Management Control System Essay

9915 words - 40 pages

Management control systems design within its organizational context: findings from contingency-based
research and directions for the future
Robert H. Chenhall
Department of Accounting and Finance, Monash University, Clayton, Victoria 3168, Australia
Abstract
Contingency-based research has a long tradition in the study of management control systems (MCS). Researchers
have attempted to explain the effectiveness of MCS by examining designs that best suit the nature of the environment, technology, size, structure, strategy and national culture. In recent years, contingency-based research has maintained its popularity with studies including these variables but redefining them ...view middle of the document...

The next
section introduces the area of contingency-based MCS research and provides an overview of find- ings over the past 20 years. The following nine sections review articles in terms of their contribu- tion to understanding topics considered within contingency-based research. These are: the meaning
0361-3682/02/$ - see front matter # 2002 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved. PI I : S0361-3682(01 )00027-7
Accounting, Organizations and Society 28 (2003) 127-168
www.elsevier.com/locate/aos
E-mail address: Robert.Chenhall@buseco.monash.edu.au 1 The journals include: Accounting, Organizations and Society; Accounting and Business Research; Accounting and Finance;
Accountability and Performance, Behavioral Research in Accounting; Journal of Accounting Research; Journal of Accounting and
Economics; Journal of Accounting and Public Policy; Journal of Cost Management; Journal of Financial Economics; Journal of Man-
agement Accounting Research; Management Accounting Research, The Accounting Review. In addition, several articles are drawn
from management journals: Academy of Management Journal, Academy of Management Review, Administrative Science Quarterly,
Decision Science, Management Science and OMEGA.

of MCS, outcomes of MCS, and the contextual variables of external environment, technology (tra- ditional and contemporary), organizational struc- ture, size, strategy and national culture. Each section comprises two parts: first, findings from the extant literature are presented and a series of propositions summarizing these findings are offered; and second, critical issues concerning each variable are examined with a view to identifying areas that provide challenges for improvement and opportunities for future research. Following these sections, issues concerning theory develop- ment are examined. Finally, the potential role of a variety of theories in progressing understanding of contingency-based research in MCS is considered.
2. An organizational framework for contingency- based MCS research
The identification of contextual variables potentially implicated in the design of effective MCS can be traced to the original structural con- tingency frameworks developed within organiza- tional theory. Theorists such as Burns and Stalker (1961), Perrow (1970), Thompson (1967), Lawr- ence and Lorsch (1967), and Galbraith (1973) focused on the impact of environment and tech- nology on organizational structure. Early accounting researchers drew on this work to investigate the importance of environment, tech- nology, structure and size to the design of MCS. Reviews conducted 20 years ago by Waterhouse and Tiessen (1978) and Otley (1980) were able to structure their commentaries by categorizing the early research into these key variables. In considering MCS research since 1980, it is
apparent that these key variables have been con- firmed as descriptors of fundamental, generic ele- ments of context. Many...

Other Essays On Management Control System

Project Management Function Essay

2544 words - 11 pages the project successfully. In Scope management processes includes like Scope planning, scope definition, scope verification, scope control.2. Time ManagementTime management means estimating work completion time, developing project schedule and ensuring timely completion of the project. In time management processes includes like activity definition, activity sequencing, resource estimating, duration estimating, schedule control etc.3. Cost

Time Management Plan Essay

875 words - 4 pages You need to manage time effectively if you're going to be successful. Better time management skills can improve your grades, help you keep stress in check, and help you be competitive in the career you undertake following your college or university education. Time management systems often fail because they the expectations of them are too unrealistic. Some people don't start a time management system until they're already falling behind in their

Experiences with Decision Making Models

997 words - 4 pages corporation, I try to find business solutions to achieve optimal business practices for process management, from payroll to benefit administration. I started looking into software vendors that could handle the task of replacing our old payroll vendor with an in-house HRMS/Payroll system so the company could have better control and eventually to replace SAP (System Analysis and Program Development). The identified problem was the lack of

Management Information System

2757 words - 12 pages A Management Information System (MIS) converts data from INTERNAL AND EXTERNAL SOURCES into information in an APPROPRIATE FORM to managers at DIFFERENT LEVELS in an organisation to enable them to make effective DECISIONS or to MONITOR/CONTROL the performance of their employees.Information comes from internal and external sources. Internal information includes data from transaction processing. External information includes market research

