Racial Barriers Of Accessing Health Care

1896 words - 8 pages

The present health crisis for racial minorities in the United States can be traced back to 400 years ago when racial discrimination rooted in this continent. For this long period of time, minorities were exclusive from the so called "mainstream" health system. The most popular health care system in U.S. - managed care, has actually built in incentives which may encourage discrimination. Research shows that "the total family premiums have risen more than $2,700 in four years, a rate was four times faster than that for workers' earnings" ("Kerry" 2004). Another research also shows that "the health care cost is continuing to increase in 12.9 percent next year. The firms are likely to shift much of the difference to employees in the form of higher required contributions and co-payment fees, or by limiting their choice of insurance plans" ("Survey" 2004).Some interest groups, like politicians, hospitals, doctors, insurance companies claim that such problem is caused by the people who don't buy health insurances. They also blame the companies which didn't provide health insurance package for their workers. These interest groups suggest each people should responsible for their own health condition. However, they only see the surface of this issue, and didn't see the essential of this issue in a large social scale.In structural functionalist's perspectives, the health crisis is caused by the failure of social structure- the society could not provide equal access to health care for racial minorities. Vernellia R. Randall, a notable professor in the University of Dayton school of Law, states that "since 1975 minority health status has steadily eroded and there has been no significant improvements in the removal of barriers that are due to institutional racism" ("Institutional Racism" 1997). Institutional discrimination occurs when normal operations and procedures of social institutions result in unequal treatment of minorities. Because of institutional racism, minorities have less education and fewer educational opportunities. Minorities are disproportionately homeless and have significantly poorer housing options. Racial residential segregation contributes to the concentration of poverty in minority communities. All these place minorities in economical, political, and social disadvantages in society which lead to numerous barriers, such as lack of insurance, lack of money, inadequate location of health care facilities, lack of enforcement of federal laws and so on, to access adequate health care.First, minorities lack of economic access to health care. A disproportionate number of racial minorities have no insurance, are unemployed, are employed in jobs that do not provide health care insurance, disqualify for government assistance programs, or fail to participate because of administrative barriers. Research shows that more than 38.4 million Americans are uninsured with no economic access to health care, mostly are racial minorities. The health insurance in the United States is most often tied to employment, racial stratification of the economy due to other forms of discrimination has resulted in a concentration of racial minorities in low wage jobs. And these jobs are always without insurance benefits. For example in the film "John Q", the main actor John, who is a black steel worker with a child in his family, cannot qualify the health insurance for his child because his job doesn't include health insurance benefits. Eitzen and Zinn in their book "Social problem", states that "structural changes in the U.S. economy- the shift of employment from manufacturing to services, the rise in contingent and part-time employment, and the decline in union membership- have resulted in a decline in employment-related health insurance coverage" ("Social Problems", p.500). As a result, disproportionate numbers of the uninsured are racial minorities who are more likely with the low wages jobs.The welfare reform enacted in 1996 worsen the problem. It changed the structure of public assistance, resulting in a negative impact on women and minorities. One of the direct effects of welfare reform is reduction in the use of Medicaid by those who qualify due to an unawareness of eligibility requirements, resulting in an increased number of uninsured. A second effect has been that the subsequent increased poverty among those in need of assistance has caused a worsening of health status and an increased in the need for health care services. Gaps in health status and the absence of relevant health information are directly related to access to health care.Second, there are many racial barriers to access health care. Many hospitals discriminate by using patient referral and acceptance practice standard that limit access. These practices restrict the admission of African-Americans to hospitals, for example not having physicians on staff who can accept Medicaid patients; requiring pre-admission deposit as a condition of obtaining care; refusing to participate in programs to finance care for low-income patients not eligible for Medicaid, and many other practices of restriction ("Institutional Racism" 1997). Such practices have a devastating effect on minorities since they set up a high wall between standard hospitals and minority groups. They may completely prevent care where minorities have no access to other sources of care.Racial barriers to health care access are based, in a large part, on the unavailability of services in a community. Increasingly, hospitals that serve the minority communities are either closing, relocating or becoming private. In a study done between 1937-1977, researchers found out that the likelihood of hospital's closing was directly related to the percentage of African-Americans in the population. Throughout the 1980s many hospitals relocated from heavily African-American communities to predominantly European-American suburban communities ("Institutional Racism" 1997). This loss of services to community resulted in reduced access to African-Americans. Another devastating trend that affects the access of African-American to health care is the privatization of public hospitals. Eitzen and Zinn states that traditionally, hospitals in the United States have been nonprofit organizations run by churches, universities, and municipalities. Since the mid-1960s, however, private profit-oriented hospitals are growing rapidly ("Social Problems", p.520). By the 1960s, there are only 90 african-american hospitals remained. By the 1991, only 12 hospitals continued to "struggle daily just to keep their doors open". Because of the capitalism economic system in the U.S., non-profit hospitals cannot survive by competing with the for-profit hospitals. They either merged, converted or consolidated to the for-profit hospitals. As a result of closure, relocations, and privatization, many minority groups are left with limited, if any, access to hospitals.Minority groups seeking care at a private hospital may face "patient dumping". As Eitzen and Zinn state, "for-profit hospitals either turn away patients who cannot afford their services or they tend to switch them to public hospitals as soon as possible or they keep the poor away by not providing the services they most require, such as emergency room"("Social Problems", p.504). Although in 1986 congress passed the Emergency Medical Treatment and Active Labor Act which makes patient dumping illegal, limited enforcement of these legislative enactments makes patient dumping continue to be a problem. Also hospitals have found other "tricks" to dump the patient without invoking the statute, such as they reroute the patient before he/she arrives to their emergency room. Here is a typical example for this case: a parent called the University of Chicago Hospital after her baby went into cardiac arrest. But the hospital told the paramedics to take the child to another hospital even though it was only five blocks away. The child was taken to a hospital without a pediatric intensive care unit and had to be transferred to another hospital. The child died after admission to the second hospital. However, the court announced the University of Chicago Hospital had no responsibility for this tragedy and it didn't violate the law ("Institutional Racism" 1997). Another way is to close emergency room. The report by the National Association of Community Health Centers finds that "in 2002 there were 110.2 million visits to hospital emergency departments, up form 89.8 million in 1998. During this time, many hospital emergency rooms closed and there were 15 percent fewer than in 1998" ("Uninsured Patients" 2004). So many hospitals continued dumping patients, most of whom will be minorities because of their low socioeconomic status.What's more, discriminatory policies and practices also prevent minority groups from accessing health care, such as medical redlining, excessive wait times, unequal access to emergency care, deposit requirements as a prerequisite to care, and lack of continuity of care, etc. One significant example is a racially-neutral federal Medicaid policy that limits the number of beds a nursing home can allocate to Medicaid recipients. The effect of this policy is that fewer Medicaid resources are spent on nursing for minority populations even though minorities represent a larger portion of the Medicaid population and have more illness. Many other policies and practices we can find in our health care system are related to structural and institutional racial discrimination. Racial inequality in health care persists in the United States because the legal system has been particularly reluctant to address issues of racial discrimination that result from polices and practices that have a disparate racial impact. In fact, the federal laws explicitly allows for such discrimination as long as the institution can demonstrate "business necessity".In conclusion, the economy, political, and legal system are dysfunction and failed to provide minorities equal access to health care. The inequality in the institutions leads to the failure of the health system. There is no simple solution to the problem. Government should enact and enforce some policies that provide affordable quality health care for the public, advocate universal health insurance, train more accessible standard physicians, encourage cities to build facilities near the poor and educate minority groups about preventative health care. But most important is to eliminate institutional racism in order to assure economic access, political fairness, and legal justice of health care for everyone.Bibliography:1. Vernellia R. Randall. "Institutional Racism in U.S. Health Care". 1997.http://academic.udayton.edu/health/07HumanRights/racial01c.htm#N_70_2. D. Stanley Eitzen and Maxine Baca Zinn. "Social Problems" 9th edition. 2003.3. Reuters. "Uninsured patients flood emergency rooms". MSNBC News. Aug. 9, 2004.http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/56517384. Adam Geller. "Survey: Health Care Costs Continue to Rise". MSNBC News. Aug 27, 2004.http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/58330565. The Associated Press. "Kerry: Health Care System 'badly broken'". MSNBC News. May 10, 2004.http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/49447646. The Associated Press. "Gaps Linger in U.S. Health Care". MSNBC News. Dec 22, 2003.http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/37861557. Sociology 3 class notes, week 1.

