How Is Animal Imagery Used In "Therese Raquin" And "If This Is A Man"?

2007 words - 9 pages

This essay will explore the topic that links both "Therese Raquin" and "If This Is a Man", animal imagery. Although at a first glance both books are different as they cover different time periods, events and the writing style of the authors are different they both use animal imagery throughout their novels. Zola's "Therese Raquin" is the tale of a contagious madness fed by the overwhelming power of sexual urges. Zola confessed to be intrigued by the pathology of a relationship between a man of brute force and a highly-strung woman. It is written in a plain and objective style. Zola describes almost everything in detail and places emphasises the animal side of human beings.Zola is famous for being one of the founders of naturalism. He created a so-called "scientific novel". The new "scientific novel" would be created by placing characters with known inherited characteristics into a carefully defined environment and observing the resulting behaviour. No novelist can actually work like this, of course, since both characters and setting are created in the distinctly unobjective mind of the writer; but Zola's novels do place special stress on the importance of heredity and environment in determining character.Zola used a lot of animal imagery thus there's a lot of attention to body types as he believed by knowing the characteristics of the person you would know the behaviour. The personalities or "temperaments" are very closely linked to body types.Zola pays a lot of attention to description of people. Zola describes Therese as being animalistic. Zola show Therese as a feline, "a long, narrow, sharp nose reached down from the short, low forehead. Her personality/temperament is closely linked to her physical appearance, "body type", she appears to be calm but is in fact highly strung, hence the comparison with cats. She is referred to as a cat continually throughout the book, "Ready to pounce" . Her personality is very secretive, Zola show us she keeps her animal instincts inside, "calm and motionless" , this quotation when compared with, "a mass of energy and a passion dormant within her torpid frame" we can see the energy she hides. Her strength is shown by using animal imagery such as, "feline suppleness". She has been sacrificed for her Aunt and Camille, "newly dug grave" she is described like a caged animal.Camille is shown as, "small, puny and listless in manner" . Zola is almost mocking human nature; the most interesting part of Therese is her animal side. Zola uses irony to convey how little difference there is between humans and animals as the bears are so described similarly to Camille.He would stay there for half an hour, leaning over the pit and watchingThe bears as they ambled heavily around. It amused him to see how these big creatures walked. He stared at them, with his jaw hanging, wide-eyed, like an idiot enjoying the sight of them as they moved. Animal imagery is used to show the differences in Therese and Camille.Throughout the novel Mme Raquin's cat helps us judge the temperament of the characters by the way they act toward it. In the preface Zola says the cat is meant to be Mme Raquin's dead husband. The cat at the beginning of the novel represents Therese's repressed desires and sexuality, " She used to stay slumped in her chair, looking at François as he lay in her arms, so as not to see these paper dolls grimacing around her", Zola enforces Therese's dislike of the others (at the Thursday meeting) by portraying them as being fake, by describing them as paper dolls it shows how they are not showing their real feelings they are merely superficial. Francois represents feelings that cannot be expressed, such as desires, as it is not considered "civilised". By chapter 21 Francois represents their (Therese and Laurent's) repressed fears and horrors. Therese's protection of the cat shows that Therese believes Camille has entered the cat's body. This quotation shows how fear can change a person's temperament, as in Therese, as she is more sympathetic to the cat's plight than Camille's."He was about to give Francois a kick when Therese cried out; don't you hurt him! Her cry affected him in a strange was. An absurd idea came to his head. Camille has entered the cat's body, he thought, I shall have to kill the brute......it looks like a human being"We can see from this passage that Laurent believes that the only way to deal with his problem is to get rid of it. This shows how the rules of society never feature in any of Laurent's decisions; society is something that separates us from animals. Zola is showing that society is not what it appears to be. Society and civilisation are supposedly what separates humans from animals, "human animals" act differently in the wild then in the city, " . Earlier in the novel Therese is described with feline characteristics, we can then read this passage as if Therese is the cat. By seeing it this way we can see Therese as protecting herself, this selfishness can also be linked to the murder. Therese wanted Camille killed to satisfy herself it shows that she has no feeling.Zola uses animal imagery to show that the "love" Therese and Laurent share is in fact lust throughout the novel "They had loved each other on a purely animal level". Laurent's personality is also brought out through their affair, he does not