Murder In Amsterdam And Its Effect On Immigration Hist 108 History Essay

1215 words - 5 pages

Amanda Conley
HIST 102
Professor Kauffman
December 1, 2018
Murder in Amsterdam
Ian Buruma in his book Murder in Amsterdam talks about the controversy regarding the assassination of Theo Van Gogh. Van Gogh made a film called Submission. In the film verses from the Koran were projected onto women’s naked bodies. This was a not so subtle attempt to show the oppression of women in Muslim communities. On November 2, 2004 Van Gogh was shot in the stomach while bicycling to work. His death was very drawn out, he staggered across the street and was shot several more times, then his killer brought out a machete and cut his throat. His killer was a Moroccan Dutchman, Mohammed Bouyeri, he pinned a note to Van Gogh’s chest that contained radical Islamist rhetoric.
There was another murder in this book that took place before Van Gogh’s. On May 6, 2002 an animal rights activist gunned down Pim Fortuyn, a politician that opposed immigration and gay liberation. Ironically the morning Van Gogh was killed he was on his way to work on 06/05 a “Hitchcockian thriller about the assassination of Pim Fortuyn,” (37). Van Gogh wanted to focus in his film about Fortuyn the outburst that followed his death. Fortuyn’s rival for Prime Minister Jan Peter Balkenende, struggled to find words to describe the situation. When asked he could only come up with “un-Dutch” (37).
Buruma grew up in The Hague but moved to the United States. After these events the country that he returns to is unrecognizable to him. It is transformed by large numbers of Muslim immigrants from Turkey and Morocco. The Netherlands have liberal immigration policies and despite that the multicultural experiment has not gone well. Buruma struggles to find out why. Throughout the book he sits down with social workers, historians, politicians, and writers, of all various backgrounds (meaning some are Dutch, immigrants, or children of immigrants). With these encounters in mind he traces the evolution of the Netherlands. The Netherlands go from a racially similar country to a multicultural sanctuary for immigrants, mainly Muslims.
One of the people he talked with was Bellari, a psychiatrist. Bellari did some research into the mental health of immigrants, specifically cases of depression and schizophrenia. Bellari found that women were more prone to depression, while men were more susceptible to schizophrenia. But what was interesting was that it was only “second generation Moroccans that were born and educated in the Netherlands that suffered from schizophrenia.” (140). Bellari gives a few plausible explanations for this. One of them is a sense of humiliation, immigrants are more likely to see a psychiatrist only when things have gotten too bad. But his main theory is that the “problem lies in the adaptation of a strictly regulated society to a freer, more open one. This can lead to disintegration of the personality.” (140).
Buruma goes into the personal histories of the victims and their assassins, looking for the social reasons that led to murder. In this search the reoccurring theme is immigration and the discord surrounding it. Mr. Fortuyn was very radical in his belief. He dropped doubt into the public about immigration, he felt that the Dutch had gotten too liberal and tolerant of Islamic cultural practices. While Van Gogh made a point of offending Islam. Van Gogh held very different beliefs and liked to offend the political establishment among other things. This was his downfall, he overstepped with his film Submission and faced the consequences of it. Van Gogh says that the Dutch savor irony because their political establishment is dull, they enjoy the politics of outrage. This sentiment is not felt by the country’s Muslim immigrants. Buruma writes, “Van Gogh, more than anyone, had warned about the dangers of violent religious passions, and yet he behaved as though they held no consequences for him.” (98).
The hatred of Islam goes deeper than the radicals who act out. Fortuyn was very public with his hatred of Islamic immigrants, and the Islamic faith. Buruma puts it best, “Fortuyn’s venom is drawn more from the fact that he, and millions of others, not just in the Netherlands, but all over Europe, had painfully wrested themselves free from the strictures of their own religions. And here were these newcomers injecting society with religion once again.” (68). The fact that the Dutch people have struggled and gotten rid of their faith and adopted “Marxist illusions”. This results in the people becoming disillusioned, they hated to look at the Islam’s and see what they had given up.
Muslim immigration was the main type of immigration that showed the most visible unease. The areas that were filled with poverty and shabbiness, were now becoming foreign as well. It became the norm to see these areas as not problematic until they became foreign. But the tricky part of this was that to worry about the social consequences only after the immigrants moved in was to run the risk of being called racist. With World War II still fresh in our minds when Fortuyn started making unkind remarks about Islam, people started comparing him to the Nazi party. Buruma being raised in the Netherlands makes him sensitive to the nuances of what’s going on. He maintains that the argument over immigration cannot be understood without seeing the long shadow of World War II and Anne Frank; “Never again, said the well-meaning defenders of the multicultural ideal, must Holland betray a religious minority.” (51).
Buruma explores the displacement and cultural alienation of Van Gogh’s killer, Muhammed Bouyeri, along with other young Muslim men that are drawn to Islamic fundamentalism. While other societies have been rigid, Dutch freedom has often proved to be oppressive, and here is where Buruma suggests that Islam might not be the main point, “More important was the question of authority, of face, in a household where the father could give little guidance, and in a society from which a young Moroccan male might find it easier to receive subsidies than respect.” (206). Fortuyn had a solution for this, foreigners who did not want to subscribe to Dutch values should leave. People like Van Gogh were not willing to move on the subject and any efforts to appease or accommodate Muslims on issues such as gay rights, or women’s rights, and many people supported this. The support for this stemmed from a fear of giving up Dutch values to favor the beliefs of the majority immigrants.
The murders of these two citizens, has left the country wondering how to move on. History is trying to repeat itself, with the radical beliefs of those like Fortuyn against the Islamic people. But with World War II only 50 years in the past, people are scared of generalizing a group of minorities, but when that group acts out against the beliefs of the people of the nation, they are living in what are we left to do? Buruma tries to answer this but in the end, he hopes that reason and moderation will prevail, and both sides of this debate will end in peace. While the sentiment Buruma makes is sweet, it still leaves a bitter taste in the mouth of those fighting for their rights.
Footnotes
Buruma, Ian. Murder in Amsterdam. New York, NY: Penguin Books, 2014.

