Reunion And Reconciliation; The Odyssey And The Iliad U Mass, Greek Civilization Essay

1301 words - 6 pages

Reunion and Reconciliation; a Quest to Restore the Home
The Odyssey and the Iliad are often compared as they share many similar themes and motifs revolving around two warriors in a pursuit of rising to heroic wrath. Book 24 of the Iliad and 23 of the Odyssey parallel with overarching themes regarding divine intervention, anger, and family with each of these themes encompassing a degree of irony that is crucial in contrasting both epics. As visitors to unwelcoming homes, Priam and Odysseus must work to infiltrate a very protected inner circle and the outcomes are ironically foreshadowed by the climatic battles that led them there—hector begs to be granted his honor from Achilles and the suitors beg for forgiveness. The final chapters reflect on how these last wishes have transferred over to Priam and Odysseus. As they struggle to make amends with Achilles and Penelope, they are reminded that they must also fight for honor and forgiveness.
Priam and Odysseus both look to the gods, hoping that they can aid them in their quest for reconciliation. For Priam, this assistance highlights the abilities of his mortal strength. In his quest to retrieve his son’s corpse, he is supported by the gods on Mount Olympus as they have watched in horror while Hectors body has been dragged each day only to be left face down in the dust (Il. 24.21). With great pity for a prince, Apollo sways the other gods to grasp the misfortune that have brought upon the city of Troy by choosing to help Achilles who in their view outranks Hector. However, the “almighty” Achilles has brought shame to the Divine world with such childish actions that the gods cannot help but pity hector. Apollo exposes him for who he really is, “a man without a shred of decency in his heart…his temper can never bend and change,” equaling him to the barbaric ways of a lion—his wild temper overpowering his grasp on humanity (Il.24.46). Once a prince, Hector has now been mistreated and stripped of his honor, therefore, the gods band together to grant Priam of his final wish—to hold his son once more and weep his fill (Il.24.271). First visited by Iris, followed by Hermes, the gods have come down to earth to reassure Priam of their intentions and more essentially their knowledge of Priam’s ability to stir Achilles’ heart; forcing or merely tricking him into emitting kindness.
Help is given to Odysseus by the goddess Athena, however, instead of leading him down a road towards triumph she helps more clearly define his limitations as a mortal man. Odysseus has become a master of trickery by the end of his journey and as he prepares to face Penelope—a woman who knows him better than he knows himself—he still falls back on an attempt to mislead her because it is all he has known for the last 20 years. He is foolish to believe that he can deceive everyone in Ithaka because even the maid Eurykleia could recognize him by his scar—a stark imperfection setting any mortal apart from the gods (Od.23.74). Athena ascends to aid him in his performance, suffusing him with great beauty she makes him taller, thicker, and with curling locks hanging down from his head—"gilding him with grace,” she transforms him to appear immortal (Od.23.156-163). By making him appear godlier than he did when Penelope last saw him, she is cautious to believe it could actually be him. Her loyalty to him is so strong that her worst fear is betraying him, so consequently Athena’s help is further exemplifying his mortal restraints on manipulating the people around him. Instead of divine intervention benefiting the mortals in this position, Penelope fears this deception as the gods tricking her into disloyalty to her husband—resisting the will of the gods proves her overwhelming devotion to her husband over any inclination of divinity.
Interestingly enough, in order to be loyal to her husband, Penelope must be at first disloyal in a different way—acting as if she doesn’t love him. Here, Penelope is embodying one of the main themes of the epic; disguise and reversals. As she disguises her feelings towards this “stranger” she is reversing roles with him without even knowing it. To be loyal, she must act disloyal; to love him, she must act as though she doesn’t, and acting this way towards Odysseus causes him to act out in anger. In this instance we see Odysseus in a fit of rage for the first time—known as a “planner”, things not going how he expected can wreak havoc on everyone around him. Ironically, Odysseus is unable to handle his anger in this scene, and calls Penelope stubborn; a woman with a heart of iron (Od.23.172), but when Priam tries to break through to Achilles, he ends up taming the “murderous” Achilles’ inner beast. This contrasts what Apollo stated about him earlier in the chapter about his fixed temper as Achilles even warns him to not anger him for his temper flaring could lead to bad things. This sense of warning—sense of caution—is a complete role reversal for Achilles, and even with a forceful visitor entering into his hut he exhibits a sense of civility for the first time since his dear friend Patroclus was killed. Achilles is not cured of his anger but in offering such a truce he is willing to reconcile for the actions that his anger led him to.
The way in which Achilles reconciles with Priam, brings forth the deep-rooted love that he has for his father. Watching Priam strip himself of his pride by kneeling before the man whose “terrible hands” stripped him of his son, Achilles is reminded of the loss he has endured by taking part in this tragic war (Il.24.599). Reminded of his own father, the two weep together; finally seeing eye to eye. He knows he will never see his father, Peleus, again but more importantly, that his father will never see his son again. He envisions Priam’s anguish on the face of his own father, and that overwhelming sorrow strikes him like the sword he so forcefully used to kill Hector. In this moment, he pities Priam but also understands why he is greatly valued by the kingdom of Troy—he stands as a father figure to everyone. His ransom is priceless for what he has endured and the two resolve their conflict, at least for the time being, and put their grief to rest in their own hearts (Il.24.591-610). The theme of family runs deeply in both of these epics and instead of Odysseus losing his son—he gains him back. Telemachus accepts Odysseus back into his life with much more ease than Penelope, but in order for Odysseus to fully make amends with his family as a whole, he must reconcile with his father who has grieved for him constantly (Od.23.359). The father figure is very prominent between both of these stories and proves that even a great warrior has someone with whom they look upon as greater than themselves. The importance of the love between father and son is far greater than any warrior’s wrath.
Even though there are many similarities, the main disparities between the two epics come into play at the end. For the Odyssey, disguise and reversal, and in contrast, the end of the Iliad highlights genuineness and a bold straightforwardness that really sets the two stories apart. With divine intervention, or lack thereof, these epics illustrate how the gods can only go so far and it comes down to a warrior himself to set things straight with others around him but also in his heart. Both Priam and Odysseus have risen to the same heights of heroic wrath by rehabilitating the nuclear family unit in order to bring stability to their kingdoms.