Window XP Outline

820 words - 4 pages supported* Built-in VPN client with configuration wizardsAdministration* Provides a centralized and consistent environment for management tools* Group Policies Group Policy settings simplify the administration of users and objects by letting administrators organize them into logical units* Resultant Set of Policy (RSoP) allows administrators to preview the effects of policy changes.* Allows administrator to control which software can run while

A Case Study Analysis

1524 words - 7 pages ZAP!!, A Case Study AnalysisZAP!! needs to be zapped. ZAP!! has a problem that will not go away. ZAP!! management has implemented a new manufacturing quality control system and would like full employee participation. However, not all employees (assemblers) participate in the weekly quality control meetings and those who do are reluctant to address the issues or express their views. ZAP!! management does not want to terminate any of the

Organizing Paper

1288 words - 6 pages . Effectiveness and efficiency is the process of using resources to complete task and goals with the highest quality and with the least amount of cost and time. The competition for all companies in every field and organizations are out sourcing, contracting, and eliminating certain parts within organizations to stay competitive. "Effective HRM is one of the key building blocks of a comprehensive HRH strategy. A responsive human resource management system

Service Request SR-Rm-012 Business Systems

1859 words - 8 pages information system will also increase efficiency of inventory control, manufacturing, and accounting. Additionally, by integrating this system into purchasing and sales, Riordan will see a return of investment in the following areas.•Reduction of work load through automation•Accelerated inventory adjustment and immediate order fulfillment and manufacturing scheduling•Error reduction through less paper handling and data entry&bull

A Report Reflection Of Magazine Distribution Order Picking Report

3428 words - 14 pages performance, accuracy and even lead time, which can clearly be the proof of huge need for 'eligible order picking and storage system and management'.Suggested strategy uses wave, batch-picking methods, and pick by light picking process together with parallel working flow with paper based sorting method. While Menzies has adopted Vertical Carousels, and the evaluation on each system will presented in this part.Suggested strategy by groupGroup has believed

Quality Improvement Implementation

2894 words - 12 pages covers design and development. Hartman Industries, LLC prides themselves on the awareness to detail, tremendous care, and high quality control standards. Hartman Industries, LLC provides the process approach to improve, control, and measure the business performance. Hartman Industries, LLC also uses the Six Sigma quality management system. This helps the organization to identify and eliminate the errors or flaws in their manufacturing process

Systems Approach

8206 words - 33 pages . For example, if the business firm system were completely isolated from the environmen- tal system, then a closed system would exist, in which case management would have com- plete control over all system components. If the business system reacts with the environment, then the system is referred to as open. All social systems, for example, are categorized as open systems. Open systems must have permeable boundaries. (p.54)If a system is

Similar Papers

Project Management Essay

3574 words - 15 pages for and principal components of project management; The characteristics of projects and project management; The application criteria and different forms of project management; The different project environments where project management may be applied; A summary of the reasons why I regard project management as dynamic. 4 Through to Page 10 10 Question 1.4 Explaining "There is so much talk about the system. And so little understanding

Internal Control Paper

1663 words - 7 pages INTERNAL CONTROL PAPERThe procedures involved in accounts payable for Jamona.com is reviewed in detail and this paper assesses the strengths and weaknesses of their internal control system. The required additional controls to overcome the weaknesses are discussed in detail. The recommended and existing controls are analyzed and each control is identified as preventive, detective, or corrective.Overview of Internal ControlInternal control is the

Discuss In Detail The Role Of Internal Auditing, Types Of Internal Auditing And How Internal Audits Add Value To An Organisation

3955 words - 16 pages Internal Audit encompasses the examination and evaluation of the adequacy, effectiveness and efficiency of the system of internal control and management performance. The internal auditor should have access to all records, personnel, and physical properties relative to the performance of duties and responsibilities. The scope of a particular internal audit activity may be as broad or as restricted as required to meet management needs. Objectivity

Impact Of Information And Computer Technology On Production Planning And Control Systems

1283 words - 6 pages and control systems.A production planning and control system is concerned with planning and controlling all aspects of manufacturing, including materials, scheduling machines and people, and coordinating suppliers and customers. According to Sridharan and Kanet production planning and control include four major activities aggregate capacity planning, materials planning, production activity planning and production activity control. Therefore it