Impact Of Biology Text Books On The Scopes Monkey Trial Poli Sci Position

887 words - 4 pages

The U.S. is regarded as the land of the free people because it hosts individuals that have fled their home countries because of lack of religious freedom. Religious fanatics from Europe imposed their beliefs on locals and insisted that they act according to their deities’ rules. Notably, these zealots interpreted the Bible literally and insisted that people should follow rules that affirm monotheism. Randy Moore’s article, The Lingering Impact of the Scopes Trial on High School Textbooks, articulates the way these fundamentalists who opposed Darwin’s theory imposed their opinion on politicians. The writer recounts how the opponents of Darwin’s argument illegalized the theory of evolution and forced politicians to convict John Scopes, a teacher who imparted the theory on his students. Moore discusses American education before and after the conviction and aims at illustrating the long-term effects of the trial on the American syllabus.
Moore describes people's reaction to Charles Darwin's theory of evolution and explains that Christians regarded it as a blasphemous concept. However, one botanist supported the theory despite being an evangelist. Moore states that the botanist proposed an argument in which he combined Christian views and the Darwinian Theory[footnoteRef:1]. The writer also introduces religious fundamentalism, which he defines as a literal interpretation of the Bible. The scholar posits that the fundamentalists opposed the Darwinian Theory and blamed it for the decline of moral values in the country[footnoteRef:2]. Therefore, religious leaders pushed policymakers to enact a law that declared the theory blasphemous. The lawmakers obliged and declared the theory illegal; therefore, forbade teachers from talking about the theory in classrooms. [1: Randy Moore “The Lingering Impact of The Scopes Trial on High School Biology Textbooks.” In The Textbook as Discourse, (New York, Routledge, 2011, 102-116] [2: Randy Moore “The Lingering Impact of The Scopes Trial on High School Biology Textbooks.” In The Textbook as Discourse, (New York, Routledge, 2011, 102-116]
In the subsequent segment, the writer discusses the content of biology textbooks before Scopes’ trial. Moore states that some textbook authors wrote about the theory, among others. In other cases, the writers dedicated chapters or entire biology books to discuss evolution[footnoteRef:3]. The scholar says that although some textbook writers focused on evolution, others omitted it and claimed that it was complicated for high school students. However, Moore believes that these authors used the statement as an excuse to omit the theory from their books. In the same fragment, the writer elaborates on the trial of John Scopes, a substitute teacher who gave his students an assignment about evolution. The writer also expresses doubt over the allegations against the teacher who was absent from school on the date that the prosecutors claimed he taught the forbidden subject. [3: Randy Moore “The Lingering Impact of The Scopes Trial on High School Biology Textbooks.” In The Textbook as Discourse, (New York, Routledge, 2011, 102-116]
After Scopes’ prosecution, publishers omitted the subject of evolution from their texts, as Moore explains. Few instructors taught the theory for fear of persecution and criticism. According to Moore, the Texas governor tore pages that entailed information about Darwin’s theory from a biology textbook, and from then on, publishers printed sanitized textbooks for Texas’ public schools. At the same time, textbook writers omitted the theory whenever they revised their texts and published new editions. Moore observes that after two decades, textbook writers included evolution in their books. Pioneers of the second wave of evolution theory in books emphasized that it was a theory and not a fact. The effort was meant to prove that the writers did not dispute the creation story; instead, they maintained that Darwin’s argument was a second opinion about the origin of species. As time passed, authors gained courage, made bold statements about the theory, and declared it a proved scientific argument[footnoteRef:4]. The opinions about science syllabus intensified when a public concern erupted because of the Soviet Union whose science projects overtook the American ones. In a quest to compete with the European country, the United States government increased investment in sciences. The policymakers eliminated the law that forbade the teaching of the theory in schools. Still, the fundamentalists insisted that teachers reduce coverage of the theory in classrooms, and while some authors complied, others wrote about the theory. Moore adds that after the confrontation between the religious leaders and politicians, the biology textbook composers included the theory in their works. However, the writers used mild word choice such as “change” and “development” to disassociate their books with the theory[footnoteRef:5]. Some writers, according to Moore, emphasized the evolution theory’s scientific proof since the elements seemed sensible compared to the creation theory, which bases arguments on faith. At the conclusion, Moore states that some scholars teach the method apologetically while others still emphasize the creationist theory[footnoteRef:6]. Lastly, the writer observes that textbook writers insist on the approach, as part of biology syllabus, since it provides an alternative explanation for people's development. Moore proves his hypothesis about John Scopes' trial since its occurrence affected the biology syllabus. [4: ibid] [5: Randy Moore “The Lingering Impact of The Scopes Trial on High School Biology Textbooks.” In The Textbook as Discourse, (New York, Routledge, 2011, 102-116)] [6: ibid]
Moore, Randy. “The Lingering Impact of The Scopes Trial on High School Biology Textbooks.” In The Textbook as Discourse, New York, Routledge, 2011, 102-116.


