Oedipalisation And The Patriarchy Sociology Essay

1526 words - 7 pages

Explain Freud’s theory of Oedipalisation. Does this explain patriarchy?
Sexuality and sexual desire are not typically associated with children, however Sigmund Freud, who was one of the great minds of the late 19th and early 20th century put forward many theories and ideas that still have some relevance in today’s societies, one of these theories was that he believed that sexuality was not learnt behaviour it was, however, innate behaviour that everyone was born with. Although many of the theories that Freud proposed have become outdated for today’s society the underlying ideas can still have relevance in explaining phenomena that are happening in modern society. Freud puts forward the theory of the Oedipus complex; which suggests that children develop a feeling of attraction towards a parent. The name coming from the Greek myth of Oedipus Rex. This essay explores Freud’s theory of Oedipalisation and the Oedipus complex and whether this theory can be used to explain patriarchy. Patriarchal societies will be explored and whether there is still a need for their relevance today as men are still often regarded as the more powerful gender.
The Oedipus complex is a psychoanalytic theory that was proposed by Sigmund Freud and is derived from the Greek myth of Oedipus Rex. The idea that a child could kill their father and then marry their mother, albeit unknowingly, has created an attractive prose for many writers and has been used by Freud to explain and explore the theory that children can hold feelings of attraction towards a parent of the opposite sex[footnoteRef:1]. This can also come with a sense of rivalry with the parent of the same sex. Freud believes this is a crucial and also a normal stage of developmental process for a child. This desire is repressed however, from a person’s conscious thought through socialisation. Socialisation and the pressure of conforming to societies norms can have an effect on how people tend to behave. Many people repress and internalize many of their desires which may have an adverse effect on their life in the later years. Freud believes that these repressed desires are buried in the unconscious because these desires break with social norms and would label the person, if these desires were acted upon, a deviant[footnoteRef:2]. [1: Sheleff, “Beyond the Oedipus complex: A perspective on the myth and reality of generational conflict”, 1976] [2: Craib, Psychoanalysis; a critical introduction, 22]
Freud’s belief around humanity was that all humans had two main desires that were an important factor in how people lived. These two desires that Freud uses to explain humanity are: Eros, which is believed to be the desire to bring about creativity, self-preservation, harmony, sexual connection, reproduction and harmony; and Thanatos, which is viewed as the opposing desire of destruction, self-destruction, anger, repetition, and impulse[footnoteRef:3]. The desire of Eros shows that this allows for a belief that sexuality can be behaviour that people are born with rather than a behaviour that has been learnt. Although sexuality and sexual desire is often believed to be developed during adolescence it is Freud’s belief that sexuality is an innate part of human existence and occurs during infancy. This theory of innate sexuality would thus allow for the Oedipus theory to be able to gain traction and be thought of as accurate. [3: Freud, Civilization and its Discontents, Page:35]
There is a strong theme of male dominated societies all throughout the world, with many monarchies being clearly male dominated throughout history and even in many democratic societies within the western world men still hold the power. It can be seen throughout many societies over the last 1000 years that a form of hierarchy is used to form cohesive communities. Within many of these societies, the hierarchical system is a system in which men hold the most power. This is formally known as a patriarchal system where the power of society or government are held with men and women are largely excluded. Although in this modern day and age women are becoming a larger part in governing societies they are still being viewed as the lesser gender in terms of power. The notion of the patriarchy has been instilled into the very fabric of society as women are still only just gaining rights that men have enjoyed for centuries. It was only in 2009 in America, women were able to file a complaint in regards to unequal pay discrepancies based on their gender, with many women being paid less than their male counterpart even though they are carrying out the same work. For centuries men have held the power in many societies based on their gender. Patriarchy has become an institutionalised part of the world and has become a part of how different social relations work together[footnoteRef:4] [4: Witz. Professions and patriarchy. Page 1]
Many of Freud’s theories can be seen as a sexist view on matters of the world and have been heavily criticised by feminists, however his thinking can be attributed very heavily to the time in which he lived and studied. His view of women and his belief that women are the less superior gender helps to cultivate the idea that Freud’s theory would be able to explain patriarchy.
The Oedipus complex that it presented by Freud can be used to help explaining the idea of patriarchy because Freud’s Oedipus model suggests that since women lack the visible genitals of the male, they feel as though they are missing a central characteristic thus feeling as though they are not as adequate as their male counterparts. The Oedipus complex theory further explains that this causes the female child to distance herself away from the mother because the mother was the one that formed her and therefore she was the reason she had no penis which was unforgivable in Freud’s eyes because now the female child was at a disadvantage[footnoteRef:5]. The idea that female children feel inadequate to their male counterparts at such a young age because of their lack of male genitalia instils the idea that they will never be able to live up to their male counterparts. This then can be used to explain patriarchy as Freud theorises that female children as young as 3-5 years of age experience this feeling of inadequacies[footnoteRef:6]. However, many feminist theorists disagree with the notion that girls have “penis envy” and that girls stray away from a relationship with their mother. A particular theorist, Karen Horney, disputes the claim that the lack of male genitalia in women is the reason why women feel as though they have less power and instead she holds the culture of society responsible for the subordinate status that women have[footnoteRef:7]. Simone de Beauvoir, another feminist theorist, believes that it is not due to the fact that women lack male genitalia that is the cause for envy from women but it is because of the social power and privilege men enjoy because of their gender and genitalia[footnoteRef:8]. [5: Freud, New Introductory Lectures on Psychoanalysis.] [6: Kendra, “Freud’s perspective on women,” Very well mind, https://www.verywellmind.com/how-sigmund-freud-viewed-women-2795859] [7: Zakin, “psychoanalytic theory” ] [8: Ibid.]
This essay explores the ideas presented by Sigmund Freud that surround the Oedipus complex and uses these ideas to help explain Patriarchy. I believe that the theory can help to explain patriarchy when you’re talking about the theory as it being entirely factual and that this is how children behave in regards to sexuality and attraction towards their parents. However, I do not believe that as a female child they develop “penis envy” and believe that males are superior to them because they have different genitalia therefore patriarchy cannot be explained in this respect. As with many other feminist theorists, I believe that “penis envy” lacks insight into the workings of the female mind. In my experience my envy towards men does not come from the fact that I was born with female genitalia but rather it comes from the notion that women have to work twice as hard as men to get to the same position. The essay covers how Freud theorises the Oedipus complex and how this theory, if considered to be true, can be related to patriarchy that is seen in modern day society. In conclusion, I do not believe that the Oedipus complex can be related to patriarchy in terms of male privilege.
By Sharla King
Word Count: 1374
Bibliography
Cherry, K. “Freud’s perspective on women.” Very well mind. Accessed: Mar. 21, 2018.
https://www.verywellmind.com/how-sigmund-freud-viewed-women-2795859
Craib, I. Psychoanalysis: A Critical Introduction. Cambridge: Polity Press, 2001
Freeman, T. Psychoanalytic concepts of fatherhood: Patriarchal paradoxes and the presence of an absent authority. Studies in gender and Sexuality, 9:2, 113-139 DOI: 10.1080/15240650801935156
Freud, S. Beyond the Pleasure Principle. London: WW Norton, 1989
Freud, S. Civilisation and its Discontents. London: Hogarth Press, 1930
Freud, S. New Introductory Lectures on Psychoanalysis. New York: Norton. (Translated by W.J.H. Sprott); 1933
Sheleff, L.S. Beyond the Oedipus complex: A perspective on the myth and reality
of generational conflict. Kluwer Academic publishers. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00158478
Witz, A. Professions and patriarchy. London: Routledge, 1992
Zakin, Emily, "Psychoanalytic Feminism", The Stanford Encyclopedia of
Philosophy (Summer 2011 Edition), Edward N. Zalta (ed.), URL = .
Word count: 130
Total word count including bibliography: 1504

