Legal Studies Essay Law Reform Concerning Indigenous Land Rights Legal Studies Essay

1221 words - 5 pages

To what extent has law reform addressed the concerns of Indigenous Australians, in regards to land rights?
To a certain extent, progression of land rights for Indigenous peoples has been addressed through law reform. Their concern, according to Ross Watson, a Murri from the Dawson River, is founded in the significance of land as a ‘spiritual and economic base’, and land rights as ‘an opportunity to once again become a self-determining people.’ As such, pursuit of such rights has been an ongoing and crucial process for Indigenous peoples. However, initial advancement, as in the case of Mabo vs Queensland (No. 2) (1992) and the Native title Act, suffered regression in the compromising issues of Wik peoples vs Queensland (1996) case and the Native title Amendment Act. This was due to the ability of the historically privileges citizens to use rights frameworks to counter the equally rights-based claims of the dispossessed and subjugated Indigenous people. Hence, the concerns of the Indigenous peoples’ land rights were at first promoted, and then impeded in this period of change through conflict of rights.
Prior to the Mabo case, law regarding land rights compromised the concerns of Indigenous Australians. Original British colonisation policies and land laws originated from the belief that Australia was an acquired by occupation of a terra nullius. Terra nullius, the common law doctrine of land belonging to no-one, entitled the British occupants to own and develop the land. According to the ‘Central Land Council’ this rendered the previous sovereignty, traditions and ties of the Indigenous people to land legally and practically obsolete. The implications of this are clear in the instance of the Yolgnu people’s protest against the removal of 300 hectares of their land by a bauxite mining company. In the follow up case, Milirrpum v Nabalco Pty Ltd, although the court recognised the “religious relationship with the land” and the presence of “Aboriginal laws” they were not willing to overturn terra nullius on the grounds of these being “extinguished under common law.” Henceforth the people were denied the right to their land, and the preferences of non-Indigenous people continued dominate this legal realm.
However, in the case of Mabo vs Queensland (No. 2) (1992) and the ensuing legislation, such precedent would be overturned and therefore advance the concerns of the Indigenous Australians. The case challenged the sovereignty of the Queensland over the land in the Mer islands through the doctrine of terra nullius. Mabo argued that his people retained ownership over the land due to their presence and continued connection to the land since ‘time immemorial’. The court overruled terra nullius and decided that the “Meriam people were entitled as against the whole world to possession, occupation, use and enjoyment of (most of) the lands of the Murray Islands.’ Moreover, the legal doctrine of native title was inserted into Australian law, which entitled...

Other Essays On Legal Studies essay - Law reform concerning Indigenous Land rights - Legal studies - essay

Capital Punishment Human Rights - HSC Legal Studies - Assignment

2633 words - 11 pages NESANUMBER- HSC Legal Studies -- Capital Punishment HSC Legal Studies Part II Core: Human Rights NESA Number: -- Question A: With reference to your chosen contemporary human rights issue, outline the roles of one domestic AND one international organisation in protecting human rights. (200 words - 4 marks) Reprieve Australia and Amnesty International are two organisations which strive to protect human rights and support the eradication of capital

An Essay on why cannabis should be legal. - CHCA Western Studies - Essay

895 words - 4 pages Max Vonderhaar Persuasive Essay Legalization of Weed January 10, 2018 Free the Green One of the most controversial topics in America is whether or not the legalization of marijuana will be beneficial to society. While there are many concerns surrounding the national legalization of the drug, namely addiction, decision-making, health risks and the like, extensive study and research has disproved these concerns and replaced them with beneficial

The role of discretion in prosecution - Saint charbel college/legal studies - Essay

803 words - 4 pages out the rights of the offender, victim and society. There are some cases where there isn’t complete discretion or none at all. Punishment is just one of the many purposes behind imposing a sentence. The crimes (sentencing procedure) Act 1999 (NSW) states allowable purpose of sentencing; ensure offenders adequately punished, prevent crime by deterring offenders of the law, to protect the community, promote rehabilitation of offenders, make offenders

Bio Piracy- How it affects Indigenous cultures - Native Studies - Essay

1818 words - 8 pages (Shiva, 4). In return the Indian people deem this as theft in what they regard as intellectual piracy (Shiva, 1). The indigenous people of India were never given any portion of profits for their knowledge. There are often disputes over bio piracy and the process within getting patents and legal rights over properties whether of knowledge, plants or rights. In the 1960’s a Dr. Joachim Voss began such a dispute over a pale yellow bean that is smaller

Summary and Indictable Offences - Legal Studies - Assignment

735 words - 3 pages UNIT 1: Legal Studies | Assignment Joash G Indictable offence vs Summary offence: Indictable offences are more serious offences that cannot be heard without the presence of the accused in court. Summary offences are less serious offences that can be heard by a magistrate sitting alone, rather than a judge and jury. This type of offence can be heard without the accused person present at the court. Twenty men were arrested in the raids

