Is Self Determination A Good Idea? Durham University Theory & History Of Ir Formative Assignment

1823 words - 8 pages

James Inge
Is self-determination a good idea?
In today’s international world order, self-determination is a good idea for a number of economic, political and social reasons. Post-World War Two notions of national self-determination and sovereignty, initially advocated by Woodrow Wilson, became integrated into international law and more reflective of the will of the people. Brownlie now sees the principle of self-determination as a definitive human right in deciding the question of the government and the governed, which the U.N. Charter confirms, specifically outlining the right to self-determination and the definition of the “peoples” such a right applied to. However, in reality, there are many countries where national self-determination has not provided an adequate solution, and further argument suggests that the effectiveness of self-determination is dependant on the way in which it is implemented.
At the centre of President Woodrow Wilson’s liberal world view was the idea of self-determination – ‘a free, open-minded, and absolutely impartial adjustment of all colonial claims…the interests of the populations concerned must have equal weight with the equitable claims of the government whose title is to be determined’ (Lieven, 1999, p.197). America’s growing status as a world power meant Wilsonianism language acted as an attractive model for other states to follow – one achievable with western support – legitimising the principle of self-determination and national sovereignty in world politics. This thinking would help bring about the secession of Slovenia and Croatia from Yugoslavia in the early 1990s and the Baltic states from Gorbachev’s Soviet Union (Lynch, 2002, p.421). Wilson believed that America had a moral duty to protect and free people from autocratic government, however his idea of providing self-determination was flawed in its roots of the ‘Anglo-American tradition of civic nationalism’ (Lynch, p.424), and he was unable to grasp the importance of distinguishing the nation from the peoples constituting the nation. This would plague his attempts to apply the principle in eastern Europe. Thus, Wilson’s interpretation was a bad idea as self-determination was only seen as the ‘right of communities to govern themselves, not the right of every ethos to its own polity’. (Lynch, p.435) As such self-determination only occurred along pre-existing boundaries as defined by previous colonial powers or federal systems – it was applied under uti possidetis juris, a principle of international law providing that newly sovereign states be within the preceding state structure. American foreign interests instead took priority – Wilson openly admitted that the self-determination would have to be put secondary to other diplomatic, strategic or economic considerations. This was the case with the USSR, where the policy of self-determination was not adopted in fear of interfering with the the territorial integrity of the state at a time when the Bolsheviks...

Other Essays On Is self-determination a good idea? - Durham University - Theory & History of IR - Formative Assignment

the Auteur theory created by Andrew Sarris is the best theory - History of Film - film

742 words - 3 pages on the Auteur Theory in 1962, says that "the way a film looks and moves should have some relationship to the way director thinks and feels"(562). The director should be in control because his or her vision is the primary vison in making a film. Music works the same way, however a musician is feeling is how a song is made. Of course, the director has to be a good director, I once heard a great director has to be a good director A movie I chose

History Of Atomic Theory Essay

706 words - 3 pages "[Democritus:] Everything was composed of atoms, which moved randomly in a vacuum, in a void. They collided into each other by chance. This was the absolute negation of Aristotle's idea that everything had a purpose as divinely ordained [the theory of the Four Elements]."Dr. Hugh SalzburgChemistry HistorianThe idea that matter is composed of atoms goes back to the Greek philosophers, notably Democritus, and has never since been entirely lost

English Short Story, idea for a short story for university english. completed as a first assignment - English - Essay

792 words - 4 pages Mrs Lizzy’s House It was early in the summer of 2018 in small rural community in Newfoundland. There was not much to do around that small community for entertainment so we all had to find a way to have fun. So my name is Angel and I’ll be telling the story of the night we decided to break into an old house that is located in the middle of the community where I am from. So it all started one night when we were just walking around and talking

A Matter Of Perception: Treasure Island Is Good Or Bad

1095 words - 5 pages . Apparently it is writtenwell enough to gain fans throughout England. So it must be a somewhat good piece ofliterature. William Blackburn writes in his essay, "Much of Treasure Island is in brilliantlyhandled dramatic dialogue, salty enough to convey the tang of piratical talk yet chasteenough to pass muster with the most respectable of parents" (Nineteenth-CenturyLiterature Criticism, Vol. 63, pp.253). It is so wonderfully written that it is

It is a good trial I had very good grade until I increased my grade.. t - History - Essay

449 words - 2 pages Ana Sofia Foy History                                          The Constitution        The Constitution of the United States was written in 1787, yet there was a struggle for its ratification that went on until 1790. Members of Congress believed that the Articles of Confederation, the first government of the United States, needed to be altered while others did not want change. After the Revolutionary War, the people did not want a strong central

