This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Normal Case Study. About A Used Car Deal Gone Bad. Canadian Law Courts

770 words - 4 pages

What area of contract law did you choose?Corporate and commercial - Illegal contractsWhich court is the case in?Alberta Queen's BenchIs it a trial decision or appeal?It is a trial decision.What are the facts about the case? (Provide an accurate summary)The plaintiff, Mr. McCardell purchased a used Mercedes Benz from an individual who used his corporation as a front. When the plaintiff was negotiating the purchase of the car, he thought that the defendant, Aldo Tisi owned the vehicle. Aldo Tisi is the director and sole shareholder of the corporate defendant, Tisi Holdings Co. Inc. The plaintiff drove the car for about 2 months and then he found out that the car was not in mint condition and that the mileage was incorrect. He stopped driving the car when he found out and sued for rescission. He also found out that the defendant was not a licensed automotive dealer and that this was not the only car the ...view middle of the document...

The reason is because the defendant was found to be running a retail automotive business that did not have a license. Since the contract was illegal rescission was allowed to be granted. The corporate veil had to be lifted even though there is acknowledgment that the corporation is a separate and legal entity because it would be unfair to the plaintiff to award judgement only against the corporate defendant alone.What relief did the plaintiff or appellant want from the court?He wanted the whole transaction set aside. Meaning he wanted a judgement which would allow for him to return the Mercedes Benz to the defendant and recover the money he paid for the car. Basically the plaintiff is looking for rescission and restitution (and not damages)What relief did the defendant or respondent want from the court?None, just to find that the contract was legal and that rescission could not be given to the plaintiff.What relief did the parties get from the judge?The judge was in favour of the plaintiff on all counts. The judge declared that the contract between the parties is rescinded. The defendant shall return the plaintiff's money and the plaintiff shall return the Mercedes to the defendants. Also an extra $350 was awarded for work done on the car during the brief ownership by the plaintiff.Does the case make new law or did the judge apply existing law to the facts in the case?The judge applied existing laws. He used the Licensing of Trades and Business Act as a reference for the case.If the case makes new law, explain what that is.The case did not make a new law.What did the judge decide on costs?The judge decided that the contract was illegal therefore it was rescinded. The plaintiff was awarded the $17,900 for the purchase of the car and also an additional $350 for work that was done during the brief ownership period. The car had to be returned to the defendant. Even though Mr. Tisi used his corporation as a front, the corporate veil had to be lifted because the corporation was found to be mere agent of a controlling corporator.

Other Essays On Normal Case Study. About A Used Car Deal Gone Bad. Canadian Law Courts

A Report On Case Study Analysis

2151 words - 9 pages This case study report is requested by Dr xxx, the lecture of managing communications technology in xxx University . The case study comes from course study guide of managing communications technology (2008). This report is due on 05th of May, 2008.1.2Company backgroundTwo companies, Gretham Young (GY) and Jameson Business Systems (JBS) formalized their relationship and became a new company which is named Gretham Jameson Consulting (GJC). The new

LS Group (A) Case Study Solutions

1128 words - 5 pages LS Group Case(a) For LS Group, what specific reasons were presented to justify the ERP implementation project? Did these reasons warrant an ERP implementation project?Reasons:1) LSG currently uses an information system, which is outdated and slow. Furthermore, it is not compatible which makes communication impossible. Hence, transmitting data is time consuming and required a lot of manpower as the staff was required to reenter data into each

Krispy Krème Doughnuts. A Harvard Business School Finance Case Study

734 words - 3 pages Krispy Krème DoughnutsObjective:To develop an investment recommendation for Krispy Krème Doughnuts and conclude whether they should go ahead with their on going expansion strategy or not.To achieve this objective, historical financial statements will have to be analyzed and an assessment of the future financial health of the firm be made.Based on the case, it is evident that Krispy Krème Doughnuts opened to the public with a

Destination Image: Image Problem Of Turkey As A Case Study

7342 words - 30 pages study, Sirakaya, Shephard, and McLelland (1998) demonstrated the likely effects of perceptual changes-regarding the safety and security issues-on potential travellers' destination choices. Their study showed that new information about potential safety, security, and health problems at a destination can lead to the elimination of the destination from the list of alternatives.Similarly, political conditions within and around Turkey may be responsible

Critical Thinking And Decision Making. Let It Pour: A Critical Thinking Case Study

1375 words - 6 pages ensure that the changes are working appropriately and that all parties involved are following them and to address any issues that were raised during the problem-solving actions.When addressing the first major concern contained within the case study, the hospital needs to have the staff follow and uphold company policy. The organization has implemented rules, regulations, a mission statement, and various other policies to protect employees and

