Purple Hibiscus And Dolls House Comparison A Level Essay

2481 words - 10 pages

“In literature the role of mothers, in family life, is to be seen and not heard” 
Compare and contrast the presentation of the dominant male and his impact upon family life in   A Doll’s House & Purple Hibiscus. 
A Doll's House,  by Henrik Ibsen and Purple Hibiscus, by Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie, are two texts that although appear to contrast contextually, have many similarities conceptually. Both texts focus heavily on familial relationships and how more often than not, these are not as they appear. Both A Doll's House and Purple Hibiscus feature wealthy families who care greatly about how they are viewed by society. The mothers in both of the texts, Nora in A Doll's House and Mama (Beatrice) in Purple Hibiscus, are presented as possessions owned by their husbands, rather than as individuals and Ibsen and Adichie present their maternal roles as archetypal of their respective times. The authors also focus on the role of the dominant male in both novels, these are Torvald in A Doll's House and Papa (Eugene) in Purple Hibiscus. Ibsen and Adichie show the different ways in which dominance can be portrayed and the similar impact it can have on family life. 
The women in both A Doll's House and Purple Hibiscus appear to have very similar roles, that are in line with the societal standards of the time. In the play A Doll's House, Ibsen presents his protagonist Nora as very compliant and submissive, with her happiness being closely linked to futile tasks. The play opens with Nora leading a porter carrying a Christmas tree inside whilst "humming contentedly to herself". Through his lexical choice of the word "contentedly" Ibsen presents the joy that Nora receives from doing even the most menial jobs. As Nora finds purpose in something as frivolous as buying a Christmas tree, Ibsen suggests that she is not given much responsibility in others areas of family life. As A Doll's House is set in Norway in the 1870's, modern readers may pity Nora for being so 'content' with little to no real influence in her family life, however, Ibsen in many ways epitomises her as a perfect Norwegian bourgeois wife. Throughout the play Nora appears as a child or possession of Torvald rather than an equal partner. In scene three, Torvald tells Nora that he has "broad wings to shelter (her) under" and that he will protect her like "a hunted dove that (he has) saved from a hawk's claws". This highlights the unequal power dynamic that exists between Torvald and Nora, as not only does Torvald view Nora as weak and unable to protect herself, but he believes it is his obligation to protect her. In doing this Ibsen employs irony, as by the play's ending Torvald becomes much like a predator that Nora seeks to escape from. Although Nora is presented as a quintessential mother, Ibsen distances her from her children throughout the play. The children are looked after by Anne-Marie, a nanny and only appear when it's time to play. In her brief interaction with her children Nora enj...

RELATED

Analysis Of Women In 'A Dolls House'

1514 words - 7 pages Women were valued very little by nineteenth century society. The treatment of these women was also extremely negative; they were stereotypical housewives, expected to stay home and fulfill domestic duties. Literature of this time embodies and mirrors social issues of women in society. Henrik Ibsen uses Nora Helmer in "A Doll's House" to portray the negative treatment of all women throughout society during the nineteenth century. In this play we

dolls house essay for ela assingments - ela or english2 - essay

1173 words - 5 pages Shelby Ducote English II Ms. Julie Humble March 29, 2018 A Doll’s House Essay Being a woman back in the Victorian Era was anything but a privilege. Women back in this time period were controlled by men and oppressed by society. Women were seen as incapable of making their own decisions or able to do anything for themselves. In A Doll’s House, Henrik Ibsen examines conventional roles of men and women in the nineteenth century. In the play, Nora

McEwan and Plath’s Comparison Essay - Stockley Academy - English Literature A-Level - Essay

2968 words - 12 pages voices was presented in contemporary literature and that Plath after over thirty years still represented the unconventional voices of female dissent. An examination of Plath’s most acclaimed poems will form the basis of the contention that Plath although often socially constrained, wrote outside the conventions of her time. A comparison with the 2002 novel of Ian McEwan, On Chesil Beach which also claims to represent the role of the female in the late

Understanding health and safety - A level - essay

5567 words - 23 pages Yasmin Hodges Unit 27;Understanding Health and Safety 02/01/2017 Introduction- Within this report, I will be explaining the legal requirements and regulations for ensuring the health, safety and security, of those employed by Sainsbury's business. Then I will be, describing the requirements for a healthy and safe workplace, as well as assessing the implications of health, safety and security legalisation and regulations for a business role in a

Representations and social criticism in Ibsen's a Doll's House - Literature - Essay

1312 words - 6 pages Task: Ibsen Take-home Essay Question 3: Literary texts often pose questions about an established social order. Discuss how representations have been constructed in A Doll’s House in order to critique, reinforce or destabilise social institutions and/or social expectations In the play A Doll’s House, Henrik Ibsen uses theatre as a means of voicing his own opinions on the imperfections of his society, posing question about the crippling effects

