransigence of others and taking the step to shoulder and accommodate those who cannot themselves change.'
How does Eliot present idea of the individual within a relationship in 'Three Love Problems'?
In ‘Three love problems’, Eliot presents various examples of relationships, with the characters in each having varying levels of individualism and cooperation within the relationship, contrary to the simplistic Middlemarch societal view of each couple as their own unit. She leads us to the conclusion that the most functional relationships are ones with mutual respect and understanding.
The way Eliot presents the idea of the individual within a relationship aligns well with the prompting statement when considering Dorothea (D) and Casaubon (C). Eliot shows that D’s empathetic nature makes her willing to accommodate C: ‘she seemed to be looking along the one track where duty became tenderness’. With the confident use of the word ‘failure’ in describing C, it is clear that D’s current moral crisis does not stem from an inability to accept her flawed perception of C. Rather, Eliot shows their non-communicative relationship, hindered mainly by C’s insecurities, as the source of her crisis. C regularly employs an approach of male superiority, which isolates D; upon her bringing up the topic of Will’s (W) employment, he states: ‘you have assumed judgement on subjects beyond your scope’. This reflects his usual ‘air of patience’ when listening to D’s ideas, which gives the idea of a barely tolerant teacher, and which leads to the detachment of the two individuals in the relationship. This is especially powerful considering D’s previous insecurity when thinking of ‘those provinces of masculine knowledge’, and later D’s perception of the marriage is described as ‘a perpetual struggle of energy with fear’. Most striking in this is the reference to fear, which shows the power of C’s volatile reactions over D, and further distances them. Despite this, Eliot steers the reader towards empathizing with C as an individual; for instance, she adds ‘as with all of us’, before ‘seeking rather for justification than for self-knowledge’, thus preventing readers from being carried away by his role in the failings of the marriage. Furthermore, D’s flaw of naivety plays a part in exacerbating their failing relationship by feeding into C’s suspicion of W: ‘her blindness to whatever did not lie in her own pure purpose carried her safely…where vision would have been perilous with fear’. The metaphor of sight is extended to C, with ‘Will not a tiny speck very close to our vision blot out the glory of the world, and leave only a margin by which we see to blot?’ (a rhetorical question which, incidentally, also generates reader sympathy towards C). In this way, they are presented as two separate, blind individuals in their relationship, leading to D’s inability to shoulder and support C.
D’s moral crisis precipitates upon her...

Other Essays On How does Eliot present the individual within a relationship in Middlemarch's 'Three Love Problems'? - Year 13 - Essay

How does Dickens create sympathy for Scrooge in A Christmas Carol - Year 11 - Essay

1315 words - 6 pages miserly ways. 'I will honour Christmas in my heart and try to keep it all year. I will live in the Past, the Present and the Future. The Spirits of all Three shall strive within me. I will not shut out the lessons that they teach. Oh, tell me I may sponge away writing on this stone!'. One of the last quotes Scrooge says in the stave shows he is desperate not to die this way which causes a major change in his behaviour and morality. The use of

How does genetic modification in agriculture benefit the food production industry? - Agriculture - year 11 essay

1445 words - 6 pages How does genetic modification in agriculture benefit the food production industry? You may have heard the saying "If you ate today, thank a farmer." Growing up on a farm I assumed that most people understood the importance of agriculture and the contribution it has to the food production industry, but over time I have found that isn't true. In today's world of 7 billion people, the scientific advances in creating sustainable food production at a

How does H.G Wells present humanity in the War of the Worlds - Oakham School, form 7 - Essay

990 words - 4 pages How does H.G Wells present humanity in the War of the Worlds Humanity can be defined as the features and qualities that make people humans or as the sympathy and kindness that is extended towards others. In the War of the Worlds, humanity is lost from the start, as the narrator explicitly references the extermination of the indigenous population of Tasmania by British colonies, and says that we humans, are not to judge them because we too had

How does Duffy explore the theme of love in first love and valentine? - english literature, poetry - essay

1498 words - 6 pages Holly Snow How does Duffy explore the theme of love in first love and valentine? Both the poems first love (FL) and valentine (V) have narrators who have loved and are appreciating that love through reminiscing. As in FL its their very first love who, presumably, they aren’t with anymore being the main centre of attention. With the narrator’s current partner being referred to once in line 10 ‘my lovers eyes.’ In

Explore the Significance of Crime Elements in this extract of American Psycho. - Pimlico Academy, Year 13 - Essay

1281 words - 6 pages element in crime fiction is the theme of deception which is demonstrated in two parts of this extract. The first person Bateman deceives in this passage is the victim, a five year old child throwing his candy wrapper in the bin. He does this by asking the child “Would you like...a cookie?” Naturally the child said yes and he used this lie as bait to then gruesomely murder him. The ellipsis shows a hesitation slight hesitation which brings us to the