RELATED

Essay On "The Iliad" And "Lysistrata"

918 words - 4 pages Free Great kings and powerful warriors engage in heroic duels with each other to gain massive power, while a group of women take a vow of abstinence until a war has ended. Two different pictures of war are depicted in "The Iliad" by Homer and "Lysistrata" by Aristophanes."The Iliad" is a poem which is believed to be a collection of stories handed down through many generations but not of just one man. It is a story of the Trojan War and the leaders of

Greek hero in the Iliad similar or different from the concept of the modern hero? - Nassau Community College, History - Essay

1448 words - 6 pages “How is the role of the Greek hero in the Iliad similar or different from the concept of the modern hero?” Provide specific examples Since early in our lives, we are introduced the concept of a hero from stories we are told by our parents and family members. These personages are usually described as fearless and righteous individuals who spend their lives in constant battles and confrontations with people and situations that try to push them to

Describe the responses of individuals, groups and governments in Australia to the challenge of reconciliation

613 words - 3 pages During the century of nationhood, reconciliation has been an ongoing issue in Australia. Reconciliation means different things to people, but a common understanding is that all Australians deserve to have equal life opportunities, and that genuine reconciliation will only exist when indigenous disadvantage has been eliminated. Many steps have been made along the road to reconciliation as a result of the positive responses of individuals, groups

Be Truthful Or Else----Essay On "The Odyssey" And "Medea" Compared And Contrasted

1697 words - 7 pages be. Odysseus is trustful throughout the Odyssey, but lies when he must to help others, whereas Jason is nothing but a sneaky, deceitful liar who in the process hurts his wife and brings horror upon himself. Throughout the Odyssey, written by Homer, and Medea, written by Euripides, we will truly see Odysseus' and Jason's true colors.In "The Odyssey", Odysseus is truthful to his family and friends. Although Odysseus is truthful, there are many

This Is An Essay On The Woman In The Odyssey And Their Influences On His Travels

993 words - 4 pages The Odyssey is an epic about a Greek warrior in the Trojan War whose wanderings around his known world and his perilous encounters are the basis of the story. Odysseus' absence from his home is prolonged by the influences of the women whom he encounters.In this epic, several female characters had a profound effect on the plot. They wielded their influence through typically feminine skills and attributes: seduction, supernatural powers

Comparison of "The Odyssey" and "O' Brother Where Art Thou"

427 words - 2 pages one eyed man.In both movies the Cyclops kills both characters friend. However, in O' Brother, the one eyed man was thought to have killed his friend, but he realized later that he didn't. Odysseus thinks that he doesn't need the god's help, but learns in the end that he does. Ulysses is cocky and thinks he doesn't need God. Nevertheless, in the end he too, learns that he does and prays for God to help him.In the Odyssey, Odysseus meets the blind

