Essay On Obedience To Authority

1393 words - 6 pages

Obedience to Authority To what degree of obedience are we to push our sense of morality? It is a known fact that obeying authority is crucial to our society; it is the very essence of it that brings about structure and order. However, there are times we have to question whether we should obey when our morals are suppressed to an extent. Every order followed and every action taken always has an impact on the individual, depending on the magnitude of said order. Throughout history, we have seen men of high authority subjugate men who are lesser to do horrendous acts. Being under a higher authority gives a sense of vulnerability, making compliance inevitable. It was a little over seventy-seven years ago that we see this exact situation take place, the Holocaust. The example of the concentration camp shows the very odd cycle of social pressure and avoiding responsibility. The Nazi people who took part in killing all of these people were not all evil or sadistic, but they were manipulated by "mass mind" and were obeying orders of someone higher in command, similar to the results of Milgrim's experiment. Even though they might have personal conflicts with their actions, the social pressure overcame their objections. This is significant because authority and social pressures are one of the most hazardous mixtures there are. The entirety of society has been programmed into a social structure that is harmonious with authority. This common ideology is making individuals blindly obey authority, even when such obedience is clearly unnecessary and despicable.

In "Perils in Obedience," Stanley Milgram studied the concepts of social forces and influences of obedience. Although some people might consider Stanley Milgram's experiments to have been seen as controversial and unethical, his work brought much attention to different behavioral tendencies among people, whose influence is both fascinating and disturbing. The data that was recorded was to make people aware so that people can get a better idea of the different reactions present and possibly change them. Milgram makes the subjects think they are shocking individuals in a chair if they get wrong answers to questions. The results showed the participants actually conformed to the higher authority by going against their own morality. Milgram stated that "group pressure need merely be inserted into a social situation on one side of a standard or the other in order to induce movement in the desired direction" (Milgram, 133). Milgram would have never thought that the participants would administer that high of a shock; they suppressed their morality to comply with the authority.

In Milgram's experiment, the authority figures kept pushing the participants; Milgram states that they "continued to shock an unresponsive and possibly dying "learner" up to the maximum 450 volts " (Haslam et al, 14). Milgram's experiment clearly illustrates that power influences authority and social pressure, the more power ...

More like Essay On Obedience To Authority

Social Psychology Essay

1270 words - 6 pages ... authority, often violating many ethical principles and basic human rights in the process. Today there are ethical guidelines that researchers are meant to abide by to get their study approved as an 'ethical study' (APA, 2010). Through an analysis of two famous but controversial studies that were considered highly unethical, Milgram's (1963) obedience study and Zimbardo's (1969) Stanford Prison Experiment, we can weigh up the risks to human ...

Summary Of Milgram's Behavioral Study Of Obedience - Humboldt State University Psychology 240 - Essay

480 words - 2 pages ... Article Summary 1: Milgram’s Behavioral Study of Obedience Brandon Rodriguez Running head: ARTICLE SUMMARY 1 1 ARTICLE SUMMARY 1 4 Humboldt State University Article Summary 1: Milgram’s Behavioral Study of Obedience Obedience is defined as the tendencies of individuals to submit to authority figures and their requests (Milgram, 1963). In a study of obedience, Milgram (1963) hypothesized only a minority of the participants would go to the end ...

Conformity & Obedience - Essay

1762 words - 8 pages ... not question commands given to us by someone of more senior authority. Obedience demonstrates how we are expected to blindly follow the orders we are given, even if we know them to be immoral, incorrect and unjustified (Hofling, Brotzman, Dalrymple, Graves & Pierce, 1966). It is expected in both types of social influence, that the request which has been put forward will be followed through by the individual. A final similarity between the two ...

Example Essay On Conformity And Obedience

1721 words - 7 pages ... presence of others. One of the things social psychology investigates is social influences. Social influence can lead to several different outcomes, two of them being conformity and obedience. Obedience is a very direct social influence. It involves following the instructions given by a figure of authority. Conformity is an example of social influences acting in a much less direct manner. It is an alteration of an individual's behaviour and opinions due ...

Essay On Comparative Critique

1249 words - 5 pages ... Stanley Milgram and Philip G. Zimbardo both address instances in which the hierarchy between authorities and subjects is clearly defined in an experimental setting. In Stanley Milgram's article "The Perils of Obedience," the experimenter researched the effect of authority in relation to obedience. The experiment involved a teacher and a learner, in which the learner would receive shocks if he/she failed to memorize a series of words (Milgram 78 ...

