Milgram Obedience Reaction Report Glenbard Highschool Psychology Essay

884 words - 4 pages

Milgram Obedience Reaction Report
Before I read the Baumrind and Milgram article, I watched the video of Milgram performing the Obedience experiment and did not conclude that the experiment was ethical. I believe that the test-subjects were being manipulated and in result, they were experiencing torment. From an act-utilitarian perspective, I believed that the benefits outweighed the costs but still, I believed that the ethical standards that allowed Milgram to perform this study were immutably preposterous. I believed that there was short-term suffering that happened to the subjects, such as the sweating, cognitive dissonance, and other negative symptoms that the test-subjects expressed. I also believed that there were some long-term consequences of the study. These long-term consequences were constituted by their obedience to authority at the cost of another’s pain. Overall, I was against the experiment from ever replicating.
When I was instructed to read the Milgram and Baumrind article on the ethics of the Milgram Obedience research, I had a deeper understanding on the reasons why the study was done and why the study was rational. When I had heard that some people thanked Milgram for the study initially, I was confused. Reading the article, I found out that the 84% enjoyed being in the study while only 1.3% had negative feelings towards the study in general. Furthermore, Milgram debriefed his participants and asked them if had learned something from the experiment and if the experiment should continue. There were 74 % that had agreed that they had learned something and 80% wanted this experiment to continue. After the experiment was completed, he sent out a report to the subjects about the findings and they agreed that they would want to participate in more experiments like his obedience experiment. A psychiatrist also checked out the individuals that expressed turmoil during the experiment a year later and he checked them out with no concern about any psychological effects on them from the experiment. When I learned about the procedures that Milgram took to make sure his study was a valid study that did not break an ethical code, I was less inclined on putting a bad label on Milgram for disregarding people’s dignity, lack of concern for others, and a rigid pursuit for scientific progression.
In terms of delivering a better argument on paper, I have to be in agreement with the counter-argument provided by Milgram. Not only his rhetoric was better but he addressed many of the issues with Baumrind’s critique on the study and how her arguments were not as well articulated. Some of...

Other Essays On Milgram Obedience Reaction Report - Glenbard Highschool Psychology - Essay

Write a rhetorical analysis on a video of Neil Degrasse Tyson talking about god - English 1000 - Rhetorical Analysis

1640 words - 7 pages essential part of any artifact. Over the years, research in the field of psychology has found that people respond to and have a sort of social obedience to authority. In 1963, research psychologists conducted the Milgram experiment as a way of justifying the horrors of the holocaust. In this experiment, subjects were ordered by normal people dressed in lab coats to look like “scientists” to administer extremely painful, almost torturous, electric

Chemistry Sanitation of swimming pool - Ch5 - Research Paper

5028 words - 21 pages settlement of Mohenjo-daro, over 5000 years ago. ("The History of Pools", 2018). Despite its popularity across the world, the chemistry behind swimming pool sanitation, which is a crucial step into assuring a safe and enjoyable time for swimmers, is rarely acknowledged. This report will explain and evaluate the complex chemical science behind the maintenance of swimming pools. The requirements for optimal pool condition will first be explained in order to

Social Psychology in Class Lecture Notes - University of Virginia - Lecture Notes

2907 words - 12 pages -… then “negotiate down” to your real request STUDY: CIALDINI IV: Request(s) presented IV1: small only Smaller request only: not that many people Rejection-moderation: jumps to 50% PRINCIPLES OF RECIPROCAL CONCESSIONS: · In negotiation situations, concession by one party should be met with concessions from the other OBEDIENCE: · Behavior change as the result of a request from an authority figure 3/29/18 OBEDIENCE MILGRAM STUDY · First “learned

Being, belonging, doing and becoming, and self-efficacy, motivation etc. in occupations - Human Mind and Behaviour - Essay

3199 words - 13 pages This essay will discuss being, belonging, doing and becoming, as well as a variety of psychological concepts including self-efficacy, motivation, stress, observational learning, conformity and obedience in terms of a chosen occupation. My chosen occupation which I participate in regularly is soccer. Soccer is a game engaged in by two teams with 11 players each. The objective is to progress the ball into the opposition’s goal, usually by kicking

art study ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc - art - essay

1344 words - 6 pages Course: BSc Psychology with Counselling and Psychotherapy Level: 4 Unit: Counselling and Psychotherapy I Unit Code: 2F4Z0015 Weighting: 50% Assessed Coursework: Critical Essay Word Length: 2500 words Brief: Discuss a key issue in mental health related to psychotherapeutic work. The essay should include a reflective account documenting development throughout the unit and the coursework completion. Further Guidance You must choose one of the four

dbq revolutions about different wars - us history - essay

1140 words - 5 pages . Then, read the directions for Part B and write your essay. Historical Context: The idea of revolution spread worldwide during the first global age. Task: Using information from the documents and your knowledge of global history and geography, write an essay in which you discuss the political, economic, and social conditions that led to political revolutions in the first global age. PART A: SHORT ANSWER Document #1      "Simón Bolívar sent a joyous