The Philippines and the United States: A Comparison - Geography - Essay

686 words - 3 pages Jessica Liu 4th Hour 3-7-16 The Philippines and the United States: A Comparison Have you ever heard of the Philippines? If not, the Philippines is a country comprised of 7,107 islands. This may seem like a lot, but most of the population lives on eleven main islands. It is located in Asia, the islands spread out near Taiwan and Malaysia. The people of the Philippines have a rich culture, passed down for eight centuries through many generations

wether the in the colour purple womens empowerment outweighs suppression inflicted by men - st john fisher year 13 - english lit a level

1522 words - 7 pages on black women. The novel reflects the attitudes of early 1900 society, exploring the status of black women and how acceptable it was for men to oppress them. Through her targeted concern, she came up with the term womanism; she stated “womanism is to a feminist as purple is to lavender”, to encompass the perspective of black women. Despite the degree of suppression inflicted on women, walker explores how bonds between women evoke their

A feminist Analysis of The Colour Purple by Alice Walker - bramalea secondary school - essay

855 words - 4 pages The Color Purple: A Feminist Analysis Aleena Rakkar December 11, 2018 Mr. McGlynn ENG 3U0 Feminism is the advocacy for equality between men and women in all social, political, and economic aspects. In Alice Walker’s novel The Color Purple, male dominance is seen to suppress women which prevents the idea of equality between the sexes. The relationships between men and women are a reflection of the views of society and are seen through the

Buddha And Jesus: A Comparison

2029 words - 9 pages son become a proper ruler instead of the Buddha. "And so Prince Siddhartha of the house of Gautama increased in stature, well nurtured, protected from the world, and surrounded by an immense retinue in regal splendor" (Mitchell 20).At this time, there comes a lull in the life of both boys. Jesus is mentioned only once in the Bible between his return to Nazareth and the beginning of his teaching. Other sources, not officially accepted by the

A doll's house analytic essay symbolism - GMHS - Essay

819 words - 4 pages her growth and shift into an empowered woman. Secondly, the symbolism of the Christmas tree in the play is utilized by Ibsen to reflects Nora’s character and value in the household, along with the progression of her psychological state. The purpose of a Christmas tree is to look beautiful and serve its purpose of embellishing a household, which is seen in her relationship with Torvald, as he sees her as an accessory to flaunt and adorn the house

Patriarchal Authority in 'A Doll's House' - Millais School, Horsham - Essay

1770 words - 8 pages Katerina Poulios English - Dr Stuart 17 March 2018 How far can it be argued that Torvald is the only tragic figure of A Doll’s House, falling from a position of patriarchal authority to ruin though not death through attitudes typical of his society and age that destroy his capacity for love? Torvald Helmer’s character is that of a typical nineteenth century male. He offers his household support and is a respectable man - staying within the

Comparison of storys A Rose for Emily and A Worn Path - College of Southern Maryland - Essay

799 words - 4 pages BLANDFORD 3 Brittany Blandford Professor Heid English 1020 June 6, 2018 The Comparison of Emily & Phoenix Although the main characters in the two stories “A rose for Emily” and “A Worn Path” may have a lot of differences but they also share a lot of similarities. What both women have in common are their struggles and the things they have to sacrifice to overcome the obstacles on their journey throughout life. Both Emily and Phoenix were strong

Journeys Involve Overcoming Obstacles In 'Life As A House'. Discuss. - Essay On 'Life As A House' Film - Essay

689 words - 3 pages ‘Life As A House’- Essay The act of self- reflection is an essential aspect of journeys. Provide extensive reasoning regarding whether you agree or oppose this concept utilising the text ‘Life As A House’. Journeys Involve Overcoming Obstacles. Discuss the statement in relation to your text and one other text selected. The prevalence of the overcoming of obstacles presented in the trials and tribulations of spiritual, physical and mental

A Comparison Of Hinduism And Theosophy

2141 words - 9 pages become an essential part of the Hindu culture and help guide a day-to-day life.The Hindu's worldview is mapped out in four goals, Dharma, Artha, Karma, and Moksha. Each one of these elements deserves a separate essay on the sole subject in order to fully understand them, but for the sake of comparison I will present the basic idea of each.Dharma, the main goal in Hinduism, consists of righteousness and morality. Dharma is your social and religious

Kant's Moral Theory And Liberalism: A Comparison

775 words - 4 pages Kant's Moral Theory and Liberalism: A comparison Liberalism is a broad body of philosophy. It is defined as the set of philosophical and social theories that, despite their differences, are committed to a common set of presuppositions and principles (Goldberg 519). It is based on four general principles: individualism, universalism, equality, and reform. Individualism is the paramount principle. It is to protect the rights of people from the