Natural Crime Versus Legal Crime Essay

1402 words - 6 pages

Natural Crime versus Legal CrimeLaw, what is it and where does it come from? There are many types of law ranging from natural law, constitutional law, criminal law, civil law, common law and positive law. Obviously there are many laws in place today that could be subcategorized under any of the aforementioned types of law. Most of the laws in America originated from common law. Common law was and is part of the English legal system. Although most of our laws originated from common law, the supreme law of the land is the United States Constitution. In America, the law mostly comes from four sources. These four sources are administrative law, common law (which includes case law) statutes and ...view middle of the document...

Thomas Hobbes an English philosopher defined a natural law as "a precept of general rule found out by reason, by which a man is forbidden to do that which is destructive of his life" (Philosophy of law).
Positive law is considered to be man-made law, meaning, law established or duly enacted by a popularly elected government. Positive law is declared official, adopted or passed by an official or person vested with the authority by a government to stipulate the regulations of a given community. In America positive laws come in a wide range for both state and federal governments. These include judicial orders, legislative enactments, administrative regulations and executive decrees. In short, a positive law is any law that came to be via a written bill of the government.
My interpretation of the lawThe previously mentioned types of law i.e. natural law and positive law give us natural crimes and legal crimes. Where an act is classified a crime could originate from one of the two mentioned types of law, a natural crime (obviously stemming from natural law) and a legal crime (being classified as such) from a positive law. As I see it, natural law and positive law work hand-in-hand. That is, the relationship between the two types of law is that natural law is used as a guide for positive law, making positive law “usually” based upon an assumption of natural law.
With that being said, how do we decide whether a particular action is right or wrong? How would we classify a behavior as wrong and call it a crime, if all acts that are inherently wrong already fall under natural law? Since natural law is that which is fundamental to man and can be discovered by, “human reason, intuition, or inspiration…” Schmalleger (1999, p. 16) and positive law (to my understanding) is supposedly based upon human reason, intuition and or inspiration then it supports my belief that positive law is based upon a deduction of natural law. And that leads to the creation of new, refined laws, since society is always changing. In every society natural laws (what is considered an inherently evil act) will very, if just to a small degree). This makes the clarification and classification of these laws vitally important since natural law will not only be used to classify certain acts as criminal, but also influence (at least in our society) positive law.
Crimes, labeled as such by lawVarious laws create crimes out of actions that I have classified as follows. Murder (with a few exceptions such as self defense) would be considered a natural crime since it is an innately evil act. Rape would be considered another one as well as Robbery. I would classify almost any crime that injures, harms, physically violates another human being as a natural crime.
A few examples of positive laws may be some of the newer Aviation laws. The Aviation laws in the United States are laws that, “govern aircraft operations and the maintaining of aircraft facilities. Statutes...

Other Essays On Natural Crime Versus Legal Crime

Police And Crime Reduction Essay

1471 words - 6 pages crime patterns allows many benefits to exist for both criminal justice officials and society as a whole. Anticipating crime trends will ensure proper preparation, adequate staff, and specialized training. Becoming a proactive versus reactive policing organization will also yield these benefits. Generally speaking, if public safety personnel know what's coming they will be better prepared to properly handle the situation.Determining how and where

Criminal Justice System Essay

1288 words - 6 pages justice.Given the huge discrepancy between the day to day living conditions of many blacks versus whites, you might say the crime statistics go with the territory, or more accurately, the neighborhood. If you are poor, uneducated, unemployed and also happen to be black, hope is just another four letter word that has no meaning for you and, without it you do anything you can to survive. When your hanging around the hood month after month with nothing to do

1960s Social Studies

1464 words - 6 pages IntroductionWe may never know what actually happened to John F. Kennedy. Since his assassination there have been numerous conspiracy theories published, laying blame from the C.I.A. to organized crime. The majority of which have spent countless hours collecting data and researching, although none are more than speculation. Official Federal investigations have left more questions than answers. The Warren Commission has concluded that Lee Harvey

To What Extent Does Psychological Profiling Assist Criminal Investigations And Avoid Miscarriages Of Justice?

