Our Response To Mental Illness: Analysis Philosophy Of Psychology Essay

1677 words - 7 pages

As people with mental illness may be suffering either as a direct result of their illness or
indirectly through their difficulties in successfully integrating into society (Hart, 2017), it is
important that the institutional, societal and individual responses to these persons are critically
analyzed and evaluated to determine whether the goals of these responses are appropriate,
whether these responses are successful in working towards the goals, and more importantly, if
the goals, actions and reasonings can be justified on ethical grounds. In this essay I will be
exploring mental health through an ethical lens, in order to highlight significant issues that stem
from the influence that the current models for the classifications, diagnosis and treatments of
mental illnesses and psychiatric disorders have on how patients are perceived and addressed on a
societal, institutional, and individual level. I will begin by addressing the problematic
implications that arise from the biological implications and criterions, reinforced by ideas based
on the disease model and deterministic perspective, that serve as a foundation for classifying,
identifying and responding to mental illnesses and psychiatric disorders. I will then recapulitate
the importance of recognizing the respective capacity and limitations of an individual’s
autonomy and free will, and the ethical issues that reinforce a greater emphasis on the role,
influence and weight of individual autonomy in determining the appropriate direction to take
when addressing and treating a mental illness or disorder. This critical analysis of the role of
autonomy and free will in mental health reveals problematic issues of ethical concern regardless
of whether the concluding judgement made by clinicians recognize the person to be functioning
autonomously or that their autonomy is compromised. These issues make it necessary for a
reassessment of the clinician vs. patient relationship regarding whether or not a moral dimension
is just as necessary as an empirical one, when making judgements that hold great value in
determining an appropriate response to the individual patient’s needs. After exploring and
evaluating the impact that a moral dimension may have on a clinician’s ability to appropriately
respond to the patient, I will highlight proposed improvements based on ideas such as the
standpoint theory, sharing partial perspectives, the project of empathy and having goals like the
augmenting of free will.
One of the most concerning assumptions regarding psychiatric disorders are that they are
perceived to be a form of disease (Bentall, 1992). A popular approach towards the definition of
diseases, involves identifying a pathological process implicated in a disturbance of body or
behavior (Bentall, 1992). The disturbance of body or behavior can be translated into any
deviation from the norm that occurs due to some form of biological disadvantage. There are
issues of concerns regarding both parts of this...

Other Essays On our response to mental illness: analysis - philosophy of psychology - essay

Different Treatment in Mental Health - Psychology - Essay

2318 words - 10 pages 2 Jussara Tavares I Taunton Analyse the effectiveness of a range of treatments and therapies used to treat mental health disorders - 1933 This essay will demonstrate knowledge on the basis assumptions and effectiveness of treatments and therapies for psychological disorders and recognise key research in the study of treatments. Psychoanalysis therapies are based on the approach of Freud (cited in Saul McLeod, 2018), mental health illness and the

rhetorical analysis of our pictures - English - Essay

974 words - 4 pages successful. Jennifer almost fell off our laps! A “must have” for every concert I attend is to get my T-shirt! If you’re a T-shirt junkie like me, get your shirt right away and not the end of the concert. There have been many concerts that I have been to but this one was different. This was the first time we attended a concert with Eric and Jennifer. When looking at this photo, take note how happy our friends are. This was their first time seeing James

Psychology of Ancient Philosophers and a Hole in Aristotle's Argument on Psychology - Randolph-Macon College Philosophy - Essay

2157 words - 9 pages Psychology of Ancient Philosophers from Parmenides to Aristotle and a Hole in Aristotle’s Argument on Psychology Regarding Hypothetical Comatose Patients For thousands of years, philosophers have debated the relation between body and soul. The ancient philosophers built upon one another’s ideas, expressing multiple ideologies that still hold relevance in the debate on philosophical psychology to this day. The following essay will examine the

Philosophical analysis of "Being John Malkovich" - MCC Philosophy 101 - Essay

808 words - 4 pages Bryan Howard Professor Gillette Intro to Philosophy 7/12/18 A philosophical analysis of “Being John Malkovich” “Being John Malkovich” is certainly a unique film with a very interesting and unique plotline. It brings up a lot of questions about what it means to be someone else, what it means to be yourself and most importantly what it means to be John Malkovich. In the Movie a Puppeteer named Craig Schwartz finds a portal in an office building

Mental Disorders Portrayed On Television - Psychology - Research Paper, Analysis

940 words - 4 pages knew that she can live outside of her house, she decides to buy an RV and travels the states. Shameless shows that someone can get better through the right treatment if they have agoraphobia. All of these characters portray their mental disorders accurately. They also show some treatment options and the result of them. Shameless is able to depict these mental disorders realistically and without sugar coating it. References: American Psychological