RELATED

The Myth of Medusa: Matriarchy vs. Patriarchy - Power of Myth and Symbol - Essay

1316 words - 6 pages the overall plot or that she is an extension of the patriarchal power. Joplin describes Goddess of Wisdom’s role: “[Athene] is no real female but sprang, motherless, from her father’s head, as enfleshed fantasy. (…) Athene is like the murderous angel in Virginia Woolf’s house, a male fantasy of what a woman ought to be, who strangles the real woman writer’s voice.” (Joplin in Higgins and Silver, 2013: 51). This showcases the need for the patriarchy

The End of Stigma: Anthropology, Psychology and Sociology - Anthropology, Psychology and Sociology - Essay

2142 words - 9 pages Free people, especially children. Sociology is a topic that could really explain how much stigma really affects people with mental health conditions/disorders. In conclusion, there are many negative standpoints on the issue of mental health conditions. However, there are people who are changing and are venturing to end stigma. As a society we need to become stronger and change our point of view in order to move forward and achieve greatness. We must be

Liberation From Sexism and Patriarchy in The Color Purple - Caesar Rodney High School, Adv. lit 11 - Essay

1826 words - 8 pages Free Hammond Mary Hammond Advanced Literature 11 Ms. Tuke 16 March 2018 Liberation From Sexism and Patriarchy in The Color Purple From the earliest of civilized societies, both, men and women have had separated roles in society. Oftentimes it is the man who is placed as the head of the household, leader of a community, or ruler of a nation. In relation, women are often given the household duties, such as, raising and educating children, cooking

Socialization and Agent of Socialization - Sociology - Essay

673 words - 3 pages Free to achieving societal goals. Conflict tries to explain that various changes in the society lead to negative impacts in the society. Socialization is part of human beings’ way of getting to know how to live and survive in the society, through acquiring knowledge and skills. Despite inequality that is usually a barrier, people still should interact and get to learn and understand each other for a better society. References: Mayer, P. (2004). Socialization: the approach from social anthropology. London: Routledge. Rosenberg, M. M. (1983). An Introduction to sociology. Toronto: Methuen.

