Assignment On Multinational Companies

2058 words - 9 pages

Multinational Companies: Out for Profit Without Regard for Life

        What a company usually wants for its business is for it to be an successful establishment and to make an abundance of profit. Some businesses do not pose any concern on what they have to do to make this profit as long as it done. Multinational companies are firms with their home base in one country and operations in many other nations. (Molyeux, 133). Most of these very immense firms establish in third word countries were they can manufacture the same identical product for very low costs compared to establishing the same firm in the western Countries producing that product. Most of these multinational companies are heartless and treat workers as slaves giving them diminutive wages for their work. The lifeboat ethics concept is the best way to describe these heartless firms. The concept of Lifeboat Ethics is fairly lucid. It is based upon choosing who lives, and who departs. Environmentalists argue that no single being or institution has the right to extinguish, waste, or use more than a fair share of its resources (Psychology Today, 54). Obviously, this is not happening. The philosophy of Lifeboat Ethics sees each wealthy nation as a lifeboat full of rich people. In the ocean outside the lifeboat are the less fortunate citizens of the world swimming around the lifeboat wanting to get in, or at least wanting to share some of the wealth with the well off. What should the rich do? In the heart of all of this are the multinational companies that practically control every developing country in the world. These companies have a very significant impact on who lives and who dies, and at the same time, they have a grim grip on the needy nations of the world all in the name of profit. These multinationals exploit the people of these countries as well as their land by the practice of slave labour in both China and the Dominican Republic, as well as many other Third World countries. Other multinational companies prey on innocent mothers promoting infant formula which ends up in advertently killing millions of infants each year.

        In the third world, around ninety percent of the people lack sufficient resources, education, and ultimately money. In the West, on the other hand, we have an abundance of resources at our disposal, good educational systems, and a significantly higher average income than the Third World. The higher income allows us to have these resources at our disposal, as well as the good education systems. Along with this capital comes power held in the hands of the multinational companies which has an adverse effect on many Third World communities.

        The Dominican Republic is one of the poorest nations of the word, with an average annual income of just over one thousand dollars per year (Hilsum, 1). Most of these people can barely afford the necessities of life such as food, clean water, and shelter. These somewhat degrading conditions are a perfect dwelling for a multinational company such as Gulf and western to "set up shop". Almost fifty percent of the Dominicans export is sugar; on third of that sugar is from Gulf and Western. The locals have a name for this company, El Pulpo, meaning octopus (Hilsum, 1). When a company's own employees to be calling it an 'octopus', meaning that the companies control everything such as resources and most of the land of the country, something has to be blatantly wrong. The main reason for this is that since G&W has come into the Dominican Republic, they have bought out much of the land for sugar cultivation and cattle ranching. Now, almost seventy-five percent of peasants are without land (Hilsum, 1). This presents an overwhelming problem for the peasants; how will they eat? Before G&W came into the Dominican Republic, most of the people relied on subsidence farming for their food. Since G&W settled in the country, they have been consuming valuable land that could be used for food cultivation. Because of this, many Dominicans perished. This argument has been brought to G&W, but they allege that they are helping the people by giving them jobs in the sugar cane fields.

        This notion of giving the peasants jobs in the fields is merely an excuse that many multinational companies use for their actions. How can a company claim to be helping people when they only pay them about two dollars a day? (Newsday, 1) The labourers in the sugar cane fields are treated like slaves, many times unable to keep possessions, and often they are cheated out of remuneration. This is all coming from the "respected" companies that most of us in the west support diligently. These same companies are exploiting the land and the people of the country, all in the name of profit. Since all of these companies are out to maximize profit, they will do anything it takes to come out on top; weather it is employing slave labour, or not providing its employees with the basic necessities of life. If this is what it takes to maximize profit, then the company will not hesitate. Because of the firm grip these companies have on people, most of the peoples' lives do not improve. One must ask oneself, does the Third world need multinationals? The answer is clearly no. When it comes to multinationals, everything is done with "dollar signs" in mind. The most money is made in the agricultural business, mainly involving cash crops. These cash crops are destined for the First World (Barnet, 147). This fact dispels a widely accepted myth about the Third World. Most people in our society believe that we cater for the Third world since they cannot support themselves, when in fact it is them that are nourishing us. Our hunger for luxury crops such as coffee, costs many peoples lives in the process. In Columbia a hectare of wheat brings in 12,500 pesos; carnations for exporting bring in one million (Barnet, 147). All of this is happening in a country that is suffering from severe malnutrition because they do not cultivate enough grain. It just does not make any sense as to why these countries put themselves in this kind of position.

        Underdeveloped countries have three major weaknesses when dealing with multinational companies. Their laws are inadequate when dealing with modern accounting practices. They also lack trained personnel and unions to handle the ever dated laws they do have. The last weakness is that local businessmen have trouble competing with the massive companies (Elliot, 139). Throughout these weaknesses there is one common trait, a lack of resources. The Third world just cannot compete with the money and resources to which multinationals have access to.
        These multinationals also resort to very desperate tactics to get what they want, as seen in the boycott of Nestle in the 1980's.