think of Camille's feelings, just his own sexual needs, "It had been a long time since he had satisfied his needs; money was short, he had been depriving his flesh and did not want to lose an opportunity to indulge a little." He does not see Therese as more than an item to satisfy himself with. Therese has a half black image of being wild therefore she doesn't recognise the rules of marriage. These traits have not appeared earlier as she has been constricted by rules and law, she has not been in the environment to let this come out in. The river Seine features throughout this novel as a metaphor for animal sexuality, "So life had improved for her. She had the same suppleness of movement, the same calm and indifferent expression: she was still the child brought up in the bed of the invalid. But inside, she lived in an ardent and passionate existence.....she would look defiantly at the river as it rumbled past" , this quotation is taking about how the wilderness unleashes her animal passion/ sexuality, Therese mimics the rivers wildness. Where nature is brought under control, as in Paris, so is Therese.Primo Levi's "If This Is A Man" is a novel describing Levi's experiences during the holocaust. He writes in a scientific fashion as he is a chemist, "we are in fact convinced that no human experience is without meaning or unworthy of analysis, and that fundamental values, even if they are not positive, can be deduced from this particular world which we are describing" However you would not expect him to write in a non adjective fashion after experiencing the horrors of the holocaust, it makes the reader believe that it is too horrific to describe in detail. The animal imagery is used to express how Levi is ashamed/ humiliated to be classified as human, he has lost the dignity that is normally associated with being human. Levi is not only asking the question "what is a man" but also "what does it mean to be an animal", what is it to strip people of being human? In If This Is A Man there is a very basic idea of greed and the animalistic effects that greed brings. Ultimately, this is not a book about the Nazis or Jews or the concentration camps. It is a comment on humanity and suggestion for how men should live. By using animal imagery it shows that humans have been degraded to animals and therefore are no different to them. Zola however, shows that we are no different to animals, we are "human animals" even the rules of society cannot change this.The camps are extremely illogical, "there is no why here" , the strong are killed and good workers don't have to work, "His fame as an exceptional worker spread quite soon, and by the absurd law of the larder, from then on he practically ceased to work" . Logical thought, understanding why something should happen and making sense of reasons separates us from animals, however there is no sense in the camp. The novel portrays the transformation of men when they enter the camp. They are physically as well as psychologically transformed, " Levi shows that by taking away sense, reason and logical thought, the Jews and minorities naturally have ,the Nazi's are making the men no more than animals on a psychological sense and by doing this the men start to think as if they are no more than animals, "One learns quickly enough to wipe out the past and future when one is forced to", like animals the past and future are not important, they just follow their instinct to survive. By treating the Jews as animals they begin to act, almost believe they are animals. Levi uses animal imagery to compare Null Achtzen unfavourably to animals therefore showing that he is no more than one of them."He is Null Achtzen. He is not called anything except that, zero eighteen,.......; as if everyone is aware that only a man is worthy of a name, and that Null Achtzen is no longer a man....When he speaks, he looks around, he gives the impression of being empty inside, ..., like the slough of certain insects which one finds on the bank of swamps.......He has not even the rudimentary astuteness of a draughthorse, which stops pulling a little before it reaches exhaustion: .... He made me think of the sledge-dogs in London's books, who slave until the last breath and then die on the track."This is almost used as a case study to show how the Nazi's want the Jews to be. This man acts like an animal; he does not think of the future or strive for education. Animal imagery is used to show how degrading the physical transformation is; "shaved and sheared" , Levi uses words that are normally associated with sheep therefore symbolising the change from man to animal.`In chapter 11 we are shown a conversation between Levi and an other (higher status) Jew. Even in the direst time Levi Chapter 11 shows the real purpose of men, to be more educated. Levi is using the chapter to show literature civilises and teaches which is why we are more than animals even in horrific conditions.Both novels use animal imagery but for different purposes. Zola uses it to show the temperament and personalities of the characters as well as to show to show an opinion on the existence of love. Levi scarcely uses animal images when he does he uses it to show the transformation that occurs to men when they are treated like animals, he also uses it to show positively the purpose of men and how it is almost impossible to take this away from them, even in the direst of situations.

