How Far Was Mao To Bllame For The Failure Of The Great Leap Forward? Alevel History Coursework

4465 words - 18 pages

Orla Gibbons
Historians often disagree on to what extent Mao is to blame for the failure of the Great Leap Forward. What is your view on how far Mao is to blame for the failure of the Great Leap Forward?
There is a prevalent historical debate regarding the extent to which Mao is to blame for the failures of the Great Leap Forward. The Great Leap Forward was an initiative put forward by Mao to transform China into a society capable of competing with other industrialised nations. Ultimately, the plan failed resulting in the death of millions. The question presupposes that Mao at the very least bares some responsibility for the failures of the Great Leap Forward. Mobo Gao argues in ‘Gao Village’ (1999) that Mao made some mistakes but is not completely to blame and the blame resides predominately with Party Cadres and USSR involvement. Gao’s views may stem from the Maoist propaganda he was subjected to when a resident of Mao’s China. However, this is opposite to Jung Chang and Jon Halliday, who contend in ‘Mao: The Unknown Story’ (2005) that Mao, through his power hungry nature, is to blame for the failures of the Great Leap Forward through the policies which he instigated and his tendency to ignore issues which had a detrimental effect on the country. Their views may have been influenced by Chang being a resident of Mao’s China. Alternatively, Frank Dikotter takes an approach in ‘Mao’s Great Famine’ (2009) which re-evaluates Mao’s role in China. He considers that Mao is not fully to blame for failures but does agree that Mao is mainly responsible as, due to his dictatorial position, it was within his power to prevent the failures of the Great Leap Forward from occurring through better researched policies. Dikotter and Chang and Halliday reach the same conclusion although their approach is different, Chang and Halliday utilise persuasive and emotive language which convey their findings in a way closer to a novel unlike Dikotter’s more researched historical work. One might argue that Mao is mainly to blame for the failures of the Great Leap Forward but that he cannot be singularly held responsible due to the involvement of the USSR and Party Cadres.
Gao argues that Mao had little blame for the failures of the Great Leap Forward suggesting that the policies were not Mao’s own, and that Party Cadres and the USSR had more responsibility for influencing Mao. Gao argues that ‘most of the ideas of the Great Leap Forward did not come from Mao himself’[footnoteRef:1] which suggests that Gao is attempting to shift the majority of blame from Mao, as it is unjust to leave culpability with someone who did not develop the ‘ideas’ which led to the failures. Gao maintains Mao had ‘misguided faith in the pseudo-scientific approach’[footnoteRef:2] of Lysenkoism, a theory, developed by Soviet Lysenko, in regards to organic evolution. It was implemented in agricultural farms in China, although failed to have substantial biological evidence and led t...


how far was the legue a complete failure? - Hartlepool Sixth Form College History - Essay

1480 words - 6 pages Free Courtney Fishwick Media Histories How far was the League a complete failure? There were both successes and failures of the league. The Corfu incident of 1923 was a huge failure and demonstrated the weakness of the league. There was an incident at the Greek Albanian border where an Italian General, Tellini and his team were ambushed and killed. The league made a decision that compensation would be paid to the league and when the people

Which of the following was of greater importance for the creation of the Nazi dictatorship? - Alevel History - Essay

938 words - 4 pages dictatorship. The main reason for creation of Nazi Dictatorship between 1933-4 was the use of violence and terror by the Nazi party, which can be seen through the election campaign for the 5th March and the Night of the Long Knives. Firstly, the Reichstag fire gave Hitler an opportunity to encourage the ‘Decree for the protection of People and State’ and allowed hundreds of anti-Nazis to get locked up considering that the fire was blamed on a communist

'Life did get better for many Americans in the 1930's. How far was Roosevelt responsible for this, or was it due to other factors?'

540 words - 3 pages because they were usually known by their initials. The main agencies were:The Agricultural Adjustment Act - This provided loans and subsides for farmers. It also gave special payments to farmers who agreed to reduce their production and therefore increase prices.The Tennessee Valley Authority - this was set up to help stop floods, which made Tennessee Valley one of the poorest areas of the USA. The TVA built 20 dams and an extensive system of

How Far Was The 1830 July Revolution In France Inevitable?

1439 words - 6 pages ). The Civil Code was retained and Church properties remained with those who had bought them.All this looks very liberal and retains the rights that the revolution was fought for. However, there were still strong elements of the ancien regime in the Charter, for example that the King had to initiate laws and had to agree to all amendments, he could rule by emergency degree or ordinances, he summoned the two chambers and decided for how long they

How Far Does Alexander II Deserve the Title of Tsar Liberator - History - Essay

2351 words - 10 pages Maddie Bryan How Far Does Alexander II Deserve The Title Of ‘Tsar Liberator’? Alexander II was Tsar of Russia from 1855 after succeeding his father, Nicholas I, and sought to fix many problems Russia was troubled with during the time. The country has no zemsta, people were relatively uneducated, the judicial system was extremely biased and therefore unfair, censorship was deceitful and strict and the serfs were still imprisoned by their lords

How was the Industrial Revolution a big part of History?