        During the 1970's and early 1980's, Nestle began advertising infant formula to the people of the Third World through signs, and promoting formula throughout hospitals. The question is, What does the Third World want with baby formula when breast milk is free? The answer is simple, there is a colossal profit to be made in the developing countries of the world because they have a lot of children. Ever since the declining birth rates in western countries, formula manufacturers found themselves glancing at the Third World. They launched aggressive advertising campaigns to convince mothers that bottle feeding is "more modern" and that breast feeding is backward and primitive (Media Center, 1). Since most developing nations look up to the west, sadly, most Third World mothers bought into these campaigns. The largest difference was in Singapore where in 1951, 71% of all babies from low-income families were breast fed. Twenty years later, only 5% were (Media Center, 1). But this problem is much more serious than marketing an unnecessary product to people that do not need it. To use infant formula effectively, you must have uncontaminated water, refrigeration, funds to buy it, and methods of sterilization. All of these factors are not available to the average person in a developed country because many people cannot afford to buy the formula, they dilute it, which leads to malnutrition. This malnutrition causes brain damage in infants, and was so widespread that doctors called it "baby bottle disease".

        About this time in the 1980's, Nestle was engaged in illegal practices of promoting their formula in developing countries. They hired milk nurses to go into the hospitals and promote their product to mothers with newborn children (Guess who is coming to breakfast). These milk nurses would give the mothers free samples of infant formula for about three weeks, then they would cut off the free samples. During this three week period, the mothers milk would dry up because it was not being used, and thus, the mother would than have no choice but to rely on formula she cannot afford. Because the mother can't afford the formula, the chances of her baby dying of baby bottle disease is very high. Under law, the manufacturer of the product must state the hazards of the product on the label, but with a low literacy rate it does no good. Also, before the bottles are sold, the labels are often torn off by the store selling them so the label does no good anyhow (Infant formula Fact Sheet). Corporations such as Nestle were also found guilty of bribing doctors to recommend the product to patients (Macdonald, June 6).

        The case with infant formula is a classic example of a multinational company's total disregard for human life. By breaking the law, they showed the world that they cannot be trusted and that they only care about maximizing profit. Nestle used aggressive marketing tactics to vulnerable people in the Third world even when they knew that their product was causing many infant deaths. It is clear that the conditions for the safe use of formula were not present in the Third World, but Nestle was controlling who lives, and who dies. What kind of world is it coming to when western companies can come into Third World countries and brainwash new mothers in buying things that they do not even need and get away with it. The value of the buck in the companies eyes are worth more than keeping children alive and healthily.

        There are solutions to the massive problem of multinational domination. Firstly, government legislation can keep multinationals on their toes providing minimum wage agreements, unions, and safe working conditions to help safeguard the lives of people working for large corporations in developing countries. Secondly, we in the First world can assist our brothers and sisters in the Third world countries by boycotting companies that subject their workers to low wages and slave labour. This was evident with the boycott of Nestle. Because of the boycott, Nestle and other companies had to abide by strict rules when selling products in developing countries. One could also look at the situation as being our fault because we are the ones that have the hunger for the products that the Third world is producing. Most of us do not realize that the banana we eat, or the juice we drink, could be causing pain and ultimately death to the peasant that cultivates it. This being said, it is ultimately us, not the multinationals that are causing death in the Third world? Are they just feeding off of our hunger and turning a profit? The bottom line is that if most of us knew about the deaths we were causing because of our practices, hopefully most of us would make a point not to do it anymore. Whereas in a multinational's case, morals cannot stop them, only the law can. The poor people of the world can only take so much. We must stop these multinational companies before they conform into a slave labour establishment once again and cause death to the innocent trying to make an honest buck and created an except able livelihood for them and their families. All this just torture and greed just to make some money.


The Importance of MNC'S to the World: Good or Bad Influence

414 words - 2 pages Multinational corporations are companies with their home base in one country and operations in many other nations. Most of these, very immense firms, establish in third world countries or developing countries where they manufacture the same identical product for very low costs compared to the ones in developed countries.One of the purposes of MNC's is to create an economic development which is described as sustained growth in income per capita

The Management Assignment

707 words - 3 pages small organization to hundreds or thousands of managers in multinational companies. In large organizations, the board of directors defines the policy which is then carried out by the chief executive officer, or CEO. Some people agree that in order to evaluate a company's current and future worth, the most important factors are the quality and experience of the managers.Read more:

international business management Essay

382 words - 2 pages poses on companies and governments.Describe different mechanisms through which foreign direct investment makes impact on host country economic development.What is the key difference between vertical and horizontal FDI? How does research measure the two concepts? What are the host country attributes that attract vertical and horizontal FDI respectively?Describe the main mechanisms of coordination and control in the multinational corporation and

In What Ways Has Globalisation Helped Multinational Corporations Coordinate And Control Their Business Functions On A Global Scale

