Is The Movie "Sully" Accurate Compared To The True Story? 10th Grade English Compare And Contrast

971 words - 4 pages

Eman Nawaz
English 10B
January 16th, 2018
“Sully”: Based on A True Story
On January 15th, 2009, Captain Chesley “Sully” Sullenberger had to make an emergency landing in the Hudson River due to a flock of geese that damaged both of the engines on the flight. Everyone evacuated the sinking plane with their life jackets on, jumping onto life rafts and even ferry boats that cruised on the freezing waters of the Hudson River. Due to his efforts in saving all 155 passengers and crew members, Sullenberger is recognized as a national hero and an advocate for aviation safety. Clint Eastwood helps retell the story of the “Miracle on the Hudson” in the movie Sully, which was released in 2016. In the film Sully, directed by Clint Eastwood, some factual events are accurate, while some are twisted to create an antagonist in the movie.
In the movie Sully, there are points in the plot that can be proven to be true. One element of the film that reflect what happened is the conversation Sully had with his first officer before the plane when down. For instance, “After the birdstrike, Sully states, ‘My aircraft.’ First Officer Skiles replies, ‘Your aircraft,’ and relinquishes the flight controls to the Captain” (Auxier 1). This dialogue is proven to be completely accurate. The National Transportation Safety Board crash investigation reports show that Sully stated the words “My aircraft” when he took over the plane. In the movie, Officer Skiles pulls out the Quick Reference Handbook after Sully takes over the plane. In the article, “The New ‘Sully’ Movie: How Accurate?” it is stated that “The movie QRH looks exactly like the real thing, and this action is also what the PM (Pilot Monitoring) would do” (Auxier 1). Eastwood made sure to emulate actions that would have been taken in that particular situation. Having made sure these small details were precise, Eastwood was able to make this movie accurate. In the Miracle of the Hudson Plane Crash documentary, survivor Barry Leonard and flight attendant Doreen Welsh opened up about their injuries. Leonard recalls, “My knee hit my sternum and actually cracked my sternum” (History vs. Hollywood) while Welsh had a deep L-shaped laceration on her leg. Both of these injuries were included in the film.
On the other hand, there are some points in the film Sully that were exaggerated or added in to provide for a more entertaining production. When looking at the script, Sully, who was an advisor to the film, requested to not use the real names of the NTSB officials. Tom Hanks also added “These are people who are not prosecutors. They are doing a very important job, and if, for editorial purposes, we want to make it more of a prosecutorial process, it ain’t fair to them” (Lowy 1). Since the NTSB officials were reimagined to be the antagonist of the film, real names of the NTSB officials were not used because they were originally very respectful towards Sully. In an article titled “What the ‘Sully’ Movie Gets Wrong,” the...

Other Essays On Is the movie "Sully" accurate compared to the true story? - 10th grade English - compare and contrast

Is Lying important and how does it connect with the story Crucible - Valley Forge High School English Class 11th grade - Essay

796 words - 4 pages cover her self Up. Abigail even still has feelings for John and she will attempt and do anything to recover his love for her back. Abigail knows what she’s doing is very wrong and she knows the consequences and she even realizes that by blaming that Elizabeth is a witch could get her killed. Abigail at this point is only lying to make her self look better and make it seem like she’s the good one. In my opinion I think lying should never be used

The Merchant of Venice Essay Compare and Contrast - English class - Essay

1147 words - 5 pages wants to make the story more entertaining, Jessica and Lorenzo fell in love in the play. “Did young Lorenzo swear he loved her well, Stealing her soul with many vows of faith, And ne’era true one.” (V, i, 16) Bassano and Portia are surly another exception to marriage. “The quality of mercy is not strained. It dropped as the gentle rain from heaven Upon the place beneath. It is twice blessed: It blessed him that gives and him that takes. The

Romeo & Juliet Compare and Contrast - English - Essay

579 words - 3 pages Karina Martinez 03/01/2018 Compare and Contrast Essay The well known story called Romeo and Juliet created by William Shakespeare, is about two young tennagers that fall in love but neither of their families want them together because, they are both rivals. Romeo came from a family named the Montagues and Juliet came from a family named the Capulets. Throughout the story Shakespeare creatively describes the love they have towards each other

The Awakening And The Pearl Compare And Contrast Essay

2487 words - 10 pages The Awakening, by Kate Chopin is a novel that discusses the awakenings of a Victorian woman living in New Orleans. The Pearl, by John Steinbeck is a novel that tells the story of a poor pearl diver who tries to seek wealth and happiness for his family. After finding a large pearl he believes that all his problems are over. He is soon to learn that this pearl would only cause him more grief and unhappiness than he had before. Both books are

Frankenstein Essay: Man is the True Monster - English 2H - Essay

1013 words - 5 pages disastrous events that would lead to the demise of all his loved ones, himself, and even the monster. By casually reading the novel through the perspective of Victor, one is inclined to believe the monster is the villain of the story. However, one must read deeper and use reason to truly understand who the real monster is, man or creature? Here, we can clearly see that man is the true monster of Frankenstein.