Module 5 RA 2: Psychological Evaluation and Risk Assessment - Argosy University/ Forensic Psychology - Assignment

2510 words - 11 pages tongue. He was informed that the interview was not going to be confidential and that any information that he discloses can and will be used within the written report. According to the Special Guidelines of Forensic psychology (2013), properties, liberties, and substantial rights are at risk due to the procedures and methods of the mental health provider and can become “complex and may not accurately predict the receivers of the service.” The

Theme essay for dead poets society - school/english - essay

756 words - 4 pages For Essay 4, now that you understand the conversation in the public sphere, research what academic scholars and experts are saying about your chosen issue. Investigate the research question you arrived at in Essay 3. Review credible academic and professional sources in an attempt to answer your research question, arriving at a clear, complex, debatable thesis. Your goal is to support this thesis with research and critical analysis. THIS IS NOT A

personality project on what our personality is - ap psychology - essay

1400 words - 6 pages on the potential for healthy personal growth. Trait theories is a characteristic pattern of behavior or a disposition to feel and act, as assessed by self-report inventories and peer reports. Social-cognitive views behavior as influenced by the interaction between people’s traits and their social context. Positive psychology focuses on discovering and promoting strengths that enable people to be successful. Psychoanalytic/psychodynamic and trait

Discuss biological and behaviourist approaches intro aggression including reductionist methodologies - NTU - Essay

2199 words - 9 pages significant element that is present in both human and animal behaviour. A Real-World Health Organization report has shown that aggressive acts account for 1.43 million deaths worldwide (Provençal, Booij, & Tremblay, 2015). This essay focuses on a reductionist approach into aggression, and the biological factors which may be the underlying cause for these impulsive responses, comparing two biological approaches to a behaviourist approach. The first

How useful are personality tests in measuring personality? - Personality and Individual Differences - Psychology - Essay

1881 words - 8 pages 9 THE USEFULNESS AND APPLICABILITY OF PERSONALITY MEASUREMENT Abstract Various tests have been implemented in the past few decades for personality measurement, however, which ones are the most useful to psychologists? This essay analyses and compares two personality measurement tests: the Myer-Briggs Type Indicator and the NEO-Personality Inventory-Revised test, which is a Big Five Factor Model test. Multiple studies have been conducted

Similar Papers

Summary Of Milgram's Behavioral Study Of Obedience Humboldt State University Psychology 240 Essay

480 words - 2 pages choice but to continue with the experiment. Future research should use a sample of both men and women to examine whether the level of obedience would fluctuate and replace the experimenter with an ordinary person to examine the influence of social roles on authority. Reference Milgram, S. (1963). Behavioral study of obedience. The Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 67(4), 371-378. doi:10.1037/h0040525

Five Factor Model Personality Test Psychology Essay, Report

1647 words - 7 pages The Big Five model is broken down into five dimensions, including; openness, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness and neuroticism. Openness includes those who are open to experience and are intellectually curious, they may also be open to emotion, and willing to try new things. Conscientiousness individuals display self-discipline, act loyally, and aim for achievement against measures or outside expectations. Additionally, it is related

Written Assignment #2 Alternate Reality Essay Psychology 2301/Blinn Essay

2147 words - 9 pages major party with. We currently live in a very “short-term” thinking world, where people are worried only about the immediate next step. If people looked forward to growing old, their other goals would follow this pattern of looking towards the possible future rather than just what comes next. In the studying of human behaviors and how our minds work, Psychology would be immensely changed given this alternate reality became the norm. Over this

Stanford Prison Experiment Essay

1336 words - 6 pages was to place a number of student volunteers to portray prisoners and another number to portray prison guards (Lee, 2010). However, the experiment itself produced some interesting results, it also brought about a number of ethical questions; these questions are why this experiment remains controversial to this day.DISCUSSIONZimbardo was the student of another psychologist, Stanly Milgram, who studied the nature of "obedience experimentation." He