Reasons For The Pilgrimage Of Grace School Essay

2418 words - 10 pages

Urjaa
Using your understanding of the historical context, assess how convincing the arguments in these three extracts in relation on the reasons for the outbreak of the Pilgrimage of Grace
Extract A is convincing to a certain extent in relation to arguing the reasons for the outbreak of the Pilgrimage of Grace. Its main argument is that the rebellion “at heart, the work of a political faction which utilised social, economic and religious grievances”. So, the extract argues the political aspect of the situation led to the cohesion of all the other factors, so the political aspect was the underlying reason for the Pilgrimage of Grace. This is contextually accurate to an extent, as in the Lincolnshire Pontefract in December 1536, it referred to legitimising Mary I and restoring the See of Rome authority (papal authority). Clearly showing there are some religious connotations in the some of the demands, but the underlying fact of these demands are about political issues and the national affairs. So, extract A is convincing to a certain extent as it is contextually accurate to deem political reasons were associated with the pilgrimage of grace.
Furthermore there is contextual evidence to support the Elton’s thoughts (historian of extract A) to say there was a “faction” as those who lead the Pilgrimage were not Northerners but in fact based London, named Darcy and Hussey and were in fact members of the court circle (Mary’s group) and to elaborate further on the political factional proposal from extract A it was clear from the concerns of certain religious policies that would point to simply a political faction. For example, many of the gentry class were concerned with the councillors’ religious policies such as Cranmer, Rich and Cromwell religious policies on divorce. This obviously points to a political faction as clearly these are councillors of the King which no commoner would no but the upper class i.e. the gentry class would only know about. So, this contextual knowledge supports the extract’s A argument that the reason for the outbreak of the pilgrimage of grace was due to a political faction igniting it and not the mass of the northerners.
Additionally, there is contextual evidence to support the fact that the political faction (aragonese the gentry class) were in fact utilising the socio-economic and religious grievances in order to threaten and attack the King. For instance, parish registers were added to the churches and it made the commoners fearful that there would be tax collectors and new taxation laws, this was especially manipulated by the gentry class as they could refer to 1525 of Henry’s amicable grant as that point henry disturbed the locality of taxation as he did not go through parliament to take tax from the gentry and nobility. So clearly the gentry political faction would be able to manipulate the commoners and insinuate the new taxation laws for marriages and burials within the church the commoners would have to pay for, so...

Other Essays On Reasons for the pilgrimage of Grace - School - Essay

WW1 The Reasons For Involvement And It's Key Players

1051 words - 5 pages WW1Though there are many causes for different countries to have entered World War I, some of the main reasons were heightened nationalism, economic interest through colonial rivalry, and a balance of power in Europe. Key players were the Central powers consisting of Germany, Italy, and Austria-Hungary; the Allies, a few of which were France, Great Britain and Russia.Europe was in the grip of nationalism in 1914. It was brought about by the

Critical Analysis of Samuel by Grace Paley - Georgia Piedmont/English - Essay

470 words - 2 pages Haughton 1 Giselle Haughton Professor Alexander-Thomason English 1102-20549 18 September 2018 Critical Analysis of Samuel Often times in life we tend to do things for the enjoyment of ourselves and peers with disregards to any awful outcomes. This was evident in the book Samuel by Grace Paley. A group of young boys were recklessly playing on the platform of subway cars when suddenly one falls off and dies. His mother is left with grief as she

"Wants" By Grace Paley And "The Collector Of Treasures" By Bessie Head

801 words - 4 pages In the short stories "Wants" by Grace Paley and "The Collector of Treasures" by Bessie Head they both have powerful similarities with the male characters. The men are often portrayed in stories as the providers, but in these stories they are liars, inconsiderate and selfish. These men behave as if they were the only ones in their families and act only to calm their cravings for something other than what their families can offer.In Bessie Head's

essay for the absolutely true diary of a part time indian - Cupertino High School - Essay

548 words - 3 pages reservation to be successful. A few days before this happened, Arnold throws his new geometry book at Mr. P’s face because of his disappointment after looking at his first geometry book which was about thirty years old. As a result, Arnold was suspended from school for a week. During his suspension, Mr. P goes to Arnold’s house to have a talk with him. Mr. P tells Arnold that he is the only one with hope on the reservation but he will have to

To what extent did life improve for African Americans after the abolishment of slavery? - School - Essay

1757 words - 8 pages ‘Life improved for African Americans after the abolition of slavery?’ 1865-1900 Assess the validity of this view. In many ways’ life did improve for African Americans after slavery. However, there was always something that meant they were never completely free and equal to the rest of society. In this essay I will be evaluating whether African Americans experienced a better life after slavery. The 13th, 14th and 15th amendments had a significant

One.tel colllapse. It describes how One.tel colllapsed. The reasons behind its demise - university of wollongong - assignment