505 words - 3 pages demand for spun thread. The "spinning bottleneck" which was invented by James Watts, was another major figure whom invented the steam engine in Seventeen seventy five of the Industrial Revolution. Even though this invention was named his, he could not have done it without Matthew Boulton and John Wilkinson whom made the engine valves and bone cylinders which made this invention possible. Watts designed the mechanism to convert the traditional up

Creative Writing-Flash forward to the future - GEOGRAPHY - Essay

625 words - 3 pages . He had some unique and innovative ideas and was so close to making history. He still made it, but not the way he was expecting to. In order to find a cure for cancer, Volgar’s focus was not on changing the genes themselves, but rather on producing a vaccine that would prevent any abnormal cell growth. He was working on an extremely hazardous and poisonous environment – his lab was full of cancer samples. He did what no other scientist could ever

Failure Of Prohibition In The US

414 words - 2 pages Free making of alcoholic beverages.The question is, why did Prohibition fail if it had so many reasons for it to be successful? I will give several reason which point out the failure of Prohibition: Prisons could not cope with the number of offenders, the number of enforcement agents was low - less than 3,000 in 1930, enforcement agents were poorly made and therefore open to bribery, many Americans did not agree with Prohibition, and were prepared to

History Of The Great Wall Of China

604 words - 3 pages No one can tell precisely when the building of the Great Wall was started but it is popularly believed that it originated as a military fortification against intrusion by tribes on the borders during the earlier Zhou Dynasty. Late in the Spring and Autumn Period (770 BC - 476 BC), the ducal states extended the defence work and built "great" structures to prevent the attacks from other states. It was not until the Qin Dynasty that the separate

Assess the reliability and usefulness of the documentary 'Prelude to War,' in determining the failure of the League of Nations

532 words - 3 pages Free The documentary, Prelude to War, is unreliable but is useful to an extent in explaining one of the core failures of the League of Nations. Its reliability is detracted due to its narrow view, blatant bias and propaganda evident in the production of this film. However, this bias demonstrates the prejudice mindset of the American people at the time and could be a useful explanation for America's refusal to join the League, which was one of its key

it was for SAC in literature year 11 for the great gatsby - class - oral speech

466 words - 2 pages and to live in his house with him as if she had been married to him all along; this is impossible for her to do. Because of this, Gatsby will always be unsatisfied, and this destroys him. This can be seen as representative of the frustration all those who try to pursue the American dream feel. Specifically in terms of the time period, the 1920s were a time of great economic growth, especially in the stock market. The theory of the stock market

How Did The Nineteenth Amendment Come To Be Part Of Our Constitution And Why Was It Significant? A History Of The Female Right's Movement And The Importance Of The 19th Amendment

1560 words - 7 pages The Nineteenth Amendment was a great victory for women, which had been in the works for decades before its ratification. This amendment says that, "The right of citizens of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any State on account of sex." Surprisingly, this amendment was not ratified until August 18, 1920. (Find Law 1) It took years of struggle and protest before women achieved the right to vote

Far Too Little Attention Is Paid To The Needs Of The Minority

818 words - 4 pages or any other forms of classifications. Minorities are not part of the shared identity of the people in societies and the government rarely felt that these minorities could make a difference.More often than not, minorities have no stake and shared identity in society. It is a common tendency of modern countries to assume a "national" identity and culture. Far too often, this tendency leads to a disregard for, or underestimation of, the multiethnic

How Successful was the Education Reform Act of 1998 - Access to Childhood and Youth - Essay

1400 words - 6 pages Free control of the curriculum. The division of knowledge into attainment subjects has also caused concern. Children who have not reached the recommended level for their age group are seen by themselves and others as a failure, again leading to a spiral of decline. In conclusion, Thatcher's marketization policies through the Education Reform Act 1998 was effective in emphasizing how important educational achievement is and offering rewards to students and

How 'Roseanne', the tv show relates to the sociological aspect of women and work. I had to write this for an extra credit paper, it's not great, but it gets the point across

524 words - 3 pages Ever since I started college in the fall, I haven't really been able towatch as much television that I would like to. I have been able too catchsnippets here and there, but nothing really "in depth". One show that I usedto watch was Roseanne. Some of the things that seem natural to thecharacters on the show reflect what we have been studying all semester inthis class.Roseanne, a wife and a mother of three, is a stubborn, loud, andobnoxious