How Successful Was The Education Reform Act Of 1998 Access To Childhood And Youth Essay

1400 words - 6 pages

How successful do you consider the Education Reform Act 1988 to have been?
The Education Reform Act (or ERA) was brought in by the secretary of state Kenny Baker and introduced a national curriculum and a system of testing and assignment for all state schools in England and Wales. This, in turn, gave greater control to schools by reducing the role of LEA’s. This essay will first summarise the pre-ERA situation, then describe the changes brought in by the ERA, before critically evaluating these and concluding that, while it was a step in the right direction, the ERA also had significant disadvantages.
Before the ERA was introduced schools were run under the Butler Act of 1944. The Butler Act presented 3 types of schools: Grammar Schools, which were mainly geared towards middle-class students with academic aptitudes; Secondary Modern schools, for the working class, and Technical Colleges. The Butler Act ended up legitimising and reproducing inequality, with the belief that academic ability is genetic rather than a product of upbringing as the two social classes were channeled into two different types of schools that offered unequal opportunities. When Comprehensive schools were introduced in 1965, their aim was to overcome the class divide produced by the tripartite system and to make schools more meritocratic. However, they continued to reproduce inequality. Grammar schools still existed, and working-class pupils now went to Comprehensives rather than Secondary Moderns. It was merely the myth of meritocracy that made it appear that there were equal opportunities in education, regardless of class background. Teachers would continue to place middle-class children in high streams, while condemning working-class children to lower streams, creating a self-fulfilling prophecy.
One of the aims of the ERA was to tackle this problem of self-fulfilling prophecy and to encourage diversity. The Conservative Government at the time, led by Margaret Thatcher, was heavily influenced by New Right and Neo-Liberal perspectives. Therefore there was a prevalence of ideas such as increasing choice and encouraging individual responsibility to raise standards, while wider patterns of social inequality were not considered.
It introduced two new types of schools: Grant Maintained schools and City Technology Colleges. Grant Maintained Schools were financed directly by central government (rather than the local authorities) and were self-governing, with the governors and the head-teachers making decisions about staff employment and the curriculum. City Technology Colleges were also introduced for 11-18-year-olds and were financed by the central government and private sector sponsorship and taught the national curriculum with a specific concentration on maths, science, and technology.
Furthermore, the National Curriculum was introduced by the ERA in 1989. This ensured that the Government had complete control over what would be taught in England and Wales. 5-16 Year olds in state schools has to study 3 core subjects of English, Maths, and Science, plus 7 foundation subjects. The aim was to provide a better quality of education for all by ensuring that all students were taught the same subjects. Students’ progress was then to be formally decided by national tests in core subjects at the end of key stages 2, 3 and 4 (although in 2003 the government removed KS3 SATS). These tests would measure student’s performance against others in their age groups. Measures could then be taken to improve the performance of children, as well as the performance of the schools, who were below the level that was expected of them. In 1992, all secondary state schools were instructed to publish the results of their SAT’s, GCSE’s, and A Levels, and local branched league tables were based on these results. While some provided raw results only, others would use a value-added measure, showing the progress of students. This would provide parents with information on where to send their children and was intended to encourage competition between schools and spur head teachers and staff to improve their league positions. The changes introduced by the ERA led to many improvements for some schools but also created further inequalities for other schools.
The rising marketization of schools is a very good example of this bifurcation between successful and struggling schools. Parental or consumer choice was a crux of the Act, unlike the Comprehensive structure where children had to attend a certain school depending on where they lived.
There were some advantages of this new system. With the introduction of formula funding, school funding was now chosen by pupil numbers and nothing related to class. Parents would be attracted to schools with higher-class facilities and teaching standards. Schools were were given an incentive to improve their teaching standards, which would benefit the children who were attending them. This competition and choice gave parents a chance and encouraged schools to compete to raise standards and league table positions, which would provide information to parents on which schools were the best.
However, there were also considerable disadvantages of this ERA reform. Popular schools were oversubscribed and could, therefore, choose which pupils they wanted. They would recruit middle-class, higher achieving students to make certain of success in the SATS and other exams. Middle-class parents were still at an advantage, they could afford to live in the best catchment areas, could offer their children more support, and even pay for private tutoring. Some middle-class parents were “privileged skilled choosers” who could become school governors or offer donations to maintain their child’s place in a higher achieving school. These developments led to middle-class students continuing to obtain a better education than their working-class peers. On the other hand, schools that achieved bad results would become less popular with parents, attract fewer new pupils, and less money would be available to improve student standards in those schools. This increasing unpopularity led to a spiral of decline for some schools and increasing numbers of working-class students with a below par education.
This inequality continued to widen between better performing schools in middle-class areas and their counterparts in working-class areas. Aforementioned high-performing schools would obtain economic and educational capital, while for schools whose performance was steadily declining the process operated in the opposite direction. Unpopular schools lost income and found it difficult to attract the best teachers or provide new equipment and facilities. This would make it even more difficult for them to attract motivated and high-achieving students, their SATS results would fall, and their funding would be reduced. Their low positions in league tables would mean continuing to only attract working class pupils and therefore their results remained poor.
There was also further harmful impact on children. Every school’s incentive was now to improve in order to obtain higher levels of funding. This led to a astounding amount of pressure on students to do well, leading to stress-related issues. Schools would now focus their efforts on pupils more likely to get higher grades and would prioritize the teaching of SATS rather than an overall education. Consequently, the national curriculum continues to lack choice and diversity. This was the government decreeing what counts as knowledge, and the national tests at 7,11 and 14 were used to their advantage to help keep a tight control of the curriculum. The division of knowledge into attainment subjects has also caused concern. Children who have not reached the recommended level for their age group are seen by themselves and others as a failure, again leading to a spiral of decline.
In conclusion, Thatcher's marketization policies through the Education Reform Act 1998 was effective in emphasizing how important educational achievement is and offering rewards to students and educational establishments that achieve. However, these reforms continued to perpetuate the class divide and with the spirit of decline, would damage working class futures. It is plain to see that the ERA was a step in the right direction, but the neo-liberal focus on choice and individual responsibility hid social inequalities and allowed them to continue.
Chitty, C. (2009). Education policy in Britain. (2nd Ed.). New York, USA: Palgrave Macmillan
Kelly, A.V. (2009). The curriculum theory and practice. (6th Ed.). London, England: SAGE Publications LImited.
Wood, K. (2011). Education the basics. Oxon, England: Routledge.
Meighan, R. (1986). A sociology of education. (2nd Ed.). Portsmouth, England: Holt, Rinehart and Winston LTD.
Flude, M. (1989). The Education Reform Act, 1988: Its Origins and Implications. London, England: Falmer Press LTD.
Jones, K. (2015). Education In Britain: 1944 to the Present. Cambridge, England: Polity Press
Maclure, S. (1988). Education Re-formed: Guide to the Education Reform Act 1988. London, England: Hodder Arnold H&S