RELATED

mark scheme of health and social care 2017 - Poole high CH4 - Health and social

3898 words - 16 pages Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations Cambridge Technicals Health and Social Care Unit 3: Health, safety and security in health and social care Level 3 Cambridge Technical Certificate/Diploma in Health and Social Care 05830 - 05871 Mark Scheme for January 2017 OCR (Oxford Cambridge and RSA) is a leading UK awarding body, providing a wide range of qualifications to meet the needs of candidates of all ages and abilities. OCR qualifications

PRACTICE IN THE DOMIMCILARY HEALTH CARE ENVIRONMENT - carers Australia , college of nursing - asignment

1159 words - 5 pages Diploma of Nursing HLTEN608B PRACTISE IN THE DOMICILIARY HEALTH CARE ENVIRONMENT Impact of Health Problems on Domiciliary Client Care Assessment Introduction As for all nurses, Domiciliary Nurses are entrusted with: • Client and family information enabling them to • Recognise and respond to - Condition changes - Care needs - Coping abilities • Family involvement is encouraged – however should be: - Co-ordinated as per the care plan - Timely and

Evaluate the effectiveness of health and social care - langly park school - Assignment

1349 words - 6 pages Unit 14 -Physiological Disorder D1-Evaluate the effectiveness of health and social care practitioners and agencies working together to deliver the care pathway Within this report I will be evaluating the effectiveness of health and social care practitioners and agencies working together to deliver the care pathway. As health care professionals it is important that as a team they work together to provide for the individual’s needs when delivering

