Political Arguments And Analysing Competing Arguments That Are Compelling University Of Johannesburg,Year 1 Essay

865 words - 4 pages

INTRODUCTION TO POLITICAL STUDIES (POLS1007) Assignment One: Analysing Competing Arguments Due Monday the 4th of March. The maximum word count is 1,200 words
Assessment Guidelines
The main goal of your first assignment is to get you thinking and writing about how different types of political arguments are put together. What makes a compelling argument? On what basis can we effectively adjudicate between competing political positions? What types of supporting evidence are decisive? How do individual experiences and identities shape how people make their case? Your task is to select between one of two potential case studies (please don’t attempt both, or attempt to put together an alternative case study of your own). Once you have selected your case study, you will need to put together a 1,200 word report which comprises two major sections: i) analysis and ii) evaluation. Both sections should be clearly identified using subheadings. Your analysis section should ideally comprise around 1,000 words, and should offer your analysis of the strongest possible version of each of the arguments found in the five pieces comprising your case study. Your analysis section should not attempt to weight the strengths and weaknesses of each individual piece Your task is to instead present the strongest possible version of the argument, or arguments, developed by each individual author (regardless of whether or not you agree with the author). Where applicable, your analysis should also include material which makes reference to the supporting evidence used by each author. You will be primarily assessed on your capacity to sucessfully identity the main arguments which each author employs, and your capacity to present these arguments in the best possible light (i.e. don’t include language which undermines arguments you don’t personally agree with). It is recommended that you allocate roughly 200 words to each individual piece. There should be no need for you to conduct further research, or to track down additional sources. The five pieces which comprise each case study should be sufficient for this task. The evaluation section is your oppourtunity to both present and defend your own conclusions regarding which of the arguments you have analysed is the most persuasive. It is recommended that you allocate roughly 200 words to your evaluation, which should come at the end of the report (much like a conclusion). Your evaluation needs to be much more than a statement of personal opinion or preference. You instead need to be able to effectively justify
and defend why you regard one line of argument, or arguments, as more compelling or persausive. This may involve identify...


Summary of arguments made in federalist paper 10 - Political science 1 - arguments made by Madison in federalist paper 10?

630 words - 3 pages Free ways that the newly formed constitution can protect against this exact thing. He makes three main arguments about how the Constitution will form a large republic and, in turn, protect against the tyranny of the majority. His first argument is that if you have a large republic and you are electing people to rule the nation, then the more people you have then the less likely it is for corruption because these elected officials are accountable

Are there any arguments to be made that self-sufficiency is desirable? What would be the arguments of those who contend that trade in cultural relics should be strictly state-regulated?

395 words - 2 pages artifacts. There should be fewer restrictions, which are said to encourage theft and black markets.One is legal ownership under straightforward and honorable sales. Second, concerns care and protection, protecting the art on behalf of all humanity (ex. China during the Cultural Revolution and the Red Guard violence). Third, who wants to see Chinese art only in China, Greek art only in Greece? If art was under strict regulation by the state, then they would manipulate art to increase nationalism or political advancement.

Discuss and analyse the importance of responsible business management using the academic literature and company examples to illustrate and support your arguments. - University of Kent - Essay

2410 words - 10 pages . This is why a responsible leader must be aware of the actions taking place within the workplace and outside while making sure that they are ethically and socially acceptable at all times. Conclusion: A responsible business manager considers the three perspectives illustrated throughout his essay and runs their business accordingly. Any manager no matter how big or small. Must be aware that their actions do not impact just themselves but also the

The Essay Is A Research Paper That Arguments A Law In Florida That Prohibits Homosexual Men And Women From Adopting Children

1251 words - 6 pages join neighborhood gangs. With many parents ready and able to adopt many of these children, Florida still denies adoption rights to homosexuals because of several studies that were conducted to support their position.Judith Stacey, a senior scholar with the Council on Contemporary Families, Professor of Sociology, and the Streisand Professor of Contemporary Gender Studies at University of South Carolina, states that there are no scientific

Should The UK Join The Euro Or Remain Master Of Its Own Fiscal Destiny. What Are The Arguments For And Against?

