How Successful Was The League Of Nations In The 1920s Year 10 Assignment

980 words - 4 pages

How successful was the League of Nations in the 1920s?
The League of nations had a few successes, but also had many failures.
The League was made up of - the Council - who were a small group of permanent members (Japan, Italy, Britain and France) who had Vetos (which meant they could stop all actions even if everyone else agreed) and also some temporary members (who were re-elected every 3 years) and didn’t have a veto - The assembly - who recommended action to the Council and voted on: new members, deciding temporary members to the Council, and what to do with the budget (all decisions being made unanimously) - the Court of International Justice - who’s job it was to settle any border disputes fairly and peacefully, however they couldn’t actually enforce these ideas - the Secretariat - the administrative part of the League, who kept records, prepared reports, etc. - the International Labour Organisation - worked towards improving working conditions around the world, yet they couldn’t make the ideas happen - and many different committees and commissions. When there was an argument or disagreement, the League wanted to resolve disputes through co-operation, however if this did not work, the League would use powers to settle the disagreement, these being - Moral Condemnation - the League would decide who was the ‘aggressor’ and command it to stop taking further action. - Sanctions - Members of the League would refuse to trade with the ‘aggressor’ - and Military Force - countries who were members of the LoN could use their armed forces to against the ‘aggressor’.
The League succeeded in creating a better world. It had many committees that worked towards many different important issues in society, such as health and working conditions. The League achieved many successful outcomes, especially for refugees after WW1. 400,000 refugees were returned home, also housing thousands in camps in Turkey, as well as stopping cholera, smallpox and dysentery spreading within those camps. Slavery was also a major success, as 200,000 slaves were freed from Sierra Leone. The LoN also organised multiple raids against slave owners and traders in Burma, challenged the use of forced labour and miraculously brought the death rate of African workers from 50% to 4%. The Health committee managed to defeat leprosy and campaigned towards eliminating mosquitos which carried malaria, which was a huge success, other countries such as the USSR asked for health advice from the League. Although the League improved working conditions by banning poisonous lead paint and limiting child working hours, the League failed in reducing work hours, as only a small minority agreed to reduce work to a 48 hour week and an 8 hour day, meaning that workers still worked for extremely long hours for many days a week.
Disarmament on the other hand, was a complete failure. Although it was one of the key aims of the league, disarmament took little action, as all permanent members agreed to limit their navies, but that was all that was done in favour of disarmament. This was unsuccessful as it destroyed the League’s reputation in Germany, as Germany had disarmed and showed that the LoN was weak, as the representatives couldn’t give up their armies.
Settling disputes was both successful in some situations and unsuccessful in others. The majority of the time both countries accepted the decision. For example, Finland and Sweden threatened war over who got control of the Aaland islands. The LoN decides they should belong to Finland and both countries accept the decision. This was successful as both countries were happy with the end result, and no violence occurred. However, sometimes neither or one country doesn’t agree. An example of this is when Poland took control of the capital of Lithuania, Vilna. Lithuania asked the League for help, resulting in Poland ignoring the League’s protests and refusing to withdraw. The League didn’t use any further powers as they were supposed to do so (no military force or sanctions) as Britain and France weren’t prepared for another war, if America was part of the League, oral condemnation would’ve been enough to stop countries like Poland as they would feel threatened by America’s power. This was a failure as The League didn’t take any further action as they are required to do so, therefore Poland didn’t feel threatened enough to stop, resulting in a war. Another example of this would be when an Italian General, Tellini, was murdered whilst supervising the border between Albania and Greece. Mussolini (an Italian dictator) was furious about the murder. He believed it was the Greek Government’s fault, so Italy bombards and occupies the Greek island of Corfu. Greece appeals to the Council, which condemns Mussolini’s actions and suggest that Greece pays compensation, which would be held until Greece was proven guilty. Mussolini disagreed with this decision, resulting in the League giving in and forcing Greece to apologise and pay compensation. Italy withdrew and Greece got the land back, but still had to pay. This was a success in the fact they stopped a war from taking place but also failed as the League gave in to stronger powers (Italy) and was unfair. Overall, the aim of preventing aggression/conflict was mostly a failure as the League could not control the more powerful countries such as Italy.
Leaders of all countries were encouraged to cooperate with each other and collaborate instead of compete. Great and small powers felt it was worth sending their ministers to meetings, helping the aim of international cooperation.
In conclusion the League was successful in working towards a better world, helping refugees, slaves and etc. But wasn’t so successful in resolving disputes between countries and completely failed in world disarmament. Overall the League of Nations was mostly a failure due to the fact the League couldn’t control major powers (such as Italy) and failed to disarm the world.

RELATED

History WWI - effects, league of nations, women, australia...... - Year 10 - Notes

2772 words - 12 pages Mussolini who took aggressive action against the countries around them. The weakness of the league of nations: The ​League of Nations​ was founded in 1919 as a result of the Treaty of Versailles and the end of World War I. The ​League of Nations​ was an international organization, headquartered in Geneva, Switzerland, created after the First World War to provide a meeting for resolving international disputes (disagreements). Although it was able to

Assess the reliability and usefulness of the documentary 'Prelude to War,' in determining the failure of the League of Nations

532 words - 3 pages The documentary, Prelude to War, is unreliable but is useful to an extent in explaining one of the core failures of the League of Nations. Its reliability is detracted due to its narrow view, blatant bias and propaganda evident in the production of this film. However, this bias demonstrates the prejudice mindset of the American people at the time and could be a useful explanation for America's refusal to join the League, which was one of its key

Asses the successes and failures of the League of Nations commissions in the 1920's and 1930's - anonymous - essay

1860 words - 8 pages Max Rogers W09 History Mr Bennett Assess the successes and failures of the League of Nations Commissions in the 1920s and 1930s The League of Nations was an international organisation of states, based in Geneva Switzerland. Its main aims were to keep peace and improve people’s lives. In 1920, it began with 42 members and grew to 58 in 1934. It was dissolved in 1946. Its various commissions spanned the length of the 1920s and 30s, they sustained

Assignment On Was The KKK Successful?

