Opposition To War In Leningrad Cemetary And Dulce Et Decorum Est

1736 words - 7 pages

In her poem "Leningrad Cemetery, Winter of 1941", Sharon Olds very frankly and very succinctly states her opinions on war, fighting, and the so-called "lust of the eye". She goes about this in such a manner that it is at once pleasing and eye opening to the reader. Wilfred Owens "Dulce et Decorum Est" deals with this same topic, with much the same feeling, but goes about it in more gruesome and personal way. Through both of these poems, the reader is shown that there is no beauty in war, when examined closely. To make their points, both authors use harsh diction, vivid imagery, a mournful tone, and gripping line breaks.The words used by Olds tell us as much about her views as does the poem ...view middle of the document...

This is very powerful; in that it gives the reader excited anticipation, and makes them want to continue. These are all very similar to the methods used by Olds to convey her message. One tool used by Owen more than Olds, though, is that of the particularly gruesome details. Owen uses the phrases "gargling from the froth-corrupted lungs"(22), "obscene as cancer, bitter as cud"(23), and "vile incurable sores on innocent tongues" to again portray war as the sickening entity that it is. Like Olds, he uses very detailed and personal images to combat Gray's idea of the sublime.While the reader is not given a glorious and heroic picture to lust over, it is, nonetheless, given a clear and vivid picture to gaze upon. Olds' poem uses very vivid imagery to give the reader a grim view of this bleak and sorrowful scene. Images of corpses "wrapped in dark cloth" (6) as they await the afterlife fly through ones mind as the mountains of dead that "could not be buried" (1) make themselves as clear as reality. These brave men, many of whom fought seeking the picture given of the lust of the eye, now have not even the dignity of being buried, but instead are left in some sort of limbo, without the finality of a funeral. Wanting life, wanting even life with the "bread made of glue and sawdust", wanting to return to the war that killed them. This grim picture gives the reader a very clear view of Olds' feelings on the atrocities of war.The imagery of "Dulce et Decorum Est" is also extremely vivid and graphic. Very early on the reader is painted a picture not wholly unlike that of "Leningrad Cemetery", dead strewn about without regard. The soldiers portrayed as weak "old beggars"(1) "coughing like hags"(2). This vision, however, soon strays from the path of "Leningrad Cemetery" and grows very active, frantic, and more disturbing. As the yelling of the man caught by gas comes tearing trough the "hoots"(7) of mortars the visual picture becomes far grimmer. Everything is seen through a "thick green light as under a green sea"(13,14); helping to portray the feeling of drowning as toxic gas fills the once clean air. This grave portrait of death is a perfect antithesis to the "lust of the eye".These atrocities are also very clearly shown through the tone used in the poem. While reading "Leningrad Cemetery", one cannot help but feel the sorrow and angst felt by the dying becoming the dead, and the living becoming the dying. It all feels very surreal, and often Olds uses different items to evoke these feelings. The "child's sled" (4) for example really brings a sense of reality and loss of innocence to the poem, helping to bring out that surreal tone, the realization that soldiers are people, and that they aren't the only casualties of war. Women, children, and civilians lay in wait of their next life right next to those who had, in one way or another, chosen their fates. Another item that adds to that same overall tone of surrealism is the "ball of roots" (7). A ball of...

Other Essays On Opposition To War In Leningrad Cemetary And Dulce Et Decorum Est

1.) For What Reason Did President Truman Decide To Use Atomic Weapons To End The War In The Pacific?

557 words - 3 pages Truman used the atomic bomb to shortening the war in thePacific and to save the lives of Americans and to keepAmerican public opinion positive. Truman's defense inusing atomic weapons was that it protected and savedthousands of American lives and money that would havehad to been used to fight the war.I disagree with President Truman's reasoning in droppingan atomic weapon. I feel that Truman could have useddifferent tactics to get the Japanese

Assess The Significance Of The Battle Of Britain In Turning The Tide Of War Against Germany In The Period To The End Of 1942

1501 words - 7 pages The Battle of Britain can be seen as a significant turning point in the war against Germany as they are unsuccessful in their bid to capture the British Isles. However, it can also be said that this battle's only real importance was the fact that Britain survived the attack, as the Allies were unable to retake Europe and defeat Germany at this point. Yet before the Battle of Britain Germany is the only victorious side.When war was declared in

Were The Promises And Agreements Made Between The Arabs, French, And British During The First World War Which Led To The Formation Of The Middle East Compatible?

2355 words - 10 pages societies who on proclamation of a Holy war, by the Sharif of Mecca, would disaffect, and form a mighty appendage to the allied forces against the Ottomans .Both premises were wrong. McMahon could not grant Hussein the unconditional independence of the Arab countries; in fact, he was indisposed to grant anything, "McMahon, an experienced bureaucrat had seen the need to be completely noncommittal". It was quite evident to McMahon that concessions would

Nathan Bedford Forrest. This biography tells about his involvement in the Civil War, KKK, and other important information

328 words - 2 pages traded them before becoming a wealthy man as a cotton planter in Mississippi. When the war broke loose he raised a cavalry unit and being a lieutenant himself he lead them in defending Fort Donelson in Tennessee. He felt that working with other Confederate troops was pointless so he moved his troops out of the fort, just before Fort Donelson was surrendered. He led his troops in the Battle of Shiloh and was very successful so he was promoted to

