Psychology Of Ancient Philosophers And A Hole In Aristotle's Argument On Psychology Randolph Macon College Philosophy Essay

2157 words - 9 pages

Psychology of Ancient Philosophers from Parmenides to Aristotle and a
Hole in Aristotle’s Argument on Psychology Regarding Hypothetical Comatose Patients
For thousands of years, philosophers have debated the relation between body and soul. The ancient philosophers built upon one another’s ideas, expressing multiple ideologies that still hold relevance in the debate on philosophical psychology to this day. The following essay will examine the psychology expressed by Parmenides and his atomists successors, Plato and Socrates, and Aristotle, observing that each provides a correction to a perceived imbalance in their conceptions of their predecessors regarding the relationship between body and soul. It will argue that Aristotle’s resolution is best, but introduce a hypothetical case of patients in comatose states with and without brain activity to illustrate the limits of Aristotle’s conception.
Parmenides, a monist, is one of the earliest philosophers of which one can study that produced a clear psychology regarding the topic of body and soul. As a monist, Parmenides believed there to be a singular, unbreakable, and everlasting being of pure existence that encompassed all. Being would repudiate the idea of empty space or void because if Being encompasses all, there can be no such thing as nonbeing. Due to this lack of void, there would be no room for motion and change to occur in the universe, ultimately suggesting that the physical world must be illusionary as it represents change and motion in every aspect of it’s physical existence.
Thus, if the physical realm is illusionary, the physical body must be as well, but what of the soul? To Parmenides, souls would be Being. In other words, soul would be an infinite and eternal substance that coincides with the rest of Being. Thus, Parmenides believed the soul to be the same as Being and significantly more important than the illusory physical world and body.
The next set of Philosophers found the idea of discounting change and motion in the physical world unsatisfactory and instead, adapted Parmenides’s theory to better fit the physical world in which they lived. By doing so, the psychology regarding the relation between soul and body changed drastically. These philosophers were the atomists.
The atomists theorized that singular, unbreakable, and everlasting particles called atoms moved around in a void, joining together and breaking apart to create the physical world one experiences. According to the atomist theory, atoms were different sizes and shapes which held different characteristics that worked together to create the different sensations that mankind experiences. Democritus, one of the atomists of this time explained that although the atoms allowed beings to experience the different sensations of the world, the sensations were unreliable as the sensory qualities were purely due to convention. To Democritus, the only realities in the world were the atoms and void as can be seen with the following...

Other Essays On Psychology of Ancient Philosophers and a Hole in Aristotle's Argument on Psychology - Randolph-Macon College Philosophy - Essay

An Analysis of the Free Will Problem - UNT - Philosophy - Psychology

1506 words - 7 pages , in context of an ever-expanding pool of choices and options of human development, does exist, allowing for contextualization and creativity to function in tandem with one another. To begin this argument, there is an importance to be put on the three main argumentative stances. Fully understanding each position’s main points of contention is key to developing a fully fleshed out perspective of what free will is and is not. First, we will discuss

Current Even Paper for Psychology 221 in Liberty University Online College - liberty university - Psychology

889 words - 4 pages "lecturing" other students in an aggressive way due to them doing things differently than him. When he would try to tell another peer his way he would tell them " You should just" or even " Did you know you should" As a result of these three young boys, showed different Social Interaction in the classroom to other peers. The special education teachers showed in different graphs on how the boy's appropriate and inappropriate behavior as resulted to

Nature vs Nurture assignments that explains the nature vs nurture debate in a scientific way - union county college/ General Psychology - Essay

834 words - 4 pages explores the role of environmental factors in influencing behaviours. In this approach it is believed that when were born, our mind is a blank slate, or in other words ‘tabula rasa’. This debate was thought of before the discoveries of psychology. It goes back to the days of ancient philosophy. In philosophy this was referred to as nativism versus empiricism; these concepts are one in the same but philosophers had a slightly more extreme view. Nativism

A Delve into the Man Behind Cognitive Development - A Biography of the Great Jean Piaget - Houston Community College - Dual Credit Psychology - Essay

1251 words - 6 pages former nanny made-up in his youth as it piqued his interest as to why and how he could so clearly produce and recall memories of an incident that never happened. He A DELVE INTO THE MAN BEHIND COGNITIVE DEVELOPMENT 4 would live the rest of his life bouncing from university to university, teaching a myriad of subject matters from psychology, philosophy, to sociology. After a storied life of conferences, studies, and publications, Piaget would go on to

Research Paper about a lot of things that are not interesting - Psychology Eastern florida State College - Research Paper

1049 words - 5 pages hundreds of years. Philosophers like Plato and Descartes stated that behaviors are “inborn”, and nativists believe that humans are nothing but products of evolution whereas empiricists believe that humans are a product of their experiences. (Eman Zaky, 2015 P.2) According to Saul Mcleod (2017), from Nature vs. Nurture in Psychology nature vs. nurture is defined as how much of human personality and behavior is influenced by either “inherited or

