Rhetorical Analysis

1272 words - 6 pages

Rhetorical Analysis of Two PSAIt was interesting to read that the Keep America Beautiful ad was aired on Earth Day in 1971. I was not alive at that time, but pollution was a heavy issue at the time. The recent Canadian PSA was aired in 2006 and I feel focuses on the environment on a broader outlook. The Native American actor, Iron Eyes Cody, was a movie actor at the time. It was interesting to find out that he became the face of environmental consciousness in the 1970's. The reason that Public Service Announcements started being aired was to get the general public's attention on issues going on in the world. These ads are on common ground in the effect to catch the viewer's attention, but with them being aired forty-five years apart it also makes them very different. Technology has obviously changed drastically in the forty-five year span and affects the quality of the video. The target audience on these ads is drastically different and can change the effectiveness of them as a whole. Pollution and littering, in my opinion, are sub topics of the global warming problem. I feel that these two ads have much in common, but also differ completely.Technology of different timesCommercial technology has advanced in an amazing way in the past fifty years. Watching these two ads is a perfect example of this advancement. Keeping America Beautiful is very basic with Iron Eyes paddling down the river in his canoe. He then gets out of his canoe and walks by the highway only to get a bag of trash thrown in his face. Regardless of the effectiveness of this PSA, it was probably a much cheaper PSA compared to the Canadian WWF ad. The WWF ad used computer graphics and was able to contrast people walking down the street in a hurricane, as if it was a clear sunny day. The ad showed a family camping in the woods with a forest fire right behind them, all while a family's house and car are under water and they are outside doing summer activities. I am sure that nowadays plugging people into drastic looking conditions is not as expensive as it once was, but it is a technology that did not exist when Keeping America Beautiful was aired. I don't think that the PSA budget has anything to do with the effectiveness of the ad. We can see proof of this in the drug PSA that shows the egg frying in a pan. That ad required an egg and pan and in my eyes was probably the most effective PSA I, personally, have ever watched. Regardless of the PSA budget, it is the message that is portrayed to the public that matters the most.The audience of the PSA mattersTarget audience is probably the highest priority in commercials. There is a reason that you don't see beer commercials on Nickelodeon and why toy ads don't appear on ESPN. The ad is meant to catch the attention of the age group that will most likely be the viewers. I believe the bigger the target audience, the effective an ad will be. In my opinion, Keeping America Beautiful has a much broader target audience than the Canadian PSA. I believe that Keeping America Beautiful could catch the attention of a five and ninety five year old. The ad is very simple and I think a 5 year old could watch this and understand that littering can destroy America. I think the message clearly states that littering is bad and that is can be stopped by only us. In comparison, the Canadian PSA I feel has a higher educated target audience due to the global warming subject. I know that when I was much younger that I would have had no clue what global warming even was, much less understand what this PSA was even trying to say. Again, I don't think that this has a direct effect on if gets the message across, I just feel that it is targeting a high school age and up audience. I saw the egg in a frying pan ad when I was very young, and there is a reason I remember it. It was a very simple PSA, yet caught my attention to remember 25 years later. Target audience is an important factor and although these ads are portraying the same general message, there is a significant difference in the audience these two Public Service Announcements are capturing.Two different similar messagesWikipedia defines a Public Service announcement as "messages in the public interest disseminated by the media without charge, with the objective of raising awareness, changing public attitudes and behavior towards a social issue. " I believe that regardless of the time gap that these messages portray a good general message, but in different ways. Obvious differences would be the quality of the picture. As I said earlier, technology is far more advances than it was in the 1970's. The model and year of the vehicles in Keeping America Beautiful are significantly older than in the more modern Canadian ad. The Canadian ad portrays the future showing that if Americans keep acting like global warming does not exist, than we will be living in constant disastrous conditions. It also shows the people in the ad going on with there everyday lives in these horrible conditions as to show them still not acknowledging the issues. Keeping America Beautiful presents more of a present time frame. Iron Eyes Cody begins by rowing his canoe in, what looks like, a beautiful body of water only to have him end up in a nasty polluted industrial part of the water. It then shows Iron Eyes pull up to shore and start walking along the highway. He is looking around and it appears he is showing disgust in his face, right before a bag of trash is thrown at him from a passing car. It ends with a simple tear rolling down his face to express his disappointment in what America has come. Again, although one shows the future and one shows the present, both present a similar message that the environment must be acknowledged. The similarities and differences in these two ads were interesting to analyze, but I feel the main goal of PSA are still exactly the same as they were in 1971.Public Service Announcements is a term that most Americans understand and forty-five years ago it was no different. Besides technology and the quality of the how the actual PSA looks, PSA's still are addressing issues that are going on in this time era. As this paper shows, PSAs can address a broad subject such as global warming or it can get more specific with a subtopic like littering and pollution. In the end, Public Service Announcements are produced to catch the viewer's attention on a certain topic. There are many different ways to get a similar message across and these two ads are evidence of that.Works Cited"Public Service Announcement." Wikipedia: The Free Encyclopedia. Wikimedia Foundation, Inc. 22 July 2004. Web. 27 June 2013.