Assess the effectiveness of the criminal investigation process as a means of achieving justice - Legal Studies - Essay

947 words - 4 pages the coronial inquest, which highlights the inadequacies and waste of resources within the criminal investigation process. · A proposed Law Enforcement Commission has been proposed which will have dual functions of both detecting and investigating serious misconduct and corruption · During the criminal investigation process, police may deem it necessary to arrest suspects for the protection of victims and society, but the rights of suspects are

Depths study - Rights and Freedom - Legal studies year 11 - Assignment

2251 words - 10 pages Depth Study - Rights and Freedoms 1. In a scene, young African Americans are shown staging a sit-in at a lunch counter to protest against segregation. What role did students from Fisk University, Nashville have in such protests? Were their actions successful? (100 words) Students from Fisk University were the first ones to organise and executed the sit-ins in Nashville, Tennessee. The campaign, coordinated by the Nashville Student Movement and

Using case law briefly explain the following terms - UWI Legal Writing and reearch - Essay

799 words - 4 pages Running head: Law1902 assignment 2 1 Law1902 assignment 2 8 LAW1902-Introduction to Legal Research and Writing Assignment 2 Marlon David Vasquez University of the West Indies (Open Campus) Author Note The work being submitted is my own work, and I understand what constitutes plagiarism and that I have not plagiarized. (1) Using case law briefly explain the following terms: (a) Ratio decidendi; In Donoghue V Stevenson, Donoghue was invited by a

Legal Studies Australian Articles Research - Thomas Hassall Anglican College - Research

632 words - 3 pages involved were charged with some sort of imprisonment. One individual pleaded guilty to manslaughter, while the rest were guilty of murder. The ratio decidendi of the case was on the grounds of murder and manslaughter. · This case relates to the rule of law since it convicted all legally involved parties with the murder/manslaughter. All counts were reached with a proper and justified amount of imprisonment. 28/2/18 Khanh Ly sentenced to 18 years in

legal research regarding legal representation in courts - law university - research paper

1942 words - 8 pages trial”[footnoteRef:6]. [6: Dietrich v The Queen (1992) 177 CLR 292, 317.] According to Australian Legal Reform Commission (ALRC), many litigants choose to represent themselves and others do not know they are eligible for legal aid.[footnoteRef:7] They may believe that they can run the case without a lawyer, or decide to continue unrepresented despite legal advice that they cannot win. However, the reports of the ALRC and the Family Law Council

Walt Disney Case Study and Analysis - Legal Studies - Waterloo University - Case

1539 words - 7 pages STRAT The Walt Disney Company 4/14/11 CMJ Discussion Questions Key Players / People Course Platform Description: Based at first on little but an animated mouse, Walt Disney had grown to be one of the largest and best known media companies in the world by the mid-2000s. Most of our cases in the course so far focus on strategy at the level of the individual business unit. In this module, we shift perspective to “corporate level strategy”. The

Similar Papers

Legal Essay About Australian Law Reform With Regards Of Current Issues Legal Studies Essay

1466 words - 6 pages Legal Assessment- Alcohol and Violence By: Hatem, A and Ziad The topic of law reform is beyond just the definition of changing the law, however it is the process in which the law is modified and shaped over time to better reflect the changing social and cultural values that we deem are important. The law cannot stay the same, as the primary function of the legal system is to respond to the changing social values and hence why law reform is

The Detainment Of Terrorists Suspects: Does It Breach Human Rights Trinity Anglican School / Legal Studies Essay

1229 words - 5 pages counter-terrorism laws is entitled to an insufficient amount of legal options to maintain their human rights. The proposed extension of terrorist suspects being detained is far too long of a duration, the ASIO and AFP should only require two days as this gives them enough time to collect any evidence if it is there. If the government don’t implement the proposed law alterations stated above then they will be found guilty of violating Human Rights

Adversarial & Inquisitorial System Of Trial Legal Studies Essay

911 words - 4 pages Inquisitorial vs Adversarial System of Law (Which do you think is most effective for justice in the community?) Whilst the inquisitorial system is effective for justice, adversarial system of trial tends to be more effective to achieve justice in the community. Systems of trials can both differ in many ways, they have their advantages and disadvantages. In most common law countries such as United States of America, England, Wales as well as

Examination Of The Queensland Criminal Law On Abortion Legal Studies Legal Studies

1089 words - 5 pages Criminal law The Queensland legal system is constantly under examination to stay relevant and appropriate for today’s society. Abortion is defined as the intent to procure the miscarriage of a woman, usually preformed within the first 28 weeks of pregnancy and remains a highly controversial topic. Abortion is a highly discussed topic, with views ranging from victims of rape or sextual misconduct at a young age, to religious and pro-life