The Gender Wage Gap in the past and present - Ryerson University, Sociology - Research essay

2493 words - 10 pages gap is known as the “Motherhood Penalty”. According to sociology, the gender wage gap and the “motherhood penalty” can be viewed from 3 seperate perspectives, the Functionalist Perspective, the Conflict Perspective, and the Feminist Perspective. The Functionalist Perspective believes that in increasing industrialized societies, women are viewed to focus on “expressive” tasks such as child care while men focus on more “industrialized” jobs which

Identity, What is the identity how and whats creating it - Sociology - Essay

1007 words - 5 pages changing is the social status. They are being citizens of different countries, have their own culture, however according to BBC (Identity 2016: 'Global citizenship' rising), there are more people describing themselves as ‘Global citizens’ than it was in 2001. Due to the rise of freedom of speech, people nowadays seem to be more open talking about their own identities and are less frightened of discrimination. In this essay I would like to discuss

Social Biography - Sociology - Primary and Secondary Factors - Uni, Sociology - Essay assignment

1420 words - 6 pages 1 SOCS 100: Introduction to Sociology Assignment 1: Critical Analysis (Social Biography) Rupa Pun (S00263292) Tutor: Ms. Nicole Stirling Word Count: 1046 Date: 22 March 2019 Social Biography This social biography is about John, the youngest son in a family of seven. The report will provide a glimpse of how he has learned to adapt and function in society through socialisation in which John’s beliefs, attitudes, values and behaviour is influenced

sociology essay, Media and cultures - newman college - essay

2516 words - 11 pages in different ways. Furthermore, media is being criticised for increasing the chances of crimes and violence in society. On, an Introduction to Sociology, Browne. K, Polity Press (2011) states "an example of this is when 2 years old child James Bulger was murdered by two teenage boys aged 11, the judge in this case has stated that the exposure for this part of violence in the society maybe a part in the films". This shows how world around young

Sociology is the study of human interaction - Assignment school - Essay

1636 words - 7 pages Sociology is the study of human interaction. It focuses on life, change, causes and consequences of human behaviour (Cornell University of Sociology, 2008). In relation to health, sociology is responsible for acquiring quantitative data that resulted from social surveys, epidemiological and comparative studies (Health Knowledge, 2011). This stands for possible influences of the society and human processes and interaction in determining health

Whose Interest does Schooling Serve and Why? - UOW Sociology 101 - Essay

890 words - 4 pages SOC101 Essay 2: Use your sociological imagination to answer the question 'whose interests does schooling serve and why?' In this essay I will use my sociological imagination (Mills, 1959) to look at “whose interests does schooling serve and why?” My focus will be on schooling in Australia’s early years; how and why schooling came about; its intended purpose and who benefits from schooling. Australia’s first school was established in 1789 shortly

Sociology Essay: Gender Discrimination In The Business World - The Glass Ceiling

2535 words - 11 pages ; Lee 2012, Mandel 2012, McDonald & Kmec 2010). The essay looks into some recent sociological issues on the role of women and the hardships they have to overcome due to gender bias which in turn restricts them from achieving the same status-quo as men. Research also shows however that women face various obstacles at different stages of the organizational hierarchy in order to reach top managerial positions and what they have to do in order to

Global Culture and the Politics of Poverty - Sociology 101 - Research Paper

996 words - 4 pages subculture. Although it could be perceived as a counter culture with their unusual and seemingly violent practices, once you break it down, one can then see that there is no harm to any person involved, and in fact, a community has emerged. The purpose in this essay is to expose the elements that make up this subculture. The best way to begin the explanation of the idea of body modification is to acknowledge that like many things, it is on a

Opinion essay on the death penalty - Madera High School/Sociology - Essay

585 words - 3 pages Free Death Penalty Essay The death penalty is a very questionable punishment in many states across the U.S. Thirty-one of the fifty states officially have the death penalty, and nineteen without. Four of the states with death penalty have death penalty with gubernatorial moratoria. This is when the state governor can change a death sentence to life in prison, instead. In my opinion, I am for the death penalty because I believe it is sometimes

What does it mean to be alienated? - Sociology and Theory - Essay

1694 words - 7 pages Sociology 200; Theory and Society Nadia Badsha, 774707570 Sociology 200; Theory and Society Nadia Badsha, 774707570 What does it mean to be alienated? Karl Marx, influenced by the Hegelians, explicitly describes alienation as “Entfremdung”[footnoteRef:1], a type of human estrangement. Alienation is said to separate an individual from their humanity; a consequence afflicted through the conditions of Capitalism. The capitalist production process

Does the TV show '16 and pregnant' promote teen pregnancy? - luzerne county community college and sociology - research paper

768 words - 4 pages Running head: Does the tv show’16 and pregnant’ promote teen pregnancy Does the tv show’16 and pregnant’ promote teen pregnancy Erdman 5 Does the tv show 16 and pregnant promote teen pregnancy Lori Wetzel Kaitlyn Erdman Sociology 101 Citation Dockterman, Eliana, Time, Jan. 13, 2014 Rodrigues Kaelyn, Medium, December 11, 2017 (n.a.) Secure Teen, Feb. 12, 2014 Abstract The tv show 16 and pregnant promotes and discourages teen pregnancy. Teenage