RELATED

rhetorical analysis paper jose rizal - english - essay

736 words - 3 pages Czarina Santos English 121 Rhetorical Analysis 3/12/18 Jose Rizal The colonization of the Philippines by Spain, also known as the Spanish Colonial Period, started with the arrival of European explorer Ferdinand Magellan who was sailing for Spain and the Spanish King in 1521. From 1521 to 1898 and for a total of 333 years, Spain had colonized and taken over the Philippines, sharing their culture, religion, and language. But this didn’t mean it

Rhetorical Analysis on Jack London's "Story of An Eyewitness" - Tennyson High, AP English - Rhetorical Analysis Essay

533 words - 3 pages Rios 1 Ana Rios Elliot AP English Language and Composition, Period 3 06 March 2018 Jack London’s “Story of An Eyewitness” Rhetorical Analysis Throughout all of its history, San Francisco has been one the most emblematic cities recognized around the world, as well as one that has seen many tragic events such as the earthquake of 1906, whose devastating aftermath ultimately destroyed the “Golden City” and menaced its citizenry. However, in “Story

Rhetorical Analysis on a Save The Oceans Ad - Class - Rhetorical Essay

1017 words - 5 pages Aramian 2 Sydney Aramian Professor Jex English 226: Rhetorical Analysis 15 June 2019 Save the Oceans The world population is living, working, vacationing, increasingly conglomerating along the coasts, and standing on the front row of the greatest, most unprecedented, plastic waste tide ever faced. Plastic wasn’t invented until the late 19th century, and production really only took off around 1950, we have a mere 9.2 billion tons of the stuff to

Rhetorical Analysis of a Speech - Effective Communication - Essay

770 words - 4 pages Running head: Rhetorical Analysis of a Speech 1 Rhetorical Analysis of a Speech 2 Rhetorical Analysis of a Speech Paulina Shirey Daytona College Rhetorical Analysis of a Speech On June 11, 1963 and March 15, 1965 two different presidents gave speeches that on the surface were about different topics, but at their core, were about civil rights in the United States. The early 1960’s were met with civil right movements that broke out that needed to

Rhetorical analysis short essay - highschool junior English - assignment

418 words - 2 pages Osier​ 1 Chad Osier Mrs. Aguirre CP English 8 January 2018 Rhetorical Analysis Essay Author and anti-slavery activist, Olaudah Equiano, explains how terrifying it was to board an over crowded slave ship to the new land. Equiano’s purpose is to display the unjust acts by slave owners in order to create a feeling of sorrow in the emotions of the reader. He adopts an emotional tone in order to reach out to the many future generations. Equiano

Rhetorical Analysis of a Speech - Chappaquiddick - English - Essay

834 words - 4 pages 1 Rhetorical Analysis of a Speech “A man does what he must – in spite of personal consequences, in spite of obstacles, and dangers, and pressures…” Senator Edward Kennedy said these words in 1969 on national television while giving his famous Chappaquiddick speech. Kennedy’s Chappaquiddick speech serves as a reminder to everyone that even great leaders have flaws and are capable of making mistakes. On July 18th, 1969, Kennedy drove his car into

Rhetorical Analysis on CDC website - Eng105/ Grand Canyon University - Essay

961 words - 4 pages 3 Jamessa Carroll ENG-105 December 5, 2018 Jan Wakefield-Darvas Rhetorical Analysis of CDC Webpage ADHD, is a typical neurological condition to a great extent analyzed in kids (National Institute of Mental Health, 2016). The turmoil is described by the subject's powerlessness to look after consideration, remain centered, and control their driving forces (National Institute of Mental Health, 2016). The Center for Disease Control and Prevention