RELATED

Was the Mexican Revolution Successful? - School - Essay

1016 words - 5 pages long-lasting which supports how the country was successful. With the revolution brought great wealth and prosperity. Lastly, the Mexican Revolution was a success because it conceived an unforgettable legacy. “…inspiration for Mexico’s artists and writers…writers such as Carlos Fuentes have set novels and stories…” “Emiliano Zapata, the symbol of land reform and proud ideological purity, has become an international icon for just rebellion against

how successful was the league of nations in the 1920s - year 10 - assignment

980 words - 4 pages How successful was the League of Nations in the 1920s? The League of nations had a few successes, but also had many failures. The League was made up of - the Council - who were a small group of permanent members (Japan, Italy, Britain and France) who had Vetos (which meant they could stop all actions even if everyone else agreed) and also some temporary members (who were re-elected every 3 years) and didn’t have a veto - The assembly - who

Assignment On Was The KKK Successful?

565 words - 3 pages existence. No matter where the Klan is headed, violence is sure to follow. However one question remains, was the Ku Klux Klan successful?Many people may think that the Ku Klux Klan was not successful because of the fact that they were a group of thugs, who coerced colored people in office, bullied black residents to keep them from exercising their rights guaranteed under law, and tried to renovate a way of life that brought on the Civil War

History of the National Health Service. - Learn Direct - Access to higher education, Health Studies. - Academic Poster

3458 words - 14 pages A History Of The NHS.A History Of The NHS. Factors leading to the creation of the modern NHS and how it has responded to changes in funding and Factors leading to the creation of the modern NHS and how it has responded to changes in funding and the demands placed upon it demands placed upon it.. Stephen McClusky, AHE (Health Studies) 12/05/2019.Stephen McClusky, AHE (Health Studies) 12/05/2019. Prior to the 1880s, The ‘Poor Laws’ created during

final paper on the effects of advertising on the youth and how ad companies manipulate the youth - english - paper

