Isolationism, Cooperative Security, Selective Engagement Or Primacy ? American Grand Strategy After The Cold War

2083 words - 9 pages

Isolationism, cooperative security, selective engagement or primacy ? American grand strategy after the Cold WarThe demise of the Soviet Union brought an end to the Cold War, the bipolar structure of the international system, and to America's grand strategy of containment. Over the past decade, America has struggled to define its role in the post- Cold War era. The purpose of this paper is to research America's alternative grand strategy choices.Over the past decade, four model strategies have emerged. Those are : isolationism, selective engagement, cooperative security and primacy. The strategies differ in major objectives , assumptions and views on issues like NATO enlargement, nuclear ...view middle of the document...

Particularly a transformed NATO have an important role to play. Cooperative security is deeply committed to arms control" the more nuclear powers there are in the world, the more dangerous it will be for international organizations to act aggressively against miscreants, the less likely they will be to act, and the more likely it is that the entire cooperative security edifice will collapse " ( Posen : 28 ). This strategy also recognizes regional conflicts among states as seriously problematic.Critics point out several basic problems with this strategy. First cooperative security downplays the importance of national interest. Second, cooperative security's commitment to arms control as a way to keep the peace cannot prevent the rise of potential aggressors.The foreign policy of the Clinton's administration ( 1993- 2001) has been largely guided by cooperative security. In 1996, President Clinton's national security team produced a detailed vision of American grand strategy called " The National Security Strategy of Engagement and Enlargement " This document promoted a strong national defense and cooperative security measures, such as NATO expansion and a strengthened United Nations.Primacy is the second alternative strategy to look at. Primacy holds that the key to future peace and prosperity is for the united States to maintain the position it held at the end of the Cold War. The central purpose of primacy is preventing the emergence of a potential new rival along the lines of the former Soviet Union. In the words of a draft of the Bush administration's defense Planning Guidance ( DGP) that subjected to much ridicule after it was leaked to the press in March 1992, the US must " endeavor to prevent any hostile power from dominating a region whose resources would, under consolidated control, be sufficient to generate global power............ Our strategy must now refocus on precluding the emergence of any potential future global competitor "( Huntington , p. 3)Proponents of primacy are committed to policies like NATO expansion and a continued American role in international organizations so long as institutions do not stray far from American core interests, such as maintaining American preeminence. Primacy pays much attention to identifying potential threads to American interest and measures to contain them. A rising China and a resurgent Russia top the list of potential challengers to American preeminence. Primacy advocates are also concerned with non-traditional military threats from non-states, such as terrorist organizations. Also , fear that a state like North Korea may try to strike the American homeland is the rationale behind primacy's call for the continued strong support for the development and eventual deployment of ballistic missile defense. Meeting all potential threats to America's preeminence will require a lot amount of money, since military modernization is a high priority.Primacy has its shortcomings too. A corollary argument says...

Other Essays On Isolationism, Cooperative Security, Selective Engagement Or Primacy ? American Grand Strategy After The Cold War

Reagan, Russia, and the cold war (Includes some citations)

491 words - 2 pages Reagan, Russia, and the cold war (Includes some citations)The cold war was a post-World War II struggle between the United States and itsallies and the group of nations led by the Soviet Union. Direct military conflict did notoccur between the two superpowers, but intense economic and diplomatic struggleserupted. Different interests led to mutual suspicion and hostility in a rising philosophy. The United States played a major role in the ending

Why Did The Cold War Break Out In The Aftermath Of World War II?

2116 words - 9 pages Americans was perhaps not the best attitude with which to forge a new relationship with the Russians, but such statements only exemplified fifty years of Russian-American hostility.Since the end of World War II, historians have struggled with the question of which side was more responsible for the onset of the Cold War, the Americans or the Russians. The more common, conventional view considers the Soviets, led by a paranoid dictator, aspired to

The Cold War, The Elongated Tension Between The Soviet Union And The U.S

1163 words - 5 pages The Cold War was the elongated tension between the Soviet Union and the United States of America. It started in the mid 40's after WWII had left Europe in shambles and Russia and the USA in superpower positions. The Cold War was a clash of these supergiants in political, ideological, military, and economic values and ideas. Though military build up was great on both sides neither one ever directly fought each other. In this essay I'm going to

Analyse the role of Cuba in the development of the Cold War

476 words - 2 pages of these missiles (after some pictures taken by spies) their scare of Cuba increased by the simple fact that the island is geographically positioned near the US, and therefore could destroy big part of it. It took 13 days for the Soviets to remove the missiles from the island.After all these facts, the relations between the US and USSR, or between Capitalism and Communism deteriorated even more; a hotline linking the two hyper powers originated from the Cuban Missile Crisis.It could thus be concluded that Cuba had a considerable influence in the development of the Cold War by accenting rivalry between the 2 powers.