Outline And Evaluate In To The Duration, Capacity And Encoding Of Information In Short Term Memory

531 words - 3 pages Assignments 12- outline and evaluate in to the duration, capacity and encoding of information in short term memoryCapacity refers to the amount of information that can be held at any one time in memory. The Capacity of STM is limited and to demonstrate the capacity of STM, the serial digit span technique is used. The study was proposed by Jacobs where experiment needed the participants to read lists of either words/numbers that they had to

Theories In Spectatorship Regarding Asian American Stereotypes In Cinema Paying Particular Attention To Harold And Kumar Go To White Castle

2190 words - 9 pages Waiting for the MomentPeople in cultures across the world congregate to local film theaters and purchase their tickets for the new popular film that everyone has been raving about. For two hours, strangers sit amongst each other in their seats with their eyes fixed upon the big screen all sharing the same feature. While the audience is equally presented with the same motion picture, each leaves with his or her own unique experience of the

The Ash Garden, By Dennis Bock Is A Moving Portrait Of Two Lives, Damaged And Changed By The War, It Is A Haunting Mediation On The Uses Of Memory And Its Power To Both Condemn And Redeem

1943 words - 8 pages emotional unstableness due to the death of her family caused by the bomb. Anton Böll, a scientist who was with the United States military during World War II everyday has to battle the memories, horrors and terrifying scenes that he had seen in Hiroshima with his research after the bomb dropped. The Ash Garden, by Dennis Bock is a moving portrait of two lives, damaged and changed by the war, it is a haunting mediation on the uses of memory and its

Space Ship One: Scaled Composites Venture To Win The X Prize And To Put Civilians In Space

4113 words - 17 pages ABSTRACTTitle:Scaled Composites is an aerospace innovation and development company located in the Mojave desert of California. Headed by Burt Rutan, Scaled Composites set out to become the first privatized company to obtain manned sub-orbital flight and to win the Ansari X Prize of $10 Million. To successfully win the X Prize, Scaled Composites developed two new and innovative aircraft known as White Knight and SpaceShipOne. White Knight, the

Responses Of Australian Ectothermic And Endothermic Organisms To Changes In Ambient Temperature

699 words - 3 pages Red Kangaroo: Macropus RufusThe Kangaroo is an endotherm. Endotherms generate heat from their body's metabolism. So their internal body temperature is independent of the external temperature. Endotherms eat more food than ectotherms. This higher food intake results in an increased level of metabolism, which is required to produce heat.The Red Kangaroo inhabits inland plains throughout Australia. They prefer open plains where trees and bushes are

Examine The Presentation Of Aziz And Fielding In Part I Of "A Passage To India"

1244 words - 5 pages One of the main themes Forster is concerned with in this novel is friendship, and the presentation of the relationship between Aziz and Fielding is the main way he explores this. This friendship is the corner stone to much of what happens, and it is clear he sees this cross-racial relationship as the way forward - in Part I it seems that if there is any hope in the novel it will come through them. Also, the relationship between the two men gives

This Essay Is About Trusting Oneself And How To Build Confidence In A Person

596 words - 3 pages Sometimes, from the outside looking in, all you can say is that the situation is complex, there's no nice, easy, safe way out, all you can do is play the cards you have and hope the dealer turns up something nice on the river. Like I said, it's invigorating to be in the throws of emotion, it's life affirming, it is the risk we take by not being hermits hiding in the shadows woeful over our forlornness. You can only love by cracking open your rib

Similar Papers

The Portrayal Of War In Dulce Et Decorum Est & Charge Of The Light Brigade

2372 words - 10 pages Tennyson's Charge f The Light Brigade and Owen's Dulce Et Decorum Est both explore warfare. However they each have significant differences. Charge Of The Light Brigade was written in the 18th Century and is about the Crimean War. It explains, in a very majestic manner, that fighting in a war is something every soldier should be extremely proud of. Sacrifices have to be made and bravery is an absolute necessity. Tennyson ignores the darkness and

Why Were The Arabs Unable To Defeat Israel In The War Of 1948 9, 1956 And 1967?

458 words - 2 pages . They were disorganized and had no coordination. Arab armies weren't prepared well enough against Israeli forces. They weren't trained well or didn't have good equipment to fight. Arab states had underestimated Israeli forces and the fact that Israelis had more experience in war gave them an advantage. Jewish soldiers were well disciplined in comparison to the Arab soldiers and had more experience than the Arabs because of their experience in world

Assess The Reliability And Usefulness Of The Documentary 'prelude To War,' In Determining The Failure Of The League Of Nations

532 words - 3 pages The documentary, Prelude to War, is unreliable but is useful to an extent in explaining one of the core failures of the League of Nations. Its reliability is detracted due to its narrow view, blatant bias and propaganda evident in the production of this film. However, this bias demonstrates the prejudice mindset of the American people at the time and could be a useful explanation for America's refusal to join the League, which was one of its key

List And Explain 3 Causes To The Great War?

268 words - 2 pages List and explain 3 Causes of the Great War? Some of any causes to a war happen with time. One of the causes of the Great War was Nationalism. Nationalism was a tension created in the world by imperialism, which was strongly linked to nationalism. Many people in each nation of Europe felt themselves to be superior to the peoples of other nations. This convinced leaders of various nations that their country had the right to rule territory beyond