Is Prostitution Different From Any Other Job? University Of Nottingham 3rd Year Essay

2617 words - 11 pages

Student no: 14270465
Word count: 2415
Are there good reasons for treating the selling of ‘sexual recreation’ differently from the selling of other personal services?
This essay will explore the complex debate of whether the selling of sex is different from the selling of any other personal service. In particular, the idea that it is more inherently harmful than other personal services. I will begin by discussing this claim, then presenting Scott Anderson’s support for it. Furthermore, I will then be criticising Anderson to show that I agree that sexual recreation is harmful to women, however not because of the job itself. Because of how toxic masculinity causes sexual recreation to be instrumentally harmful to women when they are forced into prostitution, therefore there are good reasons for treating forced sexual recreation differently from the selling of other personal services.
Justifications for inherently wrong prostitution:
To begin the discussion, it is important to clarify what is meant by the term: sexual recreation and how I will interpret it in this essay. The selling of sexual recreation is often referred to as prostitution, which is: ‘’a kind of occasional, limited transaction in which a person purchases “live” physical sexual recreation from someone who provides it in order to receive tangible, nonsexual benefits as compensation” (Anderson 2002, p748) This is how I will refer to the selling of recreation in this essay. To consider whether there are good reasons to treat it differently from other personal services, we must distinguish between whether it is intrinsically different or instrumentally different. To distinguish this, the legal and political aspects of prostitution must be put into consideration. Exchanging or participating in sexual activities for money or other goods is legal in the UK (Wilkes-Som 2017) however, there are still arguments to criminalise prostitution due to the negative impacts it has on women. Throughout my reading of feminist literature, the most common justifications for this seem to be:
(P1) the economic uncertainty of the job
(P2) the vulnerability of the women who are involved
(P3) the trauma they may face as a result.
I will explain each justification and show how since they also apply to other personal services, there are not good reasons to treat prostitution differently in itself to other personal services.
Economic uncertainty
P1 stems from the idea that prostitution can never give a woman a steady income as it is dependent on how ‘desirable’ the woman is. Like a lot of other career options, biases can be shown to different employees depending on class, race and sexual orientation. Therefore, a prostitute may struggle to gain a steady income from her job, thus not having the means to support herself. However, as mentioned this is a common theme in all modern-day careers and is evident through things such as the BBC gender pay gap scandal in July 2017. The publication of the...

Other Essays On Is Prostitution different from any other job? - University of Nottingham 3rd year - Essay

Discuss the relation between the mind and the natural world as it is understood - University of Edinburgh Third Year - Essay

2640 words - 11 pages . Intimations of Immortality from Recollections of Early Childhood’ it is this very meditation as to the transience of life which removes the speaker’s sense of dislocation and restores him with hope. Memories of childhood, and of the ultimate glorified vision of nature that he had during this youth, reinstates his connection to the natural world. Yet the true restorative power of this is only achieved when one accepts man’s mortality and the presence

Is Seeing Believing- Answering the long anticipated question cn w believ what we see - Philosophy, University Of Nottingham - Essay

462 words - 2 pages actually there . Our mind/ eyes are easily deceived by optical illusions . As neurophysiologists prove optical illusions trick our eye bye affecting half of our brain to to make an illusion work and because our brains are slow they give off differrent waves of colour or dmensions that would make the illusion seem like what it is we see. So if our brains are easily fooled by illusions what gives anybody the assurance that what we see is


1525 words - 7 pages The experiences and situations confronted by individuals in their daily life influence their perception of others and themselves. Consequently, discovery is part of the human condition. This perspective on discovery is explored through Ivan O’Mahoney’s documentary Go Back to Where You Came From (GBTWYCF) (2011) in which six participants undertook a journey of a ‘refugee experiment’, all of whom have their perception of so-called ‘boat people

Political arguments and analysing competing arguments that are compelling - University of Johannesburg,year 1 - Essay

865 words - 4 pages 1 INTRODUCTION TO POLITICAL STUDIES (POLS1007) Assignment One: Analysing Competing Arguments Due Monday the 4th of March. The maximum word count is 1,200 words Assessment Guidelines The main goal of your first assignment is to get you thinking and writing about how different types of political arguments are put together. What makes a compelling argument? On what basis can we effectively adjudicate between competing political positions? What

land law essay problem question - university of kent, second year - research paper

1880 words - 8 pages Apple manor Whether Teresa can stop yourmoney mortgages from repossessing Equitable Beneficial Interest Firstly in relation to Apple manor YouMoney mortgages are pursuing repossession as a result of their overdue payments on their mortgage, if their request will be successful is subject to if Teresa has a beneficial interest binding on YouMoney. In this case we are not informed of any document which meets the formality requirement of section 53