Relationships Between Gods And Mortals As Demonstrated In The Odyssey

1096 words - 5 pages their part to show respect for the gods through methods such as prayer and sacrifice, which are both evident in The Odyssey. However, in some cases, it seems that such respect was mutual, as demonstrated by some of the relationships portrayed by Homer. One such relationship was between Odysseus and Athena. The latter develops an extensive bond with the mere mortal because she sees herself in him. Due to this, she helps Odysseus out on many

Analysis of A New Account of Some Parts of Guinea and the Slave Trade - European Civilization - Essay

822 words - 4 pages Beginning in the mid-fifteenth century, mass numbers of Portuguese ships sailed southward along the West African coast, bringing back slaves and gold. European expansion grew at a faster rate with voyages of Christopher Columbus and Vasco De Gama. With time, other European entities, including the Dutch, British, and French, joined in the process of expansion. Slave trade was a system that involved the dehumanizing of Africans. When one reads

Interaction between Calypso and Odysseus in 'The Odyssey' - English - Assignment

562 words - 3 pages Free During their last meal together, Calypso makes Odysseus an incredible offer. Describe this offer and Odysseus’ reply. What does this convey about his character and about the values, attitudes, and beliefs of ancient Greek Society? During their last meal together, Calypso attempts to coax Odysseus into staying with her by offering him eternal life on a beautiful island with a lustrous goddess. “Stay right here, preside in our house with me,” she

Alcoholics Anonymous and Spirituality Analysis - UMass Lowell/ Psychiatric Nursing - Essay

1205 words - 5 pages Running head: THE POWER OF POWERLESSNESS 1 2 THE POWER OF POWERLESSNESS The Power of Powerlessness Miranda Lombardo University of Massachusetts Lowell Author Note This paper was prepared for Psychiatric Nursing Clinical NURS. 3150, taught by Professor Kathleen Courtney. The Power of Powerlessness The founders of Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) believed that “a power greater than ourselves could restore us to sanity” (Twelve Steps and Twelve Traditions

Judaism And Western Civilization

820 words - 4 pages Judaism and Western CivilizationThe basic contribution of Judaism to Western civilization is monotheism. Understood from the standpoint of Jewish tradition, Abraham was the first monotheist. He left polytheism behind to follow the directions of the one God. The Tanakh itself gives evidence that significant numbers of ancient Israelites worshipped multiple deities.(Rabbi Shofet) Jewish leadership called upon Israel to worship the one God with

The Iliad Is The Poem Of Beautiful Death, While The Odyssey Is The Poem Of Timeworn, Embraceable Life. Do You Agree With This Statement?

1693 words - 7 pages In this paper I intend to argue against the quote "The Iliad is the poem of beautiful death, while the Odyssey is the poem of timeworn, embraceable life". The story of the Iliad essentially revolves around the Trojan War and multiple battle scenes are included, which would suggest that it does paint a beautiful picture of death. The attitude, however, of many of the characters is not one that glorifies death and war but rather one that laments

The Amalgamation Of Science And Technology: An Essay About The Factors And Events That Lead To The Development Of Science From The Greek Period To The Scientific Revolution

4258 words - 18 pages science only become clear when modern science is compared with Western Science in earlier periods.The ancient Greek alphabet was a marvelous piece of mechanism, the result of thousands of years of intellectual effort. It distinguished itself from the alphabetical system adopted by other cultures by having a minimal set of alphabets making possible for the first time education of the masses upon which all later progress of civilization was so

The Odyssey, Oedipus the King and the Human Condition - Auburn ENGL 2200 - Assignment

1702 words - 7 pages Greek literature on human condition. The Odyssey, Homer’s immortal epic, and Oedipus the King, Sophocles’ splendid tragedy, are outstanding examples exhibiting the long insights of ancient Greeks about human life and beliefs based on their culture, knowledge and wisdom of the time. On the one hand, the Odyssey is a story of a lost hero’s journey of returning home and retrieving his identity. On the other hand, Oedipus the King is a tragedy of a man

comparison on odyssey and holden - english - essay

606 words - 3 pages English Department Literary Character Roundtable Grades 9 and 10 A Block December 19, 2018 Groups of 7 characters will have about 30 minutes for their roundtable discussion. Within each 30 minute session each character will introduce self (1-2 minutes), and then the moderator will ask a series of questions of the group. Each student must respond (in character) to each of the questions, ideally commenting upon what they have heard from others as