1732 words - 7 pages something is healthy when it really isn’t, even while avoiding legal issues with mislabeling. Advertisers are making most of their profit from young consumers therefore they study the patterns in which they spend their money, so they can have an idea how they will spend their money as adults. Body type and size are related to genetics but there are other influences like the advertising market and one’s environmental influences. Today, people are

how important was ideology to the development of the bolshevik state between 1917 and 1924 - morpeth - essay

671 words - 3 pages aspect of it. Reading this further deepened my understanding of chemistry and gave me taste of what I will be learning at degree level and just emphasises my passion for it. Having done a work placement in an Russia Lane Elderly Day Care Centre showed me how important the use of drugs are, as I saw how the care workers had to give the right drugs in the right doses and how important this was in their daily routine. This showed me how much I wanted

This essay was written about the how illegal movies damaging to movie sector and whole economies of the countries

486 words - 2 pages said that via internet, studios have chance to get audiences’ tastes and make films according to popularity.However the real situation is not as it seems. As The Economics reports, there are a growing number of pirate web sites that offers films to people at a very low price or free. These kinds of sites are hard to control even if laws forbid them. Although there are some legal sites which are supported by studios, their archives are not as

How to become a successful music producer - Lit12A - essay

427 words - 2 pages To become a successful music producer now a days you have to be confident in your work and very persistent in what kind of producing you want to pursue in. Top producer in the industry right now Marc Kinchen said “It’s a combination of skills”, meaning you shouldn’t necessarily let others tell you how you should produce your music. Behind every song there’s a team of people who stays up hours and days to get a song together and can take up to

The Essay, My Dad, Was Written During My First Year Of College As A Creative Writing Assignment. I Choose To Compose Upon A Memory From My Childhood

711 words - 3 pages at my young age didn't know how to act upon them.For days, I was devastated and constantly had thoughts flowing through my mind like water flows through the Mississippi River. I remember thinking can this really be true? My dad is my dad, right? Why did my mom say that to my father? I had so many unanswered questions and I wanted to seek answers to them but I didn't know how to pursue the task.One day, I approached my mother and directly asked

How successful was Margret Thatcher at dealing with Industrial Relations - History - Essay

2076 words - 9 pages , as previously business had been given to overseas companies in favour of their lower labour costs. In that respect Thatcher was largely successful. It was her legislation which greatly limited the legal power of the unions and her economic policy which significantly reduced the numerical power of the trade unions. Thatcher’s policies on industrial relations eventually lead to de-unionisation and despite the criticism of her policies regarding

Early Childhood Education Competency 4 - Early Childhood Education - Short Essay

593 words - 3 pages Competency Four: To establish positive and productive relationships with families. “It takes an entire village to raise a single child.” This African phrase says so much for me as I constantly engage with every family to assist in the positive growth of their child. During my time in the Early Childhood Education program, I witness the importance of the family in the young child’s education and the early childhood curriculum. I encourage

The Meaning of Adulthood and Childhood - English - Essay

635 words - 3 pages culture boys/girls have bar/bat mitzvahs to celebrate the transition to adulthood. In the U.S an individual would say 16 because girls have sweet 16’s to also celebrate the transition into adulthood. These are just 3 variations. Imagine how many more there is. Thirdly, my definition of childhood and adulthood has changed through the years. When I was young I used to think adulthood was when you turn 18. I thought this because most people turn 18 and

Child development. The development of childhood and adolescence - Harvard - Essay

2163 words - 9 pages insurance money of ten thousand dollars. No matter how hard he tries he does not feel like he can ever get what he wants and he decides to take out his frustrations on his family. Walter wants to open a liquor store with two partners. Bobo and Willy. Though he thought the idea of running this business was legit and can bring in money, they were just quick schemes that may cause more harm than good. Walter is like many today, they are quick to find ways

a essay to get access to the website - English - essay

1083 words - 5 pages surprised when the majority of the students had little knowledge on the basic foundation of creating an essay well. This for me made me think on how they have been deprived of the most valuable part of academic success. Yet, of course it was already senior year and the teachers are given a curriculum that is geared towards students that should already be able to do this, and most of them could not. I have been exposed to the task of writing more

early childhood education and care - viu - assignment

837 words - 4 pages for children's success. Because of that, a large amount of parent-child time and financial resources have been invested in academic education. The child was instilled with too much perfectionism by his parents in his early years, and their ultimate goal was to enter a good university and find the best job. However, grades do not represent competence. Different children have different talents, and not everyone is suitable to be a leader. What