RELATED

Comparison Of "The Hearing Trumpet"-Leonora Carrington And "If This Is A Man"- Primo Levi

1542 words - 7 pages make contact to all the other people who are “captive” in this institution.Primo Levi however is faced with a completely different kind of institution, an institution of death work and survival of only the strongest. Primo Levi feels this for the first time the night before their deportation. There seems to be an odd atmosphere during this time where Primo Levi goes into deep thought something which Marian does not do when first

An exploration of the path to salvation in Primo Levi's if this is a man - St Edwards - essay

1942 words - 8 pages bizarre word choice considering the fact that Elias spent many years in a concentration camp, which could suggest that he was quite a simple man. [3: ibid. p.109 ] [4: ibid. p109-110] [5: Levi, Primo. If This is a Man and The Truce, trans. Stuart Woolf (Abacus: London, 1987) p.109] [6: ibid p110] Additionally, Levi makes constant references to Elias being like an animal, which could perhaps show how brave and strong he was, which therefore lead

“Propaganda is a powerful tool used for political control in Animal Farm by George Orwell - Grade 10 - Essay

567 words - 3 pages “Propaganda is a powerful tool used for political control.” In the novel Animal Farm, by George Orwell (a Fable), it is clear that propaganda is used to manipulate the animals. I agree with the above statement, as throughout the book it is proven to be true, countless times. By further analysing the different instances where propaganda was used in the book, it can be proven that propaganda is a powerful political tool. In the beginning of the

DBMS, Explains What It Is And How It Is Used In Corporations

659 words - 3 pages development are confused to how this will works and whether it would serve their needs. The proposed model is a database model interlinked using a primary key infrastructure. To convince the other managers from other departments would be to involve them in the whole data and system analysis process.End users can be shown a demonstration of a 'prototype' database where data entered by the purchasing manager pertaining to raw materials bought becomes

What is a man profited if he shall gain the whole world and lose his own soul?

445 words - 2 pages education in philosophy, law, physics and so on. What he has gained is the power to do magic, but what he has lost cannot be substituted by anything. So, doctor Faustus gains power only during his mortal life on earth, which is not worth selling his soul. What he profits from all this is petty and miserable when having in mind that the price he pays is eternal and everlasting pain and torture of his soul. It is too great a price to pay for such a

This Essay Is About Trusting Oneself And How To Build Confidence In A Person

596 words - 3 pages your both your faults and your potential. We evolve as much in this lifetime as we do over thousands of lifetimes, the changes are infinitely more subtle, but no less important for a chain is only as strong as its weakest link. You and her have to fall for what is essentially base in the other. If you can love and accept that for what it's worth then anything that blossoms from it is icing. Maintain your integrity, be honest with yourself first

Oskar Schindler, In The Eyes Of Many, Is A True Hero. This Is A Man Who Wanted To Make A Difference And Do Things That He Thought Was Humane And Rightful

875 words - 4 pages Activity 6: Courage in the Face of InjusticeOskar Schindler, in the eyes of many, is a true hero. This is a man who wanted to make a difference and do things that he thought was humane and rightful. Although Schindler was part of the Nazi Party during the tragic time of World War Two, Schindler saved approximately 1,200 Jewish lives. Oskar Schindler, a single man, saved the most Jews during World War Two and is a hero to the Jewish community. He

"Lean, Mean, Extreme-Machine" -- This Essay Is On How Cyrano De Bergerac Is Able To Exceed Every Man In The Realms Of Art, Battle, And Love By The Extremes

742 words - 3 pages daily only to please the woman he loves, Cyrano's soul exceeds that of any other.Cyrano de Bergerac is a man of many talents: poetry, swordplay, and devotion, all of which no person, dead or alive, could ever obtain. As his life progresses, Cyrano's mind, body, and soul fade away one by one, lost by his own inability to retain perfection. He eventually loses all in the end, except for his sacred white plume, demonstrating how a downfall symbolizes complete victory when one goes to the extremes.