Milgram Obedience Reaction Report - Glenbard Highschool Psychology - Essay

884 words - 4 pages ... allowed Milgram to perform this study were immutably preposterous. I believed that there was short-term suffering that happened to the subjects, such as the sweating, cognitive dissonance, and other negative symptoms that the test-subjects expressed. I also believed that there were some long-term consequences of the study. These long-term consequences were constituted by their obedience to authority at the cost of another’s pain. Overall, I was ...

Social Influence - Psychology - Revision Notes

6723 words - 27 pages ... that the proximity of the authority figure also had an effect on levels of obedience. When the experimenter gave orders over the phone, more participants felt confident enough to defy the experimenter, therefore obedience levels dropped to 21%. Location: In the location variation of the study, the experiment was in a run-down office in Bridgeport. Obedience levels dropped slightly to 48%. Several participants reported that the location of the study ...

Analysis Of Fayol's 14 Principles

2536 words - 11 pages ... are in today's business world.2. Four Principles to Illustrate the Relevancy Today2.1 Authority"Authority is the right to give orders and to exact obedience."As defined by Fayol, the "principle of authority and responsibility is apparently connected to the importance of authority initiated by the managers. The organization is driven by the commands of managers, and runs based on the work that is carried out by workers in obedience to that commands ...

Being, Belonging, Doing And Becoming, And Self-efficacy, Motivation Etc. In Occupations - Human Mind And Behaviour - Essay

3199 words - 13 pages ... , despite these actions being uncharacteristic of my morals and values, ethics are challenged (Burger, 2018). The theoretical underpinnings of this concept stem from social psychologist Stanley Milgram’s investigation into obedience to people of authority, following his interest in the immense obedience people had to Adolf Hitler during the Holocaust. This experiment involved participants unknowingly being studied on their willingness to obey ...

Leaders In The Bible

1757 words - 8 pages ... to do because even though a leader has authority, there is still always someone above them, they need to have obedience. The same goes when God calls a leader, the leader needs to be obedient to God and to give Him their all. Another strength Ruth had was diligence. Ruth's faithfulness was noticeable. Several times throughout the story of Ruth, her character was praised by Boaz. She was persistent when she went into Boaz's field and began to ...

Feudalism In Medieval Europe

788 words - 4 pages ... relationships amongst the ranks of landowners and tenants depicted through Count William and Hugh's conflicts between each other. A relationship between a lord and vassal seemed to be very much hierarchy based in that the Lord held authority over the vassal. Count William knew he could take advantage of his vassal Hugh because of his rank that was created by the feudal system. Even though Hugh had an important city and had a number of ...

The Story Of Martin Luther - History's Most Important Reformer

787 words - 4 pages ... THE STORY OF MARTIN LUTHER"Hier stehe. Ich kann nicht anders."The moment Martin Luther said those words has been one of the greatest moments in the modern history of man. Refusing to admit guilt for what had repeatedly published over the prior four years, Luther, a German monk, was directly challenging the authority of Western Christendom and the man believed by Catholics to be the human representative of God on Earth: the Pop, more specifically ...

Rule Of Law And What Are Its Benefits And Defects

2674 words - 11 pages ... citizens and government officials. This is all apart of the doctrine of parliamentary sovereignty whereby laws are intended to represent everyone's perspectives, voted upon by the democratically-elected parliament. But judiciary precedents are necessary where lawmakers have overlooked particular cases. Ekins and Raz, conjure the concept that the judiciary should not have the final legal authority - obedience to parliament-made laws is fundamental to ...

Theme For The Lord Of The Flies - 10th Grade Lit And Comp - Novel Study

1188 words - 5 pages ... friend called Piggy” (Golding 202). He realized that the evil authority of Jack truly influenced his group and drove them to do these horrific acts. A situation similar to Jack and his boys was shown in the Milgram experiment on obedience in 1963. The results shocked the whole world and the results were recorded as, “65% of participants shocked all the way” (Milgram Experiment). A majority of the participants shocked all the way and this shows ...

Stanley Milgram And Zimbardo Experiments - Social Work 204 Slu - Discussion Question

662 words - 3 pages ... Stanley Milgram conducted the obedience study in the early 1960s. It closely related to the conformity research because it showed how far people were willing to go to obey authority figures. He was a graduate assistant at Yale and considered his mentor his most important scientific influence even though Milgram’s research went far beyond his mentor’s. Milgram recruited white and blue collar workers at random to participate in his study. They ...