How Has The Law Developed On Intention?

1829 words - 8 pages

How has the law developed on intention?Mens Rea:One of the major elements in culpability is that the accused should have a mental state commensurate with committing the offence. This state is known as mens rea, which can be translated as "guilty mind" or "blameworthy mind". Nearly all criminal offences require a demonstration of mens rea. However, it is unusual to see the term mens rea used in statute; instead statutes use terms like "intend" or "reckless" to express the mental state of the perpetrator. Some offences do not use any such words, and may therefore be interpreted as strict liability offences.In general, for a criminal conviction to succeed there needs to be a demonstration of ...view middle of the document...

This term can be translated as `blameworthy act'; it is used to denote the event on which a criminal offence is based. In many cases the actus reus will be an explicit act (theft, assault, etc). In others it will be a prohibited state of affairs (e.g., having an offensive weapon in a public place). In some cases the actus can be an omission to act, but usually only when the accused had a legal duty to act. Sometimes the actus may not be the event itself, but the effect it has on the victim (e.g., in rape), or the circumstances that surround it (e.g., bigamous marriage).It is fundamental that the actus reus be a voluntary act; if a defendant could not have acted any other way then not only is he not liable, then the actus reus is deemed not have occurred. Of course there will be the "actus" part - the action - but it will not be "reus". In offences of strict liability this is important, because in those offences the prosecution has no duty to show a mens rea; thus an offence cannot be defended on the basis that there was no intention to comment the offence, but it can be defended on the basis that no offence was committed.This defence will only be available if the defendant truly had no choice; for example, someone else physically pushed him. A defendant who makes a choice between two equally dreadful alternatives (help us rob this bank or we'll shoot your wife) is not acting involuntarily in this sense, but he may have a general defence of duress.Recklessness:Recklessness is pure disregard for the dangers of a situation. It can in certain cases be seen as heroic - for example, the soldier fearlessly charging into battle, with no care for his own safety, has a revered status amongst some. However, recklessness is more commonly regarded as a vice - this same soldier may be a liability to his own side, or get himself killed for no benefit. Furthermore, recklessness can also be a disregard for the safety of others, such as "reckless driving", and this type of recklessness is almost universally condemned.Recklessness should not be confused with bravery. Although the two are related, the latter word is usually applied to cases where a person displays a more reasonable level of fear, rather than none at all.Intention:Murder is a crime of specific intent. Intention in this context includes direct or oblique intent. Direct intent covers the situation where the defendant desired the death. Oblique intent covers the situation where the death is foreseen by the defendant as virtually certain, although not desired for its own sake.The question of intention is also often problematic. People are generally held responsible for an act which they did not intent so long as the consequences were foreseeable. Thus, a person who shoots a gun into a crowd can be found guilty of murder even though they can argue that they did not intend to kill anyone because the results, someone's death, were readily foreseeable.The definitions of many criminal offences include terms...

Other Essays On How Has The Law Developed On Intention?

A Book Report On How Frodo Shows Courage From The Fellowship Of The Ring

855 words - 4 pages in the book Frodo once more illustrates his courage by volunteering to continue on the expedition to raze the Ring. Here is a minute, modest, and feeble creature that has finished the task appointed to him, and is now out of grave danger, and yet he chose to go on with the journey, not putting anyone else in the danger that he didn't even cause. When everyone else was pondering about whom was to take the ring he got up and said, "I will take the

In 'Tissue' How Does Louise Page Present The Political Elements And What Impact Do They Have On The Audience

1163 words - 5 pages to raise awareness of breast cancer and the treatment and she constructed the play in a way that informs both male and female viewers.Page uses short episodic scenes to help maintain the audiences attention and to help them remain focused on the facts that are being expressed in the narrative. There are only three characters in the play woman, man and Sally, which means no characters except Sally become developed so the audience doesn't become

Liberal Or Authoritarian? How Would You Evaluate The 1993 Russian Constitution? Draw On The Constitution To Illustrate Your Answer

2666 words - 11 pages president has power to dissolve parliament. This places the emphasis on the State Duma to accept the candidates the president nominates, giving a bulk of the power to the president. Far better is the German system laid down in the Basic Law which enforces a constructive vote of no confidence. This vote ensures that if the legislature is unhappy with a nominee, they vote for their own candidate after voting against the president's candidate. Once a

George Lucas - What Themes Does He Deal With?, What Influence Has His Personal Life Had On His Work? And What Is The Significance Of His Work In Today's Society?

1319 words - 6 pages heart to make films and a passion to reach his target audience. George Lucas' movies deal with strong themes of rebellion and good and evil and his personal history has motivated him and developed him into the man he is today, and he uses these to impact his audience. I along with many other people around the world hope he continues on with making movies because he is one of the world's most influential men and has changed the course of our lives.