Effects of Self-Service Technology on Supermarket employment - University, management - Assignment

2512 words - 11 pages first, will give the contextual history of self-service checkouts, which will be key in analysing the impact later. In the next section I will discuss the labour process theory discussing its links to Marxist thinking and capitalism. Finally I will look at technology as a prosthesis and aesthesis analysing the specific effects of the self-service checkout. 2. Historical Context Traditional grocers are completely different to modern supermarkets. The

How does Color Affect Design and People - University of Bridgeport Color Theory - Essay, Assignment

1062 words - 5 pages Color Theory Professor Matto Mark Esposito There are a series of videos on YouTube that feature Enchroma Glasses. This revolutionary technology enable those of us who are color blind to see a full spectrum of color. The heart-breaking series, often referred to as, “Try Not to Cry Challenges,” show the affect of color on the psyche of those who had never seen it before. Color is inherently taken for granted, as it is a blessing that is almost

A good Friend is a descriptive essay of 5 paragraphs - ENG - Descriptive essay

618 words - 3 pages ENG 101_102 Definition Essay A Good Friend Friends play an important role in a person's life. They encourage when one is sad, they entertain when one is lonesome, and they listen when one has problems. To be honest a true friend is someone difficult to find. However, when you find him or her you will know the true meaning of a good friend. A true friend is someone who will always be there in times of need, who will accepts you for who you are

SELF-ACCEPTANCE IS THE KEY TO HAPPINESS - BUS - Assignment

1146 words - 5 pages cause serious health problems, including obesity. · Lack of self-acceptance often leads to inactivity. When we judge ourselves we often lack the ability to motivate to do things that we know are good for us, like exercise, getting good sleep and eating nutritious foods. WHY DO WE LACK SELF-ACCEPTANCE? Lack of self-acceptance is rampant in our modern society. Feeling like we need to be a certain way, or look a certain way to gain acceptance is

One of the cornerstones of marketing theory is the notion that marketers can “segment” the market - University of Western - Essay

1575 words - 7 pages what a market segment is), but also some evidence that you can apply that theory (e.g., by explaining how the theory is useful, and by giving good examples). In some respects, answering the application part of the question is more important. Most people can explain a simple theory like segmentation, but real knowledge is demonstrated when someone can apply that knowledge, and give good examples. 3. When reading the suggested answer below, note

What is Socrates’ argument that no harm can come to a good man - Thompson River University PHIL-1110 - Philosophy Paper

1524 words - 7 pages [Type here] 4 Question: What is Socrates’ argument that no harm can come to a good man?” Do you agree? “Yet the deeply exciting thing about human beings is that when the individual is free he chooses as the good life the process of becoming.” ~ Carl Rogers Socrates, according to his own logic, dispels the fear of death and harm as basis for his argument that, “I am certain that nothing can harm a good man either in life or after death” (pg. 9

Similar Papers

Freud Theory: 1. Psychodynamic Theory: A Topology Of The Mind Durham Notes

1583 words - 7 pages mechanisms are employed, to help ward off unpleasant feelings (i.e., anxiety) or make good things feel better for the individual. · enables the person to control their impulses and demonstrate self-control, via mastery of the ego 2. Psychosexual development · Born with the id, but the Ego and super Ego develop in childhood · Pass through series of developmental stages, resolving conflicts · Each stage is associated with a part of the body (“erotogenic

Assignment For The Project Of A Enterpreneurship Idea Syracuse University Assignment

1467 words - 6 pages Tinghan Zhu IST 195 Idea: It works both for receiving and delivering . To be specific, the machine has lockers with different sizes to store any kinds of packages, whenever a cellphone or a TV. For receiving, the delivery courier has the code to open every locker and store packages. Once your package is in one of the lockers, the machine will send you a message with a verification code. You just need to input the code and your package will show

The Idea Of Human Rights For All Is A Relatively

1415 words - 6 pages democracy itself. (Guinier 349)? Guinier?s idea of political equality is very similar to Nussbaum?s idea of women?s rights. In today?s democracy, all human beings should be treated equally. As I have noted earlier, these ideals are all very good thoughts, however very unrealistic. Guinier wishes for a democracy in which all people have a say in governmental issues. To me, that sounds over-redundant. What else could Guinier ask for to make it fair? She

Political Dominance Of The Republican Party 1865 1912 Durham Sixth Form Centre, A Level History Essay

1339 words - 6 pages was able to gain enough votes to dominate during this time. However, there were factors other than the internal divisions of its opponents that allowed the Republican party to dominate between 1865 and 1912. One of these factors is that the Republican party had the support of big business. They gained this support by having more business friendly ideas than their opposition such as a laissez faire attitude and high tariffs. Their laissez faire