3005 words - 13 pages Free found that the lab our market still needed to be improved and more robust.It is unlikely that Britain will have a referendum on joining the Euro before 2006. So what are the trade implications for Britain?A Positive Euro?As a medium sized economy heavily dependent on imports and exports, the pound isvulnerable to currency movements. To operate outside the umbrella of the Euro would leave it susceptible to buffeting from both it and the Dollar

The Flaws in Aquinas's Five Arguments - Development of Modern Europe - Essay

764 words - 4 pages HI-45 The Flaws in Aquinas's Five Proofs According to 13th-century philosopher St. Thomas Aquinas, the existence of the natural world requires the presence of God. He uses five proofs to justify his theory that God exists and that the natural world can only exist if God is real. However, Aquinas's arguments about the unmovable mover, perfect image, and master designer are deeply flawed. His attempt to confirm the existence of an almighty

“Is Google Making Us Stupid?” Arguments - English 102 - MLA essay

588 words - 3 pages Free process information, last, new age technology is altering people's ability to focus and think for themselves. Google is not making us stupid, it does, however, make people lazy. The purpose of this paper is to refute Carr’s arguments and prove Google is not making us stupid. To begin, Carr claims that the internet affects human thinking. I claim that the internet does not affect our thinking, it affects our decision to use our thinking. We as human


2264 words - 10 pages part of human existence. Changes in social, economic and political spheres of life are constantly adapting to the new demands and issues facing them. Knowledge workers face work-related stress on a daily basis. Scientific studies find that stress affects knowledge workers in a number of ways. Mental health of knowledge workers and energy levels are wasted. Stress is multidimensional and can be experienced in every area of life, in theory, it can be

Romanticism Poetry - The World is too much with us - William Wordsworth - University of Johannesburg - English 2B - Essay

1042 words - 5 pages of consumerism that is linked to the industrialisation as both detestable as viewed in the poem. For example, the speaker says that through “getting and spending we lay waste our powers” (l.2). This can be viewed in two different ways. Firstly, the central tenet of nature as a source of purity and power and secondly, the sense of spirituality as previously outline in this essay indicates that by expending the urban area into nature you are taking

Is Everything Political?: Access the dangers and advantages of the statement that "everything is political"

484 words - 2 pages The statement that 'everything is political' has some very strong arguments on either side. Politics does in some way affect everything that happens to us in everyday life, things such as tax, laws and employment opportunity are some examples of what the government has some control over. It is argued that if the concept of politics is stretched too far it loses its meaning, for everything to be political our society would cease to be a

This is a paper that tells what the American Dream is and how today's society have lost perspective - University of Toledo/Composition 1 - Essay

2273 words - 10 pages Evolution of the American Dream – Founding Fathers to Floundering Faith? Gina Gabalac 16, December 2016 Composition I ! Gabalac 1 The American Dream has evolved for this country over time, shaped by several factors that defined our borders and national identity. Perhaps it began with “We the People” and the idea of self-governance, or maybe long before, with the hopes of the early colonists who landed here looking for something better than the

Extension 1 - Self-Efficacy and Mentors - University of Maryland - Essay

585 words - 3 pages interactions with more advanced individuals is discussed early on. One quote from the textbook that stood out to me was, “Young learners are most likely to construct a productive understanding of the world when adults and other advanced individuals share with them the many concepts, principles, theories, and other cognitive tools that society has developed to explain the physical and psychological aspects of human experience.” This is extremely

Mathematics Essay 1 Assessment 1 - Swinburne University of Technology - Essay

1123 words - 5 pages Assessment 1: Essay Unit Code: EDU10003 The World of Maths Students Name: Cindy Nguyen Student Number: 100571470 The use of mathematics and numeracy has a become an important aspect in our world. The use of both mathematics and numeracy has become one of the most important aspect in our daily lives. Many individuals in the world assume that they’re both the same but, in fact they are two different concepts that have different roles to play in

gap year and experience during that time - chaminade madonna - essay

479 words - 2 pages Nowadays, gap year is a common thing for graduated high school students. Some people would argue that it would be more beneficial for them to take a gap year. However, some would claim that there is more disadvantages than benefits if one does not attend college or university right away. From my point of view, both have their own strengths and drawbacks. Comment by Tara Weinberg: article Comment by Tara Weinberg: reword Comment by Tara Weinberg

The Influence of our Forefathers in American Politics Today - SRJC Political Science 1 - Essay

879 words - 4 pages , these include, individualism, property, contract laws, freedom, and equality. All of those things are still very important in our political society today. There is no era in time where we have seen so much individualism expressed, social media is booming, people are able to express their feelings, and opinions within a moments notice. The philosopher Montesquieu expressed that there should be a separation of power in the executive