How Stable Was Russia From 1905 To 1914 A Level History Essay

529 words - 3 pages

Mohamedamiin Sharif 12S
How stable was Russia in the period from the October Manifesto (1905) to the
outbreak of war (1914)
From the introduction of the October Manifesto in 1906 to the outbreak of war in
1914,the tsar’s position and Russia as a whole was stable to a large extent.However,
there were a few occasions where instability rose, and whether Russia was stable or
on the brink of a revolution will all be explored in this essay.
One example of there being stability is the October Manifesto itself.For example,
after the 1905 revolution, the manifesto had calmed almost all of the social classes.
It accomplished this by ending the peasant’s mortgages, introducing political parties
and the duma.Stability was also brought by crushing the workers, ensuring that there
wouldn’t be another incident.This links to the duma as they’re both factors which are
integral to the stability in Russia.
Another example of where there was stability in Russia is the creation of the
Dumas.This is because, despite the second duma being called “the duma of the
people’s wrath”, they possessed no real power and were only kept mainly due to two
reasons.One being related to foreign policy as, the tsar wanted to present Russia as
a democratic nation to other European countries that it was in trade with.And, the
second reason being that they posed no real threat because they had no real power
as a result of laws brought in by the tsar.The dumas brought stability to Russia as, it
give the illusion of democracy and kept the political parties satisfied for the time
being.This closely links with repression under Stolypin as both factors ensured
stability in Russia.
The final example of stability in Russia is repression under Stolypin. For example,
between 1906 and 1911 there were, over 2,500 executions which, quieted things
down resulting in stability across Russia until the assassination of Stolypin in
1911.After ‘Stolypin’s necktie’ had been ripped apart, instability began to spread like
wildfire resulting in strikes and massacres across Russia. However, before that,
Stolypin had made many reforms, introducing land banks and by 1914 16% of the
land had been made into farms. This links to The Lena Goldfield Incident as towards
the end of both events, it sparked major instability.
Although there was stability in Russia, that’s not to say there wasn’t instability and,
The Lena Goldfield Incident in 1912 is notorious for resulting in instability. For
example, the miners in Siberia demanded better pay but, their demands were
rejected and the Okhrana were called to arrest the strike leaders. However, once the
troops got there, the situation had quickly escalated resulting in troops killing a large
number of miners.This resulted in instability as families that were already poor were
left without the men who supported the family.
Mohamedamiin Sharif 12S
In conclusion, Russia was stable to a large extent mainly due to the tsar having the
support of his army and the liberals tolerated the tsar.The most important reason for
stability in Russia is repression under Stolypin as, the mass executions served as a
deterrent to others, and as a consequence during the period 1906 to 1911 there
wasn’t any instability in Russia.

RELATED

history russia and its rulers alevel - history - a level

1255 words - 6 pages good but fundamentally, it resulted in actually repressing the peoples of Russia. This is due to the fact that Nicholas II felt threatened by the increasing popularity for the Duma to play a larger role in government and so was dissolved on 6th october 1917. This is portraying how the Tsar was repressing the people as when they got a bit of hope from the Dumas the Tsar took them away, he took away their chances of countering repression. Conclusively

Thesis on how the Texas Republic was stable - American History - Thesis paper

2103 words - 9 pages The Stability of the Republic of Texas American History April 11, 2018 After the revolution, the Republic of Texas, also called the Lone Star Republic, was free from the dictatorship of Mexico. With economic and diplomatic ties, proper money management, strong leaders, the ability to defend itself, and a well-organized government the Republic of Texas was set up to succeed.[endnoteRef:1] Although the Lone Star Republic was self-sustaining and

WHY WAS THERE A CIVIL WAR IN RUSSIA IN 1918?

516 words - 3 pages successful as they took over most of the land and even joined a Japanese army in vladivostok.There was also quite a number of people whom opposed the bolsheviks party for various reasons. The workers wanted from the party what they had promised at the beginning; they wanted equalistic wages, Russia to be ruled by trade unions,free distribution of food and so on. Those opposed the bolsheviks included the social revolutionaries, although they were

how far was the legue a complete failure? - Hartlepool Sixth Form College History - Essay

1480 words - 6 pages Courtney Fishwick Media Histories How far was the League a complete failure? There were both successes and failures of the league. The Corfu incident of 1923 was a huge failure and demonstrated the weakness of the league. There was an incident at the Greek Albanian border where an Italian General, Tellini and his team were ambushed and killed. The league made a decision that compensation would be paid to the league and when the people

How was the Industrial Revolution a big part of History?