779 words - 4 pages In what ways has globalisation helped multinational corporations coordinate and control their business functions on a global scale.'Globalization' is commonly used as a shorthand way of describing the spread and connectedness of production, communication and technologies across the world. That spread has involved the linking of economic and cultural activity. Globalization in the sense of connectivity in economic and cultural life across the

General Electric - A Fortune 500 Company: Why They Continue To Be One Of The Top 15 Fortune 500 Companies

742 words - 3 pages General electric. It can also help start-ups over some trouble, sometimes charging prevailing consulting rates for its guidance.GE Equity is one of the leading providers of equity capital to growing companies. It has $1 billion a year available to invest in growth capital; ensuring future growth. This growth translates to a good return on the dollar and a great investment vehicle for future option purchases.GE is an enormous multinational industrial

Information System paper on Digital IT - York University - Essay

4589 words - 19 pages online gambling and digital gaming. The city needs to have a solid IT sector to keep OLG in the city and also attract other companies like OLG to the city. OLG has already prepared a platform for the businesses. Types of businesses found in the sector, both multinational enterprises and small-medium enterprises.   Technical Support Technical Support is one of the main functions of an information systems department. IT is directed toward operating

Analysis Of Advantages And Disadvantages Of FDI

2279 words - 10 pages well as access to international markets. Therefore, some countries offer tax incentives to attract investment. For those multinational companies located in high tax rate's nations such as UK, and US, invest in a country which exists tax incentives is a good way to reduce tax.4. Avoidance of an uncertain cost structure created by foreign exchange. When a firm adopts exporting to be a primary method for expansion of foreign market, one of the main

Frobel’S Concept Of The NIDL

597 words - 3 pages Free the globalizationprocess, Transnational (or Multinational, as they were generally termed inthe 1970s) corporations. The 'core' is situated in the first zone of theadvanced industrial states. The 'periphery' is situated in the second zoneof the developing countries. Transnational companies whose headquartersare based in the core states are utilising increasingly accessible labour5from the peripheral states as part of the growing phenomenon of

OLI and Uppsala model comparison - Durham - Essay

2860 words - 12 pages contemporary multinational enterprises (MNEs) especially in Asian network (Dunning & Lundan, 2008b). Different from traditional business groups such as those trading companies in 19th century, those emerging MNEs are networked based instead and some of them has ultimately developed into metanational MNEs (Dunning & Lundan, 2008b). Based on Peng and Delios’s research focused on Asian firms, the existing theories of IB cannot meet the needs of analysing

On The Negative Effects of Natural Resource Extraction due to Globalization - McGill INTD 200 - Essay

2521 words - 11 pages On The Negative Effects of Natural Resource Extraction due to Globalization In the past few decades, we have witnessed the rise of globalization. In this paper, I will argue that this rise has allowed for companies to extract resources outside of their own domestic jurisdiction in developing nations, hindering positive sustainable development in those countries. Foreign multinational companies are infiltrating developing economies and exploiting

Aid To Dependent Corporations (Univ. Of Phoenix - SOC 101)

1068 words - 5 pages cases of corporate wealthfare. One example is the foreign tax credit, "which allows U.S.-based multinational corporations to deduct from their U.S. taxes the income taxes they pay to other nations" (15). A perfect argument of the foreign tax credit is the oil companies that purchased oil from Saudi Arabia. Saudi Arabia had no income tax, which was good for the American companies; but the Saudi Arabians charged royalties. Because the royalties were

Global Business Plan: Coca-Cola Company - MGMT 302 - Business Plan

3826 words - 16 pages million are deliberated as middle-class citizens with expendable incomes. Moreover, there are various aspects that make China a unique market for a number of multinational corporations. For success, many companies shift from their corporate strategy and adopt the Chinese way of advertisement and marketing so that their products are recognized as brands in the country. Similarly, Yang & Wang (2015) argued that branding and marketing in China must

Human Resources Management

970 words - 4 pages with.Globalization is a topic that affects HRM on not only international or multinational companies but also solely domestic companies. HR professionals should know about local markets, pay rates and labor laws, of the target area. Oftentimes decisions about were to locate overseas operations in HR consideration, about cost, and availability of qualified workers. The global market has also allowed solely domestic companies for example, to pull

The Sogo Shosha

2891 words - 12 pages shosha compared to Western-owned multinational companiesAccording to Young (1979, p. 17), the western owned multinational companies 'prefer assuming their own direct supply and marketing responsibilities when possible rather than using intermediaries. Manufacturers prefer direct purchases of industrial raw materials and direct marketing not only at home but also abroad'. Thus for example, companies like IBM employs its own completely controlled sales

bussiness government and global context - RMIT masters - essay

2942 words - 12 pages due to its rapid growth in the technologies such as internet and mobile. At First, it has expanded the extent of tax avoidance, attributable to a fast increase of tax havens across the world. Multinational companies have many chances than before to evade their reasonable and effective offer of taxation (Sachs and Sachs, 2018). Should contend that globalization has nominal significance, that we are among a personal change of the universal world