How is going for the look different from thinking out loud? - Leuzinger English - Essay

438 words - 2 pages ). This swiftly breezes by another good point in lookism which is the fact that when hiring, they at least try to find a good balance between looks and experience. But of course, they focus looks over experience. As many may not know a line in (Greenhouse,20) stated, “Last month the commission reached a $5,000 settlement with 36th Street Food and Drink, a restaurant in St. Joseph, Mo., after accusing it of age discrimination against a 47-year-old

What is the effect of different colours of light on plant growth? - year 10 science - experiment report

1352 words - 6 pages What is the effect of different colours of light on plant growth? Contents Introduction…………………………..…………............................ 2 Result…………...……………..…………..................................... 4 Discussion…………………………..…………............................. 6 Conclusion…………………………..…………............................. 8 Reference…………………………..………….............................. 9 Introduction Many countries have agriculture as a main product, export and

Analaysis of the poem "Presents from my aunts" - Year 9 - Essay

828 words - 4 pages , inhibition, curiousness, discomfort, alienation. So, here is the confused teenager searching for a definitive answer to her identity but never quite sure of her roots or her feelings. Her memories of Pakistan are mixed; she recalls beggars and women who had to be screened from the males, a sign of a restricted society. Yet, she is not judgemental, perhaps because she is too young. She feels like an outsider, neither fully one nor the other. And all the

Post Colonial reading of poems from Watson's 'Smoke Encrypted Whispers' - Year 12 Literature - Essay

1286 words - 6 pages protection and comfort. This further symbolises the changed Indigenous perspective towards white assimilation, from embraced in childhood, to disgusted and repelled in adulthood. Furthermore, the motif of white foods is also continued in TNH in a similar fashion to the motif of white infrastructure. The lines ‘it is not the smell of Sunday roast that lingers in the air / but other flesh that emanates from the night house’ allude to the olfactory imagery

Rear Window Analytical Essay - Is Stella the voice of reason? - Year 12 - Essay

869 words - 4 pages “We’ve become a race of Peeping Toms. What people ought to do is get outside their house and look in for a change.” Is Stella the voice of reason? Alfred Hitchcock’s film, Rear Window, directed in 1954, explores the character of insurance nurse Stella, who warns about how society has changed for the worse. Stella is backed up by events in the film when saying that people should engage with each other, though she, Jeff and Lisa disregard her

University vs. Two year college - Southern University A&M College - Essay

1407 words - 6 pages Morgan Weaver ENGL 111:01 02 December 2017 Research Essay High School Study Abroad Programs It is typically a big deal when deciding what one wants to do with their life after high school. There are many different routes for people to chose from. Some decide to attend a four year college, two year college, trade school, military, and some rely on talent. However, not all students are as fortunate as others to have long term goals or parents to

Similar Papers

Social Media And The Healthcare Industry University Of Nottingham Essay

3009 words - 13 pages from other experts (Myers, 2017). This allowed Dr. Ghaferi to add this technique to his repertoire and help his patients, showing that the social network provides an opportunity for members to “leverage the collective intelligence” of the group, collaborating to solve problems and create solutions (Gritt and Forsgren, 2018). The ability to engage in dialogue and collaborate using social media online is advantageous for the industry, as it means

Compare, Contrast And Evaluate Positivism And Constructivism University Of Nottingham Essay

2016 words - 9 pages positions (Hay 2007). However, since epistemology is about how we can question and understand ontology, shouldn’t the two be seen as co-constitutive? In Bates and Jenkins response to Hay, Smith argued so; stating they are ‘mutually and inextricably related’ (Bates and Jenkins 2007:60). The different types of constructivists create a divide within the spectrum of constructivism. Modern and Post-Modern constructivists vary with each other on their

What Is Politics In Defence Of Politics By Bernard Crick? University First Year Essay

1013 words - 5 pages of Politics, 1982) On the contrary Leftwich believes though politics is concerned with state and its conventional matters such as elections, governments and revolutions, it is but not a crucial element that defines politics. He states that “it is not necessary for there to be a state for there to be politics: it can [also] be found in ‘stateless’ societies”. (Leftwich, What is Politics? 1984) All three authors, though provide different

Prostitution In 19 Th Century Europe University Essay

2454 words - 10 pages Introduction It is generally believed that prostitution has become a focal issue and a major concern during the process of urbanization in 19th century European societies. Prostitution can be defined as the business of engaging sexual activities in exchange for monetary or goods payments. The estimated number of prostitutes in London at the time can be ranging from 6,371 according to the constabulary force to even “reaching 80,000” by the Bishop