This Paper Is About Racism And How It Is Portrayed In The Following Poems: "Jasper Texas 1998," "A Party Down At The Square," And "Night, Death, Mississippi."

1112 words - 5 pages implies a belief in the superiority of one's own race" (Internet). While reading Ellison's "A Party Down at the Square", Hayden's "Night, Death, Mississippi" and Clifton's "Jasper Texas 1998", I noticed that this disease is the theme of all three.A white boy who witnesses his uncle's friends set fire to a black man narrates Ralph Ellison's "A Party Down at the Square". This is a horrible short story of how a community gets together to have a "party

Life Expectancy For The State Of Kentucky. This Was An Assignment In A Math Class... ENJOY! It Is Missing Pictures So If You Need Them Let Me Know

1919 words - 8 pages Have you ever wondered how long the average life expectancy for Kentucky is? Well I have been wondering so I decided to find out by working on a project about the average life expectancy in Kentucky. I figured that after I got done then all of the insurance companies that offer life insurance to Kentuckians and even Kentuckians themselves would use this information. First the insurance companies might charge more if the average death age

this is a story about betrayal and how it was overcome - english paper at wcjc - essay

607 words - 3 pages and becomes king light is shown back into the pride lands because he understands that the circle of life needs to be maintained. In conclusion, tone, symbolism, and imagery are the fundamental literary tools used by Walt disney, all three of these tools worked hand in hand in order to quantify how this form of grief feels in a concrete manner. Such a story is pure catharsis and can be recommended or gifted to those in the midst of betrayal and deceit. Works Cited https://123movieshub.to/film/the-lion-king-4897/ http://www.metacritic.com/movie/the-lion-king https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/the_lion_king/

A basic understanding of concrete and it is used in modern society - memorial university of newfoundland - essay

2858 words - 12 pages , creating a crystal matrix. The crystals create strong bonds between each other resulting in a solid durable material. This chemical process is called hydration, the duration of which varies depending on the type of concrete and mix designation. The Basics of Concrete: Concrete has been used for thousands of years. Crude forms of concrete have been found in Bedouin structures dating as far back as 6500 BCE. The Bedouins found that sand, water and

"Animals Have No Say". This Essay Is About Animal Rights

3813 words - 16 pages treat you. If they have this right, then it will be violated whenever animals are harmed and certain conditions are not satisfied. Moreover, the onus of justification is always on those who harm animals to explain how they are not violating the rights of animals not to be harmed, if animals have this right" (Regan 92). Cohen agrees if animals have any rights at all they have the right to be respected, the right not to be used as a tool to advance

Explain how the place is used in the story - Shoreline Community College - Essay

527 words - 3 pages Explain how the place is used in the story The scene is one of the substantial elements of the movie, and it represents the characteristics and atmospheres of the place. For example, Milan, a metropolis in Italy’s northern Lombardy region, is known for the city in which has the most fashion costumes and accessories; Paris, France’s capital, is known for its romantic ambiance, and many couples usually like to have a date there. Also, some places

Models of Democracy- Essay about the models of democracy and how it is used in our US Government - Valdosta State University/ American Government - Essay

1557 words - 7 pages could lie to get elected and then what are they going to do? They would have to wait until that term is over to reelect someone else. But it also has more than just electing in this model. Some candidates (in the 24 states that allow it) do a policy question in a ballot and allow them to vote on it like that. About the same twenty-four states allow something called an initiative. Which is where people can send around a petition and if they get enough