DBQ Exercise: Scopes Monkey Trial Assignment

422 words - 2 pages This article is about the Scopes Monkey Trial. Although that was not the official and legal name for the case, it is universally known as such It involved a science teacher, Scopes, who taught Evolution in his public school Biology class which went against the Butler Act. He was arrested and tried by two of the most famous names in law at the time, Clarence Darrow and William Jennings Bryan. Bryan would prosecute and Darrow in association with

The Impact of Red Bull and Berocca on Urine Content - BSDE, Biology - Research Paper

3407 words - 14 pages Conclusion A null hypothesis was utilised for this experiment. This hypothesis was accepted in the instance of Berocca, as it had no negligible impact on the renal system. However, when the test subject consumed red bull, pH decreased. Thus, rejecting the hypothesis. These results, when compared and contrasted with the observations and physical changes log suggest that this was evidence of the respiratory and renal buffer system in action. Further

The Impact Of Advertisement On Gun Control

769 words - 4 pages Free pink on her dress and her lips, the advertisement is emphasizing innocence to its viewers. Her crystal blue eyes are widely open, symbolizing her naïveness. Her little smile is welcoming and trusts everyone. She is innocent to the world and everything in it. She trusts everyone, not understanding the danger around her. Violence is one of the main themes of the advertisement. It is represented by the bullet hole in the doll's forehead

The Future of Space and Humanity - Sci-Fi - Essay

1288 words - 6 pages The Future of Space and Humanity What will our future look like, specifically within a decade? The scientists are already talking about sending people to Mars, colonize, and grow population. Let me rephrase that, they’re not only talking, they’re already doing things about it such as researching and developing things that will help us, humans, survive on Mars like having food to eat, gardening on Mars, receiving air continuously, and using and

The Unjust Prosecution of Socrates - Ave Maria University, Western Civilization Honors, Sugrue - Short Essay on trial of Socrates

548 words - 3 pages Western Civilization Honors 17 October 2017 The Unjust Prosecution of Socrates In 399 BC, Socrates, arguably the founder of western philosophy, was put on trial by the Greek Assembly. He was accused of impiety against the gods of Athens and corrupting the youth of the city. Socrates is well-known for questioning every detail of every argument. Indeed, he was a social gadfly, a term he created himself that means a person who upsets the status quo

essay on sherlock describing some of the adventures he went on in one of his books - english 12 - essay

1033 words - 5 pages SAT Admission Ticket Message to Supervisors Page 1 of 2 Test Day Information Test Date: Test Center: Test Type: Message to Students: PRINT AND BRING THIS TICKET TO TEST CENTER. Tickets on a smartphone will not be accepted. All test centers open at 7:45 a.m., and doors close at 8 a.m., unless otherwise noted on this ticket. You will not be admitted after 8 a.m. Keep this printed ticket with you at all times in the test center. ID policy

The Effects of Smoking on Lung Tissue - Biology - Lab Report

2559 words - 11 pages impact of smoking on ciliary movement, the beat frequency of the cilia from a mollusc gill sample was recorded after being exposed to a high tar level cigarette extract, a low tar cigarette level extract, and regular seawater as a control variable. These extracts were created using a hooka mechanism and the mollusc gill cilia were used as a model for the cilia found within the lungs of mammals. Using our previous knowledge on the effects of smoking

What Was The Political Impact Of WW1 On Europe?

