Romeo And Juliet: A Love Story? Monte Persuasive Speech

958 words - 4 pages

Ladies of year 10 at Monte Sant’ Angelo Mercy College, my name is Rose Eagleton and this year I’ve been to not one, not two, but three professional performances of William Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet. Romeo and Juliet is widely considered a beautifully tragic love story. Star-crossed lovers unable to be with each other just because their families are unable to overcome a century-long feud, so as an act of defiance they tragically die in each others arms. It brings a tear to everyone’s eye when Juliet wakes and we are all stunned as she takes her own life to be with the one she loves. But, after 3 performances, you start wonder, “Does she really love him?”, and if she doesn’t, then how can this possibly be the greatest love story of all time?
The obvious point to mention here is their ages. Juliet is “not quite fourteen” and Romeo, well, he is described as “young” and I think we can all agree that Romeo’s passion, romantic idealism and rashness indicates that he is still a fledgling in the grand scheme of things.
It was the summer of 2013. I, a fledgling myself, had a massive crush on a boy who lived in my neighbourhood. It was rather like Romeo and Juliet, to be honest. My parents said I was too young to date, but I told them that they couldn’t keep us apart – I was in love with him!
He texted me, so eloquently, saying, “r u free sat? do u wanna go 2 froyo?” I was so excited- I came five minutes early wearing my favourite dress and he rocked up late wearing boardies. We were so different, yet so meant to be together… Until 9 months later, when, after a disaster-filled first kiss, I broke up with him.
The thing about Romeo and Juliet is that, well, they didn’t know each other for 9 months. They knew each other for 4 days. I’m sure if you had asked me on that Saturday in 2013 if I would marry him, I probably would have said yes. But, 3 years and boatload of failed relationships later, I’m so glad I didn’t marry my first crush.
Romeo and Juliet married on the second day of their relationship. They were separated for the third and on the fourth they both died. Say they spent two hours together at the Capulet’s party, and then another hour at balcony, followed by a half an hour wedding and an hour “hanging out” afterwards, according to my calculations, they spent a total of 4.5 hours in each other’s company before dying for their love. To put that in perspective, that is half of a school day. That’d be like meeting someone in period 1, marrying them in period 2, sitting in separate groups at recess and then dying for each other period 3.
Not to mention, at the start of the play, moments before “falling in love” with Juliet, Romeo is in love with another woman. Dearest Rosaline, he described, “She’s fair I love,” [but], “She hath forsworn to love, and in that vow do I live dead that live to tell it now.” In fact, the only reason Romeo went to the Capulet’s party, the only reason Romeo even met Juliet in the first place, was so he could potentially capture a glimpse of his fair Rosaline. And therefore, could Juliet be considered a simple rebound? Could Romeo be so frustrated that his “one true love” had vowed to be celibate that he jumped on the nearest girl at the time? Sounds like a classic teenage boy to me.
Over the past 400 years, Romeo and Juliet’s story has become identified as the greatest love story of all time.
It has become almost a stock image of what true love is. It is a classic cliché. Star-crossed lovers. Think Orpheus and Eurydice, Jack and Rose, Anakin and Padme- all stories featuring the time old trope where lovers are destined to be apart. But I’m here to tell you, year 10, that this cliché does not make a good love story.
In fact, I believe that Romeo and Juliet is not a love story at all. It’s one of teenage rashness and illogical infatuation. Romeo and Juliet could not have been in love. It is simply not possible. This cliché story simply perpetuates the idea of love at first sight, but I’m here to tell you that, scientifically, you can not love someone within moments of meeting them, because the hormones that are released when you are in love with someone can take up to over 3 months to fully develop! So yes, Romeo and Juliet may have been infatuated with each other. They may have thought that they were in love. But realistically, Juliet could not have loved Romeo and Romeo could not have loved Juliet, no more than one might fall in love with a packet of chilli and sour cream chips.
So, ladies, please listen to me. Romeo and Juliet were not in love; they were simply infatuated by the mere idea of each other. I sound like a mother when I say this, but they were too young and they did not know each other well enough to be in love. Not to mention that Juliet was a mere rebound because Romeo was so frustrated that Rosaline wanted to remain abstinent. How can this possibly be considered a love story if the two main characters aren’t even in love? In conclusion, Romeo and Juliet is not a love story and, ladies of year 10, I implore you to not fall for this trope again.


Romeo And Juliet Of Sheakpear Is Not A Love Story.It Is A Story About Infatuation Of Young People

1116 words - 5 pages Untitled What is true love? Each people have each own view on love so we will have different answer for this question. For me, true love is feeling deep inside my heart that we need together and can not live without other, basing mutual understanding and sympathetic between 2 people…. Therefore, in my view on love, Romeo and Juliet of Shakespeare is not a love story, there is no love in it, and it's just a story about

love and obsession romeo and juliet - english - assignment

438 words - 2 pages Caught in a bad romance Two teen lovers in love? Or gruesome reality of what love and obsession can do to someone… Obsession can make you act irrationally, which can potentially end in dangerous consequences. This is what happened when two star crossed lovers, Romeo and Juliet, fall fatally in love with one another, followed with manifestations of fate bringing unavoidable death, conflict, tragedies, fights between religion and violence, all

Romeo and Juliet - love or infatuation - Grade 10 - Essay

400 words - 2 pages Romeo and Juliet – love or infatuation? The question of whether the emotion between Romeo and Juliet is one of true love or childish infatuation, is a difficult one to answer as their "violent delights has violent ends" in only three days. I conclude, however, that there is not a question that their ‘violent delight’ was an attraction based on physical love, rather than a lasting emotional attachment. It is thus my opinion that the emotion