RELATED

EFFECT OF IMPERIALISM ON MY ANCESTORS - SOLANO COMMUNITY COLLEGE - FALL HIST 018 - HISTORY ESSAY

1548 words - 7 pages consonant with a capitalist revolution. But on the contrary it added to the existing strata of parasitic elites.”My ancestors were exploited and denied the opportunity to advance economically in their clan grouping. Score 6: Responses at this score point demonstrate effective skill in writing an argumentative essay. · The writer generates an argument that critically engages with multiple perspectives on the given issue. The argument’s

Racism and its Effect on Communities - LAS141 - Essay

1067 words - 5 pages 2 Racism and its Effect on Communities Racism has been a cancer to societies for as long as societies themselves have existed. A very large majority of the atrocities that have occurred throughout history have stemmed from the evil of racism. It seems as though racism is a problem that will never fade away, no matter how much society advances. You can find racism anywhere in the world and its effects have been devastating to many. There is no

Immigration and Nativism in the United States - History 1302 - Essay

1073 words - 5 pages Free and the Statue of Liberty stood as a tall welcoming symbol, many Americans throughout the country did not welcome the newcomers with open arms. In the video lecture, “Early 20th Century Nativism and Immigration,” Professor David Courtwright speaks about several major themes in history that changed the look on immigration from the late 19th and early 20th century as well as the nativism reaction to the mass migration of immigrants from

DBQ on the era of exploration and its effect on the native american - World history - research paper, DBQ

1702 words - 7 pages Quan Ha 4/5/18 Terry World History DBQ The age of exploration is a period of expedition that started around the 15th century and ended around the 17th century. This period Impacted the Europeans in tremendous ways. With its impact on geography, including the findings of new continents. New discoveries of methods of navigation and mapping, and the introduction of new staple diets like corn, and peanuts. The Native people that the Europeans had

immigration and racism correlation - history 101 - essay

560 words - 3 pages countries across the globe. It is not right that Mexican families are being separated and children are being kept in cages. Meanwhile, there is no focus on other races who come here illegally. The Mexicans are just a simple scapegoat the government uses to avoid the true threats to America, which are white Americans. Americans often chose to forget or ignore history, we are cold blooded murders we have shed the blood of thousands of mexicans. We