A time to kill and to kill a mockingbird - Holy Cross/ English 10 - compare and contrast essay

1051 words - 5 pages Gina Le Ms. Maliszewski English 10 Block D 22 May 2018 A Time to Kill and To Kill A Mockingbird Compare and Contrast Essay During the 1900’s, discrimination and prejudice spreaded throughout the United States. A great example of this would be Harper Lee’s Novel, “To Kill A Mockingbird”, and Joel Schumacher’s film, “A Time To Kill”. The novel “To Kill A Mockingbird” written by Harper Lee, and the film directed by Joel Schumacher, “A Time To Kill

This essay tells what is true and what is false in the movie Braveheart. So it tells the historical accuracy of the film

545 words - 3 pages Wallace in a way that is mostly true and the fictions parts only add to the plot and do not take away from Wallace and are easy to point out and don't adversely degrade him. However, in Braveheart, there is a lot of false information regarding the battle scenes. Therefore, Braveheart is a semi historically accurate movie but some details are false.William Wallace, the patriot fighter for Scotland, was a real person who really fought heroically for his

The difference between Baba and Amir - English Grade 12 - Essay

939 words - 4 pages The Differences Between Amir and Baba in The Kite Runner By Nathan Strub Usually children take after their fathers, however, In The Kite Runner, by Khaled Hosseini it is the opposite. Since Baba and Amir have many differences including their hobbies, their personality, and their expectations of each other. Because of this, they are unable to understand each other. Therefore Amir feels as though he is the son Baba never wanted. Firstly, Amir is

Compare and Contrast Essay (Jack/Lady Macbeth) - English - Essay

620 words - 3 pages Compare and Contrast Essay Edmund Burke once said, “Ambition can creep as well as soar.” This quote aptly captures both Jack and Lady Macbeth’s application of ambition. The allure of influence and power is so great that it corrupts their logical ways of thinking, ultimately leading them to disaster. If Jack and Lady Macbeth were to compare with each other, then both primarily represent the “id” side of human condition but at the same time they

Sherlock Holmes on Social Class - English 2020 - Compare and Contrast

1397 words - 6 pages pawn shop to get into a bank vault. This story was very uncommon and the twist of a notorious criminal disguising himself as an assistant. This story is another example of how Holmes takes upon any cliental he finds interesting. Wilson was one of the examples of a common folk getting helped Sherlock which later made him find a notorious criminal. Throughout this book, Doyle expressed how the police force do not use rational methods that often when

Compare and Contrast Short Stories - Pierce College English 101 - Essay

901 words - 4 pages , Myop from “The Flowers” and the young narrator from “Araby” have striking similarities. Both characters are isolated and alone express a sense of childhood innocence and have a sudden moment of insight marking the end of that innocence. A common theme that drives the story in both Joyce’s “Araby” and Walker’s “The Flowers” is that of childhood innocence. Both Myop and the young boy express qualities that show they have not yet had to face the

Similar Papers

Symbolism In To Kill A Mockingbird 10th Grade English Essay On Symbolism In The Book, To Kill A Mockingbird Essay

1004 words - 5 pages Symbolism in To Kill a Mockingbird Set in Maycomb County, Alabama, To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee is a novel about a town where innocent Scout and Jem Finch grow up and learn the harsh reality of racism and discrimination that exists in their daily lives. Their father Atticus, a lawyer, is one of the few people in the town who does not support racism. This is shown when he is called to defend Tom Robinson in court. Tom is a black man

Compare And Contrast The Crucibles English 3 Ap Essay

449 words - 2 pages , clothing, and shelter. · New England Colonies-of British America included Connecticut colony, colony of Rhode island and providence plantations, Massachusetts bay colony, and the province of New Hampshire, as well as a few smaller short-lived colonies. · Puritans-a member of group of English Protestants of the late 16th and 17th centuries who regarded the reformation of church of England under Elizabeth as incomplete and sought to simplify and

Theme Of Adolescence In The Catcher In The Rye 10th Grade English Essay

869 words - 4 pages expresses that along with​ ​adolescence comes new topics that adolescents find difficult to figure out. Learning how to develop relationships especially intimate ones with significant others is something that adolescents have to learn how to deal with. Holden like many teens today is uncertain of how to approach the topic of sex. Holden's experience with intimacy and his frame of thought about it shows just how confused he is about the matter. On page 92

Theme For The Lord Of The Flies 10th Grade Lit And Comp Novel Study

1188 words - 5 pages Kevin Park Proctor 10 Lit and Comp 1 November 2018 Theme Development in​ Lord of the Flies In the story ​Lord of the Flies​, ​Ralph is the leader of a group of British boys stranded on an island somewhere in the Pacific Ocean after a plane crash. Ralph and the kids have to work together in order to survive until they are rescued. While they are stranded on the island, they go through a series of changes that evidently throws the boys into chaos