How The Conflict Between Roman Duty And Egyptian Sensuousness Develops The Tragedy Of Antony And Cleopatra Comments: More Focus On Final Scene Was Expected

1764 words - 8 pages

Antony epitomizes the traditional tragic hero. The elements that constitute Antony's tragic standing are centrally developed by the conflict between Roman duty and Egyptian sensuousness. The audience empathises with the nature of his demise, as it deems Antony a morally respectable person, and can understand his downfall as a result of the conflict.The conflict embodies his tragic flaw, which is his stubbornness in trying to achieve an elusive compromise between his duty to Rome and his passion for Cleopatra. Antony's priorities repeatedly sway in favour of Rome and then Cleopatra indeterminably and uncompromisingly. The audience experiences catharsis upon witnessing the protagonist's dem ...view middle of the document...

Philo's speech illustrating the Roman perception of Antony's hedonism in Egypt, whilst unjust towards Cleopatra, is much more controlled than that of Antony. He describes how Antony's greatness has deteriorated due to the 'dotage of (his) general's', which 'O'erflows the measure'. This presents a more reasoning statement, contrary to Antony's reckless and exaggerated expression of disregard to Rome. Demetrius' speech expressing his regret is similar in tone, expressing his regret 'That (Antony) approves the common liar'. This epitomizes a recurring conflict between Antony's sense of honour and his unfulfilling actions.Honesty is central to Antony's idea of honour. However, he frequently speaks upon impulse, distorting the integrity of his actions. This is exemplified by his response to the news from Messenger of war led by Labienus 'with his Parthian force'. Antony is quick in accepting blame for the outbreak of war due to his desertion from the Roman Empire, urging Messenger to speak genuinely critically of him for his actions, saying 'Speak to me home, mince not the general tongue'. He stresses his resigned desire to hear Messenger's most severe and honest thoughts concerning his reckless actions, asking him to 'taunt (his) faults/ With such full license as both truth and malice/ Have power to utter'. This outburst typifies Antony's disposition to impulsively changing his moral stance, as does his sudden marking of Cleopatra as the root of his actions, which moves him to ask her for one to 'Name Cleopatra as she is called in Rome'. He maintains this tone upon the news of Fulvia's death, further depicting Cleopatra as the cause of his problems. He suggests that the queen's seduction of him into 'idleness' had a spell- binding effect of him, exclaiming that he 'must from this enchanting queen break off'. He continues in a hyperbolic manner reminiscent of his speech in act one, scene one from line thirty- three to thirty- nine, claiming his hedonism with Cleopatra to be the cause of 'Ten thousand harms'. The typical exaggerated tone of Antony's speech is emphasised through its presentation in marked contrast to the voice of truth represented by Enobarbus. Enobarbus' lines are in prose, presenting a more convincing and contained tone to the theatrical verse of Antony. He calms Antony's discomfort concerning Cleopatra's supposedly 'cunning' seductive influence on him, assuring him 'her passions are made of nothing but the finest part of pure love'.Antony's vacillation of moral stance is justified by the indecisiveness of the conflict between Roman duty and Egyptian sensuousness. Cleopatra and Caesar, the representatives of Egypt and Rome respectively, are each portrayed as possessing admirable and conflicting traits. Cleopatra has a strong and forthright character, which frequently acts upon impulse making her temperamental and theatrical. She expresses the Egyptian opposition to the disciplined manner of Rome through hyperbolic sarcasm when ...

RELATED

how the reputations of cleopatra has been presented throughout film - Open University, The arts past and present - Assingment

891 words - 4 pages Cleopatra enters Rome. This scene cost over $1 million to make, and the whole film was the most expensive movie to be made at that time. You can see in the 1934 adaptation when Cleopatra meets Julia Cesar the extravagance of the big columns and the fancy jewellery around her neck and wrist, this was to fit in with the Art Deco age. Another similarity between the two films is the way Cleopatra is played. The 1934 film and 1963 film share a theme of

In the Tragedy of Romeo and Juliet was the opposition of arranged marriages fair? - Western High School - Essay

524 words - 3 pages In The Tragedy of Romeo and Juliet, Paris is one of the reason of conflicts because he is the one who asks Capulet for Juliet's hand in marriage. Paris was a wealthy and noble man so as expected Capulet agreed. This agreement in which Juliet had no say in the marriage is basically an arranged marriage, where the person whose getting married doesn’t choose their spouse. In Shakespeare's play Paris represents arranged marriages, he essentially

Overview Of The Indus Valley And Egyptian Peoples

396 words - 2 pages The Egyptian civilization and the Indus Valley civilization were very different places. In Egypt, while pyramids were being built, cities were beginning to form in the Indus Valley. Both of these places had fertile lands and natural barriers to prevent invaders. Nobody really knows about the Indus Valley government except for Sargon of Akkad, but we do know that they worshipped several gods, including Shiva. In Egypt, their rulers, or pharaohs

how important was ideology to the development of the bolshevik state between 1917 and 1924 - morpeth - essay

671 words - 3 pages Sadeea Khatun Rahman Personal Statement Recently, interest has been focused on the design and evaluation of prodrugs that are capable of exploiting one or more of the various transport systems at the level of the blood brain barrier. This advance in medicinal chemistry means that, very soon, treatment for diseases which we believed to be

final paper on the effects of advertising on the youth and how ad companies manipulate the youth - english - paper