505 words - 3 pages (Early Coal Mining). This invention not only saves 2500 workers to carry out water from the pits, but also increases the output of coal which later produced industrial fuel. His first working engine was installed at a coalmine in Staffordshire in Seventeen twelve (Thomas Newcomen). In 1720 when Thomas died over one hundred of his engines were working in Britain.When weavers started to work alone because of the flying shuttles this increased the

’The crisis of the Byzantine Empire was the main reason for the First Crusade’ - DHSB - A-Level History Essay (The Crusades)

738 words - 3 pages into believing in the renewal to restore faith that the Byzantine empire along with the muslims were damaging. Additionally, the Byzantines always requested help from the West because Pope Gregory VII would aid them in any crises that the Byzantine Empire faced. Therefore, the crisis of the Byzantine Empire was a credible reason for the first crusade as Pope Urban II followed in Pope Gregory VII’s footsteps and as a result could not decline

Discuss The Changes And Continuities Of Russia From The 9th To The 18th Century

1061 words - 5 pages Great, the common structure of the government was autocratic. Catherine the Great further increased the power of the boyars over the peasantry, allowing them greater control in politics. Gradually transforming from a monarchy to an autocracy, the boyars political influence slowly increased as well. Since Russia was based heavily on its exportation of agricultural products and Russia was rapidly growing as a world power, it was necessary to control

The Essay, My Dad, Was Written During My First Year Of College As A Creative Writing Assignment. I Choose To Compose Upon A Memory From My Childhood

711 words - 3 pages details that occured. When I was about the age of ten my parents decided to separate. At my young age I, like most typical children at that age, I didn't exactly understand the circumstances. It was exceptionally difficult to cope with. Throughout all the arguments between my parents, I recall a few lines of one argument clearly, like a bottle of purified drinking water. I remember standing outside of my mother's bedroom door that was slightly

Factors that led to the rise of the Nazis - history - A level

2803 words - 12 pages , starting with a few seats, and importantly opportunities to partake and influence coalition governments. This happened to the Nazis who had ‘12’ seats in May 1928 that grew to ‘196[15]’ by November 1932. Hitler was given the position of Chancellor in the coalition government from this level of support, of which he uses the power to pass the Enabling Act. Whilst PR was a successful platform for the Nazis, there were other important factors that

Describe how 19th radicalism was formed and spread throughout America - SUNY Geneseo History 161 - essay

1665 words - 7 pages Dillon Szmala History 161- Final Essay Professor Jurnack Radicalism can be best described as the opinions and behavior of people who favor extreme changes, especially in government, political ideation and behavior.  This type of behavior has been studied by historians for centuries across the globe. One could argue that the first radical movement in the United States was the Colonies’ seeking freedom from Great Britain. This event sparked

How successful was Margret Thatcher at dealing with Industrial Relations - History - Essay

2076 words - 9 pages refused to join unions. By outlawing secondary picketing Thatcher limited the number of strikes and also limits how workers in unions are able to strike, the Employment Act meant strikers were no longer able to dissuade of prevent non-striking workers and supplies from entering the place of work, thus rendering secondary picketing a less effective and less persuasive means of protest as the law ensures work may continue relatively unhindered by

How is Othello presented in Act 1 - A-Level English Literature - Essay

491 words - 2 pages comparison to The Handmaid’s Tale which was set in 1984. The dystopian novel is set in England in a totalitarian state (A state with extremely high degree control of people and their private lives). This is similar to the situation in “1984” where the population are victims of omnipresent government surveillance. Both novels are set in England. Also both protagonists have some sort of relationship with a character that works for them, in “1984” Winston

Political dominance of the Republican party 1865-1912 - Durham Sixth Form Centre, A Level History - Essay

1339 words - 6 pages financial backing such as in the 1896 election when McKinley’s campaign received $3 million from Mark Hanna which helped him to run a stronger campaign than his opposition. Support from big business also benefited the Republicans as it allowed them to gain votes from people such as William Tweed and those that he told to vote Republican, and workers who would vote with their employers as it would benefit them if the business they worked for was

How Did The Nineteenth Amendment Come To Be Part Of Our Constitution And Why Was It Significant? A History Of The Female Right's Movement And The Importance Of The 19th Amendment

1560 words - 7 pages to sway votes. This national exposure led to thirteen states having referendum victories on the issue of female voting by 1918. The time had come for female suffrage on a national level. (law.umck.edu 1-2)On January 10 1918, the female suffrage amendment was again presented in Congress. The amendment passed in the House of Representatives by a vote of 304 to 89. Speaker Gillett signed the Bill and it was passed on to the Senate. Passing the bill

How far was Mao to bllame for the failure of the Great Leap Forward? - Alevel History - Coursework

4465 words - 18 pages Orla Gibbons Historians often disagree on to what extent Mao is to blame for the failure of the Great Leap Forward. What is your view on how far Mao is to blame for the failure of the Great Leap Forward? There is a prevalent historical debate regarding the extent to which Mao is to blame for the failures of the Great Leap Forward. The Great Leap Forward was an initiative put forward by Mao to transform China into a society capable of competing