The African Diaspora And Its Effect On The Veil

1355 words - 6 pages sense of always looking at one's self through the eyes of others, of measuring one's soul by the tape of a world that looks on in amused contempt and pity" (Du Bois, 11), showing that Negroes look at themselves through the eyes of others. They do not look at themselves through their own eyes. In addition, Du Bois wishes to make it possible for a man to be both a Negro and an American without the association of negativity. He also explains that the

The effect of gangs on Immigration - FWIS 100 - Informative

1025 words - 5 pages . Since there are gangs all throughout Central America, they decide to come to the United States for a better opportunity. The purpose of this essay is to increase awareness on the role gangs play in immigration. The following includes personal accounts from three immigrants from El Salvador that have experienced gang violence first hand. Mercedes Garcia came to the U.S. in 1990 when she was 25 years old. She fled El Salvador because of the civil

A short story on murder and drugs

3235 words - 13 pages field just to get in a little more practice. Then, the day of the game finally arrived. All morning, it was raining. So, I couldn’t get a lot of outdoor practice done without slipping in mud, but I still did it. At  8:00, I had the ball. Desperately, I kicked it toward a goal. Unfortunately, it wasn’t our goal I was running at, but I had the ball, and that’s all that mattered. I charged toward the goal, stomping on the moist dirt. I never ran as

Essay on Letters of Heloise and Abelard - Dartmouth College - Hist 42 - Essay

902 words - 4 pages period. Heloise, as evidenced in her direct confrontations of Peter, was an exceptionally assertive and strong willed individual. Curiously, however, Heloise makes rather misogynistic claims throughout the exchange that seem to contradict her intelligent and independent disposition. However, it is likely that this contradiction is more apparent than real because of the influence that her overpowering infatuation for Peter Abelard had on her

Irish immigration - 18th/19th century - Masters - History essay

3506 words - 15 pages Irish natives turned their backs on rural life and instead sort the wealth and fortune that American society had to offer. Nevertheless, while many chose to seek their fortune in America, others found themselves forced in to immigration by their landlords, who although had a duty of care for them, were more concerned with acquiring replacement tenants who could afford to pay regular rent. [7: Dolan, Jay. 2008. The Irish Americans: A History

Elizabeth’s Impact on England and Its Role - English I - Essay

1354 words - 6 pages Reese Reese Max Reese Cheryl Bordelon English I 5 December 2016 Elizabeth’s Impact on England and Its Role In the 1300s, a worldwide phenomenon would change the culture, music, literature, art, and leadership around the world. This time was known as The Renaissance and it marked a major milestone in humanity’s existence. During The Renaissance, England’s new Queen arose to power and reshaped her country for the better. Her name was Queen

Junk Food and Its Effects On Humans - Chaffey 2019 - Essay

1251 words - 6 pages Aguilar 1 Junk Food and Its Effects on Humans Food is one of the essential needs for people and it give us vitality that our body needs to work appropriately. Not just that, it additionally give us an assortment of supplements, nutrients, minerals, carbohydrates, and proteins that our body requests that us every day keep it in capacity. As time passes food has changed because of the requests of the advanced world. People have less time to make a

Bullying and its affect on the world - Reading - Essay

583 words - 3 pages Bullying in the schools has negative effects on individual students and on the school climate as a whole. Bullying can cause long-term problems for both the victims of bullying and the bullies themselves. To explore the effects of bullying on adolescents, we will define bullying, identify the characteristics of bullies and victims, outline the extent and consequences of bullying, and present resources for further information and assistance

An essay on Illegal Immigration - Language, North Kipling - Essay

2571 words - 11 pages strikes in their native country. Illegal immigration though refers to the violation of that countries policies and laws by entering or remaining in the country without legal authorization from the Federal Government (Immigration Laws). This essay will seek to comply on the basis of explaining illegal immigration and discussing the libertarian point of why amnesty should be granted, although to some extent, a right should be given to the

Hist 105 Shays Rebellion book review - History 105 - Essay

664 words - 3 pages . For Massachusetts, a great political flaw in the Articles of Confederation was brought to light after the rebellion. This later spread to all the colonies causing them to rethink the power of state and government laws. Through agreement and unionizing of the states, the Constitutional Convention was later help in Pennsylvania creating the formal documentation of the United State Constitution. Texas A&M University Shays’ Rebellion and Its Effect on America Analysis Levi Volk History 105 504 Mr. Resch 9/28/2018