Odysseus/Penelope's Song Comparison Baruch College English 2800 Essay

796 words - 4 pages

Penelope: Then and Now
In the Odyssey written by Homer, Odysseus is away from his home Ithaca, his wife Penelope and his son Telemachus for 17 years. In Homer’s poem, Penelope was portrayed as the loyal and devoted wife patiently awaiting the return of her husband and cunningly wards off suitors that pursue her hand in marriage and Odysseus’ land. In the poem Penelope’s Song written by Louise Gluck, Penelope is portrayed somewhat differently. This essay will analyze the portrayal of the same character in the two works.
In Gluck’s poem, Penelope does not represent the perfect wife that is portrayed in Homer’s epic poem. In the Odyssey, Homer does not go into detail of Penelope’s feelings toward Odysseus during his long absence; the reader does not know what emotions she may be experiencing. Gluck, on the other hand, gives Penelope an emotional voice as evidenced by the following lines:
You must shake the boughs of the tree
To get his attention,
But carefully, carefully, lest
His beautiful face be marred
By too many falling needles.
In Gluck’s poem, Penelope is feeling hurt for the extended time Odysseus has abandoned her. In the passage above, it would seem she is fantasizing, perhaps just a little, about falling needles hurting her husband as retribution for her pain. In this way we can see from Penelope’s perspective and connect with her pain. This is a very different trait than the one in the Odyssey where Penelope is portrayed as a stoic character. In addition, Gluck’s version of Penelope also appears to be confessional, as if she her true feelings are finally being expressed after being pent up for some time.
In Homer’s poem, Penelope is the embodiment of the loyal and devoted wife. She endures the long absence of her Odysseus and remains faithful to him even without knowing whether he is alive or dead. Gluck’s rendition, on the other hand, hints of Penelope’s infidelity: You have not been completely / Perfect either; with your troublesome body / You have done things you shouldn’t / Discuss in poems. Conspicuously, Gluck does not specifying what Penelope has done during Odysseus’ travels but we can safely presume she has bedded one (or more) of the suitors albeit it may not be public knowledge. Perhaps Penelope suspects or assumes Odysseus may have done the same...

Other Essays On Odysseus/Penelope's Song Comparison - Baruch College - English 2800 - Essay

Causation Essay Identity Theft is Real - College English - essay

514 words - 3 pages Mason Grover Mrs. Pidgeon Dual Credit College English October 5, 2019 Causal Analysis Essay Beep! Beep! The hollow drone of an angry alarm clock rips through your subconscious.  Startled, you jolt upright and rush half dressed, to the office. Still groggy, you slide your card into the reader and a red light flashes, barring entry.  Confused, but not wanting go to the boss to call attention to your tardy, you tap the glass of the breakroom to

college tution, in this essay i argue why college tution should be free - English I/ Northampton community college - Essay

1429 words - 6 pages Dean-Tuggle1 Maiya Dean-Tuggle Professor. Supinski English I April, 2018 Why students should get Free College Tuition In today’s society secondary education could mean the difference between poverty and living comfortably. There is such a large number of people who don’t go to college to get the extra education because they don’t have the money to pay for it. A large amount of people in the U.S skip going to college and getting a degree because

College Essay- Write an essay to send to your desired college - Berkner High School, English 3 - Essay

523 words - 3 pages College Essay  5th pd English 3, Kayla Hundley    I possess a common vision. I constantly work to explore the limits of nature by  exceeding expectations. Long an amateur scientist, it was this drive that brought me to  the University of Texas for its Student Science Training Program in 2013. Up to that point  science had been my private past time, one I had yet to explore on anyone else’s terms.  My time at , however, changed that

McEwan and Plath’s Comparison Essay - Stockley Academy - English Literature A-Level - Essay

2968 words - 12 pages voices was presented in contemporary literature and that Plath after over thirty years still represented the unconventional voices of female dissent. An examination of Plath’s most acclaimed poems will form the basis of the contention that Plath although often socially constrained, wrote outside the conventions of her time. A comparison with the 2002 novel of Ian McEwan, On Chesil Beach which also claims to represent the role of the female in the late

english essay what i can do for matter - bennett college - essay

423 words - 2 pages Zamira Flucas Bennet College 11/29/18 Dr. Roberts Brain storming ideas for my English essay the topics I would like to concreate on will be the following topics listed above · Class room size…. I think I should speak on how in the public-school system seems to have a tendency on making classroom sizes to large. Speak on how it makes it difficult for teacher to teach along with keep up with each student in the class. Also, Zamira you need to

