This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Opposition To War In Leningrad Cemetary And Dulce Et Decorum Est

1736 words - 7 pages

In her poem "Leningrad Cemetery, Winter of 1941", Sharon Olds very frankly and very succinctly states her opinions on war, fighting, and the so-called "lust of the eye". She goes about this in such a manner that it is at once pleasing and eye opening to the reader. Wilfred Owens "Dulce et Decorum Est" deals with this same topic, with much the same feeling, but goes about it in more gruesome and personal way. Through both of these poems, the reader is shown that there is no beauty in war, when examined closely. To make their points, both authors use harsh diction, vivid imagery, a mournful tone, and gripping line breaks.The words used by Olds tell us as much about her views as does the poem ...view middle of the document...

This is very powerful; in that it gives the reader excited anticipation, and makes them want to continue. These are all very similar to the methods used by Olds to convey her message. One tool used by Owen more than Olds, though, is that of the particularly gruesome details. Owen uses the phrases "gargling from the froth-corrupted lungs"(22), "obscene as cancer, bitter as cud"(23), and "vile incurable sores on innocent tongues" to again portray war as the sickening entity that it is. Like Olds, he uses very detailed and personal images to combat Gray's idea of the sublime.While the reader is not given a glorious and heroic picture to lust over, it is, nonetheless, given a clear and vivid picture to gaze upon. Olds' poem uses very vivid imagery to give the reader a grim view of this bleak and sorrowful scene. Images of corpses "wrapped in dark cloth" (6) as they await the afterlife fly through ones mind as the mountains of dead that "could not be buried" (1) make themselves as clear as reality. These brave men, many of whom fought seeking the picture given of the lust of the eye, now have not even the dignity of being buried, but instead are left in some sort of limbo, without the finality of a funeral. Wanting life, wanting even life with the "bread made of glue and sawdust", wanting to return to the war that killed them. This grim picture gives the reader a very clear view of Olds' feelings on the atrocities of war.The imagery of "Dulce et Decorum Est" is also extremely vivid and graphic. Very early on the reader is painted a picture not wholly unlike that of "Leningrad Cemetery", dead strewn about without regard. The soldiers portrayed as weak "old beggars"(1) "coughing like hags"(2). This vision, however, soon strays from the path of "Leningrad Cemetery" and grows very active, frantic, and more disturbing. As the yelling of the man caught by gas comes tearing trough the "hoots"(7) of mortars the visual picture becomes far grimmer. Everything is seen through a "thick green light as under a green sea"(13,14); helping to portray the feeling of drowning as toxic gas fills the once clean air. This grave portrait of death is a perfect antithesis to the "lust of the eye".These atrocities are also very clearly shown through the tone used in the poem. While reading "Leningrad Cemetery", one cannot help but feel the sorrow and angst felt by the dying becoming the dead, and the living becoming the dying. It all feels very surreal, and often Olds uses different items to evoke these feelings. The "child's sled" (4) for example really brings a sense of reality and loss of innocence to the poem, helping to bring out that surreal tone, the realization that soldiers are people, and that they aren't the only casualties of war. Women, children, and civilians lay in wait of their next life right next to those who had, in one way or another, chosen their fates. Another item that adds to that same overall tone of surrealism is the "ball of roots" (7). A ball of...

Other Essays On Opposition To War In Leningrad Cemetary And Dulce Et Decorum Est

Portrayal of masculinity in Adventures of Huckleberry Finn and The Red Badge of Courage - Fractured Identities: American Literature from the Civil War to World War II - Essay

1594 words - 7 pages Marthe Tanghe GL/EN 3472 Fractured Identities: American Literature from the Civil War to World War II Portrayal of masculinity in ​Adventures of Huckleberry Finn ​and ​The Red Badge of Courage​: Two opposite sides of the spectrum. The representation of gender in literature has been studied in depth in the last half a century. We seem heavily engrossed in how gender portrayal can mean so many thing in novels; it can reveal plot points, character

Why were the Arabs unable to defeat Israel in the war of 1948-9, 1956 and 1967?

458 words - 2 pages . They were disorganized and had no coordination. Arab armies weren't prepared well enough against Israeli forces. They weren't trained well or didn't have good equipment to fight. Arab states had underestimated Israeli forces and the fact that Israelis had more experience in war gave them an advantage. Jewish soldiers were well disciplined in comparison to the Arab soldiers and had more experience than the Arabs because of their experience in world

Assess the reliability and usefulness of the documentary 'Prelude to War,' in determining the failure of the League of Nations

532 words - 3 pages The documentary, Prelude to War, is unreliable but is useful to an extent in explaining one of the core failures of the League of Nations. Its reliability is detracted due to its narrow view, blatant bias and propaganda evident in the production of this film. However, this bias demonstrates the prejudice mindset of the American people at the time and could be a useful explanation for America's refusal to join the League, which was one of its key

List and explain 3 causes to the Great War?