Independence within Romantic Love in - english - essay

975 words - 4 pages Roda Warsame Dr. John Corr EN119 – OC1 20 November 2014 Independence within Romantic Love in Jane Eyre by Charlotte Brontë The novel Jane Eyre by Charlotte Brontë faced much controversy when it was released. To begin with, a novel written by a woman was uncommon, but the opinions and views of the character Jane were out of the ordinary and before their time. The protagonist, Jane is a character that encounters many hardships and faces difficult

Hamlet Essay - how does hamlet hold up a mirror to human nature - Year 12 English Advanced/Extension 1 - Essay

1339 words - 6 pages Through Shakespeare’s perspicacious genius, in Hamlet he has depicted an aspect of humanity that belongs essentially not to his age but ours. He does so by subverting the audiences’ expectations of a revenge tragedy through his characterization of Hamlet as having an over-active intellectual mind, which results in his delay from action. Hamlet spends the vast majority of the play ruminating over philosophical questions related to the typical

What does Romeo and Juliet illustrate about the nature of love? Consider how the play portrays love - english - essay

1125 words - 5 pages freedom of states within a federalist system to adopt the spirit or letter of U.S. Constitutional principles as determined necessary for their individual populations. Therefore, specific documents used to govern society harness legislative language to outline rights and limitations which are in some cases prescribed or open to interpretation to evolve with the needs the people and historic times. Hawaii’s state constitution is clearly more

Connecting ideas on short stories form the early 20th century - year 13 - Connections essay

1414 words - 6 pages a man named William who is trying to come to terms with the way his wife Isabel wants to live. Williams wife Isabel has found a new way of looking at the world and therefore her views clash with his. The lack of communication in this relationship was the downfall and therefore William is trying to understand what went wrong and how he could have fixed it. Isabel is an independent woman with new found freedom and William is more of the passive

“The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock” by T.S Eliot - Advanced English - Essay

564 words - 3 pages psychological thoughts of the world in which he inhabits.  The human state of situational and psychological loneliness is explicitly explored within the first and second prelude through the setting desolate cityscapes that reflect the inner man.  The opening line establishes a literal and metaphysical meaning with the word “winter” which is both symbolic and indicative of the feeling of existential despair. Eliot further develops this idea

In 'Tissue' How Does Louise Page Present The Political Elements And What Impact Do They Have On The Audience

1163 words - 5 pages ways to demonstrate this. In scene ten Sally addresses a receptionist in a doctors' surgery, the receptionist doesn't take Sally's feelings into consideration and shows no empathy towards her Page is trying to raise questions about how people were dealt with, by the NHS at the time. This scene has a slightly comic edge to it but it indicates the extent of Sally's problems and demonstrates how some areas in the NHS do not use care and understanding

Similar Papers

How Does Orwell Present The Power Of Manipulation Through Squealer? Year 10 Essay

756 words - 4 pages is actually Squealer who controls the farm animals in reality. With his use of propaganda, he can manipulate Napoleon’s subjects till they learn to love their brutal lives, and require to be told what to do by Squealer because they no longer have a motivation of their own. Through the character of Squealer, Orwell demonstrates the perilous power of propaganda in manipulating people to the point where they can no longer identify the truth and must blindly accept whatever their government, and its mouthpiece, sees best for them.

Does Plath Present Men As The Biggest Obstacle To Esther's Freedom In The Bell Jar Year 12 A Level English Ocr Essay Essay

2072 words - 9 pages ‘In literature, men are depicted as the biggest obstacles to women’s freedom’ How far do you agree that Plath presents men as the main obstacle to Esther’s freedom as an individual? In The Bell Jar (1963), Sylvia Plath explores the role that men take in the acute curtailment of Esther’s freedom. The part that men play in this restriction is largely important insofar as the fact that many of the secondary obstacles that taunt and trap Esther find

Examine The View That Love Is Presented As Something That Is Forbidden Queensbury Academy, Year 13 Essay

1234 words - 5 pages relationship is forbidden in societies eyes even as they first met. This social divide is also present in the relationship of Robbie and Cecilia, as Robbie was “the cleaning lady’s son”. This quote shows he is seen as of less importance as he is not being referred to as his own person but in a way that suggests he is lesser due to his mother’s income. The relationship between Cecilia and Robbie would have been disapproved by society, as they saw Cecilia as

Book: Guadalupe, Mother Of The New Creation By Virgil Elizando Answering The Question: How Does Elizando Present The Guadalupe Apparaiton As An Example Of "Conversion Within One's Own Tradition"?

1595 words - 7 pages "There is no doubt that everyone is called to repent and convert, but, practically speaking, conversion means totally different things to different people, depending on where they are within socio-cultural structures" (Elizando 2002: 81). In his book, Guadalupe: Mother of the New Creation, Virgil Elizando explores and illustrates the truth in the above statement, and how this change of heart, called conversion, is actually brought about. He does