1028 words - 5 pages 41% in 1996-97, 54% in 1997-98, 52% in 1998-99 and 46% in 1999-2000 though overall audit quality didn’t improve at all. As a result of the above reasons, in 2001, One.Tel was forced to get closed and was liquidated. on 25 May 2001, the last trading day for One-Tel, its shares closed at Australian 16 cents. The fundamental problem at One.Tel was their interest in chasing low yield business and not caring about the cash reserve and keep enough to

Literary essay for the Kite Runner - School 20, English - Essay

1465 words - 6 pages father’s image by saving Amir when he was getting beaten up. Assef is the antagonists of the novel because he always bullies Amir and Hassan and he always tries to hurt them when he has a chance. He joins the Taliban and he makes Sohrab dance for him but he hurts Hassan the most by raping him. The environment that these characters grew up influenced their self morality and they personality for the good and the bad of the world.In the novel ​The

Nat Turner and the reasons behind on why he did what he did - MSJC /History - Essay on a historical figure

625 words - 3 pages Cordova1 Esmeralda Cordova Professor L.Rash History 25 March 2019 Nat Turner, A Slave Insurrection From being a sweet, religious, innocent child, who was noticed for his manners, Nat Turner turned out to be the biggest mass murder of all slave rebellions in history. However, all this happened due to the fact that one day he claimed he heard loud noises up above in the heavens saying that the serpent was loosened and that it was his

Reasons for Civil War Articles - David M. Potter and Micheal F. Holt Comparison - Austin Peay State University/History 2010 36 - Essay

1317 words - 6 pages of the land but the North wanted abolishment while the South did not. Others thought its cause was not directly the conflict of slavery or sectionals but a variety of other reasons. Some historians feel that the Civil War was a result of political mistakes and that slavery did not cause it at all. Several others believe the expansion of slavery, and its entrance into the political scene was the real causation. In “The Sectional Divisions That Led

The Declaration of Independence - school - essay

1005 words - 5 pages statement showing the colonists resolve to be free of English rule. The Declaration of Independence was the starting point for the United States effectively serving its purpose, making it the most important document in history. Thomas Jefferson the author of the Declaration of Independence was a well-educated man graduating from The College of William and Mary in 1762. Born in Virginia 1743, Jefferson went to school learning French, Greek and Latin

Memour of my first day of school for creative writing class - Silvestri Creative writing - Essay

1489 words - 6 pages ready or prepared for this day. I went outside, because now everyone inside was running around like chickens with their heads cut off. Going outside it felt hot and dry, but of course it did we did move to Las Vegas, which is a desert after all. Then it started to remind me of home, cloudy and a breeze of fresh cold air. Home sickness was the worst. I missed my friends, my family, and believe it or not my school. I felt the horrible stress when i

Similar Papers

The Reasons For Hitlers Rise To Power History Essay

1603 words - 7 pages The reasons for Hitler’s rise to power essay 1. The treaty of Versailles 2. Weaknesses in the Weimar republic= hyperinflation, occupation of the Ruhr, the great depression, economic downturn, fear of communism, wall st crash, extremism on the rise 3. Nazi party organisation, Hitler appealed to all classes, being able to deal will the communists, SA, Harzburg front 4. Tactical skills 5. Hitler Role of Hindenburg- used article 48, authoritarian

Reasons For The Liberal Social Welfare Reforms History Assignment/Essay

1411 words - 6 pages Reasons for the Liberal Social Welfare Reforms Context For most of the 19th century, most people believed in ‘laissez-fraire’ and accepted that poverty and hardship were not things the government could or should do anything about. However, the Liberal Government (led by Prime Minister Herbert Asquith and Chancellor of the Exchequer David Lloyd George) introduced a range of social welfare reforms to help alleviate the poverty and hardship suffered

Assessing The Reasons Why Henry Vii Was Able To Reduce The Power Of The Nobility Dhahran School / Grade 11 Essay

1066 words - 5 pages superiority. In spite of this, it is apparent that Henry did however still succeed in one of his principle foreign policy aims, that of dissuading the European nations from harbouring pretenders. Part of the Treaty of Etaples stated that France would offer no further support for the pretender Perkin Warbeck, demonstrating clear success for Henry. With the French no longer backing Warbeck, Henry could now feel secure on the throne. As a result, he began to

“Explain The Reasons Why The Australian Imperial Force (Aif) Failed To Achieve Victory At Gallipoli” School Essay

1049 words - 5 pages “Explain the reasons why the Australian Imperial Force (AIF) failed to achieve victory at Gallipoli” The Australian Imperial Force was the main expeditionary force of the Australian army in World War I. The campaign at Gallipoli in 1915 is regarded as one of the most spectacular failures of World War One. Numerous reasons evidently state why the AIF failed to achieve victory in Gallipoli. The AIF had a poor understanding of the nature of the