Write a rhetorical analysis on a video of Neil Degrasse Tyson talking about god - English 1000 - Rhetorical Analysis

1640 words - 7 pages David Dobbler English 1000 Donish October 9th, 2018 Rhetorical Analysis Religion has always been in a touchy subject. This often makes it difficult to convey messages involving faith, especially when the message may hint at the fact that a God may not actually exist. In an interview with CBS, Neil deGrasse Tyson is asked, “Do you believe in god?” Tyson, a world renowned astrophysicists known for his public speaking and television shows where

Rhetorical Analysis between popular and academic disourse - comp 2 univeristy of arkansas - essay

955 words - 4 pages 2 Rhetorical Analysis There can be major differences in some cases between academic discourse and popular discourse. Differences between academic discourse and popular discourse can vary from the value to the length to the tone to sources used. Some cases of academic discourse and popular discourse may differ slightly or in some cases to an extreme in their approach such as a fact-based paper versus an opinion-based paper. It is important that

Pearl Harbor Address Franklin D. Roosevelt - Composition II - Rhetorical Analysis Essay

818 words - 4 pages Paper #1: Rhetorical Analysis In the "Pearl Harbor Address to the Nation," President Franklin D. Roosevelt presented a speech on the following day of December 7th, 1941 to formally propose to Congress and urge them to declare war on the Empire of Japan. (Roosevelt, Franklin D. “Pearl Harbor Address to the Nation.”) Prior to the bombing President Roosevelt had promised in his election campaign that they did not want to pursue in the war and would

Slippery Slopes: Media, Disability, and Adaptive Sports” - Vincennes University writing assignment - Rhetorical Analysis Essay

814 words - 4 pages Cullen 1 Abby Cullen Mr. Houston Period 2 9/5/2018 Rhetorical Analysis People with disabilities are shown in the media in a negative way. William J. Peace, the author of “Slippery Slopes: Media, Disability, and Adaptive Sports”, hopes to change the general public’s view in order to make disabilities not a bad thing. Peace’s use of diction, syntax, and testimonies conveys his feelings towards the public’s view of the disability community. Peace

The Hypocrisy of American Slavery: A Rhetorical Analysis - Lower Merion High School, AP Language and Composition - Essay

970 words - 4 pages Eve Bickel Mr. Mays AP Language and Composition 14 November 2018 The Hypocrisy of American Slavery: A Rhetorical Analysis A former slave, abolitionist, and American orator, Frederick Douglass, in his 1852 speech, “The Hypocrisy of American Slavery”, addresses the sanctimony of celebrating American independence while the prosperity of slavery runs rampant. Intentionally deriding American ideals of liberty and freedom, the purpose of Douglass

Rhetorical Analysis of MLK Jr's I Have A Dream Speeck - New Jersey Institute of Technology Humanities 101 - Essay

1543 words - 7 pages Baladithya Balamurugan Professor Margaret Yobbi 18 F – HUM 101045-Writing Speaking Thinking I 04 December 2018 Rhetorical Analysis Essay Over the course of a couple centuries since the founding of the United States, there existed a great many leaders whose support and adoration from their followers rivals that of a small religion. In the past half- century itself a man by the name of Martin Luther King Jr. called for civil and economic rights to

Rhetorical Analysis of Marijuana - College' Level - Essay

819 words - 4 pages Shubhav Baniya Professor Bridget A Draxler Writing 111 03/05/2018 The article ‘Association with Marijuana exposure: Facts, Fallacies, and Implications for Legalization’ is written by Mark Plether, M.D. The sole purpose of Plether’s article is to persuade readers and voters that marijuana should not be legalized. Plether focuses on the use of ethos and logos, while also slightly focusing on the use of pathos, to help persuade his audience. The use

Lathe of Heaven rhetorical analysis - English - Essay

1088 words - 5 pages Divine Favor Throughout history, rulers and conquerors alike have given all they have to give for one reward: power. Once the necessities of life have all been attained, there is little left to vie and compete for, aside from influence over others in one manner or another. Many successful humans inevitably find themselves scheming rebellions, groveling for power, killing others, and destroying previous ties. They do this in hopes of greater power