This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Response To Dharmasiri's "A Buddhist Critique"

598 words - 3 pages

To utilize a Buddhist perspective and to quote the Buddha for the purpose of constructing an evaluation of theism seems to me singularly inappropriate, if only for the mere fact that these Buddhist beliefs are taken out of context. Early in "A Buddhist Critique," the author, Gunapala Dharmasiri, states, "it is the context that gives religious statements their meaning" (Kessler 1999, p.116). However, contrary to this professed belief, he continues on to draw from the Buddhist canon examples that are distorted when not viewed in light of other essential Buddhist beliefs.Thus, Dharmasiri becomes caught up in his own trap by citing Buddhist examples out of context. For example, the author calls upon the fact that, though others ...view middle of the document...

A man has been struck by a poison arrow and he is dying. When a physician comes to him and offers to remove the arrow, the man says " No, I won't let you take out the arrow, until you tell me the name of the man who shot me, what class he comes from, what his family is, what kind of material the arrow is made of, etc. Such a man will die before the arrow is removed. (Lanka On-line, March 4, 2002) The parable illustrates the Buddhist belief that contemplating the origin of the universe, the idea of a Supreme Creator, and other such theistic subjects, is futile because it does not provide people with the path to salvation. This does not mean that the Buddha forthrightly rejected the belief in a Supreme Being-he merely did not see it as functional.Apart from the above-stated example, others are to be found in the text that depart from the primary Buddhist belief that the origins do not matter, rather it is the outcome that is significant. Thus, in utilizing the Buddhist dogma to argue theism, Dharmasiri is contradicting himself by taking the former ideas out of context and by forgetting that "original" Buddhism can be explained as an eight-step plan to attaining salvation with the Buddha as a physician figure and with no thought to the past or to origins, be it of the world or of God.Works Cited Dharmasiri, Gunapala. "A Buddhist Critique." In Philosophy of Religion. Gary E. Kessler, ed. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth Publishing Company. Pp. 115-122.Lanka-Online. The Man Struck by the 'Poison Arrow'. Lanka On-line. March 4, 2002. http://www.lanka.com/dhamma/dhamma/man_struck_by_the.htm

Other Essays On Response To Dharmasiri's "A Buddhist Critique"

The king and I had land

403 words - 2 pages Olivia MullinsLIT 2100LIT 2100 Students10 Oct. 2014Second Essay InstructionsA critique is a formal evaluation of a text, and one of the most common forms of critique in literature is the review. In a review, you - as the reviewer - get to evaluate the text. For your 2nd essay, choose one of the novels I've assigned to review. Your 4-6-page review should include quotations from the text wherein you will cite your sources according to MLA

Buddha Essay

905 words - 4 pages the overall ideals that Buddhists must achieve. Also, he laid out an Eight Fold Path to help the Buddhist find his way to nirvana step-by-step. Yet, the notion of avoiding destruction of living objects is slightly difficult for me to understand. Since followers of Buddhist teachings do not believe in harming others, the suffering is not only mutual among the believers but is shown to all. As a Christian, the concept of not causing harm to the

Buddhism: An Ordered Way Of Life

1623 words - 7 pages or Observance day. These days are held on the full moon, the new moon, and the quarter moons. There are neither rites of passage nor a special ceremony in becoming Buddhist. There is a long process of disciplinary training and education given to those seeking to become a monk (Bhikkhu). Anyone seeking to become a Bhikkhu is know as a novice. There is a ceremony that happens between the novice, the abbot (head of the monastery) and the Sangha

Hinduism

476 words - 2 pages reincarnated they would be in a higher level. When bad deeds are done in their next life they would be brought down to a higher religion. Hinduism is large and has approximately 726 million believers. Buddhism is a religion that does not believe in God or any type of Gods. Buddhist believe in reincarnation, the theory of being born, living, and dying many times. After many times of being reincarnated, once one releases their attachment to desire

Abortion And Euthanasia. How Different Religions View Such Practices

1178 words - 5 pages against euthanasia. Cardinal Clancy refers to it as either 'murder or suicide'. To the church any act that brings about a persons death is the same as murder. It the Catechism of the Catholic church it states that 2324'euthanasia, whatever its form or motives, is murder'.Buddhism teaches that the first moral precept of refraining from destroying life should be observed. Mr Graime Lyall, of the Buddhist council of N.S.W takes the stand that the