Theme paper, Mental illness in literature - English III AP, Franklin High School - Essay

1492 words - 6 pages Paola Aguirre Ms. Mendoza English III AP 05/02/18 Mental illness in literature Mental illness is a difficult topic to talk about, the next novels illustrate the problem of seeing and recognizing mental illness, and address the issue of which words we use to talk about mental illness. This, is the central theme in “The Waste Land” by T.S. Eliot, “The Yellow Wallpaper” by Charlotte Perkins and “A rose for Emily” by William Faulkner. The texts

Critically evaluate the evidence for a link between life events and illness. - Health Psychology - Essay

1179 words - 5 pages Stress and Health Exam question: Critically evaluate the evidence for a link between life events and illness. Stress was first defined by Hans Selye in 1936, where he described stress as “the non-specific response of the body to any demand for change”. There are different approaches to stress such as stress as a transaction, which focuses on the way an individual assesses a stressor and how this affects the way they would cope or respond to the

personality project on what our personality is - ap psychology - essay

1400 words - 6 pages Lau 1 Tammy Lau Mrs. Nelson AP Psychology, Period 4 30 March 2018 Personality Project In order to figure out our personalities and who we are as an individual, we use personality theories, such as psychodynamic and psychoanalytic, humanistic, trait, social-cognitive, and positive psychology, to determine it. Psychoanalytic and psychodynamic puts emphasis on our childhood memories and how our unconscious mind functions. Humanistic theories focus

"The Silence of Our Friends" analysis - u of m comp 327 - Essay

1337 words - 6 pages explains that it is the people who go on about their lives oblivious or willfully ignorant to racism and racial slurs that shove people of color down. The authors intended to use this specific racial slur to portray White racism without any restraints and tell it like it is. Using such language evokes an uncomfortable response from readers—it challenges our views and makes us think that if we address our history, so much of today’s ignorance could

A Response To "Of Studies" - An Essay By Sir Francis Bacon

545 words - 3 pages The topic of the essay 'Of Studies' by Sir Francis Bacon is clearly visible in the title itself. The main theme of the essay is to explain the use of studies as they serve for delight - in privateness and retiring, - in discourse, and for ability - in the judgment and disposition of business.The author, by means of this essay, stresses the importance of studies in life. He supports the notion that study is an immensely important aspect of life

The Book of Ecclesiastes: Judaism’s Answer to Existentialism - Philosophy 210 - Essay

984 words - 4 pages most important “why are we here”. The meaning of existence is a question humans will always ask. It is important for daily life because it gives purpose and direction. This question is even possibly the catalyst for the creation of religion and philosophy. Therefore, as all the largest religions have, Judaism also gives its own answer to this question. In the Torah is the book Ecclesiastes, which contains wisdom that not only that gives reasons

Similar Papers

The Importance Of Environment In Mental Illness Psychology Essay

1209 words - 5 pages the different expectations surrounding a culture. Psychology and the question of nature vs nurture plays a crucial role in the large spectrum of mental illness. Overall it can be see that ones ‘nurture’ or experiences are the most crucial part in the development of a mental illness. Which shows that it is partially up to one’s own self and the other around them in ensuring one's own mental sanity. Reference list CDC, (2012) Attitude towards mental

Stigmatisation Of Mental Illness Psychology 100 Annotated Bibliography

941 words - 4 pages illness is positively associated with increased psychiatric treatment. This study is important to my argument as it highlights both positives and negatives associated with the biogenetic model. It also briefly addresses the idea of structural discrimination being positively influenced by the biogenetic model. Deacon, B. J. (2013). The biomedical model of mental disorder: A critical analysis of its validity, utility, and effects on psychotherapy

Evaluate The Contribution Of Interview Research To Our Understanding Of Friendship. Undergraduate Psychology Essay

1102 words - 5 pages Evaluate the contribution of interview research to our understanding of friendship. The use of interview has long been used by researchers to elicit information from questions in order to better understand a topic from that person's perspective. In relation to friendship, interviews are a very useful tool as it allows researchers to give rich detail on their thoughts and feelings in response to the question. Despite this, being based on

An Analysis Of The Free Will Problem Unt Philosophy Psychology

1506 words - 7 pages 6 An Analysis of the Free Will Problem, Creativity, and Contextualization There are many arguments for and against the notion of free will. For as long as humanity has been discussing the concept of the mind, so has the debate about choice and its foundation been under question. Do we as a society create our own paths or do we simply follow a predetermined set of functions, reactions, and ingrained social ques to result in the patterns and