Describe how the endocrine system affect behavior? - Saber college / Intro to psychology 14 edition - Essay

450 words - 2 pages Course: PSY 1000 Theme: Modulo 2 Discussion Instructor: Alexandra Lis Student: Alain Marichal Describe how the endocrine system affect behavior? Explain The endocrine system sends chemical messages called hormones, and hormones effect on behavior, the endocrine glands works as a chemical communication system within the body, the flow of hormones from the endocrine glands entering the bloodstream affect behavior, personality, and moods; Many of

psychology quizpsychology quizpsychology quizpsychology quizpsychology quizpsychology quiz - philosophy - assignment

854 words - 4 pages following is one of these steps? a. Gauge what is realistic. b. Consider other options. c. Analyze and dissect your dream. d. Let it sit for awhile (incubation). 13. T F One test of a “passion” is when one becomes fully absorbed in an experience. 14. T F One guide offered on returning to college is when you do not have a direction or plan. “The Unpredictable” by Nelson Goud 15. The author became a professor for all but one of the following reasons: a

Journal Entry Chapter 2 For Child Psychology - Catawba College Child Psychology - Assignment

690 words - 3 pages CJ Harris Dr. Holmes Child Psychology 1340, 8:00 a.m. 11 April 2018 Journal Entry In chapter 8 (Early Childhood) Physical Development, I learned about and reviewed in class: growth patterns, motor development, health and illness, sleep, and elimination disorders. While working at the Partners in Learning Center, I was able to watch a couple of preschoolers (4-5 years old), demonstrate gross motor skills, they were skipping and pedaling tricycles

Childhood disorders Chapter 1-5 - Brooklyn College/ Psychology 3240 - Notes

3355 words - 14 pages % *children with a parent depressed 14x more likely before the age of 13 *children with depressed parent are at risk- 3x more likely than peers *Risk is higher when both parents are depressed *Earlier age of onset *They can also display a variety of other disorders. *Findings show multiple brain regions implicated, not one specific. *Genetic findings focus on those involved in the synthesis, release and reuptake of the neurotransmitter serotonin, and BDNF

Discuss idiographic and nomethetic approach in psychology - Psychology - Essay

1011 words - 5 pages to predict and control any likely future behaviour. The approach is associated with methods that would be regarded as scientific within psychology such as experiments, which would include large numbers of participants in order to establish ways in which people are similar or different. The humanistic approach in psychology is a key example of the idiographic perspective. Rogers and Maslow, took a phenomalogical and subjective approach in the study

Focus Paper on Stages of Grief and Parenting Styles - Psychology 2012 - Essay

1455 words - 6 pages types of parenting styles, everyone will experience both these concepts every day in their life, either being themselves or a close one. Writing this paper showed me how to understand people better, and learn what they’re going through. Either something’s are going on with their parents or if they feel like they’re losing a loved one. Either way it made me a more of an understanding person and I’m thankful for that. Jose Oliveira Psychology 2012

Similar Papers

Our Response To Mental Illness: Analysis Philosophy Of Psychology Essay

1677 words - 7 pages , and more importantly, if the goals, actions and reasonings can be justified on ethical grounds. In this essay I will be exploring mental health through an ethical lens, in order to highlight significant issues that stem from the influence that the current models for the classifications, diagnosis and treatments of mental illnesses and psychiatric disorders have on how patients are perceived and addressed on a societal, institutional, and

Stress In College Athletes And Non Athletes Psychology Apa Style Essay

1327 words - 6 pages 1 Running head: Stress in College Athletes and Non-Athletes 3 Stress in College Athletes and Non-Athletes Stress in College Athletes and Non-Athletes Lakisha Camacho PSYC104v01 or v02: Introduction to Psychology II Dr. Pipitone College of Mount Saint Vincent February 24, 2019 Our group decided to focus on the stress of college student-athletes and non-athletes. Stress can be defined as emotional levels that affect an individual's mind

Psychological Effects Of Wrongful Indictments In Molly's Game College Psychology Essay

1102 words - 5 pages Psychological Effects of Wrongful Indictments Molly’s Game Molly’s Game is the fascinating and true book to movie adaptation of Molly Bloom, former professional freestyle skier and poker game runner.  In her youth, her father, a profession phycologist himself, pushed her and her two older brothers to achieve incredibly high academic and athletic goals.  While Molly was only ever number three in North American women’s freestyle before she

Secondary Research On Nivea. Psychology And Demographic Research. Rationale And Conclusion Sheridan College Research

1662 words - 7 pages healthy skin, the Nivea active clean shower gel for men is a modern skincare product that will be assist in protecting against dirt while being convenient and simply elegant. It is recommended that Product Differentiation Appeal strategy would work best for Nivea because it focus on Nivea unique attribute and key benefits. As Market analysis shows, nowadays men are more aware for selection of skincare product. This strategy also important because