Means To An End Essay

739 words - 3 pages

"Concequentailists will lie to save a persons life. But then they are treating those to whom they lie as a mere means to the end of saving others. So their actions cannot be justified" "Concequentailists will lie to save a persons life. But then they are treating those to whom they lie as a mere means to the end of saving others. So their actions cannot be justified" This statement evidently states a contradiction in ethics. A consequentaialist duty is to bring about the best overall state of affairs judged from an impartial perspective. From an impartial perspective, what reason these people are being hunted down is considered to be irrelevant. Yet to bring the best happiness, this reason becomes very relevant. From a Kantian perspective, the "˜situation' in which this person has got himself into is a rational basis to decide on ones life, such ...view middle of the document...

Yet is it valid for this individual to use you as a mean to an end of the person you are hiding? Is it their duty to make ones end your judgment? This may turn into a redundant circle of who it treating who as means and as an end. It is conclusive to say that using someone as a mere means to save another's life brings about a greater happiness than to be used as an end to the ones life in which you are protecting. Accordingly if one is to lie to another in order to save one from death it is valid to use another as a mere means to saving another's end.Any rational being exists as an end in himself, not merely as a means to be arbitrarily used by this or that will, but in all his reactions, weather they concern himself or other rational beings, must be always regarded at the same time as an end. I wish to agree that depending on the circumstances that person you are lying for, is being looked for, should influence you decision to give them up or not. In the case of a murder, one should give them up as a greater decision for that society. You have to ask yourself if you feel safe in a community who shelters criminals from justice? Contrary to when the Jews were being discriminated for their religion and eye color; this is an acceptable reason to lie in order to save a life. Why, because in this case you are lying to save an innocent life. It can be argued, it is not your decision to decide who is innocent and who is guilty. Yet as Kant supports, in obvious circumstances it is suitable to make a judgmental decision. Rationalizing it is justified to lie for and innocent person.Lying to someone to preserve another's life is justified by a consequentialist, yet using someone, as a means to the end of saving others is not. In regards to deontology it is more just to use someone as a means than opposed to an end. Therefor from an ethical point of view it is safe to say that; it is just to lie to someone to save an innocent person even-though you are using another person as a mere means because a means is more "˜just' that an end.

RELATED

What It Means To Be An American Paper

513 words - 3 pages What it means to be an American? It means a lot to be an American. Especially now after what happened on September 11th. To be an American means being proud about all the things that we have that other people don't have. It means that you have to stand up for your rights, that some are people are unfortunate to not have. Being an American means that you can have the job that you want whether you are male or female.Before September 11th people

What It Means To Be An American Today

807 words - 4 pages always remember what it means to be an American, why we are unique, and how we should live. To be an American today means to be wealthier than ninety percent of the world. It means one is educated and has a bright future to look forward to. Although many people might look at this and feel prideful and arrogant we should be humbled and grateful for every second. To be an American today means that we have more rights than any other citizen of any

We cannot depend on mankind to put an end to war for us. We can put an end to war ourselves - Leichhardt Campus Year 10 - Persuasive Speech

797 words - 4 pages We cannot depend on mankind to put an end to war for us. We can put an end war ourselves. Do you think mankind can put an end to war? Do you think war is guns and bombs? The concept of war has been challenged by people nowadays. It doesn't have to WW1 or WW2 or WW3. War can be any form of social conflict (x). Issues such as gender inequality, racism and the exploitation of our natural environment are considered to be war. For so long mankind

Definition of what it means to be an American - English - Essay

763 words - 4 pages Yee-HAW! A cowboy rides off in the sunset. Alan Jackson's masterpiece "Chattahoochee" begins to play, softly yet surely. The cowboy pulls a blade and begins to shave, he scraps through his back right pocket, pulls his Mail Pouch and packs a hog-nut. The sun beats down on the barren Wild West. An excruciating day of herding longhorns, the cowboy reaches for a flask and takes a swig of his last few drops of Jameson Whiskey. He dismounts himself

Deontological Ethics Chapter 13: The Categorical Imperative Immanuel Kant - Ethics - Philosophy

611 words - 3 pages capacity to act in accordance with principles 5. What kind of imperative commands an action to be done as a means to some other end? *** hypothetical 6. What kind of imperative is the imperative of morality? *** categorical 7. According to Kant, for an action to be moral, what principle must motivate it? *** universalizable 8. What does Kant claim respect is? *** feeling 9. According to Kant, what are we obligated to do (be able to identify something he