The study of falling in health care facilities - nbcc nursing - essay

791 words - 4 pages there was a curb beside the car. This accident resulted in the swelling of my ankle for months. Falls is the most common factor that negatively affects our daily living, especially in the healthcare facility falling and falls related injures are one of the main concerns of a patient’s safety, especially in among those 65 years and older. Patient’s safety, efficient patient care and quality patient care are top priority of healthcare organization

Introductory Awareness of Sensory - tlc - health and social care level 2

1765 words - 8 pages time to get to know the individual by using their preferred method of communication taking care not to come across as patronizing can make the individual feel empowered and make them feel like they can effectively contribute to the community and open up the individuals social network . It can also reduce the likelihood of challenging behavior, because if the individual is experiencing pain or another issue and can effectively communicate this issue

Health Care Stigmas Among Minorities - Bethune Cookman University, English - Argumentative Essay

1539 words - 7 pages every measure of healthcare quality. Financial barriers, communication barriers and lack of trust in doctors play a large role in this but it is not the only reasons. Minority communities often face challenges in having access to quality medical care. When compared with whites, minorities appear to have a lower quality of health insurance. Minority communities are more likely to suffer from certain health conditions, suffer complications and even

Food Insecurity and Its Correlation to Type 2 Diabetes - GEO 716 - Research Paper

4853 words - 20 pages as a significant barrier in accessing primary care healthcare. The spatial relation between primary care hospitals and clinic have direct affect on individuals’ risk and ties in the notion of how geography and health go hand in hand. Conclusion The literature review reiterate theme there is definitive link between food insecurity and its increased risk in the development of chronic diseases such as Type 2 diabetes. Problems of food insecurity

The New Vision Foundation

2572 words - 11 pages of Koreans in the United States has grown over 300%. Today, there are over one million Koreans in America. Of these people, about 25% live in California’s Los Angeles-Riverside-Orange County area. In Los Angeles and Orange Counties, a majority of Koreans face cultural and linguistic barriers that impede access to health care. Also, minorities face disadvantages in receiving health care because prejudices still persist in the American health care

Aging and Systems within the African American community and the discrimination they face - ASU Foundation Practice - Essay

2148 words - 9 pages family”. Research investigations have shown that Black women reside at the root of race, class, and gender intersection and are more likely to have poor health outcomes, specifically depression (Copeland & Snyder, 2011). Disparities in access to mental health care, as well as the quality of treatment continue to disproportionately affect people of color (Atkins, 2016). Observable barriers to quality treatment may include lack of community resources

level 5 health and socail care unit 513. - weymouth college - essay

5133 words - 21 pages and quality assurance measures.” (Diploma in leadership for health and social care 2016. Tina Tilmouth) Outcome based practice is an activity or process which has a positive impact on the client’s life. An example of this would accessing the community. We have clients who wish to socialise but are unable to get out on their own anymore. We are able to provide them with the relevant information to access the community, whether it be the local day

racism in the different region - class - essay

1487 words - 6 pages nondominant populations. Individual and institutional discrimination, along with the stigma of inferiority, can adversely affect health by restricting socioeconomic opportunities and mobility. Racism can also directly affect health in multiple ways. Residence in poor neighborhoods, racial bias in medical care, the stress of experiences of discrimination and the acceptance of the societal stigma of inferiority can have deleterious consequences for health

Argumentative essay Nurse Practitioners - English 255 - Assignment 6

1224 words - 5 pages problem with accessibility and a decrease in patient satisfaction which has the potential be solved, at least partially, with the increased utilization of nurse practitioners across all areas of health care in Canada. It is time to move the nurse practitioners into the mainstream and out of the rural, remote areas of our country. 2 NURSE PRACTITIONERS: A BENEFIT TO MODERN References Ali, W., David, P., & Alan, H. (2002). Barriers to developing the

Health people 2020 Communication project - Marian University - Research Paper

1060 words - 5 pages that influence a person’s health literacy include personal factors, which are education level, language, race and ethnicity, age, and social economic status and genetics. Goal The goal of this topic is to use health communication strategies and health information technology to improve population health outcomes and health care quality, and to achieve health equity. Researched Literature Based on my research, health literacy is a priority for

Family Violence

2591 words - 11 pages , sexually transmitted infections, chronic pelvic pain and stomach ulcers (Healthy People, 2010).The Eby article revealed that much of the abuse was physical in nature all of the symptoms revealed in Healthy People 2010, along with gynecological problems (Eby, 2004).Nursing intervention strategies applicable to Family violenceMany barriers exist to implementing intimate partner violence screening programs. Health care providers have difficulty

Legislative Testimony and Health Disparities - Geneseo, NSG 559 - Nursing Leadership

2153 words - 9 pages Disparities that Contribute to Decrease Access to Primary Care among the Hispanic Immigrant Population There are many complex barriers that contribute to decrease access to primary care among Hispanic immigrants in the United States. Three of the notable barriers are immigration status, lack of English proficiency and low socio-economic status. The first obstacle Hispanic immigrants face when attempting to access primary health care is their