2895 words - 12 pages , N. (2008) 'Offender Profiling in Comparative Perspective', in Offender Profiling in the Courtroom: The Use and Abuse of Expert Witness Testimony, Portsmouth: Greenwood Publishing Group.Eysenck, H. (1964) Crime and Personality. London: Routledge.Meehl, P. (1954) Clinical versus statistical prediction: A theoretical analysis and a review of the evidence.Muller, D. (2000) 'Criminal Profiling Real Science or Just Wishful Thinking?', Homicide Studies

Canadian Legal System- Restorative Justice

2228 words - 9 pages Restorative JusticeAssignment 7ABy: Karyn White12/22/2008Submitted to: Robert TuckerFor the Course in CriminologyA discussion of the use of Restorative Justice Programs and their role in the Canadian Justice System. In discussing the effectiveness of Restorative Justice Programs as a method of reducing crime and the possibility of re-offence it is important to take note of the fact the crime rates in Canada are much higher than they were

Potential Threat: The New OAS Concept Of Hemispheric Security

2133 words - 9 pages of the region's armed forces to intervene politically under authoritarian regimes or during periods of armed conflict or social instability2. The US "War on Drugs" which encourages a greater role for the region's militaries in domestic law enforcement.3. The inability of most of the region's police forces to respond effectively to growing crime and violence.4. The US "War on Terror" particularly in expansive and nebulous definition of terrorism

Euthanasia

497 words - 2 pages June 3, 2004EuthanasiaIn "A Crime Of compassion", Barbara Huttmann writes about the moving story of an expert on the euthanasia. She tried to convince the readers with taking the law into her own hand as nurse. I disagree with Barbara, but I can not ignore that she did well in her essay to persuade the readers. Her description is very detailed and very effective.Huttmann begins the essay by describing how she encounters hostile reaction from the

How Has The Law Developed On Intention?

1829 words - 8 pages serious crime has been committed if someone actually gets killed, than if the bullet hits a pot plant. For a more detailed discussion, see subjective and objective culpability.This term can be translated as `blameworthy act'; it is used to denote the event on which a criminal offence is based. In many cases the actus reus will be an explicit act (theft, assault, etc). In others it will be a prohibited state of affairs (e.g., having an offensive

Illegal Immigration

630 words - 3 pages Have you ever wondered about how safe our country really is? If immigrants can elude capture from the border patrol, what is stopping terrorists from doing the same? I believe that illegal immigration has a very bad effect on our country, and not just because of our border problems.In the next few paragraphs I am going to talk to you about the cons of illegal immigration. I will cover topic such as how the current legal U.S. Citizens experiences

What Is A Juvenile Delequient

833 words - 4 pages 595 Words Specific Question: "Laws holding parents responsible for their children's crimes would not result in serious injustice." Purpose: To persuade parents to be more cognizant of their impact on their children's lives.Audience: My parents, my class, potential lawmakers, and myself.Central Idea: A child receives its his moral values through his its parents and if these values are wrong, should we not hold the parents responsible in a crime

Characteristics Of Common Law

1237 words - 5 pages decisions made by independent courts.At the heart of Hong Kong's system of government lies the principle that no one, including the Chief Executive, can do an act which would otherwise constitute a legal wrong or affect a person's liberty unless he can point to a legal justification for that action. If he cannot do so, the affected person can resort to a court which may rule that the act is invalid and of no legal effect. Compensation may be

Similar Papers

Legal Crime Essay

2056 words - 9 pages Reporting crimeCitizens have discretion regarding whether to report a crime, assuming the police are not present, which is often the case. There are numerous factors which impact upon whether a citizen, victim or not, reports a crime to police.Example: sexual assaults are offences which are under reported, as are domestic violence related offences.A person should consider the many reasons why crimes are reported and not reported. There is a fear of

Is The Relationship Between Drugs And Crime A Causal One?

2322 words - 10 pages are 'drug users [who] seek illegal funds to pay for their drug use' (Bennet, T. 2005, p.11). This seems on the face of it to be the most natural connection between drug use and crime as many drug users behaviour changes dramatically after using drugs and once one has become addicted it can be the case the careers and other parts of their life can fall apart somewhat. However, there are many other ways that drug use can be the cause of crime

Motivation Essay

358 words - 2 pages . On the other hand, law enforcement personnel are faced with the assessment of a criminal act. Even though a motive does not have any legal functions, it may still assist in excluding some suspects. Thus, establishing the motive during the investigation of a crime has several benefits. Benefits include limiting the suspect pool by giving law enforcement personnel a focus in their work and setting priorities (Turvey 2002). To summarize, "motive is an important factor in pointing to possible suspects in a homicide" (Osterburg & Ward 2000: 383). If motive is disregarded altogether, the search for a suspect or suspects might be compromised.

What Are The Major Difficulties Associated With Theorising White Collar Crimes?

1971 words - 8 pages -collar crime under his definition that included activities that were not, at the time, certified by criminal law but which, being violations of civil or administrative law were punishable by law (Croall, 1992). Some scholars have argued that the misbehaviours considered by Sutherland or his adherents do not always satisfy the legal criterion for crime, Tappan (1947) goes so far as to insist on the requirement for penal conviction at court