Three Main Events That Caused The Escalation Of The Cold War Up To The Berlin Blockade

933 words - 4 pages I believe that there were three main events that caused the escalation of the Cold War. This essay is going to assess how these three events contributed to the escalation of the Cold War and how important they were to its continuation.In my opinion the first strains in the relation between the two sides started at Potsdam more then at Yalta. When we look at Yalta we only see agreements such as "Hold free elections in Soviet occupied territory

The USSR's Actions Against The US Were Simply Reflexes, Not Direct Contributions To The Causation Of The Cold War

1245 words - 5 pages the leader and main aggressor who began the Cold War and perpetuated the growth of tension between the two nations in the war's infancy. What ally would accuse another of paranoia because of one single telegram? What country for freedom and democracy would blindly find the concept of security incomprehensible? The USSR's actions against such ill-purposed policies are only reflexes, not direct contributions to the causation. And so, the Soviet Union's allotment of blame for the four years in question is not primary or great in amount.

What were the consequences of the Spanish American War?

583 words - 3 pages The United States of the 19th century and the United States of the 20th century differ a great deal. In most of the 19th century, the US was isolationist and did not get involved much in the affairs of the world. However, by the start of the 20th century, the US began to get involved a greater amount in world affairs. The Spanish-American War (1898) established the United States as a world power and caused the US to follow the path of

Conflicts That Caused The Spanish-American-Cuban War

474 words - 2 pages the ships ammunition up in flames and sank the ship. Most of the 350 officers on the ship lost their lives. Nobody knows exactly what cause the U.S.S. Maine to blow up, but people believed that Spain had something to do with it. Newspapers everywhere blamed Spain for the sinking and Americans were outraged and war broke out soon after. The Spanish-American-Cuban War was called "a splendid little war". Jose Marti fighting for Cuba's freedom, the De Lome letter, and the accidental sinking of the U.S.S. Maine caused the war. It was a short war but America gained much from it.

To what extent did economic, political, and social change effect the lives of colonists after the American Revolution?

547 words - 3 pages Although the colonists' lives changed significantly in many ways after the American Revolution, the economic, political, and social conversions are viewed to be the most dramatic. The American Revolution was the war between the American colonies and Great Britain from 1775-1783 . Most consider this war not to be a nationalist revolution, in which the aim of the revolutionaries was to overturn the existing system, but rather to set up the North

Clara Barton, Founder Of The American Red Cross And A Civil War Nurse

560 words - 3 pages formally educated at New York State. Barton was primarily a teacher from the age of 15. Only during the civil war did she pursue nursing passionately. She is known best for the founder of the American Red Cross in 1881, an organization that it still strong today. During the civil war, Clara helped identify over 13,000 dead soldiers and aided in the search of missing soldiers. She began her work in 1861 at the Battle of Bull Run. In July 1862, she

Describe The Main Characteristics Of A Specific Style Or Period In Jazz Since World War II

1718 words - 7 pages Illustrate your answer with reference to recordings by a key artist. Discuss briefly how this style relates to previous developments in jazz and/or other contemporaneous movements in jazz, and show, as appropriate, how the discussed style relates to the broader social and/or cultural environment.Jazz is a form of music originated around the beginning of the twentieth century in the Southern United States within the African American communities

Similar Papers

The Cold War Essay

2281 words - 10 pages disabled by a flameout in its jet engine. Whatever the truth maybe, or combination of truths, the fact remains that Powers survived the encounter by parachute in the vicinity of Sverdlovsk. Upon landing, he was apprehended, disarmed, and escorted to the security police by four residents of the small town.The fault of the incident lay with the American administration's handling of the situation, not with the flight itself. It was assumed that Powers had

The Cold War And Technology Essay

1179 words - 5 pages to reconciliation, however.Between 1979 and 1985 was a "freeze" in relations between the U.S and Russia. This became known as the Second Cold War. The Soviet invasion of Afghanistan led to outcries from the West. Many boycotted the 1980 Moscow Olympic Games. Both the U.S. and the Soviet had missiles ready in case of war. After president Jimmy Carter, Ronald Reagan became president in 1980. Then, in 1985, Mikhail "Gorby" Gorbachev became the

Why Did The Cold War Start

682 words - 3 pages Marshall Plan was the action which seemed to bring the two nations (USA and Russia) more towards the Cold War than ever. In the summer of 1947 American general named George Marshall decided that America should give out $17 billion for aiding Europe. He reckoned that Europe was so poor that it is in danger of falling into Communism. It was said that it was up to the countries to decide whether to accept the help or not. The USSR hated that plan and was

Cold War In The Middle East: Afghanistan

1937 words - 8 pages takes precedence over a unified administration. (Saikal 2004, p.218). The great impact of Cold War was not in directing regional politics in any particular way but in altering the interactions between social groups (Halliday 1997, p.19). The fragmentation of Afghani identities has contributed to the contemporary security problems in Afghanistan and instability. No single group or leader has the legitimacy to reunite the country. The impact is a