Faces On The Wall: "The Yellow Wall Paper" The Husband's Intention Is For His Wife To Get Well, However, His Way Of Doing So Drives Her To Depression And Insanity

498 words - 2 pages Faces On The WallIn Charolette Perkins Gillman's short story "The Yellow Wallpaper" it is evident that good intentions do not always produce good results. I am making the assumption that because the time this story takes place is in an era in which such practices seen in this story were considered beneficial, that John's desire for his wife is for her to get well. Accordingly, he secludes her to a dreary room with only yellow wallpaper to look

How The Conflict Between Roman Duty And Egyptian Sensuousness Develops The Tragedy Of Antony And Cleopatra Comments: More Focus On Final Scene Was Expected

1764 words - 8 pages , asking 'Why did he marry Fulvia, and not love her? In act two, scene five, Cleopatra demonstrates her impulsively temperamental character. She begins in a light- hearted mood, likening Antony to a fish, which she has caught, joking that she will catch fish and 'think them every one on Antony, /And say, 'Ah, ha! y'are caught!' She then reminisces about the control she had over Antony recalling how she 'laughed him out of patience; and that night

The Nervous System: A Basic Summary Of The Nervous System And Some Little Peices On How It Is Affected By Disease And Drugs

1560 words - 7 pages or tail region. Even though they have no brain, creatures with a nerve net are still capable of some complex behavior. Bilaterally symmetrical creatures have a defined head and tail region. Scientists believe bilateral symmetry has a lot to do with cephalisation (the development of a head with the majority of sensory organs at the front end of the organism). Flatworms have small clusters of bundled neurons (known as ganglia) throughout their

El Dorado Explored: Explains How El Dorado Was A Utopia And What Effect It Had On Candide. It Also Explains How Eldorado Is A Counter For The Evils Of Europe

1754 words - 8 pages and has only wished to return home, yet upon seeing El Dorado; he thinks it is more beautiful than his home.After traveling a short distance, he and Cacambo notice that riches are everywhere. Gold is on the highways and children are playing with precious stones as if they were common stones. They assume that the children must be the children of the king and wander past them. They eat at an inn and are surprised to find that they are not required to

"Lean, Mean, Extreme-Machine" -- This Essay Is On How Cyrano De Bergerac Is Able To Exceed Every Man In The Realms Of Art, Battle, And Love By The Extremes

742 words - 3 pages In today's world, it is accepted that, no matter the ability of an individual, somebody has a greater gift than him. Whether power, knowledge, or character, any person can equally find a talent to compare with another's. In Cyrano de Bergerac, however, one man has more skill in everything than anyone he faces. Cyrano, with his gentle spirit and vibrant swordsmanship, proves to surpass mankind by taking his actions in art, battle, and love to the

These tragedies are founded on family relations. How does the introduction of incest enhance the power of the family structure here? How does it pervert it?

401 words - 2 pages The structure of an average American's family tree is pretty simple. A mom and a dad, their parents and parents of their parents, their kids and then spouses of kids and their parents. Nobody was initially related to each other and unless it is a married couple who came from two different families, there are no sexual relationships whatsoever. In the Greek tragedy "Oedipus the King" , Sophocles wrote about the ruler of Thebes who crossed the

Biography On JK Rowling And How She Wrote About Harry Potter. Mainly About The Consistent Theme Throughout The First Two Books

649 words - 3 pages . Rowling was the author of the famous series about "Harry Potter". It was the year 1990 when J.K. Rowling first conceived the idea of writing about a wizard named "Harry Potter". She recalls it was a long train journey from London to Manchester when she started forming in her mind, the characters of the series. Also, she decided on the fact that he was a young boy that was a wizard, but didn't know it yet. When she

Similar Papers

Trace How Sparta Developed Into The Most Militarily Effective State In Greece (800 550 Bc)

2034 words - 9 pages This question will look at how Sparta grew to become the most powerful Greek state by 550BC, and how the different aspects of state policy brought this about. Most remarkable of all is that this successful ascendancy was achieved with a remarkably small citizen population compared to other poleis. The essay will focus on three main aspects that will be discussed individually and then linked together to help explain the greatness of Sparta's

What Is The Natural Law? What Are Its Principles? How Does It Relate To Positive Laws?

1992 words - 8 pages government. The virtue that manifests itself as a result of law are therefore civic virtues; the virtue of being a law abiding citizen. It follows therefore, that the measure of the specific human virtue in subjects is the rationality of the laws to which they are subject. "For if the intention of the law giver is fixed on the true good.....it follows that the effect is to make men good absolutely." If laws are good, subjects are good both in the

"The Scarlet Letter" By Nathaniel Hawthorne How Hester Prynne Has Romantic Characteristics, But Is Inevitably Transcendental. This Essay Is Also Meant To Be A Short One Page Paper

370 words - 2 pages problems would have been rooted with Puritan society and its evils. But all of her downfalls are based on decisions made by her own inner thoughts and feelings. The tragedy of Dimmesdale dying can only be seen as the tragic flaw of the character, and not a tragedy to society. The "evils" of the puritan society never made its way into the life of Hester, but the burden of having to deflect it made her a problem to herself.Although Hester can be seen

The Greeks Placed Great Importance On Hospitality. How Is This Displayed Throughout Homer's The Odyssey?

1163 words - 5 pages hosts, the Cyclops and those who abuse the guest friendship that is extended to them, the Suitors. How these different groups were portrayed and the consequences of their actions provide an insight into the importance placed on hospitality by the Greeks of that period.Hospitality comes easily when the guest is pleasing to the eye and quite attractive, but Odysseus was quite the opposite when he first arrived in the land of the Phaecians. He was