Rule Of Law And What Are Its Benefits And Defects

2674 words - 11 pages

INTRODUCTIONThere has been debate over the Rule of Law suggesting a separation between the rules by law and rules made by mere power of a ruler. In the days of Aristotle and Plato, there was a clear distinction between rules and rule by mere power. These distinctions will be discussed below, detailing the benefits and defects of both types of rules.More recently, the Rule of Law encompasses both rules (mainly Statutes) and judiciary-made rules. Statutes are necessary to limit judges' ultra vires but at same time, judiciary precedents are needed to 'complete loopholes' within these general statutes.As seen throughout the discussion, notwithstanding defects/benefits statutes and judiciary-made ...view middle of the document...

Is this is murder or manslaughter? Is there a claim for 'self-defence' as it was 'necessary' for the killer to not be killed by the deceased? The laws do not expressly provide on how to deal with this specific situation and judgement must then be made on moral principles ("principles" are discussed by Dworkin under the Modern Discussion section). Permanent laws are incompatible with changing demographics and technology. Laws must change at the same pace with the rest of society to maintain society's current perspective of justice & righteousness, but time delays in passing laws precludes this. For example, the new dog laws in New Zealand. Still now, the public waits for tougher dog laws to be passed on pit bulls and others alike. Even worse, there is no guarantee administration will be efficient. Here, Plato argues, rules fail to meet the differences of time and there is a need for rulers to exercise discretion as it encourages efficiency.Another example Plato uses is a physician who treats people by the book rather than by looking at patient's particular & peculiar problems. Dr Patch Adams proved physicians looking at specific & different problems may lead to the patient not needing "text-book" treatment at all, but simple love & care.Aristotle supported being ruled by law and not rulers. Judges may be swayed by passion or from public-hostility. In some cases, their actions should be checked against laws to ensure that their exercise of legally-conferred powers are consistent & impartial. This does not mean that the law is good but shows law is essential for everyone to look at and compare if just decisions have been reached.Rules are crucial to maintaining neutrality within the legal system. Aristotle uses Plato's physician example and presents how rules for doctors are needed to maintain trust & honesty within the patient. Say the doctor conspired with the patient's enemy regarding what the patient's illness was, because the doctor thought she had the power to do what SHE THOUGHT was right in the circumstances. Here, patients would be more inclined to be treated by the book than be treated by one who judges on what they think is 'right' about the patient.Where rules fail to take into account of specific, exceptional cases, Aristotle claims, equity should apply. Judges should correct errors of the law, rising from oversight by the lawmakers, given there are rules to be corrected in the first place. This is therefore, an argument to being ruled by laws.He favours rule by democracy where government by a collective of good men is better than being ruled by an absolute king. Decisions ought to be made by a democratically-elected assembly (e.g. parliament in our present day). Unlike Plato's idea of 'permanence', offices and positions will be rotated, enforcing the idea that everyone is equal and everyone should both rule & be ruled. For Rotation to proceed, laws must govern such rotations (cf. nowadays where there are...

Other Essays On Rule Of Law And What Are Its Benefits And Defects

What Are The Major And Minor Harms For Self Tattooing??

437 words - 2 pages What are the major and minor harms for self tattooing?? What makes tattooing so bad that it is illegal until your 18?? People ask some interesting questions. As for the age requirements, it's like drinking, driveling a car, or anything else with an age restriction attached to it! A point I've always argued on this, there are 14 year olds today that have much better judgment that 21 year olds! Age doesn't automatically indicate maturity by no

What Are Some Of Characteristics That You Would Associate With The American People And Their Society? Why?

2189 words - 9 pages What are some of characteristics that you would associate with the American people and their society? Why?The United States of America - country which is home and shelter for almost 300 millions of people, divided into 50 states. The larges population of many different nations undeniably has many features which are considered as characteristic ones, like obesity, patriotism, mainstream and race diversity. These features are unique for Americans

Nursing Ethics And Law

420 words - 2 pages give significance to such activities. A person's culture plays a major role in the development of an ethical and a value system in that the value system, a collection of ethical and cultural morals, is normally constructed from the ethics and cultures of the different. Again, a person's culture is important in the sense that the value system should work in such a way that there are no value or ethical conflicts and that the value system is fair and

"Occupational Safety And Hazards: Costs And Benefits"

5217 words - 21 pages benefits of their actions?A. As I said earlier that Maybank is the first to implement these measures, and that the law itself is still in development stage, the period of calculating the exact outcome is not short. OSH measures are meant for the long term profits of an organization, hence it is too early to say anything about its costing benefits or its period of calculation.•What are the initial visible results of implementing OSH at Maybank?A

Management And Its Functions

1248 words - 5 pages organization's activities. The way I work toward the organizing for the benefits of my organization is by providing at least week training to my staff about the products we are selling and its prices, promoting products to the customers, and ways to deliver excellent customer service. After a week of training, I oversee the employee I have trained, what I call as "shadow shift," in which the trainee is evaluated for his/her performance. In addition, I

Should Australia reduce its use of coal and build its own nuclear reactor for generating energy?