1732 words - 7 pages difference between healthy and unhealthy food and everybody should be sufficiently educated on health, but these advertisers’ manipulating ads are keeping us uninterested and unmotivated. Kids are so vulnerable to these advertisements and it is their parents job to educate their children at an early age on the importance of health and healthy foods and the impact they have on the body. Everybody should be taught to crave a lifelong healthy lifestyle and

The Conflict Between Nature and Culture in Wuthering Heights

469 words - 2 pages The Conflict Between Nature and Culture in Wuthering HeightsIn Wuthering Heights there is a clear battle between human nature, and the attempt to control it with civilization and culture. The conflict between nature and culture which is a part of the thematic structure of this novel is presented in the relationship between two residences: Wuthering Heights and Thrushcross Grange as well as its inhabitants. Wuthering Heights represents the

explore Williams’ presentation of the conflict between Blanche and Stanley so far. - School Lit - Essay

1440 words - 6 pages to comprehend the new world. The final way that Williams may have attempted to create conflict between the old world and the new is through plastic theatre and the overall production of the theatrical performance of the play. From stage directions to costumes and most importantly the physical scene itself, Williams has used proxemics to make props and staging easy to understand to an audience - this is important in a performance as the show is

Frankenstein: How there are more similarities than differences between Frankenstein and the creature - Valley Christian High School - English - Essay

933 words - 4 pages Alexa Neal Visual Art Conservatory 25 February 2018 Art Museum Visit Essay For my art gallery/museum visit assignment, I wanted to travel to someplace that was one of a kind, and not just any average exhibit, which is usually comprised of similar art styles in a more classical era. So, after much deliberation and scrolling through various museums near my house, I decided on The San Francisco Museum of Modern Art(MOMA), one of the largest museums

How is Caius Martius presented in the first scene of Coriolanus? What conflicts and oppositions are set up in this scene? - English Literature - Essay

1882 words - 8 pages How is Caius Martius presented in the first scene of Coriolanus? What conflicts and oppositions are set up in this scene? The play commences in the city of Rome where the common folk, the “plebeians”, are rioting against the patrician class due to the increase in hunger. The action of the play is semi-historical and is set in the aftermath of the fall of Tarquin. It focuses on the ongoing struggle between the plebeians and patricians during

'the Scope And Focus Of Memory Are Too Intimate For The Grand Sweep Of History,' Do You Agree Or Disagree. Based On Text Fiftieth Gate

291 words - 2 pages explore their history with great detail.Marks change in the way he delivers the history of the holocaust is also influenced by the pain he felt through his parents memory,'alone frieghtened .... I was so scared. But my mother said,'run to judenrat' ....saved my life.' The memory of the survivors gives a unique perspective on the holocaust and the intimacy of such personal memories enriches the event.The biased view of mark and his parents memory does not affect the text as a historical source as it is written from the perspective of jewish survivors as they were the largest victims of the holocaust.

open admission a play that explain the conflict between student and a teacher - jefferson college - essey

817 words - 4 pages The play “Open Admission” gives a specific way of shaking the audience. It grabs attention of the audience and refuse to give us the way out. It tells us off the conflict between the white female teacher and a black male student in a public College. It reminds me of a boxing match, Small cubical area in darkness as Allice was cornered at the door by Calvin. Calvin requesting to be seen by Allice immediately like it was life and death matter

Roman Influences On Western Society (Between Rome And Greece, Without Mentioning Greece)

854 words - 4 pages Parliament, which is also equated to the Senate. Most western societies have based their governments on the tried and true methods of the Roman civilization. Roman law was known for being equitable and fair through the old "innocent until proven guilty", which is also arguably the most important right that the United States' Constitution provides. Another aspect of government is military, which, it was noted, the Romans had this "doggedness" about them

What was the significance of the naval race between Great Britain and Germany? - class 213 - Research paper

1411 words - 6 pages foreign policy focused on extending Germany’s influence as a global power and thereby aligning it with the other big players on the world scene”(Clark 150). This term illustrated that Germany was eager to prove itself as one of the Great Powers. As a result, Alfred von Tirpitz, a German Grand Admiral, advocated the “Risk Fleet Strategy”, whereby Germany would “pursue an aggressive foreign policy and using the emerging high speed fleet to bargain

Othello- analysis of speech by Iago taken from Act 2 Scene 3 occurs just after the brawl between Cassio and Montano, where Othello is disgusted with his lieutenant's behavior and dismisses Cassio

505 words - 3 pages English SpeechThis vital speech by Iago taken from Act 2 Scene 3 occurs just after the brawl between Cassio and Montano, where Othello is disgusted with his lieutenant's behavior and dismisses Cassio. From the beginning Iago behaves in this way because of his intense jealousy he has at Othello for promoting Cassio over him.His motivation develops further due to jealousy of both Cassio and Othello, and their happiness. These projections of hate

Height Of The Roman Empire

750 words - 3 pages At its height, the Roman Empire stretched from the north of Britain to the desert of Egypt. Emperors were cruel and bent on conquering. Art and architecture flourished, but math and science did not. The idea of the empire began with Julius Caesar, who was killed because he was ruling the government by himself. His adopted son, Octavian, became the first emperor, calling himself Augustus Caesar. The Roman Empire split into two parts, East and