Role Modeling: A Positive Influence

493 words - 2 pages the most important qualities a positive role-model can hold.Kindness is another very important quality that any good role model should possess. Showing loving and affection and goodwill towards others is crucial because without a kindness behind an action, the action becomes selfish. Unconcerned with others, those acting without kindness tend to damage the lives of many people as well as their own. As difficult as it is sometimes, one should make

Harrison Burgeron

484 words - 2 pages Burgeron. He was too smart for the mental handicap and to strong for the physical. He tried to rebel against society but was executed for his feeble attempt. He was arrested for thinking outside of the ox but was killed for defying the ruler. He was trying to die as he saw it as his only way out of his miserable existence. To conclude, Kurt Vonnegut Jr. portrayed a society where thinking was outlawed. The only way a person could survive was to conform. This society strove for equality but only achieved a society of zombies. This society thought that the end justifies the means, but the end saw the desrurction of individualism and the means was conformity.

Response Piece on 7 Habits of Highly Effective People

546 words - 3 pages , and in a working environment.To internalize something means to "take it in and make it an integral part of the attitudes and beliefs that guide your behavior" (www.thefreedictionary.com). Being proactive is important in many environments because it allows the person internalizing it to reach their fullest potential. That person can then go on to have a fuller sense of self, a more effective means of approach on problems, and a more useful way to

Just War Doctrine And The Gulf Conflict

1381 words - 6 pages and during this time the US abstained from any military action. In conjunction with efforts of Perez de Cuellar, US Secretary of State James Baker spent countless hours negotiating directly with the Iraqi Foreign Minister in an attempt to bring about a non-violent end to the crisis. When all efforts failed to bring an end to the conflict by peaceful means the UN Security Council drafted Resolution 678 which authorized 'all means necessary' to

Grit essay, An example essay of the essay all freshman are required to write - Bryant University, Freshman entrance - Essay

450 words - 2 pages school work. If you put time and effort into it, you will succeed. There are many pointers that Angela Duckworth gives us to acquire passion one of them is just to show up, if you don’t show up for class it means you don’t care and it will show it in your grade. She also tells us to practice or study and to have an interest in what you do if you are not interested you won’t try as hard. If you are not interested in your major find another one

did the parents reflect the death of romeo and juilet - language arts - essay

958 words - 4 pages Free all turn out. This leads to him being a secret and it wasn’t brought upon on how it might end and he shouldn’t have let this all happen. He can also be held responsible for the deaths because he knew the outcome of the marriage would end badly, "These violent delights have violent ends" (2.6). This explains that all the fun their having will slowly come to an end because they can't keep it a secret or else other bad things will happen. This means

Giving Gifts

283 words - 2 pages For me, gift giving supplies me with an armload of self-gratification. I am not a needy person, by any means, BUT I do need to be needed. Gift giving is just one of the many ways you can show a person how you feel. Not just love but gratitude and appreciation as well. I use it as a way to let someone know that I am thinking about them. The smallest, out of the ordinary, unexpected gift, if presented with a smile, will yield the biggest reactions

Defense of Language within Modern Society - Southern New Hampshire University ENG 550 - Essay

596 words - 3 pages always going to be societal updates available to assist with the language. As was previously stated, with society and technology constantly changing, this means that language has to change as well in order to collect the words that society and technology both provide. Language is important within society especially when the society relies upon the same language. Think back to the Tower of Babel in the Bible in Genesis 11:1-9. It is an origin myth

Competition In High School

503 words - 3 pages most likely give us an advantage over our peers. Daily, we young people are tempted to compromise our morality in order to make competitive progress. Our challenge no longer lies in identifying what to do but rather what not to do. In the natural, how are we supposed to identify right from wrong when our egocentric society dictates that, "The end justifies the means"? As competition continues to gain strength over morality, it seems that it is

moral ethics : kant vs korsgard - ualbany/college - essay

1692 words - 7 pages never morally right to tell a lie as it violates the maxims in the 4 stages he presents. Kant’s second formulation is the formula of humanity in which he states, “Act in such a way that you treat humanity, whether in your own person or in the person of any other, never merely as a means to an end but always at the same time as an end”- (Kant GMM). To understand this formulation what it means to treat a person as a means to an end or as an end must be