446 words - 2 pages Coal provides about 78% of Australia's electricity. It is also the main source for carbon dioxide emissions from electricity and heat production. Coal fires produce pollutants into the atmosphere; mainly they are the gases carbon dioxide and sulfur dioxide. These cause acid rain and lead to the greenhouse effect. Australia is practically the only developed country not using electricity from nuclear energy.If Australia was to replace its coal

Analysis Of The Bicycle And Its Role In Society

398 words - 2 pages Not only are Parents responsible for providing food and shelter for their Children, but they should also help them to develop their mental and physical condition. A Bicycle, a vehicle having two wheels one behind the other, influences a child's physical, intellectual and social development. It also can improve the quality of life. Riding a bicycle will provide children with health and other benefits. A bicycle can save them money in gas and also

What Are The Main Changes In French Agriculture Since 1945 And What Challenges Does It Face Today?

1612 words - 7 pages agriculture has arguably become dualist. On the one hand, some holdings have turned into productive capitalist firms linked with food processing industries and mass retail distributors -a fifth of the exploitations producing two third of the national production. But on the other hand, many others -often small-sized and poorly located- have not been able to invest enough to be economically integrated and dynamic, and are consequently

What are some recommendations for continuing HIV research and scientific investigative processes?

586 words - 3 pages obtain the lowest prices, the licensed manufacture of generic equivalents, and differential pricing based upon relative ability to pay. The U.S. should encourage its G-8 partners to support similar trade agreements.While the U.S. is the leading international donor on global AIDS efforts, we provide a far smaller percentage of our national budget to these efforts than many other countries and far less than what is needed for these efforts. In FY 2001

Compensation And Benefits Plan Executive Summary 431

744 words - 3 pages methods of compensation and voluntary benefits for SMC.Cost Of PlanIn order to address the issues of retention at SMC, we must first look at cost: are we spending too much, or are we not spending enough in addressing the compensation and benefits needs of our employees. We plan to look at the following areas to see how cost will affect our bottom line in profits; current benefits plan vs. optimal benefits package, incentive programs such as bonuses

Employment Law And Sexual Discrimination

1404 words - 6 pages posted on the walls. The victim complained about this atmosphere of harassment on a number of occasions, but the company's supervisory personnel provided little or no assistance. The court found this conduct violated Title VII because the harassment was based on sex, it affected a term or condition of her employment, and the employer knew or should have known about the harassment and failed to take remedial action.There are a few benefits of a

Similar Papers

What Is The Natural Law? What Are Its Principles? How Does It Relate To Positive Laws?

1992 words - 8 pages In order to understand the concept of natural law and its principles it is important to understand what Aquinas sought to achieve with his political philosophies. Prior to Aquinas, the mainstream of Christian political thought had been rooted in faith. Faith, by its very definition is the belief in something for which there is no logical or rational justification for. Since the very concept of religion was based on faith, reason was thought

Should The Uk Join The Euro Or Remain Master Of Its Own Fiscal Destiny. What Are The Arguments For And Against?

3005 words - 13 pages benefited least from EU status . When assessing British business attitudes to Europe this cultural bias cannot be discounted. Certainly the government needs to help informed decisions. This document is intended to present facts by outlining the concepts of the Single Market and Currency, collate opinions and try to draw some conclusions on to which way Britain trade should proceed. Are its perceptions of Europe insight or inertia?The Single

The Benefits And Hazards Of Gene Technology

566 words - 3 pages and commercial, are planted across the globe. So far, fears that they might turn out to be ‘super-weeds’, resistant to herbicides and spreading uncontrollably, or that their genes might transfer into other closely related wild species, forming a different kind of ‘super-weed’, or that they might reduce biodiversity by genetic contamination of wild relatives seem to have proved unfounded. A paper was published in Nature in

What Are The Advantages And Disadvantages Of Living Away From Home To Freshmen Students?

513 words - 3 pages , we often miss all the facilities we used to have back at home, like our bedrooms, our beloved bed, our stuffed animals, and even our bathrooms. As a result, we start to realize how valuable our family are, and appreciate everything we had back where we used to belong.What's more, once we live far away from home, we have to learn how to do things by ourselves. Say goodbye to the carefree life, and step into a life full of duties. Now we have to