Narrative Conventions And Lesbian Desire University / English Lit Essay

2432 words - 10 pages

One subversive way of encoding lesbian desire has been through undermining dominant textual narrative strategies. Compare how Cather, in My Antonia, and Stein, in The Autobiography of Alice B. Toklas, rework narrative conventions as a possible strategy to encode or reflect lesbian desire in their works.
Both Cather and Stein are seen as authors who create a lesbian narrative space within their work. Marilyn Farwell argues that a lesbian narrative space occurs ‘when two women seek another kind of relationship than that which is prescribed in the patriarchal structures’ (Farwell, 1990, p.98). This meant that the period in time limited an author in terms of what they were able to write about, and this was because it was not socially acceptable to be openly lesbian. Therefore, a theory of Lesbian reading, known as resistive reading, is used to find a place of alterity or otherness in the text to critique heteronormative practices of reading. Both Cather’s My Ántonia and Stein’s The Autobiography of Alice B. Toklas seem to rework the narrative conventions in order to encode lesbian desire in their works. Cather does this through detailed descriptions of landscape and nature as she is able to encode hidden sexual meaning within the description. Furthermore, she portrays heterosexual relationships as negative and critiques conventional gender norms through heterosexual characters in the novel. Finally, she uses a feminised male narrative voice as her own. This is similar to Stein as she also uses a narrative voice that is of her lesbian lover, Alice Toklas. Stein also encodes female desire through complicated syntax and lack of punctuation; this break from traditional writing is seen as defying the patriarchal constructs. Finally, the descriptions of her and Alice’s daily lives encode the relationship that they have together as it portrays a mimicking of a heterosexual relationship, just as the ‘geniuses and their wives’. ‘In opening a new narrative space, the reader can forge a subtext that explores female desire while the main text does not. The subtext gives us the possibility for a transgressive narrative’ (Farwell, 1990, p.102).
There seems to be a dominant body of Cather criticism that sees My Ántonia as a heterosexual love story due to the many heterosexual relationships within the novel. However, it could be read as a critique of conventional gender norms as Cather uses the portrayal of conventional heterosexual relationships in a negative light. Ántonia is a perfect example of this, having been ‘deserted’(Cather 1994, p.223) by Larry Donovan while pregnant and ‘never married’(Cather 1994, p.223) she had become ‘an object of pity’(Cather 1994, p.223). Whereas, Lena Lingard ‘that was always a bad one…had turned out so well’ (Cather 1994, p.233). Lena is a working woman who refuses to accept the constraints society placed upon her. Even when society predicts that by becoming a dressmaker instead of marrying she will fail and become a "loose"...

Other Essays On Narrative conventions and lesbian desire - University / English Lit - Essay

GMO Research Paper- Described through narrative, informative, and conclusion - Honors English 10 - Essay

1981 words - 8 pages Shaw 1 Clayton Shaw Mrs. Unger Honors English 1/2B 8 March 2018 A Day at Work My Story: When I was about eleven years old, I decided to stay at home while my family went on vacation during the summer. My dad had to stay home as well because he had started a new job at a fertilizer and seed company. During the day, rather than stay at the house all alone, I decided to go to work with my dad. I went with him almost every day that week, but one day

Compare and Contrast Difference between Chinese and English Crime Fiction Novels - National University of Singapore - Essay

1413 words - 6 pages styles and contents to lump itself under it is the fact that there is the centrality and focus on a crime within these texts (Scaggs, 1). Indeed, when we examine the texts in this course, while common themes such as justice and morality emerges, we note the differences in character tropes, recurring motifs, methods of resolution, and more. This, then, influences the detective figure present in the stories as well. For the purpose of this essay

Imagination in Don Quixote and A Midsummer Night's Dream - Kean University English 2403 - Essay

1892 words - 8 pages Maria Veligurskaya English 2403/World Literature October 27, 2017 Formal Essay No. 1 “Imagination in Don Quixote and A Midsummer Night's Dream” William Shakespeare and Miguel de Cervantes are two of the most influential writers in the world that have been compared by scholars for centuries. It is commonly believed that the two men died on the same day, April 23, 1616. However, that is not entirely accurate as England followed the Julian calendar

Compare and Contrast of symbols in Death of a Salesman and A Streetcar named Desire - IB LIT - Literature paper

1360 words - 6 pages Giovanna Amodio IB LIT 2 Mrs.Marusevich 4/5/2018 “Paper 2” Assessment: Tennessee Williams’ A Streetcar Named Desire Arthur Miller’s Death of a Salesman Façade: an outward appearance that is maintained to conceal a less pleasant or creditable reality. In both works of A Streetcar Named Desire by Tennessee Williams’ and Death of a Salesman by Arthur Miller, the main characters’ of each play put up what is known as a Façade throughout the entirety

Stylistics and their Relation to Meaning and Mood - Southern New Hampshire University LIT 555 - Close Reading

786 words - 4 pages might believe him….” (Dos Passos 21) These paragraphs, marked by the label “Indented,” underscore that Debs was feared, because of his proliferating influence, and emphasize this was because of his socialist inclinations (flag), desire to re-distribute wealth (prosperity), and the determination to self-government (democracy). In addition, similarly structured paragraphs create characterization: “[Indented] He was a tall shamblefooted man, had a