Definition Essay about what home feels like to me - English/Comm College - Essay

1073 words - 5 pages Samantha Adamson Professor Christine Gallo English 101-27 September 19, 2018 Defining Home Most of us can say we have heard the quote “home is where the heart is,” but everyone's heart is in a different spot. What home means to me is probably not what home means to you. Everyone does certain things to make their space a bit homier, whether that’s painting the walls, lighting a candle or arranging fresh flowers on the table. In the essay

Essay about jane eyre and comparison to other womens in book - brooklyn college - jane eyre

663 words - 3 pages Konstantyn Umanskyy English 102 Essay 1 Revision In the Jane Eyre by Charlotte Bronte shows that the character, Jane Eyre, becomes important that shows how she express British women and show how characters changes during the story progress. She is a smart, plain featured, honest young girl whose reaction to her situations brings more depth to her personality. At the beginning, Jane has an emotion for pride and the idea of freedom, along with her

Song Analysis in Song of Solomon - Columbia College - Essay

1780 words - 8 pages The Function of One Piece of Music: Song of Solomon As one African American writer, Toni Morrison applies African culture in her writings as other black writers do. She talks about important issues in African American society by connecting folktales, myths and cultural beliefs with various characters as well as incorporating African folk in her stories. As a kind of representation of traditional black art, music records history, culture and

The Benefits of Marijuana Legalization - Washtenaw Community College English 111 - Essay

1757 words - 8 pages Omar 0 Aseel Omar Mark B. Owen English 111 13 April 2018 The Benefits of Marijuana Legalization Marijuana, also known as cannabis, was brought to the New World by the Spanish in the year 1545. Marijuana has till this day, various uses. From the day it was brought to the United States, marijuana was used to produce hemp; a replacement for cotton. During this era, cannabis was also used as certain medicines. By the year 1920, marijuana became an

The Internet’s Effect On our Minds (Nicholas Carr) - Rowan College at Burington County/ English 101 - Essay

721 words - 3 pages 3 English 101 14 February 2018 The Internet’s Effect On our Minds Technology has grown to become a major part of our everyday lives. In his essay, “Is Google making us stupid?”, Nicholas Carr argues that although the internet is providing us with many benefits, it is negatively changing the way we think. I agree with most of Carr’s views because I have found them to be true in my own life; however, I think that some of the changes our brains are

Temple Essay for College Acceptance - English - Essay

1220 words - 5 pages life. During study halls, if there were problems that were occuring, I would jump in and help out as best as I can. I also did many volunteering work, helping around the school. This also helped me in my academics, as I would often speak up and ask for help if I am struggling. I believe that this skill is an absolute necessity. Self advocacy is one of the most important skills you need to learn when you are out on your own, especially in college

Similar Papers

The Taming Of The Shrew Play Within A Play Baruch College / English Essay

855 words - 4 pages Cherry on top of the cake It doesn’t really matter what genre author is going to present to audience, what really matters is setting up a proper mood for the reader. It might be some critical final moment or some totally out of context situation – in both cases intro atmosphere is what can create or demolish further experience in any reading, this is what makes a story believable. Shakespeare was aware of this trick and perfectly used induction

Comparison Between Beowulf And Odysseus Honors English Iii Essay

945 words - 4 pages Honors English III March 7th, 2019 Fatal Flaws in Ancient Heroes In ancient monomyth, a hero is the exemplified ideal of the society and culture, someone people of the time would look up to as being perfect. However, despite their strength, knowledge, bravery and other inhuman abilities, most heroes (if not all) have fatal flaws within themselves that leads to significant consequences. For example in Odyssey and Beowulf, both heroes need to pay

Popul Vuh And Old Testament Flood Comparison Essay West Los Angeles College/English 203 Essay

1488 words - 6 pages create life. They have to make humans before sunrise. The gods seem to be less powerful than a divine being should be. The comparison between the “Popul Vuh” and Adam and Eve is very similar. In “A Maiden’s Story” a girl named Xquic, who was the daughter of a lord of the underworld attempts to consume fruit from an odd tree. A skull spits in her hand and gets her pregnant before she can reach the fruit. The skull belonged to Hunapu, an ancient

2018 Chevy Silverado Vs 2018 Ford F 150 College English Comparison Paper

729 words - 3 pages 2018 Chevy Silverado 1500 vs 2018 Ford F-150 1 When people think of trucks what do you think of? What is the first brand that comes to mind when they think of trucks? Is it Chevy, Ford, or maybe some other company? Chevy and Ford dominate when it comes to the truck market; Chevy with the Silverado 1500 and Ford with the F-150. Some people choose their truck strictly because it is their preferred brand. With the Chevy Silverado 1500 and the