268 words - 2 pages List and explain 3 Causes of the Great War? Some of any causes to a war happen with time. One of the causes of the Great War was Nationalism. Nationalism was a tension created in the world by imperialism, which was strongly linked to nationalism. Many people in each nation of Europe felt themselves to be superior to the peoples of other nations. This convinced leaders of various nations that their country had the right to rule territory beyond

Revolutionary War and War of 1812 - University of Hawaii - US History to 1877 - History Paper

1485 words - 6 pages The Revolutionary War and The War of 1812 The Revolutionary War and the War of 1812 were no easy feats for the United States. In both conflicts they faced an enemy that was far superior to them in almost every aspect. Victory was not straightforward, and at times did not seem attainable, but undeterred, Americans kept on fighting. Hardships were abundant after the Revolutionary War, yet through perseverance and democracy, those too would

Conflict Essay - To Kill a Mockingbird and Prelude to War - Magdalene, year 11 - Essay

855 words - 4 pages Conflict Essay “An individual’s perception of conflict is intrinsically linked to their core values and beliefs!”  To what extent is this view represented in the texts studied? Refer to To Kill a Mockingbird, Prelude to War and one related text. Through an individual’s perspective and central principles, it is an essential component for the insight of conflict. This is extensively engrained in the texts To Kill a Mockingbird, Prelude to War and

Comparative of How British and German Soldiers Were Viewed in Society Post World War I: Physical and Psychological Traumas - Lawrence Academy, History - War & Gender

2286 words - 10 pages not tell with such high zest to children ardent for some desperate glory, the old Lie: Dulce et decorum est pro patria mori.”[footnoteRef:1] Owens depiction of World War One, which lies in his poetry, illustrates the horrors of the war front. The phrase “Dulce et decorum est pro patria mori” means that it is sweet and seemly to die for one’s country. Owens refers to this saying as an “old lie” because it was simply not the case. Life in the

God of Carnage: War as a Constant in Society - Quincy College, Intro to Theater - Analysis

958 words - 4 pages God of Carnage Social Change or Meaningless Chaos? When we talk about theater for social change, topics like race, sexism, war, homophobia, and other hot-button social issues are the themes that dominate our conscience. Those topics are the sorts of things that we associate with social change- the sorts of issues that dominate our political rhetoric and dinner table banter. But it would be wrong to limit the definition of theater for social

1.) For What Reason Did President Truman Decide To Use Atomic Weapons To End The War In The Pacific?

557 words - 3 pages Truman used the atomic bomb to shortening the war in thePacific and to save the lives of Americans and to keepAmerican public opinion positive. Truman's defense inusing atomic weapons was that it protected and savedthousands of American lives and money that would havehad to been used to fight the war.I disagree with President Truman's reasoning in droppingan atomic weapon. I feel that Truman could have useddifferent tactics to get the Japanese

Historical transition from Feudalism to the modern day - Humber/War and Terrorism - Essay

513 words - 3 pages . A lot of new and important discoveries were found during this period. Scientists found new theories and new rules were developed. This event made people know more about the world and the place they live in. Q: Provide a detailed comparison of the theories offered by Fukuyama, Barber, and Hungtington. In your view do any of these theories provide a useful lens through which to understand political violence in the Post-Cold War era? Why or why

War On Drugs- Analyzing the transnational war on drugs in the US and Mexico - chs 245 - Essay

1112 words - 5 pages forced to participate in the drug trafficking business. The very own Mexican government has been linked to certain drug trafficking trades. In 1971, U.S. president Richard Nixon declared a war on drugs due to the rising levels of drug addiction. Nixon imposed penalties for offenders on the illegal drug use, distribution and trade. Nixon declared a combat war alongside the Mexican- U.S. border in order to cease any illegal drug importations. The

Similar Papers

The Portrayal Of War In Dulce Et Decorum Est & Charge Of The Light Brigade

2372 words - 10 pages Tennyson's Charge f The Light Brigade and Owen's Dulce Et Decorum Est both explore warfare. However they each have significant differences. Charge Of The Light Brigade was written in the 18th Century and is about the Crimean War. It explains, in a very majestic manner, that fighting in a war is something every soldier should be extremely proud of. Sacrifices have to be made and bravery is an absolute necessity. Tennyson ignores the darkness and

Beach Burial And Dulce Et Decorum Est Cidhs Essay

1203 words - 5 pages 1. In ‘Dulce et Decorum Est’, why were the soldiers fumbling with their helmets? · War usually is a bloody series of battles between 2 or more factions. Usually it is between tribes or countries. In Dulce et Decorum, Wilfred Owen describes war as being deadly, very bloody and disgusting where soldiers are innocently killed, ripped apart and treated like beggars without hope and they are very smelly. However, in wars countries generally tell the

Analysis: Wilfred Owen’s “Dulce Et Decorum Est” University Of Phoenix Lit/330 Essay

1239 words - 5 pages during World War I. During this time of discourse, change, and war, the romanticism and ethereal qualities of previous literary periods were replaced with works that used more realistic language and imagery to comment on world events and the truth of a growing disconnect between society and the individual. “Dulce et Decorum Est” uses blunt and gruesome images to describe conditions faced by soldiers fighting in WWI and is one of a number of poems

In The Tragedy Of Romeo And Juliet Was The Opposition Of Arranged Marriages Fair? Western High School Essay

524 words - 3 pages arranged for Juliet to be his bride in a certain time by asking not Juliet but Capulet. Though the article, “Arranged Marriages (Looking Through the Cultural Mirror).” by Dr. Jefferson M. Fish argues for arranged marriages and explains the reasons behind them and their success. Arranged Marriages are actually good because they last longer, parents know best for their children, and that they teach couples how to love. In many instances arranged