Presidential War Powers Essay

1964 words - 8 pages

Throughout history politicians and scholars alike have hotly debated the interpretation of the United States Constitution. This debate has been going on since the founding of the constitution up to modern day America. One of the more intriguing debates is that of the powers given to the president of the United States in article 2 of the constitution. More specifically, the power given to the president proclaiming him the commander in chief of the United States armed forces. This abundance of power comes with great affect, making the president the ultimate decision maker to decide whether or not to put American troops in harms way. Yes, many times in the past presidents have put troops i ...view middle of the document...

S. military involvement is necessary without the approval of congress.The title "Commander in Chief" given to the president does not go without meaning. In other words it is not an "empty title." The solution to the conflict between congress and the president can be found within the words of the constitution. The president has sole responsibility of commanding the U.S. armed forces. Among others to be named later, congress has the sole responsibility to declare war. There is no gray area between the two distinctions. However, time and time again congress has tried to slowly chip away at presidential war powers. It would take a novel to look at every time congress has tried to limit the presidents war powers so lets look at the most recent and blatant attempt; The War Powers Act of 1973.Under the War Powers Act "the president would be required whenever feasible, to consult with congress before sending American forces into armed conflict. He was also to report the circumstances necessitating the action; the constitutional, legislative, and treaty provisions authorizing the action, together with his reasons for not seeking prior congressional authorization; and the estimated scope of activities (Fisher p1)." Congress did not stop there; they set a time limit for how long U.S. troops could engage in conflict without their direct consent. Even more, the U.S. Armed Forces could only be used in three situations: first, to deter an armed attack on the United States, it's territories and possessions, retaliate in the event of such an attack, and forestall the direct and imminent threat of such an attack. Second, repel an attack on armed forces located outside the U.S.; and third, to rescue endangered American citizens (Fisher p1, 2). These limitations set upon the president by congress will have a negative and deterring effect on the "War on Terrorism" (the Bush administrations number one priority). These types of checks and balances are not what the founders had in mind by separating the branches of government.The writers and founders of the constitution knew from past experience and the revolution itself congress would not be able to run or fight a war effectively. They left those powers specifically to the executive branch. Could you imagine 535 legislators trying to agree on what to do after September 11, 2001? Yes, I know initially after a crisis everyone agrees. But what happens later? Everyone starts to bash the president because it's taking to long or costing to much. The president would go crazy if he heard everyone's complaint. In times of crisis the president must have complete discretion as to what steps must be taken if any to defend the country. Meaning he or she should not have (it would be nice of him or her if they did) to consult with 500 plus people and take suggestions. Isn't that what the American people hired the president to do, speak for us, act for us, and make decisions on our behalf? Former White House spokesman Ari Fleis...


Article II of the US Constitution grants the president numerous powers and responsibilities - Government - Paper

1437 words - 6 pages Free Article II of the US Constitution grants the president numerous powers and responsibilities, but the authority granted to the modern presidency far exceeds the constitutional definition of office. And through the years, a variety of presidential roles have evolved that were not originally or specifically outlined in the Article. Some of these roles were legislated by congress, the courts granted some, and powerful presidents assumed others. The

How do we Amend the Constitution - Essay

1514 words - 7 pages minimum number of electors. To today Washington D.C. has no Senators or Reps. to the House.  24 Abolition of Poll Taxes (1964) · Poll taxes are illegal in federal elections Many Southern states had used  poll taxes and literacy tests to limit black voting after the Civil War. Literacy tests were already illegal by the 1960's, but an amendment was required to outlaw the poll tax. 25 Presidential Succession (1967) · Establishes a clearer

an essay on the causes of the vietnam war - sydney grammar school, history class - essay

1322 words - 6 pages .] [5: Fisher, Louis. 2009. “The Law: When Laws Begin: Misleading Statements by Presidents, 03/2010 Presidential Studies Quarterly” Volume 40, Issue 1] North Vietnam’s goal for the war was simple, to unify Vietnam under one government and have autonomy from foreign intervention, however they were dragged into the war by the antagonism of

The Reign of Rafael Trujillo - Research Paper

1779 words - 8 pages several European countries. Which had the potential to lead to the possible movement of foreign powers onto the Island. This would not only pose a threat to the canal but also a defensive threat, with the region being so close to American soil. In response to this the United States, it looked to resolve the poor economic situation the country was in. Talks between the nations began, eventually leading to the signing of a financial accord being

Essay On Franklin Delano Roosevelt - Li

1993 words - 8 pages from starving death. President Franklin also led the U.S. through World War II and constructed the United States to become the world power enabling it to compete with other foreign powers such as the Soviet Union. Over all, There is almost no doubt that President Franklin Delano Roosevelt was among the finest President of the United States.