565 words - 3 pages existence. No matter where the Klan is headed, violence is sure to follow. However one question remains, was the Ku Klux Klan successful?Many people may think that the Ku Klux Klan was not successful because of the fact that they were a group of thugs, who coerced colored people in office, bullied black residents to keep them from exercising their rights guaranteed under law, and tried to renovate a way of life that brought on the Civil War

Why did the League of Nations fail? - High School/History - Essay

742 words - 3 pages Carpenter Carpenter 1 Austin Carpenter Ms. Hjort 20th Century World History April 30, 2018 Why did the League of Nations fail in the 1930’s? In 1919, when the League of Nations was first created. One of its main objectives was to ensure lasting peace. Despite several successes throughout the 1920’s, they failed to maintain this goal in the 1930’s. This lead to a loss of credibility, the collapse of the League, and lastly resulting in World War 2

How Successful was the Education Reform Act of 1998 - Access to Childhood and Youth - Essay

1400 words - 6 pages How successful do you consider the Education Reform Act 1988 to have been? The Education Reform Act (or ERA) was brought in by the secretary of state Kenny Baker and introduced a national curriculum and a system of testing and assignment for all state schools in England and Wales. This, in turn, gave greater control to schools by reducing the role of LEA’s. This essay will first summarise the pre-ERA situation, then describe the changes brought

Was the Mexican Revolution Successful? - School - Essay

1016 words - 5 pages other nations, which were developing industrially and socially.” Even with the large industrial change of the country, its social and economic base was still in crisis. The peasants stayed impoverished while rich land owners stayed above them. The quote suggests that the nobility who controlled the country were biased towards the rich. The hierarchy of Mexico had affected how everyone was treated. This can conclude how the rich only received the

Functions Of The United Nations

768 words - 4 pages Functions of the United NationsThe United Nations is an international body that was formed in 1945 after World War II. The United Nations was formed to replace the League of Nations. Its primary objectives includes; stopping wars between countries and to providing a platform for dialogue. It contains multiple subsidiary organizations to carry out its missions.The United Nations contains 192 member states. - (This includes nearly every recognised

how do the characters of Claudio, Leanato and Don Pedro behave towards Hero - year 10 - essay

1765 words - 8 pages easily misled, and his naivety and gullibility expose a different side to him. On just the words of Don John alone, he is quick to believe the worst in Hero and in Act 4, scene 1 we see how he choses to shame Hero on what was supposed to be their wedding day. Here, Shakespeare presents a different side to Claudio, one that would have been quite relatable to the audiences of his time. From the very onset of the scene, it becomes clear that Claudio’s

How does Orwell present the power of manipulation through Squealer? - Year 10 - Essay

756 words - 4 pages George Orwell’s 1946 novel Animal Farm uses the animals of Manor Farm as a metaphor for Stalinism to establish the corruption and dangers of a Communist leadership. In keeping with this theme, the novel uses many examples of propaganda–often used by totalitarian leaders–to illustrate that people can be easily influenced by faulty ideas if they are presented in an appealing manner. Animal Farm proves that true power may not come with the dictator

Lenin was the critical factor in the Bolshevik consolidation of power - Year 12 assessment - Essay

1404 words - 6 pages followed – Accept all the terms of a peace treaty, no matter how harsh, in order to gain time. Lenin argued that any losses to Germany – a nation on the “doorstep ” of socialist revolution – would be temporary. The signing of the Treat of Brest-Litovsk was a critical component of the consolidation as it allowed Russia to focus on internal problems, such as the economic crisis and food shortages (caused by WWI). As it was Lenin who convinced the

lord of the flies comparison piece - year 10 - essay

518 words - 3 pages civilization is presented in the beginning, the texts have a different sort of evil within, Lord of the flies ‘beast’ was an actually object, while The Twilight Zone ‘aliens’ were themselves. Nevertheless, both eventually replaced their good morals leading into a downwards spiral turning mankind into its own worst enemy. In the beginning, The Lord of the flies and The Twilight Zone have many corresponding aspects. Many of the characters represent each

“The experience of slaves who worked in the fields was typical of all slaves' - Pultney Grammar School Year 9 - Essay

2124 words - 9 pages “The experience of slaves who worked in the fields was typical of all slaves.” How accurate is this statement? Refer to a range of slave groups in your response. There were numerous experiences that all slaves had regardless of their situation. Slavery existed in the Americas from the sixteenth to the nineteenth century. Slaves were utilised for the most part to make or harvest materials, like sugar and cotton to export to European countries

why the protest were successful in removing the rulers in some Arab Spring countries - Politics of the Mi - Essay

1302 words - 6 pages Discuss the key actors that help explain why the protest were successful in removing the rulers in some Arab Spring countries, such as Tunisia or Libya, while the protests in countries like Bahrain or Syria failed to achieve the same outcome. The Arab Spring was a series of anti-government protests, uprisings and armed rebellions that spread across the Middle East in early 2011. These demonstrations initially varied in size and intensity

"The Rookie Arrives" By Thomas J. Dygard: Why Ted Bell Was So Successful?

851 words - 4 pages To be successful will take a lot of hard work and practice people that are successful do not happen overnight. In the story The Rookie Arrives, the protagonist Ted Bell has his dream come true when he plays for a major league baseball team. He demonstrates that no one would stop him from achieving his. Ted keeps his head up even when things aren't the way he would like it and when his parents want him to go back to school. The qualities