Communication Case Study Analysis: There's A Syringe In My Pepsi Can! - MKT438

1797 words - 8 pages Effective communication between an organization and its publics is key component of crisis management. Organizations must see the importance of releasing the right information to both internal and external publics to minimize negative publicity and negative public reaction. In today's marketplace organizations have to make a concerted effort to manage a crisis situation or inevitably the media will. A crisis such as the Pepsi Case Study: There's

Case Study Essay - Stem cell Research : Students were asked to read and respond to a controversial issue raised by advances in modern biological sciences

555 words - 3 pages , and even to repair brain cells. Because of their research with stem cells they have gone along way from biotechnology and stepped into the modern world of medicine. This research will give hope not only to people with Parkinson's and their careers, but to many others with long term non-curable diseases and illnesses. This makes me think about my father, he is a hard working man, and unfortunately has diabetes, and has had it for many years. He

Examine The Controversy That Surrounds The Question Of What Judges Are Doing When They Are Deciding Cases

3717 words - 15 pages ) as giving voice to his own moral or political convictions, or even to those convictions which he believes the legislature or the majority of the electorate would approve. The judge would see himself 'as an author in the chain of common law'. As Dworkin put it 'He knows that other judges have decided cases that, although not exactly like his case, deal with related problems; he must think of their decisions as part of a long story he must

Financial Distress Prediction Using Z-Score

5279 words - 22 pages bankruptcy is economically disastrous for both stakeholders and owners of business entities, which needs a law that governs the whole process. Dealing with insolvent estates for legal procedures dates back to ancient Roman law. The principles of insolvency got extensive codification during the middle ages, and then the study of insolvency prediction evolved. Smith and Winakor did the first study in 1935, during the Great Depression era, then in 1942

Should Cell Phones Be Ban From Driving Or Do Away With?

1451 words - 6 pages as a phone call is an even bigger burden to bear,"{f}. In a Canadian study, it was stated that " the risk of a collision when using a cellular telephone was four times higher than the risk when a cellular telephone was not being used"{f} according to Bryan Knowles.Unfortunately, in all the research it has yet to be proven that cell phones are the main cause for car accidents. According to Bryan Knowles "no U.S. studies have proven that cell phones

CULTURAL DIVERSITY IN CONFLICT RESOLUTION

7751 words - 32 pages local or tribal custom sets the standard of behaviour and provides for conciliation and dispute settlement as is the case of Afghnistan.The justification for the legal system is therfore perceived in broader terms than mere utility as illustrated by the Canadian Constitution Act 1982 which begins by stating that 'Canada is founded upon principles that recognize the supremacy of God and the rule of law.' Therefore in such a society the legal

Similar Papers

International Trade Law Case Study

1972 words - 8 pages Civil Aviation Legislation Amendment (1999) Montreal Convention and Other Measures Bill 2008. The bill was passed into law under the new Act; a more modern set of rules for air carrier's liability contained in the Montreal Convention of 1999 came into effect for Australia on 24 January 2009. Based on Schedule 1A of The 1999 Montreal Convention Article 1, this convention applies to all international carriage of persons, baggage, or cargo

A Case Study Analysis

1524 words - 7 pages ZAP!!, A Case Study AnalysisZAP!! needs to be zapped. ZAP!! has a problem that will not go away. ZAP!! management has implemented a new manufacturing quality control system and would like full employee participation. However, not all employees (assemblers) participate in the weekly quality control meetings and those who do are reluctant to address the issues or express their views. ZAP!! management does not want to terminate any of the

Precocious. A Short Story About Bad Communication And Father/Son Relationships"

3231 words - 13 pages doctrine related to something we've rarely experienced: bad behavior. This, put simply, is a system of colored cards ranging from yellow through red, with a few shades of orange that only a flamboyant interior designer would recognize, that are "pulled" in succession or in the extreme case of some dire transgression, the dreaded "red" card is pulled bypassing the usual stepped progression; a bad thing indeed. We prefer to, when Owen has the

Health South: A Case Study Of Business Ethics

1717 words - 7 pages professional services, of government and the courts, of law enforcement, religion, and anything it touches (Kusi, 2005).Sarbanes-Oxley ActHealthSouth's fraudulent activity put them in the company of industry giants like Freddie Mac, Enron, WorldCom and Sunbeam. According to the Economist magazine, "in 2001 approximately 250 cases of revenue overstatement occurred" (Hutton, 2005, p.354). The questionable accounting practices included:aggressive accounting