1064 words - 5 pages The first Total War also known as the 'bloodiest' war of the century, WWI proved to have a great impact upon all of Europe. Politically, there is a clear scene of what impact the War had on the main powers in Europe: for some countries, such as France and Britain, the change in regime was merely slight, in Germany rather significant, whereas in Russia it proved drastic and sparked off two revolutions. Hence, there were several common aspects of


401 words - 2 pages Free Throughout history, the roles of women have changed dramatically. Women have been enslaved, been stripped of their rights, been given more rights, have been put down in society and been brought up. Women slowly, but surely have evolved into individuals one sees today: in public office, law firms or even the five o'clock news. However, this evolution did not occur overnight. It took time and effort to attain the position in society they have

The impact of edward tulane on children - Children's literature - Essay

532 words - 3 pages Nick Habibi P.6 The impact of edward tulane on children In the novel “the miraculous journey of Edward Tulane” the author has made this book for kids because he feels like kids should be able to handle death when they face such tragedies. In this book, the author tries to teach kids how to handle death by showing some things that are hard to deal with in the story and he has the main character (Edward) pass all of the problems that he face and

Othello: Essay on the themes, description of the Shakespeare's text - English - Essay

775 words - 4 pages universally timeless themes of jealousy, love, manipulation and revenge to demonstrate humanity’s existence on the brink of monstrosity. Shakespeare believed mankind’s obsession with reputation clouded their judgement and made it easier to manipulate them according to the desire for power or greed. This is evident in Cassio’s crisis following the destruction of his reputation “Reputation, reputation, reputation! O, I have lost my reputation! I

Informative text on the context of Romanticism - Ryde Secondary - Informative Essay

1272 words - 6 pages 1 Victoria Vu / 11ENA03 Writing Portfolio Task 1: Romanticism Informative Essay Task: Compose an informative text about Romanticism. This must be 500-800 words and may include history, conventions and purpose of the literary movement. Romanticism was the dominant artistic, literary and intellectual movement during the late 17th century to the mid 19th century and is known as the reaction against the Age of Enlightenment. This movement was a

Short analysis on the primary source of Sinbad the Sailor - History - Analysis of a primary source text.

569 words - 3 pages through out Sindbad’s tales of his adventures. He is constantly praising Allah or asking why Allah would put so much misfortune upon him. Although he doesn’t understand why bad things keep happening to him, his faith only grows stronger in Allah after each adventure he goes on. When Sindbad is flying in the air with the winged man he exclaims “Glory and praise eternal be to Allah, King of the Universe!” The winged man then drops Sindbad. He

The Impact of Media on the Perception of Rape - Feminist Literature - Essay

2684 words - 11 pages Rape is defined as the unlawful sexual activity and usually sexual intercourse that is carried out forcibly against a person's will. However, this definition does not encompass the pain or fear victims of rape experience. Nor does it address the fact that for every 1000 rapes, only six rapists are put on trial, found guilty, and sent to jail. It does not even mention the high suicide, drug abuse, or alcohol abuse rates that are common among

Suskinds use of imagery and description and it’s effects on the read and the text - Bullard - Essay

1529 words - 7 pages on the bright side instead of using violence as an  answer to solution to problems like Okonkwo does. In the book these missionaries are  visiting villages and are trying to share their beliefs and values to them, they want to  change there whole perspectives that they were taught growing up because in their eyes  there is only one god. These character each had a different view of the missionaries  arriving and a different reaction or answer to