Western lit paper paper. On donte - Western And litature - Essay

1035 words - 5 pages Natalie Teets Professor Cluff Western lit sec 02 12/6/17 Thanksgiving and family life discussions . Me?.. You want to know what I think of Western Literature? I glanced over at Patsy who was looking at her plate. It is not that bad… I mean I have a great professor that tries hard to make it interesting and current. My college classes are not as huge as Pasty’s Brigham Young University which is a much larger University . At Southern Virginia

Robert Downey Jr vs Benedict Cumberbatch - Spring Hill College English Lit - Essay

1518 words - 7 pages Nikki Carpenter 10/19/18 English Lit .02 Sherlock Holmes vs Sherlock Sherlock Holmes is one of my favorite characters in fiction novels, movies, and shows. He uses his crazy personality in solving crimes, and the interesting and intellectual way of testing his hypothesis. There are two actors who that play Sherlock Holmes very well, Robert Downey Jr. and Benedict Cumberbatch. Robert Downey Jr. is an amazing Sherlock Holmes compared to Benedict

To what extent should we consider The Picture of Dorian Gray to be a Gothic novel? - English Lit - ESSAY

2891 words - 12 pages ESSAY 5: To what extent should we consider The Picture of Dorian Gray to be a Gothic novel? Oscar Wilde’s first, and only, novel published in 1890 in Lipincott’s Magazine. Despite the censorship that the editor made unbeknownst to Wilde, his text still largely offended its bourgeoisie audience due to its critique on moral sensibility and public morality in the upper-class society. Wilde, irrefutably, includes many stereotypical conventions and

In the essay Achievement of Desire, author Richard Rodriguez - English 110 - Paper

1795 words - 8 pages Jacob Kullot Literacy Narrative In the essay Achievement of Desire, author Richard Rodriguez, explains the struggles with the desire to learn. He believed that in order to receive a good education he had to be separated from the culture he lived in and the people he loved. In doing so, Rodriquez lost sight of the big picture and the true meaning behind education. Education is supposed teach you new knowledge and give you a stable, balanced life

Dr. Faustus and the power of greed and pride - brit lit to 1603 - essay

1047 words - 5 pages Tyler Morrissette, Brit lit final paper, 12/04/18 Dr. Faustus and the uncontrollable power of greed and pride Many people believe that the main sin of doctor faustus is lust. They believe that his lust and sexual desires for women was so bad it's what got him to sign his soul to the devil. However, I am going to push back on that and say that marlow was not talking about lust but pride and greediness. More specifically humanities greedy nature

Prufrock and Other Observations been regarded as marking a radical break from poetic tradition? - English Lit - Research

2392 words - 10 pages Inferno. It is about a male’s torment in hell and is the only part of the poem that offers a sensation of warmth while the rest of the poem is cold and has a detached tone. In an essay written by Emanuel S. Shaw for the Atlanta University titled ‘Tradition and Revolt in the poetry of T. S. Eliot,’ he talks about how Eliot has used the ‘whole of living literature’ (1961) to convey his attitude toward the culture of his time. He was not using the

Similar Papers

Romeo And Juliet Gender Conventions Fadf Essay

543 words - 3 pages Essay Question: In what way do Romeo and Juliet break gender conventions? How do these roles fluctuate throughout the play? In the play “Romeo and Juliet”, Shakespeare uses characters Romeo and Juliet to break gender conventions. During the Elizabethan period, men were expected to defend their honour while women were expected to be loyal to their family and were believed to be incapable of logical thinking. Romeo is obsessed with love and this

Vampires: The Ever Changing Face Of Fear And Desire English 1500 06 Essay

1708 words - 7 pages Deliah Pemberton Professor Weaver English 1500-06 04/30/2019 Vampires: The Everchanging Face of Fear and Desire Vampires have been around since the 18th century in folklore, widely reported from Eastern Europe. These tales formed the basis if the vampire’s that later spread its way into Germany and England where it was subsequently embellished and popularized. Since then, it seems as though the world has not lost a brink of interest. In fact, as

Poetic Genre Conventions, Techniques And Idiom. Tcd Literature Essay

1425 words - 6 pages Write an essay analysing three contrasting examples of one poetic genre, paying close attention to conventions, techniques and idiom. The Ballad is a poetic genre usually used to convey a particular narrative. It is one of the oldest poetic forms in English poetry, originating in the medieval times. However, a revival of the form occurred during the 19th century which is also known as the “romantic period”. A poet would consider this form of

Literacy Narrative Pertaining To My Personal Experience With Words And Spelling English 1010 Essay

1386 words - 6 pages Fugal Fugal Halle Fugal Mr. Williams UVU 1010-A4: Literacy Narrative 6 September 2018 Forever Impenetrable The stage light shone so brightly in my eyes that I couldn’t tell how many fourth, fifth, and sixth graders I was standing in front of. I tried to remain calm, though I knew my turn was approaching. I had made it through every round successfully, leaving it down to only two contestants: Caden Cole and myself. This was my second year