Hinduism vs. Buddhism

528 words - 3 pages other hand, Buddhist are allowed to change their social class. They can go from a slave to an emperor, if that is their calling. If they follow the Eightfold Path, then this is allowed. It is honorable to be a monk or a nun, because they have reached nirvana. Buddhists are also allowed to associate with people in lower social classes.Another one of the many differences is the way that each religion practices meditation. A Hindu meditates to

Buddhism: Case Study - Continuity, Change And Globalisation In Buddhsim

708 words - 3 pages encouraged Buddhists to help and teach other people, though the Nan Tien Temple did not quite display this belief. I feel that, from my personal experience (prior to studying Buddhism) that Buddhism has not had a great impact on the wider society. I think that this is immediately linked to the lack of knowledge about Buddhism. It seems that, while there are Buddhist groups in Australia, generally Australian society feels no great need for another

How Do We Know If God Exists

250 words - 1 page the same sense in which anything else exists but in a sense peculiar to himself. Logically, however, this is no different from saying that God does not exist." Works Cited Kolak and Martin, "The Experience of Philosophy" Wadsworth Publishing, 1999 Kaufmann, "Critique of Religion and Philosophy" Princeton University Press, 1986 Aquinas' Five Ways was taken from "Core Questions in Philosophy" by Elliott Sober

A Critical Analysis Of A Review Of The Film 'I Am Sam'

636 words - 3 pages had been somehow corrupted. The critic is somehow correct but to claim that all the film's weaknesses smothered it is outlandish, it is undeniable that in the two key relationships melodrama did pay a part. However, the characters would have seemed unrealistic and emotionally dead, it is hard to imagine any of the characters involved in lawsuit not showing the sort of emotion they were displaying in the film.Berardinelli's critique is

Religion In Tibet

1508 words - 7 pages How does the Buddhist religion tie in with the Tibetans, affect their cultural society in modern day, and through out the generations? Buddhism was born from the Hindu religion during the Axis period around 563-483 B.C.E. " Buddha was born Siddhartha Gautama, a prince of the Sakya tribe of Nepal, in approximately 566 BC. When he was twenty-nine years old, he left the comforts of his home to seek the meaning of the suffering he saw around him

Consistent Perseverance

615 words - 3 pages Consistent Perseverance"You gain strength, courage and confidence by every experience in which you really stop to look fear in the face. You must do the thing you think you cannot do."-Eleanor RooseveltPhi Theta Kappa is a group of students who are honored for achieving a cornerstone as they embark on their journey of education and flourish in the years to come. As stewards of leadership and radiant lanterns of success, they are qualified to

Similar Papers

A Response To A Paragraph In Oedipus

543 words - 3 pages Men of Thebes: look upon Oedipus.This is the king who solved the famous riddleAnd towered up, most powerful of men.No mortal eyes but booked on him with envy,Yet in the end ruin swept over him.The first half of the ending of the Sophocles shows the rising action, climax and the falling action of the tragedy. It implies the definition of tragedy: One of high station due to a flaw (Hamatia) in Oedipus' character meets his demise. When Thebes is

A Response To "Of Studies" An Essay By Sir Francis Bacon

545 words - 3 pages , as he goes on to explain what type of study, books, reading and writing he considers essential and what type he regards dispensable. Sir Francis believes that expert men can execute and judge in a very orderly fashion, bearing in mind the details; but, general direction, planning and management of affairs come best from the learned. Also, he says that reading is important, but only to weigh and contemplate issues. Moreover, he states that while

How The Future Looked In 1899 An Essay In Response To A Newsweek Article Citing Ninteenth Century Predictions Of How The Future Will Be

607 words - 3 pages In the past century, humans have progressed through technology, medicine, and society. We have made flying machines, cars, lasers, rocket ships and things we could not even imagine a century ago. In fact, one hundred years ago people still only had a small idea of what was to come. Some imagined that we would have moving streets that would "whoosh people and stuff around". Others thought that poverty would be exterminated and the middle class

Syliva Plath Using The Poems "Daddy" And "The Arrival Of The Bee Box," Write A Poetry Response To Plath's Works Noting The Language And Imagery

974 words - 4 pages this appears to inform the reader that no longer will she put up with the 'black shoe'. Though, as the poem progresses, we see emotions see- sawing and no longer do we feel that the speaker of the poem has the power, no matter how hard they try to gain it. In the line "I have always been scared of you", we are shown that the speaker admits that their father had a clear hold on them, and that he actually had the ability to control their emotions. We