Romeo & Juliet Persuasive Essay - English 9th - Essay

692 words - 3 pages impulsive. From the beginning, they knew that they were going into a toxic love which will lead into death,”For never was a story of more woe/Than this of Juliet and Romeo” (Romeo & Juliet 5.3.309-310). Romeo and Juliet had an idea that chaos would come and the would be demised by fate,”From the forth the fatal loins of these two foes/A pair of star-crossed lovers take their life” (Prologue 6-9). Fate does not play a big role in their lives

Who’s At Fault Romeo and Juliet Persuasive Essay - Connections Academy English - Persuasive Essay

463 words - 2 pages Free Urosevich 1 Urosevich 4 Mila Urosevich Mr. Sutton English 9B 4/16/18 Who’s At Fault: Romeo & Juliet Persuasive Essay Who is responsible for this tragedy!? A play written by William Shakespeare, Romeo and Juliet, is about two lovers from different families that fall in love, get married, then shortly after die, but who was the most responsible for the death of these two star crossed lovers?. I believe Friar Laurence is responsible for the deaths

Does Romeo and Juliet end in love or hate - St Augustine, 10 - Essay

924 words - 4 pages Question number 1: Romeo and Juliet is ultimately a love story and Shakespeare leaves audiences with an optimistic view of true love and its ability to overcome hate. Do you agree or disagree? Love can be presented in many different forms such as unrequited love, filial love, forbidden love, romantic love and sexual love. Love is a powerful emotion that can overcome hate, but hate cannot overcome love. Romeo and Juliet, written by William’s

What does Romeo and Juliet illustrate about the nature of love? Consider how the play portrays love - english - essay

1125 words - 5 pages their bill of rights and a comparison of their provisions for protection of privacy rights. The U.S. Constitution’s Bill of Rights and the Hawaii State Constitution’s Bill of rights are similar in their approach to outlining citizen’s protected rights. Like the U.S. Bill of Rights, Hawaiians are specifically guaranteed freedom of religion, speech, assembly, and petition. For example, in article 1.4 of the Hawaiian Bill of Rights, “No law shall be

ROmeo anmd juliet love anal sex - poopo - fgd

921 words - 4 pages context. Example: At the end of the story, Tony’s father tells him, “A man of learning can be anything in this world, he can be anything” (250). You do not have to use an entire sentence as a quote and can incorporate it into your own sentence. Example: By the end of the story, Tony realizes that “the owl was Ultima’s spirit” (256). · Notice that the period is after the parenthetical page number. There is no comma at the end of the quote. You can

How relationships in the play reveal Shakespeare's depiction of love in Romeo and Juliet - jcm, english - esaay

633 words - 3 pages Essay - Describe how the various relationships in the play reveal Shakespeare's depiction of love in Romeo and Juliet. Lemony Snicket once said love can change a person as a parent can change a baby, awkwardly and with a great mess. This statement implies that love is the reason why one while having positive intentions can cause a very negative impact and can change a person immensely. Such examples of good intentions gone awry can be found

Romeo and Juliet Essay on how they were so in love and that no one can interrupt their elationship. - Monsignor Paul Dwyer Catholic High School - Essay

908 words - 4 pages Jackson 1 Tuoyo Jackson Mrs. Prebble ENG1D1 November 24, 2016 Romeo and Juliet Essay Assignment “The fool doth think he is wise, but the wise man knows himself to be a fool.” “Love all, trust a few, do wrong to none.” In Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet, Romeo and Juliet are doomed as they had no way of preventing the inevitable due to the outside forces such as the secrecy, parental influence and the lack of responsibility of Friar Laurence and

Romeo and Juliet Essay: Love is Tragic - Grade 11 - Essay

468 words - 2 pages “Fair is foul, and foul is fair”, a phrase that is in the play Macbeth written my William Shakespeare. This quote is an introduction to one of the important themes of this tragedy: how the appearance of someone is not always the reality. Shakespeare uses various characters to empazie this confuction between the real and sureal, the autehic and fake and the act and the sincere. - Sitatuation of witches given macbeth good looking (clear cut

Romeo And Juliet

1309 words - 6 pages Free metaphor used in 'A pair of star-cross'd lovers take their lives' helps highlight the foretelling of the death of 'star-cross'd lovers', Romeo and Juliet. This quote tells readers that Romeo and Juliet die at the end since it is written in their fate. The juxtaposition in "The fearful passage of their death marked love" is used to express the fact that Romeo and Juliet's love has death written all over it. This shows that Romeo and Juliet were destined

Romeo And Juliet

1147 words - 5 pages , indispensable part of the whole play. They fall in love with each other and get married all in a rush. Their rush love leads many problems to them. One of the examples that show their rushed love is when Romeo falls in love with Juliet at first sight. "O, she doth teach the torches to burn bright." This a quote from the book said by Romeo when he first sees Juliet at the party. He compares Juliet with the torches. He describes that torches look dim beside

Romeo and Juliet, West Side Story paralleds to and Snow Falling on Cedars - english 101 - MLA

586 words - 3 pages it? In the novels Romeo and Juliet, West Side Story, and Snow Falling on Cedars different factors in our society contribute greatly to the destruction of love.In West Side Story and Romeo and Juliet, the hate that the characters feel for each other takes on a form of fighting. In West Side Story, the hate between the Puerto Ricans and the Americans accelerate to a point where they act on this hate. Street fights, small brawls, and rumbles all

Confusion in Romeo and Juliet

548 words - 3 pages Peter LigeiroWilliam Shakespeare's highly acclaimed drama Romeo and Juliet is the story of two lovers against fate who by their death end the quarrels between their families, the Montague's and the Capulet. After meeting each other at a masquerade, they fall in one. However, the dread between the houses proves too strong as the story ends with a tragic ending. People who become masters of their trade have first to become masters of the tool. For