The Presidency: As Time Changed Power Gained

515 words - 3 pages Free three major powers that the president has that have given him more power. The presidents power as commander and chief is known as his biggest power of all to most citizens. That is because that power is directly related to the nations security. The founding fathers gave this power to the president so that in case of an emergency to our nation or other nations that we needed a strong executive that could act when the time has come to do so

Cold War In The Middle East: Afghanistan

1937 words - 8 pages society give the Taliban strength as the national government struggles with unification. The recent presidential elections saw the final two candidates agree to an unheard of (and currently unconstitutional) power sharing deal in an attempt to mend fraying government unity (The Economist 2014). The contemporary threats to security, democracy, and national unity have deep roots in the Cold War interest in the Middle East. This is the legacy

what were the long term international effects of the Vietnam war? - history - essay

4401 words - 18 pages , which gradually became the overwhelming force in dictating foreign policy. [footnoteRef:31] This led to the passage of the War Powers Resolution (1973), which required presidents to inform Congress forty-eight hours prior to a troop commitment and prohibited troops from remaining in the field for more than sixty days without congressional approval. In theory, the passing of this act has changed the way America operates in international affairs, with

the Consitutional notes of united states of america chaoter 2 - Government - Reasearch

3443 words - 14 pages the major alternative to the American separation of powers system in the world. vi. Critics of these proposed remedies argue that many times, Congressional scrutiny has improved presidential decisions more than it has worsened them, that other systems have done no better than the U.S. in dealing with their problems, and that the average person stands a better chance of fighting back against bureaucracy in the current system. vii. Each of these

JFK Speech We Choose To Go To The Moon - History II - Effective speech in world history

2780 words - 12 pages War, two world powers sought to enlarge their security zones. The entire world watched as these two nations attempted to prove their government the more successful by proving superiority in science, military, and outer-space technology. Rulers in each country played prominent roles in the Cold War, each showing their support for their nation’s beliefs by traveling the land, communicating with their population. One such leader, American President

apex final exam for government sem 1 - apex spring valley - final exam

2381 words - 10 pages ) The legislative branch is made up of the House and Senate, known collectively as the Congress. Among other powers, the legislative branch makes all laws, declares war, regulates interstate and foreign commerce and controls taxing and spending policies.The executive branch consists of the President, his or her advisors and various departments and agencies. This branch is responsible for enforcing the laws of the land. The judicial branch consists

Graba, Birk, and Rauschenberg- Divisions in a Modern Inferno - Phillips Academy Andover PHR480 - Research Paper

2409 words - 10 pages violation of such, Rauschenberg effectively conveys that in order to do God’s bidding, one must unite to counter the chaos that is the absence of God. Out of all the images in this story that he could’ve chose, Rauschenberg chose one representing one depicting Soviet superiority, tying the theme of the giants to the Cold War and encouraging the unification of global powers to undermine communist expansion. [27: Ferrante, "The Relation," 33-34.] While

the reasons for hitlers rise to power - history - essay

1603 words - 7 pages leadership, a form of presidential dictatorship formed, appointed Hitler chancellor with the belief that he could be controlled Introduction: The rise of the Nazi Party (NSDAP) was swift and far from certain. Support for Hitler and his Nazi Party only took off after the full impact of the Wall Street Crash (October 1929) was felt on Weimar Germany. Up to this point the Nazis had been a noisy but far from important part of the Reichstag that was

andnasndnsad and as asdsnmdasndcasmcasnccnasc sss. ss. s s. s s. s - sadasdas - dsadsa

2199 words - 9 pages War of 2008, Russia had been playing a crucial role interfering the Eastern European politics. In February 2014, the protesters in Kiev stirred up the Euromaidan Revolution which removed President Viktor Yanukovych from administration and pushed the domestic politics off the cliff into chaos. The Populist leader Viktor Yushchenko, the anti-Russian presidential candidate, who lost to his opponent in the election 2010, gained power as a interim

Government of the United States - government - essay

2084 words - 9 pages Constitution is not law ○ Any act of Congress that goes against the Constitution is void ● Gave power of judicial review Three Eras of Court’s Judicial Review Nation versus State ● Founding to Civil War ● Period Of Nationalization ● McCulloch v. Maryland ○ National Supremacy ○ Marshalls decision ■ “the power to tax involves the power to destroy.” ■ States cannot tax federal property ■ Federal authority trumped state authority ● Dred Scott v. Sandford